EVERY Halloween Death RANKED By Stupidity

Ranking every death of the Halloween franchise, from least stupid to most.

Rob Zombie's Halloween II Michael Myers
Dimension Films

For many long-time horror fans, the Halloween franchise is the greatest franchise in horror history, with Michael Myers and Laurie Strode rightfully viewed as two of the greatest characters in the genre.

Across 13 movies involving several different lines, we've seen Michael forever tormenting Haddonfield, be that targetting Laurie, going after his own bloodline, being controlled by a cult, or even getting Rob Zombie's patented grim and grimy sheen put on him. And then there's the one Michael-less film, Halloween III: Season of the Witch, which instead focussed on Conal Cochran and his nefarious Silver Shamrock scheme.

Of course, throughout those movies, we've seen an incredible amount of bloodshed and brutality; some movies more so than others. While some of those deaths are iconic and rank as some of the best in horror, there are those other deaths that fall flat for various reasons, not least in just how dumb they were - be that decisions made by characters, or decisions made by the creative powers-that-be behind these pictures.

Having painstakingly looked back through all 13 films and every single death, we've an exhaustive, comprehensive breakdown of those deaths in order of stupidity, going from least stupid to most stupid. However, this article will not feature the franchise's off-screen deaths, is based on the theatrical cut of the movies, and no, those pesky androids from Season of the Witch don't count; human victims only here. And if you've got a different opinion to the one here, that's all fine and good. Different opinions are fun and are highly encouraged, especially when doing something as daft as deciding to rank every kill from a 13-film franchise.

So with that in mind, let's get going with the first of approximately 200 deaths...


Harry Grimbridge - Halloween III: Season of the Witch

Halloween III: Season of the Witch Harry Grimbridge
Universal

Harry had no chance, the poor fella.

Chased by a bunch of androids, one of which he manages to destroy, he's pleading with anyone and everyone to believe him that Conal Cochran is up to no good. And when he collapses in the shop of Walter Jones, he's taken to the hospital, where he again proceeds to warn Dr. Dan Challis and Co. that "they're going to kill us, all of us."

Still, everyone presumes Harry is just a smidge unstable.

That is, until the sleeping Harry is visited by one of those androids, who then puts his fingers through Harry's eyes, his hand through Harry's skull, and just generally makes a mess of the guy, killing him in brutal, brutal fashion. Oh, and then the android - who we don't actually know is an android yet - calmly sits in his car, pours gasoline over himself, and sets himself on fire.

So, Harry deserves to be right at the bottom of this list. He tried to warn everyone of what was really happening at Silver Shamrock, and he was then helpless to prevent his own death, as he was asleep when it happened. Well, he was asleep until he was awakened by his eyes being squashed.

Buddy Kupfer Jr. - Halloween III: Season of the Witch

Halloween III: Season of the Witch Buddy Kupfer Jr.
Universal

It sure was bold of Halloween III to kill off a kid, but that's exactly what it did with Buddy Kupfer Jr., with him the guinea pig of sorts for the Silver Shamrock masks.

Buddy's dad was one of Silver Shamrock's best salespeople, and so the family got a nice little tour of the factory, complete with being the first people to witness the final Silver Shamrock Halloween commercial. As a test subject, young Buddy Jr. gave audiences a first glimpse of what those masks could really do, with his head turned to mush when the ad plays. Not just mush, but all kinds of bugs, snakes, and various other creepy-crawlies burst out of Buddy's mask.

On the stupidity scale, this was simply an eager kiddo excited about Halloween, totally unaware of what was around the corner.


Annie Brackett - Halloween

Halloween Michael Myers Annie Brackett
Compass International Pictures

Played by genre fave Nancy Kyes, Annie Brackett is the first present-day victim of Michael Myers. Well, the first present-day death that we see on-screen, at least, for there was a mechanic killed by the adult Michael shortly after he escaped from Smith's Grove Sanitarium. That victim doesn't count for this list, though, as it occurred off-screen and we only got a brief glimpse of the dead body.

The daughter of Sheff Brackett, Annie gets in her car to go and pick up her boyfriend Paul, unaware that Michael is waiting in her back seat. And with that, the Shape strangles her and then slits her throat.

On the stupidity scale, you have to give some of the victims of that first Halloween a little leeway, for this is at a time when Haddonfield had no idea that Michael Myers had escaped or what he was capable of. Sure, they may have heard of the troubled six-year-old boy who killed his sister 15 years ago, but we're now 15 years removed from that and with zero indication to the general public of what the adult Michael was capable of, that he'd escaped Smith's Grove, or even if he was still alive.

The last thing Annie would have expected was for a would-be serial killer to be lurking in the back of her car.

The Mechanic - Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers

Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers Mechanic
Galaxy Releasing

So brief was this guy's Halloween 4 appearance that he didn't even get named. Generic mechanic, it is, then.

The second on-screen kill of The Return of Michael Myers, this man is simply doing his job, working away under a car, only to be attacked by a bandaged-up Michael, who stabs him through the body with some sort of metal pipe.

Deputy Eddy - Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers

Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers Deputy Eddy
Galaxy Releasing

Eddy also didn't even see it coming...

With Michael heading to the Myers House towards the end of Halloween 5, the Shape drives a car into the back of the unsuspecting Deputy Eddy's police car, and then just beats the absolute tar out of the fella through the driver's side window before Eddy can even react. It's a brief kill, but it's a brutal one, with Michael just beating the cop to death.


Mason Strode - Rob Zombie's Halloween

Rob Zombie's Halloween Mason Strode
Dimension Films

Mason Strode, we barely knew ye.

The adoptive father of Laurie Strode, Mason is kind of killed off-screen, but we have enough of an idea of what happened to him.

As Mason stands outside his home, about to join his wife Cynthia inside, he's suddenly punched in the face and grabbed by Michael, with us then switching to a knife-carrying Michael dropping the stabbed, bloody corpse of Mason in front of Cynthia as he decides she's next on his hitlist.

For the pure speed of this assault out of nowhere, Mason never stood a chance.

Bob Simms - Halloween

Halloween Bob Simms Michael Myers
Compass International Pictures

Oh, Bob...

In hindsight, and with what we know from the 'rules' of horror - thanks, Randy Meeks - Bob's goose was cooked the moment he told his girlfriend Lynda that he'd "be right back" after she told him to go and get her a beer.

I mean, you can maybe look a smidge disprovingly at Bob and Lynda for not only taking over the Wallace family's house, but for having sex in the Wallace parents' bed, but Bob is one of those poor souls who had no idea that a masked maniac was on a murderous rampage in the small town of Haddonfield that night.

So, when Bob grabs a beer in the dark Wallace family kitchen, it's easy to see why he'd be caught off-guard when Michael Myers jumps out of nowhere, with some fair ol' force, too, and lifts Bob against a wall, before pinning him to it with a knife in one of the franchise's more memorable kills. This is also the first time we get to see Michael admiring his work with a post-kill head tilt or two.

Bob Simms - Rob Zombie's Halloween

Rob Zombie's Halloween Bob Simms Michael Myers
Dimension Films

The Bob of Rob Zombie's Halloween had near-enough the same fate as the Bob of John Carpenter's 1978 picture, stabbed and pinned against a wall by Michael Myers after going to grab some post-coital beers. The only slight difference is that the original Bob was killed in the kitchen of the Wallace House, whereas the 2007 Bob met his fate on the staircase of the Myers House.

Interestingly, Bob actor Nick Mennell has the unique privilege of appearing in both the Halloween remake and Marcus Nispel's Friday the 13th redo.


Nurse Janet Marshall - Halloween II

Halloween II Nurse Janet Marshall
Universal

The discovery of Dr. Mixter's dead body is done brilliantly in Rick Rosenthal's Halloween II, with the doc having had a syringe stuck in his eye. Unfortunately, Mixter doesn't make this list due to his death not being seen on-screen, and instead, his corpse just casually turns up in his office.

It's poor Nurse Marshall who's tasked with finding the deceased Mixter, and it doesn't take long for her to join him on Michael Myers' hit list. Unaware that Michael has been lurking in the shadows behind her, the obviously shocked Nurse Marshall receives a syringe to her temple that causes her to immediately drop down dead.

Steve Haley - Rob Zombie's Halloween

Rob Zombie's Halloween Steve Haley
Dimension Films

In a particularly grim and disturbing movie, Steve is one of the more sympathetic characters of Michael Myers' initial killing spree in Rob Zombie's Halloween.

The boyfriend of Michael's sister Judith, this is someone who is shown actually being pretty nice to young Michael. While there are some truly despicable characters dotted across this film, Steve isn't one of them - and he's even the one who brings the famed William Shatner mask into the equation in this timeline.

Still, that doesn't stop him from having his head bashed in with a baseball bat shortly after having had sex with Judith.

Andrea Wagner - Halloween (2018)

Halloween Andrea Wagner
Universeal

Listed on IMDb as Andrea Wagner, as played by Marian Sing, this poor woman is another caught totally off-guard by Michael, with Andrea staring out of her front window on Halloween night, completely unaware that Michael Myers has entered through the back of her house, with the Shape then sticking a kitchen knife through her throat.


Betty Kupfer - Halloween III: Season of the Witch

Halloween III: Season of the Witch Betty Kupfer
Universal

It's a little stupid in how it's presented, granted, but it's hard to be too harsh on Betty Kupfer.

For Betty, she dropped down dead in shock after seeing her son Buddy's head turn to mush as bugs and snakes seeped out of the Silver Shamrock mask the kid was wearing. That's quite the sight for any parent, even if it was almost comical in the way she fell to the floor.

Cynthia Strode - Rob Zombie's Halloween

Rob Zombie's Halloween Cynthia Strode Dee Wallace
Dimension Films

Much like her husband Mason, Cynthia was caught completely off guard by Michael Myers.

After the Shape had dumped Mason's dead body in front of her, he attacks Cynthia and eventually snaps her neck, but not before she's able to piece together that Michael's returned to Haddonfield to go after her adopted daughter - and Michael's sister - Laurie Strode.


Nurse Mary - Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers

Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers Nurse Mary
Dimension Films

Appearing only for a few minutes, this nurse, known only as Mary, doesn't make a stupid decision, but instead chooses to make an extremely brave, noble decision.

During the opening sequence of The Curse of Michael Myers, Mary is one of the nurses present when Jamie Lloyd gives birth to a baby boy. And it's Mary who eventually ushers Jamie and her baby to safety, allowing Jamie to escape the clutches of the Cult of Thorn. But in doing so, of course, that means Mary has the ire of the Shape, who swiftly appears and smashes her head onto a conveniently placed wall spike.

Misty Dawn - Rob Zombie's Halloween II

Rob Zombie's Halloween II Misty Dawn
Dimension Films

Having seen her boss/lover Big Lou brutalised by Michael, and then found the corpse of her co-worker Howard, The Rabbit in Red Lounge dancer Misty Dawn knew she was done for as soon as she was confronted by the Shape.

Upon revisiting his mother's old workplace, Michael takes Misty out by repeatedly bashing her head into a mirror.

Nurse Jill Franco - Halloween II

Halloween II Nurse Jill Franco
Universal

Like certain others in Halloween II, Nurse Jill Franco was simply trying to do her job, killed by Michael Myers at Haddonfield Memorial Hospital while doing her best to help Laurie Strode recover from the night he came home.

In terms of stupidity, Jill doesn't do too much wrong, really. Her death comes in the film's second act, as Laurie stumbles through the hospital's halls at a point that Michael is very much now on the scene. So much so, as Nurse Franco walks towards Laurie, the Shape steps out from a corridor, sticks a scalpel in her back, and lifts her off the floor in a way that mildly mirrors Bob's death from the original Halloween.

As an added touch, Nurse Franco's shoes drop off her feet as Michael claims yet another victim.


Annie Brackett - Rob Zombie's Halloween II

Halloween 2 Annie Brackett
Dimension

Danielle Harris' Annie may have gone one better than Nancy Kyes' version, managing to survive until the sequel, but that sequel saw Michael Myers finally add Annie to his victims' list, and it's done in a very raw, emotional way.

Alone at home on Halloween night, Annie is attacked in her bathroom by Michael as she's brushing her teeth. What happens from there is a chase sequence where the bulk of the violence takes place off-screen, with us later getting to see Laurie Strode find Annie's dying body; Annie taking her final breaths in Laurie's arms.

For a movie that's so often about extremes and excess, the handling of Annie Brackett's death and its impact on Laurie is handled incredibly poignantly by Zombie and all involved.

Judith Myers - Halloween

Halloween Judith Myers
Compass International Pictures

When looking at the 200+ deaths of the Halloween franchise, it all starts with Judith Myers, Michael's older sister.

It's maybe easy to forget all these years later, but think back to the very first time you saw John Carpenter's Halloween, before you were fully aware of Michael and, more importantly, his origins. That first watch, especially if you went in completely blind, followed a first-person shot of somebody sneaking around outside a house, entering the kitchen, grabbing a knife, heading up the stairs, and repeatedly stabbing an unexpected young woman to death, as she screamed the name "Michael."

It's only when the killer heads outside the house that we realise he's an angelic-faced six-year-old boy, which is a thoroughly chilling revelation the first time you watch the 1978 Halloween.

For Judith Myers, there was no particular stupidity tied to her death. This was a girl slightly startled by her younger brother, who inappropriately walked in on her while she was undressed. While this was certainly a surprise, there was no way Judith could ever have expected her sibling to be capable of such evil.


Deputy Neale - Rob Zombie's Halloween II

Rob Zombie's Halloween II Deputy Neale
Dimension Films

Assigned by Sheriff Brackett to protect the Brackett House and his daughter Annie, Deputy Neale is ambushed from out of nowhere by Michael Myers.

It's a little hard to see the specifics of what happened to Neale due to the lighting and the quickness of the attack, but it appears he had his neck snapped and a piece of metal shoved through his head.

Sandwich Woman - Halloween (2018)

Halloween Sandwich Woman Marian Green
Universal

Played by Marian Green, who also did stunt work on the movie, this unnamed character is listed on IMDb as simply Sandwich Woman.

A death that technically happens off-screen, there's enough seen for this one to warrant inclusion here. For Sandwich Woman, she's casually making herself, well, a sandwich, blissfully unaware that Michael Myers is back in town. Before she can even dig into her sandwich, Michael enters her kitchen and brutalises her with a hammer, as we then get a grim glimpse at the end result of this particular attack.

Paul - Rob Zombie's Halloween

Rob Zombie's Halloween II Paul Michael Myers
Dimension Films

Paul might not get a last name in the credits, but he at least gets to appear on-screen, unlike his 1978 namesake that was only ever heard on the phone.

The boyfriend of Annie Brackett, Paul's caught off-guard whilst making out on a sofa with Annie, with his death another extremely swift one that sees him fatally stabbed and dumped on the floor, as Michael then goes after Annie. We later see Paul's corpse with a pumpkin over its head.


Harley David - Rob Zombie's Halloween II

Rob Zombie's Halloween II Harley David
Dimension Films

One of Laurie Strode's new friends in the one-year-later portion of Halloween II, Harley is killed shortly after Wolfie, the guy she'd hooked up with at Haddonfield's Phantom Jam.

Michael Myers barges into the van Harley and Wolfie were in, grabs her, and strangles her to death in a rare understated kill for Zombie's Halloween II.

Officer Lowery & Deputy Charles - Rob Zombie's Halloween

Rob Zombie's Halloween Deputy Charles
Dimension Films

The final two kills of Rob Zombie's first Halloween movie, Officer Lowery and Deputy Charles respond to Laurie Strode's call to the police after discovering the dead body of Paul and the brutalised-but-still-alive Annie Brackett at the Wallace House.

To their credit, the officers are quick on the scene and have their guns cocked and ready for whatever may await them. Despite Charles even managing to shoot Michael, the two cops are made quick work of, both stabbed to death.

Wolfie - Rob Zombie's Halloween II

Rob Zombie's Halloween II Wolfie
Dimension Films

With the character's real name never given, the fella dressed up as a werewolf for Haddonfield's Phantom Jam party was affectionately known simply as Wolfie. And when Wolfie hooks up with Laurie's friend Harley, he needs to take a quick bathroom break before he fully gets down to action.

Unfortunately, the decision to take a leak against a tree results in Wolfie being stabbed in the back by Michael.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.