X-Men: 10 Massive Questions About Its Confusing Canon

Does anything from the original trilogy still count?!

The continuity of the X-Men franchise has always been a cause for debate and confusion. Even before Fox started making spin-offs and prequels and playing around with multiple timelines, there was still niggling little errors, such as that hairless version of Hank McCoy who showed up in the background of X-Men 2 before appearing as Kelsey Grammer and covered in hair in X-Men: The Last Stand. It€™s a tiny detail, but one that fans noticed. As the demand for superhero cinema continued to grow, Fox carried on making errors. Audiences had to try and make sense of two conflicting accounts of Wolverine getting his powers (X-Men Origins: Wolverine and X2 didn€™t exactly match up), multiple other characters being recast, and lines of dialogue that contradicted previously established events. And now, the double-bill of X-Men: Days Of Future Past and Deadpool have both thrown caution to wind: the former by rewriting the canon and the latter by ignoring continuity altogether (and even pointing out how 'confusing' the timelines have become). There are still these massive questions, though, which the franchise needs to address€

10. Which Sabretooth Counts, Or Are They The Same?

Back in the year 2000, Tyler Mane portrayed Sabretooth in X-Men, the founding film of this franchise. There was no mention of him being Wolverine€™s brother - he fought with Hugh Jackman€™s Logan on a few occasions, but the film never hinted at a familial connection between the two - and he communicated mostly through grunts. This would cause a lot of head scratching when the character reappeared a few years later. In 2009, Liev Schreiber was cast as Sabretooth in X-Men Origins: Wolverine. This prequel version was definitively Wolverine€™s brother, was intelligent enough to speak, and forged a fierce rivalry with Logan. Towards the end of the film, they formed a tentative alliance to stop Stryker€™s latest creation before going their separate ways afterwards. Fans were left puzzled by what this meant for Tyler Mane€™s version? Is he still canon, or is everyone just meant to forget that this vastly different version of the character ever existed? Some believe that Mane and Schreiber€™s versions are actually one and the same, and that Sabretooth somehow lost his memory and was transformed into a more bestial form between Origins and X-Men. However, this theory doesn€™t account for the fact that Schreiber €“ not Mane €“ has apparently been approached for a role in The Wolverine 3 (which is believed to be set in the far-flung future, a la Old Man Logan).

9. WTF Happened To Colossus?

2014€™s X-Men: Days Of Future Past and 2016€™s Deadpool include totally different versions of Marvel Comics metal man Colossus. When Daniel Cudmore - who played Colossus across four X-Men movies - refused to sign up for Deadpool, Fox just went ahead and made a different iteration of the character (which took 5 people to create via CGI). Daniel Cudmore€™s appearance as a teacher at the end of Days Of Future Past suggests that his svelte and not-massively-Russian version of the character is still canon, although the CGI Colossus of Deadpool stakes just as big a claim by popping up throughout the movie and attempting to recruit Deadpool. He looks and sounds nothing like Cudmore, but he€™s the most recent version of Colossus to appear in cinemas, and in X-Men it always seems like new is always better. Again, is this ginormous, CGI and very-Russian Colossus somehow meant to be an older version of Cudmore€™s character, even though there€™s barely any resemblance between the two? Did he just work out a lot and get a new voice-box/face? It doesn€™t seem like Fox will ever give fans an answer, which is a little bit infuriating if you€™re a real stickler for continuity.

8. Where Does Deadpool Fit?

Speaking of Deadpool, there€™s a bit of a question mark hanging over the film in terms of where it actually fits in relation to the X-Men franchise€™s overarching narrative. The film itself pokes fun at this predicament, with Ryan Reynolds€™ character at one point asking whether the current Professor X looks like €˜McAvoy or Stewart€™, because the timeline has gotten €˜so confusing€™. The film gives no answer to this question, and uses humour to deflect it instead. This, of course, is exactly what you€™d expect from Wade Wilson, the wisecracking Merc With The Mouth. But, I think we can determine when the film takes place, if not what the main X-Men look like at the time; the film seems to be set in the modern day of 2016, placing it seven years prior to Wolverine waking up in 2023 at the end of X-Men: Days Of Future Past. Deadpool, then, must take place in the rebooted timeline enabled by the events of Days Of Future Past, in which the Sentinels never took over the planet and Xavier's school thrived. X-Men: Apocalypse takes place in 1983, meaning that the First Class iterations of the core cast (McAvoy, Fassbender, Lawrence et al) have a long way to go until they catch up to Deadpool. As to whether McAvoy or Stewart was occupying the X-Mansion during the events of Deadpool, it doesn€™t really matter. Nobody outside of Fox's inner sanctum will ever know for sure, unless a future film attempts to clarify the timeline in a clearer way.

7. What Remains Of Wolverine's Backstory?

Wolverine€™s backstory was explored in depth in both X-Men 2 and X-Men Origins: Wolverine. Although those films don€™t perfectly mirror each other, they at least agree on the basic facts that Hugh Jackman€™s Logan was experimented on by William Stryker, who endowed him with an Adamantium skeleton and wiped him of his memories as part of the Weapon X programme. However, the events of X-Men: Days Of Future Past saw the Wolverine of 2023 sending his mind back to 1973, a time when he still had bone claws and hadn€™t yet been subjected to Stryker's experiments. And €“ judging by the scene at the end of the film when Mystique poses as Stryker and rescues 1973 Wolverine from the riverbed €“ there€™s a chance that he never will be. So, how much of the established Wolverine backstory still stands? Does this 1973 version of Wolverine remember all the details of his past, including his childhood, his brother Sabretooth, and all the battles that they fought together during the early scenes of X-Men Origins: Wolverine? Wouldn't these memories make him a rather different man to one that audiences got to know in the original trilogy? Perhaps X-Men: Apocalypse or The Wolverine 3 will provide some answers to these questions. In the meantime, another big one has presented itself€

6. Does €˜Other Deadpool€™ Still Exist?

The events that took place in the gap between 1973 Wolverine being saved from the riverbed and 2023 Wolverine waking up at X-Mansion remain a mystery for upcoming films to fill in. However, you€™d think that the pre-1973 events that were established in earlier movies would still count, given that nothing has erased any of this.

This would include the Vietnam War (which was waged from 1955 to 1975, in real life), which Wolverine fought in during X-Men Origins: Wolverine. He got sent to the firing squad during the conflict, and was subsequently recruited by William Stryker for Team X. He was then introduced to some new friends, including a certain wisecracking assassin called Wade Wilson.

So, when Ryan Reynolds turned up as a new version of this character in 2016€™s Deadpool, some viewers may have had questions. Wasn't there already a Wade Wilson in the X-Men universe, who must have been born in like the 1950s if he was old enough to know Wolverine the 1970s? Does the original movie Deadpool still exist within the canon?

The short answer to this one is a big fat no. The original Wade Wilson no longer counts. Lauren Shuler Donner said at the premiere of Days Of Future Past that fans should €œJust forget about X3 and the first Wolverine€™. In terms of whether anything from Origins still counts, then €“ probably not.


5. What€™s The Deal With Professor X€™s Paralysis?

Fox€™s lax approach to continuity means that James McAvoy€™s Charles Xavier was crippled in 1962 during X-Men: First Class, despite the fact that fans had already seen Patrick Stewart€™s version walking around during a 1980s flashback scene from X-Men: The Last Stand and the final moments of X-Men Origins: Wolverine (which must take place around 1980 as well). €œMcAvoy or Stewart?€ gets a big laugh in Deadpool, but €œIs he still walking or not?€ would be just as difficult a question for Fox and their scriptwriters to answer. They tried to remedy this error somewhat in Days Of Future Past by introducing the idea of a drug that could cure Charles€™ paralysis but dampens his mind-reading powers in the process. This doesn€™t really solve the problem at all, though, as Charles walks and uses his telepathy in quick succession in both The Last Stand and Origins: Wolverine (consequently, the fact that Hank created a power-dampening drug back in the 1970s renders the whole €˜mutant cure€™ thing from 2006€™s The Last Stand a little moot... couldn't Rogue just use that drug and not have to choose between Bobby and her powers?). The question of when Charles was actually permanently wheelchair-bound is sure to be answered in X-Men: Apocalypse. But fans will probably never get an explanation €“ besides €˜the original trilogy are in an irrelevant timeline now, so it doesn€™t matter€™ €“ as to why Stewart€™s version of Charles was able to walk and use his powers simultaneously in the 1980s.

4. Can The Original Characters Die?

Wolverine wakes up in 2023, and everything is hunky dory. Jean Grey is alive again, as is Scott Summers. Rogue and Bobby are holding hands, while Colossus and Kitty Pryde teach a class. Storm and Charles are safe, too, even though they can€™t remember the events of the movie. This was a lovely little scene for fans of the original X-Men trilogy, but it also raised some big questions€ If Wolverine has met these characters in 2023, does that mean that their future is set in stone? Are Jean and Scott et al safe from ever dying, because Wolverine already knows where they€™ll end up? Wouldn€™t that be a bit rubbish (think: Star Wars prequels), knowing what happens to all the characters? According to director and franchise founder Bryan Singer, fans needn€™t worry. "What I€™m doing with these in-betweenquels is playing with time€™s immutability and the prequel concept, meaning that yes we erased those storylines and anything can happen," he told Collider during the production of X-Men: Apocalypse. €œI€™ll kill any of those characters any day I want. They€™re all fair game€, he promised, discussing the characters glimpsed in 2023 at the end of Days Of Future Past. It€™s still possible to €œupset the timeline€, he teased, meaning that X-Men: Apocalypse€™s new versions of Jean, Scott and Storm can still face mortal danger. Well, following continuity hasn't been his best skill thus far.

3. Does Any Of The Wolverine's Post-Credits Scene Make Sense?

The Wolverine€™s post-credits sting threw up a load of questions, which fans had expected to see answered in Days Of Future Past: How has Magneto got his powers back? How is Charles alive again? And, if Charles mind-swapped into his twin brother€™s body as teased in The Last Stand, how come he€™s crippled again? Somewhat flippantly, Days Of Future Past ignored all of these questions and just jumped forward a few years to an age where Bolivar Trask€™s robotic inventions (which were also teased in The Wolverine€™s stinger) ruled the Earth and had killed almost everybody. Fans never got see how this transpired, or why Charles and Erik went looking for Wolverine so many years before deciding to send him back in time. That airport doesn€™t look like a very post-apocalyptic landscape, does it? And the €˜going back in time€™ idea only came up at the very last minute, multiple years into the future. In another weird little continuity error, Future Wolverine of Days Of Future Past has metal claws, even though the version that met up with Charles and Erik at the end of The Wolverine had bone claws (after having the metal sucked from his system by that giant Silver Samurai. When and how did he get his Adamantium skeleton back? Nobody knows, and perhaps Fox will never both explaining. They often don€™t, after all...

2. Why Did Charles Never Mention Mystique Before?

Over the course of the original X-Men trilogy, Charles Xavier was the leader of the X-Men while Mystique was a henchwoman to Magneto and his Brotherhood Of Evil Mutants. In these three movies, nobody mentioned once that Mystique had once been Charles€™ best friend and that they€™d known each other since childhood. However, this was established as canon very quickly within Matthew Vaughn€™s prequel X-Men: First Class. As soon as this friendship was established in First Class, fans began asking €“ why did neither of them ever mention this before? The obvious, real-world answer is that Bryan Singer had never intended to play Charles and Raven as former friends when making the original X-Men movies. Matthew Vaughn and the other writers of First Class must have come with the idea, leaving Singer to ret-con wildly when the time came to mesh the two iterations of the franchise together in Days Of Future Past. He included a line for Patrick Stewart to say (€œRaven was a dear friend of mine€ I drover her away€), allowing the whole story to retroactively fit together, if you squint a bit and forget about every previous movie. Many fans get peeved by the inconsistent use of superpowers in Days Of Future Past (Mystique's DNA being useful for absorbing powers, while Kitty can now send minds in time... both brand new powers they'd never displayed before), but in the shoehorning in of a friendship for Charles and Raven peeves me more, personally.

1. Does The Original Trilogy Still Matter In The Slightest?

Three whole movies €“ X-Men, X2 and X-Men: The Last Stand €“ were seemingly wiped out by X-Men: Days Of Future Past€™s timeline resetting finale. Only Wolverine can remember the events of these movies, leaving Charles, Jean, Scott, Storm and all the other original teammates without any established backstories or character development. Also, for fans, this resulted in a big question €“ do those original three movies still matter at all? Not really, I€™d argue; within the context of franchise continuity, they don€™t really matter at all. Wolverine 3 could see Logan as the nearly-last man standing in a global wasteland €“ allowing him time to reflect on his previous adventures €“ but after that, I wouldn€™t be surprised if the original trilogy were never overtly referenced within the canon of the series again. The main X-Men franchise has moved on to Apocalypse and recast the likes of Jean and Scott. This allows Fox to have another stab at these characters, and they might even dust off old storylines like the Phoenix saga (which Brett Ratner adapted to very little fanfare in The Last Stand). It€™s a shame, really. X-Men and X2 got a whole lot of fans hooked on this franchise, and they€™ll soon fade into complete insignificance. All because Fox couldn€™t hold a coherent continuity together and had to reboot instead. Which X-Men continuity issue riles you the most? Let us know in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

Film & TV journo. Quite tall.