Creed II Review: 6 Ups & 3 Downs
Formulaic yet highly entertaining.
Creed II lands in UK cinemas this weekend, and while it unsurprisingly doesn't quite live up to the brilliance of its excellent 2015 predecessor, critics are largely embracing it as a rock solid entry into the Rocky franchise.
Because while the eighth Rocky movie doesn't bring much new to the table, how can you resist the charm of Sylvester Stallone transitioning fully into the Mickey role?
For all of the film's dramatic concessions, it is nevertheless a compelling, character-driven boxing film which retroactively makes Rocky IV more watchable. Quite an achievement, that is.
Neither as corny nor as fan-baiting as it could've been yet also not an unqualified success, Creed II sits comfortably in the middle-tier of Rocky movies, even if continuing the franchise any further from this point might be ill-advised.
You probably know if you're going to watch it already, but if you need some convincing to catch it in cinemas, read on. Seriously, those meaty punches won't sound anywhere near as intense at home...
Downs...
3. It's Totally Predictable
Some will argue that predictability isn't really a suitable criticism of the Rocky franchise considering that the overwhelming majority of the movies follow an incredibly similar trajectory, and being surprised isn't really the point.
Be that as it may, it does feel like the series should be attempting something a little more adventurous eight movies in, because if you've seen any of the trailers for Creed II, you won't have much trouble piecing together the relatively by-the-numbers plot.
There are some occasional wrinkles which provide a few neat surprises, but the A-to-B-to-C through-line of Adonis Creed's (Michael B. Jordan) journey is almost exactly what you expect it to be.
It's especially disappointing as there were some incredibly signposted moments where the movie could've taken a dramatic left-turn and served up something a little different, but instead it lightly flirts with these possibilities before moving on as expected.
2. Ryan Coogler's Direction Is Sorely Missed
One of the main reasons for Creed's success was Ryan Coogler's outstanding direction, which helped make the generic tropes feel fresh, while serving up by far the most visually compelling fight scenes in the entire series.
With Coogler busy directing Black Panther, though, he and Stallone selected young indie director Steven Caple, Jr. as his replacement.
And while Caple certainly does a decent enough job - especially given his lack of Hollywood experience - his approach just lacks the confidence and persuasiveness of Coogler's assured work last time.
There are no flashy single-take boxing matches, the dialogue often defers to a boring shot-reverse-shot format, and ultimately the film just feels like it has less of a personality than its predecessor.
There's no directorial stamp here to speak of, and while Caple should be lauded for not simply trying to copy Coogler's style, he also doesn't bring much to the table that's terribly memorable in terms of shot selections.
His work with his actors, at least, is terrific, but more on that later.
1. The Excessive Melodrama
A sprinkling of cheese is also common in the Rocky series, though the first Creed actually did a surprising job mostly veering clear of cornball melodrama, something its successor isn't quite so adept at.
Though the key theme of family - namely fathers and their children - is ultimately well-wrought, the ride to the finish line can be a little bumpy, especially in the first two thirds of the movie.
Adonis and his partner Bianca's (Tessa Thompson) surprise pregnancy feels like a fairly tacked-on attempt to up the dramatic stakes, when the parallel of the current Creed, Drago and Balboa bloodlines is probably sufficient enough.
There's certainly nothing here that's embarrassing to watch or comparable to some of the lesser Rocky movies, but considering how straight Creed II plays itself, it is prone to soap opera plotting on occasion.
If you can accept these issues - and if you're still a fan of the franchise up to this point, you probably can - there's a lot to enjoy in this movie. So, here's what Creed II gets right...
Ups...
6. It's A Fitting Send-Off For Sylvester Stallone
Don't worry, that's not a spoiler: Sylvester Stallone announced this week that Creed II will most likely be his final time playing Rocky Balboa, and if that's the case, it's most certainly a dignified, fond farewell for the boxing icon.
While the first Creed dealt with Rocky recovering from non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, this is largely in the rear-view by the time Creed II begins, and there's virtually no hand-wringing about Rocky's health to speak of.
Instead, Rocky gets to take a slightly more subdued role dramatically, serving as Adonis' trainer and spiritual confidante.
Stallone, who co-wrote the movie, gives himself some wonderfully poetic working-class truisms to spit out on regular occasion, ensuring Rocky is about as charming as he's ever been.
Ultimately the film not only cements Rocky as the stalwart mentor, but also shows him experiencing some major personal growth of his own, especially as he comes to reflect on the events of Rocky IV and his relationship with his own son.
Stallone probably won't end up with an Oscar nomination this time around, but the nature of his role is very different and in its own way equally as satisfying, especially if it truly is the end.
5. The Dragos' Surprisingly Poignant Character Development
Without question the most pleasant surprise of Creed II is how well it handles its most potentially goofy and offputting element: the re-emergence of Ivan Drago (Dolph Lundgren) and his son Viktor (Florian Munteanu).
The film devotes a surprising amount of time to developing the pair as actual human beings as opposed to Ivan's cartoonish portrayal in Rocky IV.
The fallout of his loss to Rocky is palpably felt decades later, and it's fair to say that despite being mute for most of the movie, Viktor has a motivation for victory at least as compelling if not more so than Adonis himself.
In fact, there are honestly parts of the movie where you'd be forgiven for rooting for Viktor, because like the very best sports movies, both fighters are easy to empathise with.
Of the three families focused on in the movie, it's the Dragos who unexpectedly provide the most dramatic nourishment. This is especially true with one shockingly touching moment late in the movie that might even tempt the viewer to shed tears for the supposed "villain" of the film.
But that's the real beauty of Creed II: even the "bad guy" isn't really a bad guy, and in his own way Viktor almost seems too great a character to use in just a single movie.
4. Michael B. Jordan's Outstanding Performance
In conjunction with Ryan Coogler's direction, Michael B. Jordan's performance was one of the primary reasons Creed ended up so damn compelling, and once again, he gives it his all with another thoroughly committed turn.
The material isn't as strong this time around and Adonis actually spends a decent chunk of the movie being a bit of an egoistical a**hole, but Jordan sells Adonis' fiery attitude perfectly, and of course nails the brutal physical requirements of the role.
Whether they're exchanging pleasantries or heated words, Jordan and Stallone's many shared scenes generally rank among the best in the film, again reminding that Jordan's one of the most distinct and impressive actors of his generation.
If Creed III does indeed happen, there's no doubt he'll rise to the challenge yet again regardless of how it turns out.
3. The Intense Fight Scenes
Though we've already covered how the movie's fight scenes can't match the stylish aplomb of Ryan Coogler's work on the previous film, it's reasonable to say that Steven Caple, Jr. does easily his best work in the movie during the boxing set-pieces.
The two battles between Creed and Drago are shot and edited for high visceral impact, with every rib shot sure to make the audience wince, in large part thanks to the excellent sound editing.
While some of the middle-era Rocky movies got a little carried away with the comically OTT punching sound effects, like the last few films Creed II takes a more grounded, less-exaggerated approach that's ultimately more believable and engaging.
Aside from perhaps a few too many slow-mo shots, the fights are exciting as hell and ensure easy audience investment.
2. Tessa Thompson's Expanded Role
One of the few qualms about the first Creed was how utterly perfunctory Tessa Thompson's Bianca seemed to the overall narrative.
Rather than just go the whole hog and make her "the new Adrian", she seemed like a bit of an afterthought, as though a studio exec insisted that the film needed a love interest to spice things up a bit.
Thankfully Thompson has a decidedly more expanded role in the sequel, and though she also gets saddled with some of the aforementioned hokey melodrama, she mostly serves a stronger storytelling purpose this time around.
She is effectively Adonis' ballast and grounding force, attempting to pull him back from the brink when his lack of self-regard becomes too much.
Thompson nails the concern brilliantly, and while the role of long-suffering wife and mother is hardly a progressive one, she carries it out with absolute dignity.
1. It's A Strong "Ending" For The Series
Again, no spoilers here, but if Creed II ends up being the capper to the Rocky franchise, then it's a totally smart and affecting way to close things out.
Of course, money suggests that this won't be the final Creed film, but it nevertheless leaves all the principal players in dramatically satisfying places with little left hanging.
It would be a shame to undo all that, especially as it's tough to imagine where Adonis' story could really go from here, and with Stallone reportedly quitting the Rocky role after this film, it would be extremely odd to go on without him.
The final moments of Creed II totally stick the landing, and it'd be a wonderful act of integrity if MGM actually put the franchise to rest here. After all, eight movies and $1.5 billion at the box office is a pretty damn good run.
What did you think of Creed II? Shout it out in the comments!