Fanboys. My first article admission into the WhatCulture elite had me talk about how much I hate smarks within the wrestling industry and how their inane rhetoric and critique about the WWE, even when they claim not to watch it is not only downright wrong but blatantly insulting. Now let's add to that the modern day fanboy (or girl). These people just simply refuse to allow any adaptation of any comic book film, regardless of how good it is, any leeway or credit when it comes to the final product. As Smarks tend to do, they nitpick every decision the director makes, constantly complain about the most insanely small details and all seemingly are under the belief that the only good comic film that will ever be made is the one they will never get to make. Just an update to those who may not have read my previous articles, I grew up in the "Outback" of Australia where there was not much access to all things entertainment, whether it be films, music, or anything for that matter. We were always the last to get it and it was usually out of date by the time it got there. And the last thing a country town of only 200 people needed or thought to have stocked in the local general store was comic books or as the modern afficionado calls them, graphic novels. The only one we got on a regular basis was Mad Magazine (and for some reason, Eagle Comics "Judge Dredd", go figure, but you had to go to the bigger neighbouring town for those). No Batmans, No Supermans, No Justice League, No Avengers, No X-Men, nothing at all. And even when I did move to the city in the early 90's comics still weren't at all popular like they are now (in Australia anyway). The only Superman we grew up with and knew was Christopher Reeve. Batman was Adam West (until Micheal Keaton showed up), Wonder Woman was Lynda Carter and Lou Ferrigno was the Incredible Hulk. So I have no idea who Deadpool is and don't care about how many X-Men there are all up or who was the originals. Not at all fussed whether Batman is "camp" or if he is "reality based" like the Chris Nolan efforts. Couldn't give a damn about which actor should have been assembled for the Avengers Initiative and the "Age of Ultron" sounds to me like something Optimus Prime dealt with back in the original 80's Transformers cartoon. Nightwing, who in the blue hell is that? And if continuity is going to be explained by a crisis between parallel worlds then all I ask is that we get to see the reverse Flash (Okay, I did catch up on that one, ha). But there is one thing I care about and that is being entertained at the flicks. And quite frankly these films I am about to mention not only entertained the hell out of me but some I actually thought were filmed quite courageously, knowing full well the backlash from the freaks that actually do fit that stereotype of fat guys in basements with no girlfriends, which would've been fully realized beforehand. You see, regardless of the source material, these are not comic books, these are movies. And the object of adaptation is to introduce the world that you are adapting to us who may not be an encyclopedia of all knowledge pertaining to the Marvel Universe or whatever. Most of you people go to see these films regardless of whether they are bad or not, so the movies are not made for you. They're made for the extra $200,000,000 the studios hope to get by reaching the average Joe (or Johanna) who have never heard of Thanos or Galacticus and whose only source of comic book fandom is regular visits by Bart Simpson to The Android's Dungeon & Baseball Card Shop. And I say to you all, go watch "Battleship", "The Room", "Jack & Jill" (or any Sandler movie of late nowadays), the "Twilight" Saga or Michael Bay's "Transformers" anthology to date, then come back and explain to me why these movies should not be treated as reverently as "Citizen Kane" in comparison. Or at least given some slack. For these films I believe only get the ridicule that they do simply because everyone loves to jump on the hate bandwagon like the sheep that they are. With one example making it blatantly obvious to anyone who is witnessing as an outsider (like me) that no matter if God himself created the ultimate Marvel vs DC film you people would still be hating on it because Christopher Nolan did not direct.
Let's get started...
Honourable Mentions:
The Dark Knight Rises. I don't understand how people can nitpick a story about a man who dresses like a bat (This site is no exception). You can suspend your disbelief for this but you can't when it about his fateful trip to India. And one more thing, he does not use a bat voice, HE HAS A VOICE SCRAMBLER BUILT INTO HIS SUIT. That's why he still talks with the trademark growl even when people know who he is. That right there is the most infuriating aspect of the fan boy complaints about this picture. Most of their arguments can be rebuked with straight ahead thinking. It's common sense people, not rocket science. But it does not make this list as even though it is ripped apart with a fine tooth comb, it generally is accepted as a good film. Superman Returns: Same as tTe Dark Knight rises, suffers from a severe nitpicking from most but is generally accepted to be good movie.
Watchmen; The movie that apparently everyone asked for, was delivered to near perfect synchronicity when it comes to adaptation of the source material but seemingly still all got your knickers in a twist. I can't understand the argument you people make when you say "the movie is not true to the source material" but when one comes along that takes it literally frame by frame you still complain. But as is this movie is generally accepted by fan boys to be a good film. Although anyone who thinks seeing Malin Ackerman in all of her glory as "uncomfortable to watch" or "completely unnecessary" needs to rethink their sexual preferences I reckon...
Dis-Honourable Mentions
Batman and Robin: Yeah, I get the hate, ha. I get the ridicule. There is no doubt how badly this film was made. But with the horror stories about Warner Brothers and how they rushed pre-production I can hardly blame just the filmmakers. And don't forget that I mentioned that the only Batman I knew of before Michael Keaton was Adam West, so I will deny the hate and be the first one to stand up proudly and say "yes, not only can I be entertained when I watch this film but can enjoy it also." Plus it is actually a great way to introduce Batman to the little kids as I have had experience with this personally. My ex's 5 year old son loved this movie when I showed it to him and he became obsessed with all things Batman, so I say to you is that a bad thing? My advice to first timers is to watch it as a sequel to the 1966 tv movie. Then tell me how much fun you had spouting off Mr Freeze one liners. Green Lantern Although I do enjoy this movie, I can understand SOME of the hate in which it's directed. They went the kid route when they instead should've lined this up to be the dark precursor to the Justice League. So it doesn't make the list.
6. Daredevil
If you just so happen to live under a rock and completely off the grid in this day and age, you may not have heard that Warner Brothers has recast Batman with Ben Affleck. Now I am not a fan of this decision by any means but when people use the argument that is "Daredevil" as the sole reason why he is already is the worst ever Batman I just want to slap someone upside the forehead. For starters, I think "Gigli" is a much better contender for why he should not play the Dark Knight. Because I honestly don't think Daredevil is that bad a film. I knew absolutely nothing about Daredevil prior to him being named as the blind superhero from Hell's Kitchen. NOTHING. AT ALL (I have to emphasize that). And yes, although it is a bit hokey, it is no more so than a lot of other superhero films (X Men finale, anyone?). In actual fact, Daredevil sets a much darker tone than most of the previous comic book films (it came out before X2) to date, which in turn makes it technically a precursor to Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Trilogy. I mean, they kill off the love interest and the bad guys lived, are you serious bro? What I find funny is that this stars Jon Favreau pre Iron Man days at his comical sidekick best and if released today, would probably have the same fan boys who nowadays claim he can do know wrong frothing at the mouth. Yes, Ben Affleck is not the best actor going around but he didn't massacre this role as so many said he did. I found his portrayal as an actual blind man was quite effective. Colin Farrell, although lacking a decent attire, made an awesome job as demented assassin Bullseye. And if anyone can look me in the face and say Michael Clarke Duncan has ever put in a bad performance (for what he's given) than I say that you must be a Michael Bay fan and know nothing of acting. The only real issue that stands out for me is the performance of Jennifer Garner, but as eye candy she was prefect for the role, and lets face it, all of these super heroines nowadays are just that, the hottest actresses in the world to pull in the teenage boys (again, X Men anyone, Avengers?) And even though the CGI isn't all that great, it does not affect the flow of the film as bad as say, Catwoman. Actually apart from the finale in the church I would dare say that it is barely even noticeable. And recently with the release of the Directors cut that not only adds to and heightens the overall dark feel of the film but proves that movie execs should just steer clear of artistic decisions, I think it's time to give Affleck the benefit of the doubt when it comes to Batman.
5. The Incredible Hulk
Now granted, I am not that big of a fan of the Ang Lee adaptation. Although I do enjoy the movie and the origin story was pretty good. It was way too long, a little melodramatic (in a boring way) and suffered from too much synopsis for too simple a story. There really is no complex back story to the Hulk. He is a scientist who has an accident which turns his dark, subconscious side into a manifestation that we all come to find out is a menacing green hulk. Not much there if you really think about it.. But they tried to stretch what they had over 2+ hours. I find if they had edited a good 20 minutes of filler out of t it would have been accepted as a great addition to the superhero genre.
But then came the sequel/reboot in the form of Edward Norton and "the Incredible Hulk", and to this day I simply don't understand why fanboys complain about this. The reasons they give are completely nonsensical and can be rebuked in just about every way. It is EXACTLY what I would expect an Incredible Hulk film to be like. But unlike certain other people who appear in this list, the studios actually seemed to give you everything you asked for. It's true to the source material with Edward Norton putting on a great job with his performance as Bruce Banner. They took out a lot of the unnecessary subplots that bogged down "The Hulk", added some truly intense action sequences and gave us Tim Roth (again, quality actor) as the villian taken straight from the pages of Marvel lore. But no, that is simply not good enough apparently. Okay, fine. But you tell me, what more do you expect from a movie about the Jolly Green Giant having a mental breakdown (come on, lets face it, it's all the Hulk is technically). After all is said and done "the Incredible Hulk" and its legacy was affected by one thing. The ability for the sheep to jump on the hate bandwagon at a moments notice. But unlike "Watchmen" where it still seems to be accepted as a good film, this movie does not have that luxury and has been relegated to history of "what never should have been." Which is completely unfair, untrue and proves the point of this article tenfold. Oh, and one other thing. Comparing Norton's performance to Ruffalo's is mind numbingly unrealistic. I always hear the argument that Ruffalo's is the superior Hulk in every way, but allow me to retort. I can't for the life of me comprehend this ideology as even though Ruffalo was a good Hulk, he didn't actually have a whole movie to carry and was surrounded by not only some of the finest actors in the world but an entire superhero team he could fall back on to at a moments notice. Even my cat could be the Hulk in those circumstances....so until Ruffalo gets his own film, Norton is by far the superior Hulk.
4. Superman 3
Now this one actually offends me as not only is there anything wrong with this film, but it's a personal favourite. It has it all, artificial intelligence and its implications, the iconic character at his best with Christopher Reeve, corporate greed the likes of which gave rise to the GFC, a great inclusion and extension of the pre Superman/Smallville days and it's story arc, Evil Superman vs Superman (by far the greatest scene in any superhero movie) and humour. Yes, humour, and what is wrong with that? Why does everything have to be "uber" serious nowadays (is that the term the kids use nowadays?). All of you adult fan boys always seem to neglect to remember that all of these characters were designed to appeal to children and as such needs a "camp" element involved to make sure they are entertained as children. To which I was as a child. That first sequence is truly awesome. The way it was filmed, the way it is all in sync and as far as slapstick goes, this rivals to glory days of "the 3 Stooges", but without the inherent use of mental illness as a precursor to such events(to which I take offence personally as I have a few issues myself). Did I mention that it starred Richard Pryor, comic genius. His timing in this movie is impeccable & he truly is a great comic foil, unlike Rob Schneider in "Judge Dredd" (shudder). And for people to actually say that he is detrimental to this film is a serious kick to the nut sack to the legacy for this great comic actor. He has great rapport with all of his co stars and funnily, he is actually quite believable as the 80's computer genius he doesn't realize he is. If Bill Gates got seduced by an evil corporate entity with an idea for World Domination other than country size profits, who knows what might of happened when Windows XP was released. Understandably it would have been nice if the studio and Richard Donner could have just gotten along and gave us the original trilogy under his complete direction, who knows what may have come out of that. But as it stands Superman 3, for all of the problems it went thru in getting made, is a strong edition and one of the better ones in the current bloated climate of superhero films. And as for my personal opinion, far better an inclusion to the Superman mythos that was Man of Steel, which completely misses the point about Superman in every way and has Kevin Costner NOT being saved from a tornado. Even Superman, The Quest for Peace managed to nail the tone Superman is meant to set more so than that film, and I will go to the grave saying that the concept for "Quest for Peace" was sound, just executed horribly.
3. X-Men: The Last Stand
Oh wow, the hatred for this film knows no bounds, up to the point where it seems the only way it can be fixed is through time travel with Bryan Singer returning to the helm with the upcoming "Days of Future Past." The pure evil rhetoric that comes out of mouths of fan boys about Brett Ratner and how he almost destroyed the franchise I seriously haven't heard outside of a Klan rally (so I have seen on film, ha). "This man took Bryan Singer's X-Men franchise and reduced it to nonsensical garbage that completely misused or miscast every character, destroyed the iconic back story and mythos that surrounds Jean Grey as the Phoenix and completely wrecked the trilogy. And they killed off Cyclops in the first 10 minutes." According to these people, Brett Ratner should be stripped of all directing credentials and sent back to the dungeon of doom that is filming commercials. Now I am not the biggest fan of Breett Ratner, far from it. But lets look at a few actual "facts" about X Men 3. After the success of the first X-Men film, Bryan Singer signed on to a 3 picture deal with Fox which included both sequels. But when the Superman Returns project got placed in front of him by Warner Brothers his massive fan boy love for Richard Donners iconic adaptation of the character mean't that he just couldn't pass this up or hold it off, so he asked the powers that be if he could put off the finale to the X-Men so he could go make Superman Returns. But the thing was, X-Men 3 had already started pre-production (which costs money) and he was already signed. In an extremely rare event for Hollywood the execs were in fact 100% right in everything that was occurring. But no, Bryan Singer had to have his cake and eat it too, and once the negotiations fell apart, he was subsequently dropped (or left by his own will according to some sites). Now remember, the movie was already in full swing when it came to pre-production so the execs were forced to shop around for a new director at the very last minute, and even though several high profile directors were offered the job, essentially the only reason Brett Ratner was hired was for his ability to complete rushed productions under budget (see Rush Hour). He was given the basic synopsis and had to go from there. And considering the end product, I think he did a fantastic job with what was given. "But he killed Cyclops you say." Well, guess what. It's not quite hard to find out with a bit of research that apparently that was the plan all along. Singer was either going to kill him off or reduce his role to simply being background fodder. So your argument if this is the case becomes completely invalid. Add to that the very fact James Marsden left X-Men 3 mid pre-production as well to work on Superman Returns at either Bryan Singer's request or that he is also a douchebag indicates one simple and logical fact. If you have any problem with X-Men 3, then your beef is with Singer, not Ratner. Singer is the one who bailed on his own franchise, Singer is the one who bailed on the fans to make Superman. All Ratner did was pick up the pieces (and perhaps even saved it in the eyes of those money hungry execs). And like the previously mentioned David Fincher, if anything Ratner should get all the credit in the world for what he accomplished. He even left it open for it all to be fixed at a later date by Singer (unforeseen obviously) even though it was initially developed as the final X-Men movie ever. Which alone would've have you fan boys screaming all types of nonsensical ramblings about characters that were never to be used or storylines that would've been so much better. Not that there is anything wrong with the movie as an action flick. It has many subtle references to the comic for which it's based (the Fastball Special, the Danger Room and the Sentinels), has great action set pieces (anyone's who's mouth didn't drop open at the Golden Gate sequence simply cannot be entertained) and again can be seen as a definitive end to a trilogy, that's if you don't wish to hang around for the post credit scene, WHICH by the way was added at the behest of fan boys wanting more sequels after test screenings rejected the endings finality. My God you X-Men fans should be cheering this guy's name. He had a lot of courage to film this when he really didn't have to. And by the way, I don't understand the hate for this version of "Juggernaut." The arguments I read don't seem to make any sense, as the main one seems to be "he is nothing like the original Juggernaut." Well, upon my research for this article I find a little snippet of info regarding the "Ultimate X-Men" series and the fact that the movie version is based on this Juggernaut and not the one found in the original Marvel comics, where he is not a mutant but gets his powers from a rock or something as ridiculous. Now that version not only doesn't make sense but is so stupid on infinite levels. Plus, I grew up on 80's one liners. "Don't you know who I am, I'm the Juggernaut Bitch!" My favourite part of the film, ha. It's up there with the "Running Man" when it comes to iconic one liners with me. Goes hand in hand with "Here is Sub Zero, now....plain zero!" Speaking of X Men....
2: X-Men Origins: Wolverine
Deadpool. If there was one single reason and one alone for this film's status as an abomination it is this iconic character of the X-Men Marvel Universe and how they completely massacred him in every way. Apparently there was talk of giving this famous character (?) his own stand alone movie with the initial plans being that after the X Men trilogy wrapped up, there would be a spinoff series that would introduce us to many of the X-Men and their individual stories on how they came to be. Hence the title "X Men Origins". But after this movie "supposedly" under performed (which is insanity in itself as I will point out later) the franchise was rebooted into a different direction with X Men: First Class. Which in turn has allowed for all the mistakes this film and the Last Stand made (Again, ?) to be rectified using time travel and the talents of original director and the be all or end all of the X Men series, Bryan Singer. Which means Deadpool could be brought back somehow in all of his comic book glory. But for those who do follow this belief system, I have to ask you? WHO IN THE BLUE HELL IS DEADPOOL? You see, in the years before this film came out I was too busy touring the road and attempting rock stardom to bother with such minor detail (yes, I am sorry, but they are minor in terms of filmmaking for non comic book brethren). I never got to catch up on 90's Saturday morning cartoons as I was either always coming home from a show or sleeping off a gig. In fact, I had never heard of him before this film came out. And let's couple this with the character Gambit, whom I had actually heard of before, but did not know his back story, merely his image. Now granted, his first foray on film was brief and his appearance in comparison does seem a little less ordinary (not good for any X Men). But let's not forget (which you all seemingly did), this is an "Origin" story set in the 70's. Mutants were literally a hunted species back then so Gambit was not going to traverse the planet in his trademark purple muscle shirt (It is what it looks like folk) or showcase his wonderful card tricks outside of a magic show or impressionable young lady. And apart from the physics problems associated with Deadpool (the blades are too long for his arm to bend if you didn't notice), no one seem to notice the main problem with their argument. There is not one piece of dialogue in this whole film that actually refers to Ryan Reynolds or anyone else for that matter as "Deadpool" (even in the credits). So yes, even though the character obviously is based on this mutant, who is to say that it has to be the actual Deadpool and not like a distant relative, say his Uncle, or even Grandfather. For again, if the X Men Universe is in the not too distant future, this being the actual Deadpool would make absolutely no sense. Which again draws my ire and makes me crazy. There has been precedent for this with two characters amalgamated into one before this. So there is no reason why this can't be the case with Ryan Reynolds. And to top it all of this film is actually a great action adventure with the right amount of drama to give an emotional context to all involved. The story arc itself is not only a great prequel to what some say is the definitive superhero movie with X2, but has a lot less continuity issues than just about every other spinoff that has come out. First Class, although a fine stand alone film seemingly disregarded the entire backstory developed in the original X Men and now has forced them to hack out a time travel story to essentially tie up the loose ends. Origins did not do this. It's story parameters when it comes to what came previously is almost second to none. Everything is explained, from his jacket right down to where he lost his memory. You can watch this than follow it up with X2 (or X Men for that matter) and it fits perfectly within this narrative, which you can't do with "First Class." Some people throw out the argument that "if Sabretooth is Wolverines brother, how come he did not recognize him originally?" Oh wow, how stupid can fan boys be (or unimaginative)? Well, lets forget the fact that Wolverine has lost his memory and it is set quite possibly 50-70 years into the future. There actually is no dialogue in X Men also that makes the claim that Sabretooth did not recognize Wolverine. And the surprise look he gives Wolverine in the initial outing. Well, try going by life not seeing your best friend from kindergarten for fifty years and then tell me how much surprise (and confusion) you had after the initial first meet. Coupled with this the fact that Sabretooth has no dialogue and seems to generally be distracted at times explains a hell of a lot more to someone who is willing to suspend a little disbelief. I enjoy X-Men Origins where to the point that the trilogy for me is this and X Men 1 & 2 (not discrediting the third outing mentioned previously of course). There is nothing really wrong with this movie because to me all of the petty arguments the unimaginative fan boys have against it can all be pretty much rebuked. One more thing, this is a film that according to sources, because of its underwhelming performance profit wise, almost ended the entire franchised and started the current reboot. Well allow me to retort.... Budget: $150 Million Worldwide Box Office Take: $375 Million DVD Sales (in the United States alone): $80 million That's right, a half a billion dollar return with a $350 million dollar profit = FLOP! It's madness I tell you.
1. Alien 3
Again, like Superman 3, I actually get offended when people give this movie its unjust deserves as personally, I hold this film in higher regard than Aliens nowadays. BLASPHEMY I hear you all scream in unison, GAME OVER MAN, GAME OVER! YOU CAN'T BE SERIOUS? Now before you go all Corporal Hudson on me let me explain my argument. Aliens is a great film, a classic action blockbuster with iconic, unforgettable characters, set pieces that just blow your mind & to top it off, was a sequel to undoubtedly the greatest sci fi film ever made. And Bill Paxton. But the thing is, have you watched it lately? I don't think it has aged that well. Regardless of how great an action film it is, that's just the problem. It is a generic 80's action film. Quite possibly THE definitive action film, but still an action film.
And the original Alien was anything but. It relied on atmospheric tension and a claustrophobic feel to create genuine horror that scared the bejeebus out of everyone. And of all the sequels and spinoffs that followed the only one that was based on the actual framework the original Alien laid down was David Finchers horribly underrated effort (dare I say, masterpiece). Only Alien 3 truly went out to capture the original feel that made Alien such a landmark classic. And as I mentioned with Batman and Robin, the preproduction was a complete nightmare (probably one of the worst in film history) with the execs once again showing how truly untalented they are at filmmaking. I mean, they released a teaser to a film that didn't even have a script yet. Come on! So with half a script (if that), angry management and frustrated actors. David Fincher went out and created a truly amazing film, showcased even more with the definitive Directors Cut (initially released as part of the Alien Quadrilogy dvd/vhs boxset) which highlights the original religious motif Fincher and Co. were going for. This version of the movie I think is a much superior film in many ways to James Cameron's Aliens in terms of direction. But aside from that, I thought the concept of the Xenomorph coming from something other than a human was mind blowing and exciting (Dog or Ox, doesn't matter. It was something different), even at the time of the theatrical release. And they had a plethora of thespians who seemingly used the stressful situation to their advantage and put in some truly solid and strong performances. And unlike Aliens there was no witty one liners to fall back on or massive explosive set pieces to hide behind. This film was everything that Aliens wasn't and Alien was. The fact alone that he did this with such immense pressure from the execs, with the budget constantly being cut back and with half a script, I say should've earn't the man an Oscar. It actually angers me and makes me lose a little respect for Fincher with regards to his feelings about this movie (he has disowned it completely). My personal belief is that no director should omit anything from their resume. It just shows how pretentious you are as a person and if you have the nerve to take the job, you should be willing to put your name on it regardless of how bad YOU might think it is or it turns out to be. Nothing is stopping these directors from walking now is there? Why did he sign up in the first place as the pre-production problems were already well known? I don't see George Clooney running from the fact that he was the star of "Return of the Killer Tomatoes." He embraces it, and for that reason he is awesome. But I digress. Alien 3 is just as much a definitive sci fi classic as much as the first two with a great story, excellent direction by Fincher, wonderfully acted by all involved and has a definitive end to the "trilogy", although we all know that concept didn't last long. And if none of this convinces you to change your mind about Alien 3, why not watch it after a viewing of the abomination known as "Prometheus", then come back and tell me why it has a bigger rating on both Rotten Tomatoes and IMDB. Give me a break, pfft. So there it is, 6 films that in my opinion are given way too much flak, deserve a way lot more credit then they currently receive and in comparison to some of the garbage Hollywood is throwing out there as of late. probably should be re-evaluated & given fresh ratings. But I guess that in the long run it is up to the personal tastes of the individual cinema goer. Although considering Grown Ups 2 beat out Pacific Rim in the US at least I think maybe that I might actually be a voice of reason on a planet of madness. Tell me I'm Wrong?
Passions in life: Movies, Music and Wrestling....My childhood was spent growing up in the "Outback" of Australia (I'm a little bit country) and my adulthood resided within the city limits (I'm a little bit rock and roll), so you could say that I am the best (or worst) of both worlds. A 6 foot 7 ex wannabe pro wrestler (whose career was cut short due to a busted back, NOT caused by wrestling) & muso who has a precocious cat & a habit of doing the wrong thing but for the right reasons. The story of my life????
All demos, no albums ;)