Justice League Film: 5 Reasons Why It Will Fail
Fast-tracking a live action Justice League movie is a bad idea for Warner Bros., and here is why...
With Man of Steel on the horizon and The Dark Knight Trilogy now concluded, a Justice League movie seems like the next logical comic book film step for Warner Bros. Recent internet rumours have hinted at a possible 2015 release date, meaning it would most likely be the next superhero film at DC after Man of Steel. With the critical and commercial success of Marvel's The Avengers, the blueprint has been laid, and a Justice League of America movie is a great idea on paper. Like a dating website profile, however, looking good on paper does not always lead to wedding bells. Fast-tracking a live action Justice League movie is a bad idea for Warner Bros., and here is why...
5. Lack of Foundation
The summer of 2008 was a landmark year for comic book films. In May, June, and July of that year Iron Man, The Incredible Hulk, and The Dark Knight were released respectively. As important as The Dark Knight was for Warner. Bros., Iron Man meant even more to the future of Marvel Studios. While Warner had decades of experience releasing comic book films, Iron Man was Marvel's first movie as a standalone studio and its success or lack thereof would certainly impact the studio's future. If marijuana is a gateway drug, then Marvel Studios must have been higher than Tony Stark after he first tested the altitude limits of the Iron Man suit off the response of the film. Iron Man earned a 94% Rotten Tomatoes score - identical to that of The Dark Knight - and also went on to earn over $585 million worldwide. Iron Man's success proved that Marvel Studios could flourish with characters not named Peter Parker, and laid the groundwork for the films that would ultimately comprise the Marvel Cinematic Universe. That universe was the foundation that would generate the audience buy-in that was necessary for The Avengers to be the box office behemoth that it was. By comparison, a Justice League of America film would have no such foundation. Assuming the screenplay for the film includes the original seven members of the Justice League, only three members have had recent films: Superman, Batman, and Green Lantern. Unfortunately, none of those films are likely to factor in a JLA movie at all. Superman last appeared on screens in 2006's Superman Returns. Although it was financially successful, Warner Bros. did not feel it warranted an investment in a sequel with President of Production Jeff Robinov stating in 2008, "Superman Returns didn't quite work as a film in the way we wanted it to." Being that Batman retired at the end of The Dark Knight Trilogy, Christopher Nolan's interpretation of Batman will not be part of a JLA film either. Finally, Green Lantern was such a critical and commercial flop that Warner Bros. will probably cut ties with Ryan Reynolds' take on Hal Jordan also.
4. No Star Power
Since Man of Steel will likely be the only film to which Justice League will be directly attached, Henry Cavill may be the first actor cast. Can you name three other movies he's been in? If you can without researching it, kudos to you because I can't. The aforementioned Ryan Reynolds may not be recast, and Christian Bale has stated that he would only star in another Batman role if Nolan was attached; and Nolan has made it clear he has told his Batman tale and he is finished with it. Conversely, four of The Avengers had solo films (Iron Man, Captain American, Hulk, and Thor) not only allowing audiences to become more familiar with the characters, but also the actors. The only actor replacement was Mark Ruffalo as Hulk, and the Hulk is the one character where it really doesn't matter who the actor is because he is all CGI when in "costume." With no audience familiarity with the characters as they would appear in a JLA film or the actors who portray them, audience buy-in becomes extremely difficult and will rely heavily on marketing. This lack of any real star power makes marketing the film difficult, but another marketing concern is...
3. Who is the Leader?
Superman is clearly the leader of the Justice League, but for marketing purposes that may not work. Unless Henry Cavill can do what Robert Downey, Jr. did with his take on Iron Man, Warner Bros. will need an actor with whom they can market the film. The director of the Justice League film will have immense pressure to wisely cast the League member roles. Since there will be no test solo runs like there were for Eric Bana and Edward Norton who were ultimately replaced in The Avengers, the casting will be a one shot attempt. The results of miscasting have been seen in flops like Fantastic Four and Green Lantern. If the marketing department ultimately determines that having Cavill as the face of the film won't work, the next logical character to use to sell the film will be Batman. Assuming the film would have to start shooting sometime next year, it may be difficult to find a reputable actor willing to don the cape and cowl that is still damp with Bale's sweat. This then becomes...
2. The Batman Dilemma
The issue with finding an actor to portray Batman is only the start of the problems. As the Joker told Batman himself: "You've changed things, forever. There's no going back." The Dark Knight Trilogy pushed the Batman character ahead light years from where Joel Schumacher had him. There is no denying that any future take on Batman will be inferior to Nolan's vision. Batman's role in the Justice League is pivotal, and so he cannot be written out or minimized in the script. Because a recent take on the Caped Crusader was so groundbreaking, even a decent take on the character in a Justice League film may leave fans underwhelmed. There is a reason that The Godfather has never be remade, or that Scarface (1983) never had a sequel. Sometimes a take on a character is so definitive that any attempts to add on, re-imagine, or otherwise alter the previous incarnation will prove futile in the discerning eyes of fans. As a lover of all things film, and a huge fan of superhero movies it pains me to suggest to Warner Bros. that...
1. Comic Book Movies May Not Be the Way to Go
The comic book film world peaked with The Dark Knight. Warner Bros. was the fortunate studio that enjoyed the financial success of it, but it also bares the burden of having every subsequent comic book inspired film living in the shadow of it. Like a heroin addict trying to get back to that first high, Warner Bros. may try to duplicate the success of The Dark Knight, but are unlikely to do so, especially without Christopher Nolan's involvement. Similar to the aforementioned dating website profile, looking good on paper is not always enough. Sometimes it takes the hard realization that that profile may be a better match for someone else regardless how promising it looks. Even though they possess the film rights to much of the DC Universe, Warner Bros. should leave the team superhero films to the superhero movie studio. So if not comic book films, then what? Math has never been my strong suit, so I stick to very simple math problems; and I will employ that logic with my proposed solution: take the phrase 'comic book films' and just subtract the word 'comic.' Warner Bros. should instead focus its efforts for big budget tentpole movies on books. They have already enjoyed immense success from the Harry Potter films, and The Hunger Games again proved that films based on books - especially those for young adult readers - can be quite lucrative. With the popularity of the iPad people, including children, are reading a lot more. Books also offer the opportunities for studios to stretch stories far beyond a trilogy. Regardless of my thoughts, Warner Bros. will still make a Justice League film, and I'll be there at midnight on opening day to see it. I really hope it succeeds and that it is a fantastic movie. In full disclosure, I thought making an Avengers film was a bad idea at first, but I immensely enjoyed it. So just as a pre-Commissioner Gordon told Batman when he was taking out the trash in Batman Begins, "I've been wrong before."