Sigourney Weaver: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

There's more to life than killing xenomorphs...

Frequently referred to as being the 'queen of sci-fi', Sigourney Weaver's reputation for playing the no-nonsense, steel-willed Ripley in the Alien franchise has led to the actor being recognised as one of the first and greatest lead female characters in any film series. Weaver's starring role in the original Alien not only cemented her fame among fans of science fiction though, her performance, along with Ridley Scott's directorial prowess directly contributed to the genre becoming a mainstream one. Ripley is undoubtedly Weaver's most famous role to date, but it's certainly not her only one, and it's all too easy easy to overlook some of her other equally brilliant performances due to the massive shadow cast by the xenomorph horde. The characters of Dana Barrett in Ghostbusters and Grace Augustine in Avatar both continued Weaver's successful status as a science fiction icon, but the genre is by no means the only one Weaver should be known for. Films like Copycat and Heartbreakers proved that Weaver isn't just a one-tick pony, with the former having her play an agoraphobic criminal profiler and the latter one part of a mother-daughter con artist team. There's certainly no shortage of critically and commercially successful films starring Weaver, and unlike many actors in Hollywood today, her great films far outweigh the bad. Weaver's record isn't spotless though, there's certainly some stinkers that are present on her large filmography. Nobody has a perfect work record, but Sigourney Weaver certainly has one of the greatest ones you'll ever see. To celebrate her return to working with Ridley Scott in his latest movie Exodus: Gods & Kings, Weaver becomes the latest candidate in our 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked series;

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Dr. Grace Augustine - Avatar (2009)

The highest-grossing film of all time, Avatar follows a human corporation's attempts to rob a distant planet of its natural - and very valuable - resources. However, the world in question is home to an indigenous and sentient species called the Na'vi who have made their home on top of the resource that the humans are trying to gather. Queue a narrative about foreign invasion that many have compared with Disney's Pocahontas. Cameron's film may not have the most original story to have ever graced a cinema screen, but there's no denying that the acting talent involved with the film is of a very high degree. It's obvious from the very first introduction of Weaver's character that she relished the opportunity to play Augustine - a woman who's outward toughness is matched only by her inner compassion for her colleagues and the preservation of nature. Weaver brings many of the personality traits that made Ripley so interesting to Avatar, including the hard-faced persona, and her performance in Avatar is certainly one of the best the film has to offer. Under-appreciated and overlooked given the other giant successes of Avatar, Weaver's performance here stands tall among the others on this list.

4. Helen Hudson - Copycat (1995)

A criminal profiler that suffers from chronic agoraphobia due to a prior incident, Weaver's performance as Helen Hudson in Copycat could easily be forgotten when glancing at the actor's filmography. However the psychological crime thriller and indeed Weaver's performance is the biggest uncovered treasure that so few people reading this have probably seen. When a new spate of murders start happening in her home-town, Weaver's Hudson finds herself in the situation of being a reluctant consultant for the police in an effort to solve the growing number of murders. Confined to her apartment and finding herself becoming part of the murderous plot of the serial killer, Weaver's performance as an anxious and reluctant criminal profiler is a treat to watch. The feelings of isolation and hopelessness that Weaver displays as her character pull you in almost immediately and you won't be able to rest until the film reaches its satisfying conclusion.

3. Dana Barrett - Ghostbusters (1984)

Forget about those silly romantic comedy films, Bill Murray's constant attempts at wooing Dana Barrett (Weaver) as Dr. Venkmen in Ghostbusters forms one the greatest love stories ever written. Okay, so that's obviously a barefaced lie, but the comedy chemistry on display between both Sigourney Weaver and Bill Murray's characters in the science fiction comedy is what's missing in most modern movies today. It's Weaver's dual performance as the reserved, everyday Dana Barrett and as the flamboyant, seductive demon Zuul though, that truly makes her talent shine in Ghostbusters and makes it hard to imagine anyone else playing the part with as much energy or guile as her. With the personalities of non-possessed Dana and possessed Dana being at completely opposite ends of the spectrum as far as their behaviour is concerned, the film gave Weaver the freedom to show audiences that she wasn't just an actor content on being famous for one role.

2. Dian Fossey - Gorillas In The Most: The Story Of Dian Fossey (1988)

Gorillas In The Mist, a true-to-life film adaptation of Dian Fossey's life-long devotion to the protection of Gorillas is both heart-warming and horrifying in the events that it depicts. Sigourney Weaver's role of playing Fossey on-screen is frequently cited as being an example of perfect casting due to the actor's reputation as playing stern, strong female leads: traits which the real Fossey was known for. Gorillas In The Mist is perhaps the single greatest piece of proof that Weaver isn't and shouldn't only be known for her reputation as the 'Sci Fi Queen'. Weaver never puts a foot wrong in Gorillas In The Mist, and her portrayal of Fossey helped audiences the world over to understand one of history's greatest anthropologists. While certain aspects of Fossey's life were toned down and left open to interpretation in the film, the minor inaccuracies do nothing to subtract from Weaver's expert portrayal of a woman that valued animal life above her own.

1. Ripley - Alien/Aliens (1979)

Despite the constant references to Sigourney Weaver's versatility outside of her reputation as a science fiction icon, there's just no getting away from the fact that Alien is still, by a country mile, the film that garnered Weaver the most critically acclaim and recognition across the globe. Alien is a film so ingrained in the history of film, critical analysis and popular culture that it barely needs any explanation or introduction. As part of a skeleton crew aboard the Nostromo in deep space, Ripley is just one of several crew members that gain the dubious honour of being the first to encounter the xenomorph species. As her crew mates are gradually dwindled down to zero, Weaver's Ripley becomes progressively courageous steel-willed in an effort to survive the xenomorph's rampage. Alien has not only been subject to analysis from an endless amount of theorists, but it also firmly established both the horror genre and the female lead as mainstream ideas. Many may argue that any female actor could have filled that role, but it's impossible to imagine anyone other than Sigourney Weaver filling such an iconic role.

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Rex Brooks - Vantage Point (2008)

Vantage Point follows a terrorist plot to assassinate the President of the United States in the middle of a summit held in Spain, that's told through the lens of several eye witnesses. The particular gimmick of the movie is the movie spends a dedicated time unfolding the events from one vantage point before the film 'reboots' its own narrative and starts again from a different perspective in an effort to reveal more around the events of the supposed assassination attempt. With an all-star cast and an intriguing premise bolstering the film's narrative, Vantage Point looked to be a unique thriller that could have stolen 2008 from its genre rivals. Sadly, it didn't. Constantly retreading the same events over and over again became tiring by the fifth reset, and while the film does a good job of ratcheting up the tension the first time around, each subsequent reset becomes less and less interesting. Besides that though, Sigourney Weaver's character Rex Brooks, a news channel producer, is so underused that it feels almost criminal to have such a good actor sidelined to a rather dull role. Weaver's character has the honour of being the vessel for the first viewpoint, but rather than give her some interesting scenes, dialogue or character interaction, all audiences get are some static scenes of her shouting down a microphone giving orders to other reporters. She wasn't the only big name actor totally wasted in Vantage Point but that doesn't make the performance's place on this list any less deserving.

4. Ripley - Alien: Resurrection (1997)

"Better than Alien 3 but worse than the first two." The above is the consensus on Alien 4 that most fans of the original films usually come to, and while Resurrection certainly did many things better than its predecessor, it certainly wasn't great. Set 200 years after the events of Alien 3, the iconic character of Ripley reappears after her death at the end of Alien 3. Through the use of cloning, Ripley is resurrected with the curious side effect of her sharing traits with the xenomorphs that she hates so very much due to the alien embryo she had inside her at the end of the previous film. Queue an almost two-hour-long film that uses such an explanation to give Ripley an entirely new personality and audiences some unnecessarily gory and over-the-top scenes involving the most violent extraterrestrials in cinema history. On the one hand, watching Sigourney Weaver relish her opportunity to let loose with a character she made famous is extremely enjoyable to watch, but on the other, Ripley's new personality is the complete opposite to what audiences know and love her for and it just didn't work. The presence of alien blood in her system if a poor explanation, and the entire film as a whole reeks of being a desperate attempt to cash-in one last time on a franchise that has gone from genre defining to utter disaster.

3. Dr. Geraldine Bennett - Abduction (2011)

Aside from Abduction being a permanent stain on Taylor Lautner's show-reel for the rest of his life, the 2011 film has almost nothing worthwhile within it to make it recommendable it anyone. However cynical the viewpoint may be, Abduction's box office takings were probably largely due to Twilight fans making it their mission to watch anything with Lautner in it. But it wasn't just the revelation that Lautner wasn't skilled enough to be a leading man that made Abduction awful to watch. Aside from some cringeworthy dialogue and forced emotions, the supporting cast for Abduction weren't up to scratch either. A phoned-in performance, Weaver plays a former CIA agent and psychiatrist that carries no believability. In truth, Weaver probably never stood a chance here with a character so poorly written and with so little depth that the performance was always likely to end up on this list. It was clear the screenwriters of Abduction had one job and that was to make it work as a Taylor Lautner vehicle. Everything else just didn't matter.

2. Ramona Clark - You Again (2010)

You Again is a type of film not usually associated with Sigourney Weaver. Normal, everyday life, bitchy women and a dull script are all things scarcely found in the same place as the actor, but You Again features them all. As part of an ensemble cast, Weaver plays Ramona Clark, the former best friend of Gail (Jamie Lee Curtis), and a woman jealous of her old 'bestie' having always outshone her in their high school years. Intriguing casting given their respective genre statues as the horror and sci-fi scream queens of their eras. Sadly, Weaver's performance as Ramona never feels quite authentic in the role of an ordinary woman, and while she certainly can play such a character (Copycat, Red Lights), the shoe never quite seems to fit in You Again.

1. Ripley - Alien 3 (1992)

The Alien franchise is an oddity for Sigourney Weaver: the iconic series features some of her best performances and remarkably some of her worst. Alien: Resurrection was a sequel that showed promise and a certain love for the franchise, but its predecessor Alien 3 never even exhibited the faintest glimmer of hope in regards to being a great continuation of the series. Its premise was nonsensical, forced and extremely coincidental, and the setting was duller than a rusted blade. Weaver's performance is easily the the star's weakest turn as the unlucky Ripley and sadly the most disappointing performance in her whole filmography. You could argue she has worst performances in her filmography but after the sheer awesomeness of her Ripley role in Aliens 1 and 2, this one is easily the most criminal and such wins the unwanted prize of her worst role. Are there any films starring Sigourney Weaver that you love or hate that aren't featured here? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a freelance games journalist who, while not spending every waking minute selling himself to websites around the world, spends his free time writing. Most of it makes no sense, but when it does, he treats each article as if it were his Magnum Opus - with varying results.