Marvel Cinematic Universe: Phase 2 - Has It Been A Success So Far?

Marvel-Cinematic-Universe-P With Thor: The Dark World out in cinemas, Iron Man 3 still fresh in our minds, and Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. on the small screen on a (almost) weekly basis, phase 2 of the Marvel/Avengers project is in full swing. If anything, it's been a bigger roller-coaster ride than phase 1. Principal characters have been established. The events of New York in The Avengers have acted as a kind of catastrophic September 11th to this epic and always-growing universe. And "bigger and bolder" is certainly the motto at play now. Okay, so I'm writing this article as someone who loves superhero films and television, but doesn't actually read the comics. I know enough to know there have been some amazing characters and stories written over the years, but I just prefer my superheroes to be based on the screen. Whether it was Superman or Batman on film or animated shows like Spider-Man and X-Men on TV during the 1990s, this genre has always sparked my interest. I prefer to approach superhero films and television with a bit of a naive eye. I am really enjoying Arrow now; four episodes into its second season so far. I don't know where it is going, but I can have fun guessing. The same goes with the movies. I know titbits about the comics. I'm aware of Doctor Strange, for example, but I also appreciate that I know virtually nothing about Guardians Of The Galaxy. A walking, talking tree and a raccoon with a rocket launcher? Sign me up! I'm the superhero viewer who simply enjoys seeing the genre unfold before my eyes without background knowledge of every main plot or character. I'm very excited for X Men: Days Of Future Past. I'm intrigued by the rumours going on with Batman Vs. Superman. I'm looking forward to a whole host of Marvel shows on Netflix over the coming years. But you won't get the 'which villains should appear in future movies' or 'which classic comic story lines should be adapted next.' I'll leave that to the experts like WhatCulture's own Kev Stewart. This is an article from a fresh pair of eyes. As someone who loves the genre but doesn't know too much about the detailed comic history most of these stories are based on, how is Marvel's phase 2 shaping up for me? On the back of experiencing Thor: The Dark World at the cinema just a couple of days ago, let's take a look... PLEASE NOTE THIS ARTICLE CONTAINS SPOILERS FOR EVERYTHING AND ANYTHING MCU RELATED: PLEASE DON'T READ ON IF YOU'RE NOT UP TO DATE

Before Phase 2... How Was Phase 1?

IRON MAN Before phase 1 began, I was vaguely aware of who Iron Man was. I knew that Captain America was a big deal but knew little about his story. Thor was a god from Norse mythology. I probably knew the Hulk best. I had seen (and sorry - kind of enjoyed) Ang Lee's film version. But I knew him best from the Bill Bixby/Lou Ferrigno TV series from my childhood. The Avengers, well... I knew they were a superhero team-up, but that was it. So I really was stepping into entirely new territory with these films. It was the 'biggies' that myself and the majority of audiences were familiar with. Superman. Batman, Spider-Man - Iron Man had an incredibly tough job, then. It had to introduce mass audiences to what was probably acknowledged as a second-tier superhero (regardless of what he was in the comics). It was also one of the first films to link superheroes together. Get it wrong and the Avengers would start off on a rocky road. Get it right, and... Well, they got it right, didn't they? I bloody loved it! Everyone did! Robert Downey Jr. blew us away with his charm and wit. He wasn't all angsty or burdened with great responsibility. He played it like a very rich and very clever man who built a kick-ass suit and saved lives. What surprised me most was how much fun it was - and not in the forced fun way like in those mediocre Fantastic Four movies, either. It also started that grand tradition of post-credit teasers for what was to come. When Samuel L Jackson's Nick Fury came on screen, muttering those immortal worlds, the 'Avenger Initiative', my comic book-reading friends squealed with delight (yes - literally.) And I was hooked. The next film, The Incredible Hulk, actually passed me by at first glance... perhaps there wasn't enough hype about its connection to the Avengers to bring audiences in. Instead it made it into my 'list of films to watch', which are duly did before the release of Joss Whedon's superhero team up extravaganza. And it was quite good, if not up there with the magic of the other phase 1 films. Following this we had Iron Man 2. Sure, it was fun and it had some great action set pieces, but even I couldn't fail to notice that it was essentially one big advert for the Avengers rather than a fully developed sequel in its own right (thankfully, that came later). After Iron Man, Thor had a lot to prove. It was the first of the superhero films to be truly 'out there' and in all likelihood the first film to truly bring the Avengers franchise down if it failed. With its Shakespearian undertones (Kenneth Branagh was an inspired choice for director), otherworldly monsters and planet hopping adventures, it was certainly a far cry from the real world tones of Iron Man. But it worked. It worked brilliantly. Click "next" to continue reading...

Before Phase 2... How Was Phase 1? (Cont.)

Captain America 1 And that's in no small part to Chris Hemsworth's nuanced performance as Thor, taking a larger than life figure and making him believable. Of course, we were introduced to Tom Hiddleston, who stole (and continues to steal) every scene he is in as the villainous Loki. X Men First Class showed that a period setting for a superhero could work, and Captain America: The First Avenger was no exception. Again we had a performance with depth and heart from Chris Evans as the titular hero with some great moments in an unfamiliar superhero setting. And then to cap it all off (pardon the pun), we got the brilliant Joss Whedon to bring his unique brand of drama, humour and action in The Avengers (or Avengers Assemble over here in the UK just in case, God forbid, we confused it with the ham-fisted big screen remake of the acclaimed 1960s TV series). For me, it met all my expectations. A superhero team up has to be epic. The final battle of New York certainly delivered on that scale, and the four main stars all got their own great moments (and just how amazing was Mark Ruffalo?). I don't know how comic book aficionados found the movie but as someone who knew nothing of the rich history it came from, it certainly blew me away. Overall, Phase 1 was a bold experiment that succeeded and then some. With great casting and things us causal viewers had never witnessed before on film, it set the precedent for many more great things to come... not just in the Marvel cinematic universe, but for superhero movies as a whole. Click "next" to continue reading...

Iron Man 3: Back To The Beginning

ironman31 Once again, it was up to Robert Downey Jr.'s roguish hero to lead the charge and he certainly delivered. As I said before, Iron Man 2 was a bit of an enjoyable mess, which failed to find its own identity by becoming instead a stepping stone to the big movie that ended phase 1. Iron Man 3 needed to be its own film as well as the first sequel to The Avengers. But could it find the right balance? The horrors on New York hang over this movie just as they do over everything else that has followed it. Tony Stark's sleepless nights, his battle with the bottle, his struggle to find purpose... it's all as a result of that battle with the Chitauri. But it doesn't smother the plot. Instead, it serves as a springboard for Stark, a mirror of the events that occur when the Mandarin tears down his life (literally). It's a film about Tony Stark finding purpose again and defining who he is as a person. It truly feels like a worthy follow up to the events of Iron Man. And whilst I appreciate the anger of Mandarin fans, I loved the twist that came later. It's bigger. It's bolder. The final battle with the Extremist soldiers versus the various Iron Man suits adds a bigger scale to Stark's story.. .something that could easily felt flat after the battle of New York. The rescue of the passengers from Air Force One is simply spectacular. And that assault on Tony's beach house is as gripping as the trailer made it out to be. But what's more, it was fun. A lot of fun. From the great casting Ty Simpkins As Tony's young tell-it-like-it-is 'assistant' Harley, to the bromance between Stark and Rhodes... this is where Shane Black's magic really comes into its own. The man who wrote Lethal Weapon makes Iron Man 3 as much a buddy-cop movie as it is an action thriller. I left the cinema with a big smile on my face. As the first film in phase 2 it set the bar high. Bigger and better was definitely key.. .something we have seen (and I'm sure will see) as phase 2 continues. I think it's only fitting that Tony Stark started off phase 2 as he did phase 1. And if this is to be his last solo film out of the Avengers movies, then it certainly was a strong one to end on. A success, then? Absolutely - without a doubt, in fact. Click "next" to continue reading...

The Small Screen: Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D.

Shield The first foray into television, this is as much an experiment as, say, Guardians Of The Galaxy will be next year. Has it been a success? Well, with only six episodes under its belt, it's too early to tell. And I think people have to remember that it's early days yet. A lot of fans, myself included, had visions of another Buffy The Vampire Slayer or Firefly. With Joss himself helming the pilot, expectations were incredibly high and indeed, the next four episodes seemed weaker by comparison. The thing is, though, Joss is working executive producer - it's not a full-on Joss Whedon show. Writers like Marti Noxon. Jane Espenson. David Fury. They're not actually involved. And as such, this show should be considered on its own merits. The best comparison is probably Arrow - the first batch of episodes on that show were fun but had plenty of awkward moments. Oliver Queen's continuous, righteous voice over? Thank God Diggle got on board quickly so that the narration went out of the window. Still, Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. still needs to iron out a few quirks. The balance between humour, drama and action (something that Joss balances perfectly) is off. The characters need development. We don't have that spark between them that Firefly had from day one. Agent Ward needs to be more than just the action hero agent. Fitz and Simmons need to be more than just science geeks. Agent May needs to be more than just ambiguous and quietly dangerous. Skye needs to find her place on the team. Coulson. Well... he's great, isn't he? The other trouble is, after The Avengers, this version of S.H.I.E.L.D. is so much smaller... though is that really surprising? If you want a bigger budget, then you get a mini-series. Maybe 10 episodes, even, as with the likes Game Of Thrones. And perhaps there is an argument for quality over quantity. But with so many genre shows seemingly shorter and shorter in season length, I'm enjoying a fun superhero show that, like Arrow, last a full 22 episodes (and really Arrow is the most comparable show to this one). The episodes haven't been bad, exactly. They just haven't been great either. It speaks of a show finding its feet. A chance to introduce what I can only imagine are fun B-list villains and expand on the events that happen outside those big superhero battles. And this week, we get the Thor: The Dark World/Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D crossover. That could be a blast. Or it could be indicative of a show that is still trying to find its identity if it relies too much on the film and less on its own story. If the latest episode, 'F.Z.Z.T', is anything to go by, maybe we're getting there. By changing direction from a procedural story line to a personal central character driven piece I saw the magic for the first time. When Simmons jumped out of the plane just as Fitz realised there was a cure, I was stunned. This show had me gripped for the first time. I doubt this show can be properly measured until we hit the final run of episodes of season 1. Think back to Arrow again. Those final episodes. That season finale. That was bolder than I ever expected this show to be. And I am confident that Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. can get there, too. We just need to give it a little more time. Click "next" to continue reading...

Leaving Earth With Thor: The Dark World

Thor The Dark World 39445Thor: The Dark World. It absolutely encapsulates the mantra of phase 2, bigger and better to a T. It isn't really a superhero film as such. At least not until the whole 'Thor saves Earth during the battle with Malekith in London' in the final act. But it is a brilliant expansion of the story began by Kenneth Branagh back in 2011. The duties of the throne. The tenuous balance between a father and his two sons. Sibling rivalry. All those facets triumph here, making it a far more worthy sequel to Thor than Iron Man 2 was to Iron Man. The effects are stunning, the battles captivating. Director Alan Taylor brings his Game Of Thrones experience just as Branagh brought his Shakespearian drama to the franchise. It's something quite different. Lord Of The Rings meets Star Wars in the assault on Asgard and Loki's jailbreak. The love story between Thor and Jane Foster, something I felt a little weak in the last film is made stronger by her purpose in this film. The portal-hopping struggle between our hero and adversary is spell binding. Most of all, it's actually very funny... something that audiences might not have suspected when they saw the trailers or viewed the poster. Kat Denning's inappropriate intern Darcy (complete with intern of her own) adds a very human element to the events back on Earth, surprisingly being the one to get characters like Jane and Erik Selvig together. And of course, there are Erik's naked escapades at Stonehenge. My favourite but though has to be Thor hanging his hammer on the coat rack. Simple but very effective comedy. Chris Hemsworth continues to make Thor a fully three-dimensional character, creating a balance between the sense of loyalty and heroism, tempered with the 'fish out of water' humour we saw in his first on screen performance. But Tom Hiddleston steals every scene again as loyalty, not in his mischievous cunning and roguish behaviour but in the more dramatic moments, such as the loss of his mother Frigga. Thor: The Dark World will probably not be everyone's cup of tea. It's already doing much better than expected at the box office though it will unlikely do as well as Iron Man 3, which is going to attract broader audiences. But it does set the scene for wider adventures than audiences, like myself, will not have seen before in the superhero genre. A success, for sure. Click "next" to continue reading...

Is Phase 2 On Track And Where Is It Going Next?

Guardians_of_the_galaxy-Copy I think by now general audiences are familiar with the direction Marvel is going in. In a way, phase 2 has been an easy win. Three of the four pre-Avengers films are sequels. Regardless of the content, Iron Man 3, Thor: The Dark World and next year's Captain America: The Winter Soldier were/are going to get big audiences. It's easy money. Fortunately, two great films have ensured that Marvel hasn't lost its touch yet. If anything, they've both delivered on raising the stakes for our heroes and giving audiences more than they got in phase 1. The new trailer for Captain America: The Winter Soldier shows a new direction again, with a political action thriller that is vastly different from dark elves or super soldiers. It's actually the one that has me most excited. Can phase 2 fail? Well, it's unlikely. We'll need a few bad films for the franchise to fall apart. That being said, like Thor in phase 1, Guardians Of The Galaxy seems to be the most 'out there' film on the horizon. Positive reviews and big box office numbers have shown that Thor can still prove accessible even when so much of the story was set away from Earth. Let's see how that holds up next year with Guardians. And with Joss back for The Avengers: Age Of Ultron... frankly, I can't wait to see what he does next (and who he'll kill off because Joss... well, he's evil isn't he?). And as far that little TV show? I think the most it can be is disappointing. It's certainly the one element of phase 2 could fail to light up audiences. But as I said... we need to give it time and hope that it finds an identity of its own than outside of being just a TV spin off. In the meantime, let's keep watching. I like not knowing everything that is to come, though I can appreciate the buzz that comic book fans must feel when long-enjoyed characters finally make it to the big screen. I think phase 2 is definitely delivering, certainly on the film front and hopefully on the small screen. I'm certainly enjoying the ride. Are you? Feel free to comment below and let us know what you think.

Contributor
Contributor

A writer for Whatculture since May 2013, I also write for TheRichest.com and am the TV editor and writer for Thedigitalfix.com . I wrote two plays for the Greater Manchester Horror Fringe in 2013, the first an adaption of Simon Clark's 'Swallowing A Dirty Seed' and my own original sci-fi horror play 'Centurion', which had an 8/10* review from Starburst magazine! (http://www.starburstmagazine.com/reviews/eventsupcoming-genre-events/6960-event-review-centurion) I also wrote an episode for online comedy series Supermarket Matters in 2012. I aim to achieve my goal for writing for television (and get my novels published) but in the meantime I'll continue to write about those TV shows I love! Follow me on Twitter @BazGreenland and like my Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/BazGreenlandWriter