Ghost In The Shell: 10 Big Talking Points From The Trailer
There's a Shell of a lot to discuss.
The Ghost In The Shell anime blew minds back in 1995 with its mix of stunning visuals, cool action scenes and thoughtful sci-fi. It also showed Western audiences anime could be about more than gratuitous gore, nudity and bad English dubs. It was praised by the likes of James Cameron, and the cyberpunk aesthetic was a notable influence on live-action fare like The Matrix Trilogy and AI: Artificial Intelligence.
Of course talk of a live action adaptation quickly emerged, but surprisingly it took more than twenty years for a glossy Hollywood version to emerge. After months of controversy over casting and teaser images, a trailer has arrived and left fans and newcomers with plenty to dissect.
The reaction has been divided for sure, so it’s hard to know if Ghost In The Shell will mark the beginning of the next big action franchise, or be yet another embarrassing live action version of a classic anime series. That said, let's look at some of the major talking points so far.
10. Scarlett Johansson Is The Female Action Hero We Desperately Need
There’s a depressing lack of female action stars in mainstream cinema, but Scarlett Johansson seems intent on helping fix that. She’s proven to be a major asset to the MCU, where Black Widow has provided support and ass-kickings in equal measure. Johansson also helped Lucy on its way to being a huge hit, despite the strange premise.
So it’s not much of a shock she was chosen for the lead, since Hollywood likes to make safe bets. The trailer shows her looking supremely comfortable firing machine guns and throwing punches, while also have the acting chops needed to draw us into The Major’s headspace.
If the movie is a hit hopefully it will prove to studios female led action vehicles can be a thing, and that Kevin Feige needs to greenlight that solo Black Widow movie sharpish.
9. It Heralds The Return Of Cyberpunk
We’ve been disgustingly deprived of cyberpunk movies in the last decade or so, and it hasn’t really been in vogue since The Matrix; and please, don’t count the remakes of RoboCop or Total Recall. Since Ghost In The Shell is a cyberpunk classic it makes sense it should be the one to bring the genre a high-profile makeover, and it’s doing so in style.
If we play our cards right it may even stick around for a few years, because next comes both GITS and Blade Runner 2049. If they’re both successful they could usher in more big budget movies that have meaty drama to go along with the slick visuals, and if 2016's blockbuster season proved anything, it’s that we could use more of that.
8. No Tachikomas...Yet
A minor note, but it looks like the fan favourite Tachikomas won’t be putting in an appearance this time out. While they appeared in the manga and TV series – Stand Alone Complex and 2nd Gig – they didn’t turn up in either of the anime movies.
A Tachikoma is basically a little tank the main characters use in combat, but they’re also equipped with artificial intelligence that gives them child like curiosity. They’re used for some easy comic relief on the show, which given the serious tone of the trailer, makes it easy to see why they were left out.
Maybe they’ll make a cameo, but they’re probably best saved for a sequel. Their spider-like appearance has being given to the robo-geisha’s instead, ensuring nightmare fuel for any kids in the audience.
7. It's Got A Great Supporting Cast
Aside from ScarJo, there’s a hell of a line-up of talent backing her. Pilou Asbæk may not be a famous face yet – he’s Euron Greyjoy to you and me – but he’s a solid choice for The Major’s partner Batou; at least if Dolph Lundgren was too busy for it.
Even from the brief glimpse in the trailer we already know Takeshi Kitano will be an awesome Aramaki, the head of the Section 9 task force. Juliette Binoche will keep things classy as Dr Ouelet, the designer of The Major's cybernetic shell. If the villain teased at the end of the trailer is to be believed, Ouelet may have some explaining to do about The Major’s past.
Michael Pitt will be on bad guy duties since he does smug creepiness so well. Finally, we have the glorious return of Michael Wincott, who was a bad guy mainstay in the 1990's (The Crow, The Three Musketeers etc).
6. The Source Material Is Amazing
To the casual eye Ghost In The Shell might look like a typical anime series, with a hot chick firing machine guns in a futuristic setting. Fans will know there’s more to it than that, with the movies and television show providing much food for thought.
Woven throughout the action-packed stories is a thoughtful commentary on politics, nationality and what it means to be human in a technologic world. The reason the anime has lasted so long is because of these themes, and it appears the live action version has taken this onboard.
Johansson’s Major carries the same feelings of isolation she had in the source material, and it looks like the story will dive into these discussions between explosions. Hopefully, it’ll bring something fresh to the table too since the anime already tread this ground quite expertly.
5. The Director Is Hardly A Visionary
One potential cause for concern with Ghost In The Shell is that the director – Rupert Sanders – is hardly a filmmaker with a distinct voice. His other feature-length directing credit is Snow White And The Huntsman, which was full of pretty visuals and camerawork, but the rest was utterly forgettable.
Only Charlize Theron made an impression because she was freely hamming it up in style, and despite being a hit it left such little impact the eventual sequel only grossed half as much. It’s obvious from the trailer Sanders has a lot of love for the anime and how it looks, but that alone doesn’t guarantee it’ll be any good.
If Sanders last movie is anything to go by, he might be from the Len Wiseman / Brett Ratner school of directors; they can make it look fantastic, but the characters and story will be pancake flat. GITS deserves better, so let's hope that isn't the case.
4. It's Packed With References To The Original
There are clearly fanboys of the original anime working on the movie, because the trailer is absolutely jammed with visual references. There’s the opening shot of Johansson jumping off a skyscraper, which is a direct mirror of the anime – though Scarlett is significantly less naked in the movie.
There’s the scene where she beats the tar out of an assassin while wearing an invisibility cloak, the creation of her cybernetic body and a copy of the scene where she takes cover behind a pillar being torn to shreds with gunfire. While it appears to be borrowing key sequences it doesn’t appear to be a direct adaptation either, with the story branching off into new areas.
They’ve also included nods to the sequel and the animated series, so if nothing else GITS fans can take comfort in knowing the filmmakers actually know the source.
3. Live Action Anime Tends To Suck
Another worrying element about the film is that - by and large - live action anime tends to be awful. Dragonball: Evolution left scars that are still healing, and a quick glance at the genre unleashes other turkeys like Fist of the North Star, Blood: The Last Vampire, City Hunter, Devilman, The Guyver, Attack On Titan and countless others.
Obviously taking a medium based on larger than life characters and action, and trying to ground it in reality, is a tricky assignment. Ghost In The Shell stands a better chance than most, thanks to the rich source material. With a good script and a healthy budget, there’s no reason it should end up on the same list as the movies above.
Just like video game movies, live action anime could use a shot in the arm, and maybe this could be the one that breaks the cycle.
2. It's Visually Stunning
The Ghost In The Shell anime movies are two seriously gorgeous works of art. They have beautifully fleshed out futuristic worlds, populated with all manners of weird and wonderful characters. Paramount have clearly spared no expense on the big screen version, which also looks absolutely stonking at this early stage.
While the cityscape has definite Blade Runner vibes – which is almost inescapable in a cyberpunk movie – it’s also a vibrant, believable environment. The set and costume designs are top notch, and props must go out to the insanely creepy robo-geisha’s seen in the trailer. They’re clearly a tip of the hat to the second anime, but somehow they’re even more unsettling in live action.
Whatever complaints people might have about GITS at this stage, we can at least agree the filmmakers have nailed the look of the world, which is no easy feat in itself.
1. Whitewashing
When it comes to discussing Ghost In The Shell, there’s really no getting around this thorny debate. Logically if you’re going to cast a character named Major Motoko Kusanagi with Scarlett Johansson, it might seem a touch insensitive.
We all know Hollywood operates purely on the cold, hard quest for cash. If they want to launch a potentially huge franchise will a female lead, they’re going to seek out the biggest actress they can find regardless of race. They did that with Johansson, but rather than owning the decision to make the character American, they instead carried out tests to see if they could make her appear subtly Asian. Good intentions or no, that leaves a bad taste, which has only added fuel to the fire.
Maybe the movie will explain this change rationally or make her ethnicity part of her feeling of disconnect from the world around her, but for now, the only thing the trailer tells us is that she looks badass in the role.
Are you excited about Ghost In The Shell? And what do you think of the "whitewashing" issue? Share your thoughts in the comments thread.