How Avengers: Endgame Was Almost Completely Different

The film we got wasn't always the one intended...

Avengers Endgame Iron Man Heimdall
Marvel Studios

Making one movie the culmination of 11 years worth of exposition was always going to be a challenge, but Avengers: Endgame managed to pull it off in excellent fashion. Coming as the second part to Infinity War where all hell has broken loose and most characters are rendered nothing more than torn up Hoover bags, Endgame managed to neatly tie up the plot threads with a healthy dose of death, retirement, and rapid old ageing - but it wasn't always designed to go down that way.

The Endgame that we got was the result of a fair few rewrites across the board, and whilst most were absolutely for the better, there are plenty of 'what ifs' hanging in the air for the movie that could have been brought to life instead.

Were there other visions of the future Dr Strange saw that were supposed to be played out on screen? Have we been shortchanged on a film that doesn't owe the fate of the universe to one wayward rat? Screenwriters Stephen McFeely and Christopher Markus have revealed all in a recent interview with The New York Times.

8. Hawkeye Could've Died Instead Of Black Widow

Avengers Endgame Black Widow Hawkeye
Marvel Studios

One of the big deviations that could have been is born from THAT Black Widow moment. When the two BFFs Black Widow and Hawkeye are sent to retrieve the Soul Stone, we already know what's about to happen. The damn thing can't be lured out of hiding without chucking someone you love in the pit, so the dynamic duo will have to be whittled down to a solo act one way or the other - causing a bizarre suicide competition as neither could bear to let the other go.

Black Widow is the one that manages to smear herself over the concrete, but there was talk of having Hawkeye make the sacrifice instead. They ultimately decided that him taking the hit instead of her was 'melodramatic', and unfair to Widow's arc to have Clint steal this moment - since essentially, her whole story has been leading up to her clearing the red from her ledger.

Screenwriter Stephen McFeely said: "Jen Underdahl, our visual effects producer, read an outline or draft where Hawkeye goes over. And she goes, “Don’t you take this away from her.” I actually get emotional thinking about it."

In fairness, giving Black Widow autonomy over this decision and a fulfilling purpose to her years of work in the aftermath of the snap is only right. Having Clint take the hit would have been too easy, especially considering he's looked like dead meat from his very first appearance.


7. There Was Almost A New Character Introduced

Living Tribunal
Marvel Comics

Endgame was definitely full of surprises, from Professor Hulk's fully-formed appearance to Thor's own, er, full appearance, but everything that came as a shock was through years of development in the other numerous films of the franchise. We've had years of solidifying well-known character traits that were then played with to great effect - so how would Endgame have looked if they'd included a whole new character nobody has ever seen before?

Interestingly titled 'The Living Tribunal', this was a comic book hero that Markus and McFeely wanted to include during the runtime of Infinity War and Endgame, originating as a cosmic entity that maintains the balance between the Marvel multiverse as a pillar of judgement.

Considering we're getting a hell of a lot of messing around with the universe as we know it as well as the timelines that construct its existence, it makes sense that such a character could fit into the MCU here. At least, if you ignore that no-one knows who the hell he is, what he does, and why on earth he would have taken this long to appear in the film franchise.

Of course those were the reasons cited back to the screenwriters when they chucked him into the battle on Titan, with The Living Tribunal's complicated inclusion not sitting well with the rest of the narrative. Whilst it would have been a great nod for those that have been fans of the physical works for some time, this wasn't his moment to pop up.

That being said - he is still being floating around by big Kevin Feige for other projects, so this isn't the last of him just yet.


6. Tony Stark's "I Am Iron Man" Moment Was A Last Minute Save

I Am Iron Man
Marvel Studios

At the end of the final battle in Endgame, Tony Stark's sacrifice to save the universe as we know it comes with one final sassy quip, as all good things should. Of course, when the big purple grape Thanos decides his new catchphrase is "I am inevitable'", it fires up a retort of "I am Iron Man" from big Stark himself as he snaps Thanos into dandruff. It's a moment of triumph, calling back to the first Iron Man movie where Tony deliberately outs himself in celebration of being a superhero, and that these should be his last words feels only appropriate for the journey that he's been on.

There was a point, however, where Tony Stark remained silent in the face of Thanos, choosing to let his actions speak louder than his words for the first time in his life. It would've been a moment of quiet consideration coming from the man that has built a career around being outspoken, and ultimately didn't sit right with the screenwriters in the end.

They chose to add in his comeback after talking to editor Jeff Ford, who thought the cyclical storyline was best - and Stark's arc was made all the better for it.


5. The Snap Wasn't Supposed To Happen In Infinity War

Infinity War Thanos Snap
Marvel Studios

That's right - the defining moment of Infinity War and the ending that broke comic book movie nerds the world over wasn't actually originally written as such, since the screenwriters were unsure about where to drop their 'oh snap' moment. We could have had two very different movies, had one of the earlier drafts been chosen.

McFeely previously spoke to Empire to say that "We had so much story in those early drafts of Infinity War that, if anything, we thought we maybe shouldn’t do The Snap until the end of act one of Endgame." It's a crazy idea, and one that would fundamentally change the way these films work. We would have gotten more narrative build-up, yes, but at what cost? Infinity War wouldn't pack half the punch it does without sticking its neck out for that mind-blowing ending, and Endgame functions so well as it's a movie that came with that difficult wait where we didn't know what could possibly undo the traumatising finish.

Kevin Feige commented on the choice, saying: "We talked about that ending for years and years and years. It was the reason to adapt Infinity Gauntlet... What was the most shocking thing we could do? End the movie with The Snap."

Thank god they all saw sense.


4. There Was Almost A Giant Orgy... And Marvel TV Characters

Thor Natalie Portman
Marvel Studios

And aside from the Alexander Pierce cameo which they debated between Nicky Fury or Maria Hill, McFeely and Markus also toyed with giving smaller characters bigger parts, and where to fit them during the overarching threads of the story. Markus mused "There were moments, as they brought everybody back, where we’re like, technically, Michael Douglas and Michelle Pfeiffer have [Ant-Man] suits. Do we bring them back? It became impossible to track the people we did bring back, but also, it’s just going to be an orgy."

A giant superhero would have really been one way of doing it, but hey, we get what we're given.

Aside from that, the screenwriters mentioned the viability of including the Marvel TV characters too, but insisted it was far too much to expect the fans to have seen all the Netflix shows as well as the movies over the course of their lifespan, as well as it messing up their timelines. The idea is that they all got unceremoniously dusted and revived simultaneously with the movie counterparts, so there's no big loss on their end for anyone desperately wondering what happened to Luke Cage and company.

One last cameo seems the most differential though, where Thor was to have much longer scenes with Natalie Portman rather than dredging up archive footage for her bit part. However, Thor's inability to face Jane Foster works far more effectively for representing his mental state throughout Endgame, and seeing the touching conversation with his mother is a much better way of unpacking Thor's struggles instead.


3. The Final Battle Had A Few Tweaks

Avengers Endgame Captain America
Marvel Studios

Being one of the largest parts of the movie and the biggest set piece of Endgame, it's not particularly astonishing revelation that the final battle went through some work to get it to its finalised state. Originally, this sequence was going to be far longer and more intricate, with its own three-act arc played out through the battle.

There was even a two-minute pause for the heroes to regroup and devise a plan mid-fight, though the screenwriters felt that it was too unnatural to have 18 different people popping off a line each when they're supposed to be clobbering the outrider army. Christopher Markus quipped about the moment: "It also required them to find enough shelter to have a conversation in the middle of the biggest battle. It wasn’t a polite World War I battle where you have a moment."

Whilst this fight felt well-paced and the right length in the end, the screenwriters also didn't want to appear as if they were pandering to their audience - and almost cut the fantastic scene of the female superheroes banding together for fear of sending the wrong message in the finished piece. Luckily, they kept it in as they 'liked it too much', and wanted to celebrate the team-up nature of the Avengers in a wholesome way.

They've got cosmic entities, a billion different Iron Man suits, and a whole load of wonderful men at their disposal. Why not celebrate the badass women in the same way, too?


2. Professor Hulk Was Already Supposed To Be Introduced

Professor Hulk
Marvel Studios

Professor Hulk's debut was one of the biggest and best moments in Endgame, with Bruce Banner making peace with the large green lad living inside of him to become brains and brawn in one neat package. Discovering him living the life of a celebrity, Hulk has to wave away avid fans wanting to take his picture in a hilarious scene with poor, forgotten Antman vying for a bit of attention - though the filmmakers originally envisioned this scene a little differently.

Rather than appearing in Endgame, Professor Hulk was intended as an Infinity War feature, becoming his best self in Wakanda where he hammered out his 'performance issues'. "It was a lot of fun, but it came at the wrong moment. It was an up, right when everyone else was down," Markus said, with the pair writing in gene-splicing lab scenes before deciding the ride the whole scene out around Antman's 'I'm so confused' moment instead.

This seems to work much better, giving credence to the five year time gap and Bruce Banner's development without wasting time unnecessarily pushing him. There's space to come back and revisit his transformation if needed, but for what amounts to a jump-cut to this new and improved Hulk that he's been working on for years to figure out: they definitely did him comedy justice, and reflected fans equally impressed and mind-blown reactions.


1. Heimdall Vs Tony Stark And No Battle Of New York (2012)

The Avengers
Marvel Studios

With a sprawling back catalogue of movies, time zones, and Infinity Stone locations to choose from, the choices for Avengers: Endgame's time heist were practically endless - so the writing of the movie took some pulling together to pick the most perfect moments. Before we got the run down that we did however, there was talk of Tony Stark heading to Asgard in his stealth suit, forgetting there's one man who invisibility proves no obstacle for: Heimdall. That meant the pair would have to throw down across the Nine Realms for Mr Stark to get the stone back.

The screenwriters wanted to avoid being "too obvious" and "pander-y", which is why they opted for far more difficult scenarios in Asgard rather than just giving everyone what they wanted to see. McFeely stated: "In the first draft, we didn’t go back to the [original] “Avengers” movie," which is absolute madness.

Markus elaborated that the Avengers "went to the Triskelion at one point to get the [Tesseract], and then somebody was going to get into a car and drive to Doctor Strange's house." Even Morag was made far more complicated, with McFeely exclaiming "It was underwater!", but just quite what they were doing didn't seem right for the movie.

In the end, they overcame their qualms with going back to the first team-up film when Joe Russo pointed out they could just easily use the clearest option available to them to make it work. It all makes sense now, but we still really want to see whatever the hell would have gone on in the sea, to be honest.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Horror film junkie, burrito connoisseur, and serial cat stroker. WhatCulture's least favourite ginger.