Black Widow: 10 Huge Questions We Still Have
Yelena could have a big role to play in the future of the MCU.
After a longer than usual wait between MCU installments, with Spider-Man: Far From Home releasing all the way back in July 2019, Black Widow is finally on the horizon. The marketing campaigns have ramped up with new trailers and posters, and the wait is nearly over.
While Marvel have kept their cards close to their chest as always, we aren't going into the cinemas completely in the dark. Natasha Romanoff will return to Russia after the events of Civil War to team up with the figures from her past to take down Taskmaster and the Red Room in which she was trained.
However, there are certain aspects of the movie, with regards to character, story, and the future of the MCU, that Marvel have deliberately kept quiet about, and rumours and theories that make so much sense we can't help but keep asking ourselves the same questions over and over.
While the trailers may have shed some light on certain aspects, and we can make several assumptions based on the source material, there are still some huge questions hanging over Black Widow that can't truly be answered until May 1st.
10. What Happened In Budapest?
Not only is this one of the biggest questions heading into Black Widow, it is one of the longest standing questions throughout the entire MCU. First alluded to in Avengers Assemble all the way back in 2012, Marvel Studios have never elaborated on what actually happened between Natasha Romanoff and Clint Barton in Budapest.
We can certainly piece together a rough picture based on a few puzzle pieces picked up over the years. Clint was sent to kill Natasha but had a change of heart, and ended up saving her from her previous life and putting her on a different, better path.
The conversation between the two in Endgame about how far they've come since Budapest seems to suggest that Hungary was the first time they had ever met. Why then would Hawkeye choose not to complete his mission? And why would Natasha even listen to the stranger sent to kill her?
It's been eight long years, but Black Widow in 2020 seems to be when we will finally learn how the titular character came to get so much red in her ledger.
9. Who Is Ray Winstone Playing?
Even before Black Widow was officially announced by Kevin Feige at San Diego Comic Con in 2019, details were beginning to leak. Everyone knew the movie itself was coming, obviously with Scarlett Johansson set to reprise her role, and even David Harbour's name had been mentioned before he appeared on the Hall H stage.
Another name that started getting mentioned was that of Ray Winstone, who was reportedly cast in June of 2019. While Comic Con clued us in on David Harbour's role as well as the other cast members, Winstone was completely left out.
Even now there is no word on who the English actor is actually playing. There was some speculation for a time that he would be bringing Taskmaster to life, but he doesn't exactly fit the body type of the villain we have seen in the trailers.
The fact that Marvel is being so secretive seems to suggest the identity of Winstone's character may well be a spoiler. Why else would the actor be all but ignored in any and all marketing up to this point?
8. Will Melina Become Iron Maiden?
Aside from David Harbour and Florence Pugh, Rachel Weisz was also introduced to the MCU at San Diego Comic Con in 2019, portraying Melina Vostokoff in the movie. Like Natasha and Yelena, Melina is another graduate of the Red Room, and appears to be part of Black Widow's team set to bring Taskmaster down.
However, there may be more to this character than it first appears, particularly if the MCU iteration of Melina follows in the villainous footsteps of her comic book counterpart.
The character became Iron Maiden in the source material, sporting an metal suit similar to that of Iron Man that lent her an arsenal of weaponry and a cocoon-like defence system that made her very difficult to defeat.
This could be used to great effect in a couple of different ways by Marvel Studios. Either Iron Maiden could remain a good guy and potentially fight with the Avengers as something of an Iron Man replacement, or she could go more accurate to the comics and become a villain, potentially reforming later in the franchise, joining the Thunderbolts when the team is inevitably introduced to the MCU.
7. Who Else Has Taskmaster Learned From?
Though traditionally the MCU has struggled somewhat with creating compelling villains, phase three began to turn the franchise's fortunes with the likes of Adrian Toomes, Erik Killmonger, and of course, Thanos. Looking to continue this trend going into phase four, the latest antagonist of the MCU will be Taskmaster.
There have been criticisms that villains have too often simply been carbon copies of their opponents, mirroring their powers and moves. With Taskmaster, this is absolutely true, but with enough of a difference to make it interesting. The villain's power is that he can instantly mimic any fighting style he sees, allowing him to adapt to any and every fight.
So far through the trailers we have seen the antagonist imitate Hawkeye's skill with a bow and arrow, Cap's use of his shield, Nat's general fighting style and positioning, and Black Panther's claws. Immediately this makes Taskmaster a villain that Nat will struggle to overcome.
But which of her other Avengers team mates can she expect to come up against? Will he have picked up Spider-Man's acrobatics? Maybe he'll simply hit Nat with a barrage of brute force rage attacks like the Hulk? There really is no end to the possibilities of what we could see from the villain.
6. What Is Thaddeus Ross' Role?
With the movie set between the events of Civil War and Infinity War, it makes sense that Thaddeus Ross will appear. The Secretary of State was a key factor in the establishment of the Sokovia Accords, and was actively hunting down those Avengers on the run even during Infinity War.
However, this is about the only thing that currently makes sense about Ross' appearance in Black Widow. Firstly, his voice over in the trailer seems to be talking to Natasha in the way a friend would, rather than an enemy. Based on what happened at the end of Civil War, Ross would certainly not class Natasha among his friends, so what gives?
Then there is the character's physical appearance. From the trailers and leaked set photos we have seen Thaddeus Ross looking very obviously digitally de-aged, and we have also seen him looking older and weaker than ever. Does this mean we can expect to see some time jumps in Black Widow, both forward and back?
It's no stretch to think that Ross may have met Widow in the past, but in terms of the older version of the character, he looks a lot more aged than even in Endgame after the five year time gap. The most obvious explanation is a time jump even further forward than Endgame, but what could we see Ross doing in the future?
5. Will Red Guardian Be Killed Off?
Black Widow looks set to be all about the titular character's past. Based in 2016, she is returning to Russia to the family she had before she joined the Avengers, to take down the Red Room that trained her as a child. However, this doesn't mean that the MCU present and future won't be affected by these events.
One of the biggest question marks is the ultimate fate of David Harbour's character, Alexei Shostakov. The Red Guardian, essentially described as Russia's answer to Captain America, is a super hero fighting alongside Natasha to bring down Taskmaster, but what happens to him post 2016?
Fast forward seven years to 2023, for the final battle between Earth's Mightiest Heroes and Thanos. Doctor Strange pulls help from all corners of the universe, including the Wakandan tribes, the Ravagers, and even Howard the Duck. Though Nat was gone by this point, if there was a super hero who could be found to help, Strange would surely have sought them out, even double checking with Wong that he got everyone.
Where then was the Red Guardian? Why wasn't he brought into this fight with everyone else? If Alexei was alive and able to help, there is no way he'd have been ignored by the Sorcerer Supreme, right? This could potentially mean that Alexei dies in Black Widow, possibly sacrificing himself for the greater good as he did in the comics. Plus the fact that Marvel loves killing off their heroes' father figures, this seems a likely outcome.
4. Why Has Mason Appeared In None Of The Trailers?
Joining Scarlett Johansson on stage during the film's spot at Comic Con last year were David Harbour, Florence Pugh, and Rachel Weisz, set to make up Natasha's first family as Alexei, Yelena, and Melina, respectively. We have seen plenty of these characters in the promotional material, but there was one more person on stage with them.
Star of A Handmaid's Tale, O-T Fagbenle, was also announced to be portraying Mason. The character is described as a former ally of Natasha, but through months of marketing campaigns and trailers, we have seen Mason just once, as a very small addition to one of the movie's promotional posters.
Why are Marvel seemingly hiding him away with Ray Winstone's unnamed character? There are many rumours and theories that Mason will actually be Taskmaster, but holding him out of the trailers altogether seems too obvious. Marvel rarely give big clues away to these kinds of twists.
Besides, he has appeared in the most recently released poster for the movie in seemingly civilian clothing, so why not the trailers? If Mason is set to be revealed as Taskmaster, Marvel Studios would do better to throw people off the scent by treating him as a normal character in the build up, instead of omitting him completely, giving fans every reason to suspect him.
3. Who Is Taskmaster?
Throughout the entire MCU, Marvel have loved a good villain twist. From Obadiah Stane being revealed as the antagonist to Bucky's dual identity as the Winter Soldier, and Adrian Toomes being Liz's dad, there has been no shortage of shocking reveals over the years.
Kevin Feige and co.'s insistence on keeping Taskmaster's face hidden behind his mask seems confirmation enough that the villain's identity will be yet another shocking twist, leading to numerous rumours and theories about who Taskmaster will actually be. One of the main candidate's is O.T Fagbenle's Mason, but he is far from the only option.
Some of the most popular rumours have claimed that any number of characters could ultimately be revealed as the Black Widow antagonist. From Steve Rogers or Clint Barton, to Melina or even a clone of Natasha, the face hidden by Taskmaster's mask really could belong to anybody.
If, after building such mystery and intrigue around the character, the movie does not reveal Taskmaster to be someone shocking from Natasha's past, or even her future, Marvel Studios will likely have some angry/disappointed fans on their hands. They have had villainous twists backfire on them before like Trevor Slattery, but here's hoping fans will go away happier than then.
2. Will Yelena Become The MCU's New Black Widow?
After an entire decade in the MCU, Black Widow is finally joining the likes of Iron Man, Captain America, Thor, and Spider-Man in having her own stand alone movie. Though it is thoroughly deserved and far too long in the making, now does seem like a strange time to bring to life the Black Widow franchise.
Scarlett Johansson has indeed seemingly confirmed this will be the beginning of a new franchise, which makes sense since Marvel Studios doesn't do stand alone movies. But with the inconvenience of Romanoff's recent death, there is only so much Kevin Feige can do with any more Black Widow movies.
Unless of course, the title is passed on to someone else. Technically speaking, Nat, Yelena, and Melina have all been through the Black Widow programme, and could all carry the name, however with Nat dead and Melina likely evolving into Iron Maiden, Yelena may well be the one to carry the Black Widow mantle forward into phase four and beyond.
Florence Pugh is one of the best young actors in Hollywood right now, and Marvel Studios would do well to lock her in to a multi-movie contract, carrying on the name that Scarlett Johansson made relevant throughout the last ten years.
1. What Will The Post Credit Scene Set Up?
There are several things that can be guaranteed with any Marvel Studios movie. The MCU's trademark blend of humour and action, incredible CGI, and at least two mid or post credit scenes, with the exception of Endgame. The latter have been integral through the last 23 movies for keeping interest in the next installment at the absolute maximum it could be.
There will likely be at least one scene purely there for comedy value during the credits of Black Widow, but there will surely be something to tease the future of the franchise. This may be something to further the Black Widow story, like Yelena taking the titular mantle for herself, or Melina becoming Iron Maiden.
It could however, be something completely different. Could we see Thaddeus Ross begin recruitment for the Thunderbolts? Perhaps a glimpse at the next MCU movie on the slate, Eternals, in a similar way to Doctor Strange's post credits taking a scene directly from Thor: Ragnarok.
This could also be a chance, for Marvel Studios to tease something they've never been able to show properly before. Could a Black Widow post credit scene give us our best look yet into the world of Marvel's Disney+ corner of the MCU? Maybe something as simple as Bucky and Sam reminiscing over Nat, or a glimpse at Clint with Kate Bishop would be enough to ramp up excitement for any and all of Marvel's Disney+ shows.