Oscars: A Look Back At The Films Of 2003

It's been said that time, above all else, is the best measuring stick when determining the worth of a movie. I've heard it suggested that the Academy Awards would be better served if they operated on a tilt of ten years, meaning if that were the case then this years awards, honoring the films of 2013, would actually serve to honor the films of 2003. This is a bold sentiment and while there's no real way this can or will happen, it's certainly fun to think about. When looking back ten years, many factors come in to play, the most notable of those is legacy. The way the system stands now, there can be, at best, only an assumption of legacy. If you went with a ten year scale, you'd get a much better look at exactly which films have held up better over time. Hell, you can even get a better perspective on individual performances within each film. I'm sure you've heard of the phrase, "ahead of its (or hers/his/their) time." This brings up a whole bunch of new possibilities. What performances have aged better than others? Maybe we see a director, ten years later, who's influenced cinema more than whoever took home that award ten years ago. What we're doing here, in honor of the impending ceremonies mind you, is outlining the six biggest categories of the Academy Awards. I'm talking the four acting categories, director and of course, Best Picture. We'll take a look at who was nominated, who won and whether or not time has possibly changed minds. I look forward to debating with you in the comments section so let's get started...

Best Supporting Actor - Tim Robbins (Mystic River)

Ten Years Ago: Tim Robbins took home the award for his role as Dave Boyle in Mystic River. He beat out Alec Baldwin's ruthless Shelley Kaplow in The Cooler, Benicio Del Toro's haunted Jack Jordan in 21 Grams, Djimon Hounsou's heartbreaking Mateo Kuamey in In America, and Ken Watanabe's honorable Katsumoto in The Last Samurai. Now: Ten years later and this group of actors holds up surprisingly well. Most notably, Ken Watanabe has used his Oscar nomination to carve out a pretty nice Hollywood career for himself. Does that mean he'd now win the award? I don't think so but there is something else to discuss here. There was a lot of talk ten years ago about Sean Astin's heroic Sam in Return Of The King and while many would look to see that "wrong" righted, I think history maybe has cooled on that a bit. However, Andy Serkis' cg performance as Gollum has only gained recognition. He went on to portray King Kong and Caesar in the Planet of the Apes reboot. He's solidified himself in the business as THE guy when it comes to creating cg characters. My guess is that he sneaks in with a nomination over Alec Baldwin or Benicio Del Toro. This is probably the biggest change because Tim Robbins is still going home with the award for his emotionally devastating performance as the haunted Dave Boyle in Mystic River.

Best Supporting Actress - Renee Zellweger (Cold Mountain)

Ten Years Ago: Renee Zellweger won for her role as Ruby Thewes in Cold Mountain. She beat out Shohreh Aghdashloo's pitiable Nadereh Behrani in House Of Sand And Fog, Patricia Clarkson's Cancer ridden Joy Burns in Pieces Of April, Marcia Gay Harden's shell shocked Celeste Boyle in Mystic River, and Holly Hunter's desperate Melanie Freeland in Thirteen. Now: The actress categories are difficult because Hollywood has, for too long, been more of a boys club. The scale of great roles for men vs women has, for the most part, been extremely skewed in the favor of the guys. We're beginning to see a welcome change in the last two or three years but that's a whole different article. I could see the likes of Emma Thompson or even Laura Linney sneaking in now for their underrated work in Richard Curtis' brilliant, Love Actually. I also found it very curious that Scarlett Johansson wasn't nominated for Lost In Translation. Maybe she was one of those in-betweeners where they couldn't decide whether she was a supporting player or lead. Whatever the reasoning, she got snubbed and my best guess is today she get in as a supporting actress. As far as Zellwegger winning for Cold Mountain in what I always viewed as not much more than a hammy, scenery chewing performance, time hasn't been that kind. With some perspective I think Shohreh Aghdashloo wins for her role in House Of Sand And Fog. She was truly a revelation in that film, giving such a soulful and quiet performance which are the types of performances that time is ALWAYS kind to.

Best Actor - Sean Penn (Mystic River)

Ten Years Ago: Sean Penn won for his role as Jimmy Markum in Mystic River. He beat out Bill Murray's melancholy Bob Harris in Lost In Translation, Jude Law's determined Inman in Cold Mountain, Ben Kingsley's uncompromising Massoud Amir Behrani in House Of Sand And Fog, and Johnny Depp's eccentric Jack Sparrow in Pirate's Of The Caribbean. Now: This category might see some of the biggest changes ten years later. First and foremost, Paul Giamatti gets in for his crazy brilliant turn as Harvey Pekar in American Splendor. The unfortunate soul getting left out is most likely Jude Law but there's no time for tears because Giamatti was just that good. The other big change would be in the actual winner. There's no one arguing Penn's merit here for his turn as the grieving, vengeful Jimmy Markum but I can't see how Bill Murray doesn't now win for Lost In Translation. Sofia Coppola's masterpiece has only gained acclaim over time and is the type of film that gets better and better with each viewing. What this does is give viewers additional insight into the individual performances and Bill Murray gave a performance for the ages. They hold the vote this year and Murray wins, hands down.

Best Actress - Charlize Theron (Monster)

Charlize Theron MonsterTen Years Ago: Charlize Theron won for her role as Aileen Wuornos in Monster. She beat out Keisha Castle-Hughe's not taking no for an answer Paikea Apirana in Whale Rider, Diane Keaton's coming out of her shell Erika Berry in Something's Gotta Give, Samantha Morton's soulful Sarah Sullivan in In America, and Naomi Watts' shattered Cris Peck in 21 Grams. Now: Again, we bring up the Scarlett Johansson question. Where does she fit for her role in Lost In Translation. I concluded she'd be up in the supporting category but so much of the film is seen through her eyes that it would be anyone's guess. The lead actress category is thinner and maybe she gets in over Keisha Castle-Hughes or Samantha Morton -- it's really a big question mark. Again, I think she gets considered a supporting actress which would leave this category largely unscathed. That is, unless the voters decided to nominate Uma Thurman for Kill Bill Volume 1. That's not entirely outside the realm of possibility but at the end of the day none of this matters because nobody is taking that statue away from Charlize Theron. Her performance/transformation as/into Aileen Wuornos is the stuff of acting legend. She took her career to a whole other level and easily wins again.

Best Director - Peter Jackson (The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King)

Ten Years Ago: Peter Jackson won for The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King. He beat out Sofia Coppola for Lost In Translation, Clint Eastwood for Mystic River, Fernando Meirelles for City Of God, and Peter Weller for Master And Commander: The Far Side Of The World. Now: I'll start by saying that Peter Jackson easily wins again. This was an award honoring his near ten year commitment to the once thought unfilmable trilogy he turned into the most honored trilogy in history. He wins again but there is a big change concerning the nominees. Peter Weir does not get nominated now. I'm sorry, Master & Commander is a fine movie but Chan-Wook Park gets nominated for Oldboy. In fact, there's a lot more that happens now with regards to Oldboy and the status Park has now achieved in the film community is because of that insanely brilliant film.

Best Picture - The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King

Ten Years Ago: The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King reigned supreme over the likes of, Lost In Translation, Mystic River, Master And Commander, and Seabiscuit. Now: The biggie and the one category where my own personal feelings are the most conflicted. I love The Lord Of The Rings and I'm not ashamed to admit that these films brought tears to my eyes. They represented my childhood playing out in front of me and will always hold a special place in my heart. With that said, I'd personally vote for Lost In Translation if that vote were held today and I was given a vote. I loved the movie back then, partly because of its excellence and partly because of the circumstances in which I saw it for the first time. Ok, quick story. My wife and I are newlyweds and celebrating her birthday in NYC by seeing Wicked on Broadway (Idina Menzel was still headlining, amazing) and afterword we snuck Champagne filled coke bottles into the movies to catch Lost In Translation on its opening weekend. One of the single best nights in my life. Back on task and ten years later I'm still married and still in love, both with my wife and Sofia Coppola's masterpiece. However, does it get everyone's vote? Probably not because of what Return Of The King represents. The biggest changes come in the other nominees. First, Master & Commander and Seabiscuit lose their nominations. The first and easiest to replace them is Fernando Meirelles' brilliant City Of God. Considering his best director nomination, I'd guess the film was already on the cusp. I also think either Oldboy or American Splendor get in here too. Oldboy, perhaps more than any other movie has been more highly regarded in the ten years since its release. Here's the biggest thing to consider now: We live in an age with up to ten nominees. I'm a big fan of the ten best picture nominees and think it should be a hard number. Ten, at least to me, is a much better representation of the year in film than five. Some would argue that it waters down what should be the celebration of the truly elite but I whole heartedly disagree. The winner is the celebration of the truly elite -- nominees are the celebration of what was great, what stood out. Ten is by no means a watered down number, not with the number of films released each calendar year. So now, with that in mind, here's the new and improved best picture nominees: Return Of The King, Lost In Translation, Mystic River, City Of God, Oldboy, American Splendor, Kill Bill Volume 1, Love Actually, Big Fish, Master & Commander. That's a pretty damn good representation of where film stood in 2003. Return Of The King still wins and I don't know how I feel about that but Lost In Translation closed the gap considerably and by God don't forget about Oldboy (he didn't forget about you).

Contributor
Contributor

I'm married and live in New York with my wife and pets. I'm a writer and definitely not a comedian (just ask my wife). I've successfully linked my twitter, goodreads, facebook and google+ pages although the successful aspect of all that is up for debate. I also started my own blog on wordpress and have just finished my first novel, The Violent Winds. Now it's time to try and trick some unsuspecting fool into buying it.