10 More Things Today's Gamers Wouldn’t Understand

contrPlease Note: This is a sequel article to a previous What Culture classic written by Rob Beames. You should check that out article first before reading this one! I don€™t like the phrase €œgamer€, because it reminds me of some dude calling himself a €œmusician€ because he plays crappy Led Zeppelin covers in his bedroom. I also don€™t like the phrase €œWouldn€™t Understand€ because it€™s condescending and inaccurate. That being said, I think it's important that the current generation of gamers understand the roots of the industry they're giving millions of dollars to. Just like that guy playing guitar in his room, if you don't make an effort to understand the history of the material, you're doing a disservice to those who pioneered the craft. Here are ten trends in modern gaming that are problematic, flawed, and detrimental to the video game environment. As a point of reference, I would like to mention that I was born in mid-1990, and my first memory of playing a video game involved beating goons over the head with trash cans in River City Ransom on an NES emulator in 1996.

10. Health Didn't Always Regenerate

Back in ye olde days of video games, the player was responsible for taking care of their character. Mario needed a carefully measured running start to execute a jump with an ideal trajectory; Link mowed entire acres of grass with his sword looking for hearts; Solid Snake had to scavenge every inch of an abandoned laboratory in order to find a single Ration that would allow him to breathe comfortably until the next firefight broke out. Nowadays, thanks to Halo€™s invention of the €œovershield€ concept, players are encouraged to be lazy about health management. Did a sniper just tear a structurally superfluous hole in your abdomen? Did you just take a rocket-propelled grenade to the teeth? No problem. Hang out behind a rock for ten seconds and you€™ll be fit as a fiddle.

h3F896538

Health regeneration is problematic because it reduces the sense of urgency that makes video games so fun. If your most pressing issue is that you need to find a tree to hide behind while all your wounds heal like you€™ve got an adamantium skeleton, what€™s the point in having a battle plan? Just run in, take out as many faceless thugs as possible, and duck behind some foliage when your screen starts turning red. It makes sense in puzzle games like Portal. You're not meant to keep track of resources like ammo or health, you're supposed to be focusing on getting across a room. But twisting your ankle after hurtling through a trans-dimensional wormhole and needing a breather to regain your composure is much more believable than taking a hollow-point .45 round to the gut and being right as rain seven seconds after the bullet leaves your spleen.

9. Great Graphics Can't Fix Weak Gameplay

I don€™t have a problem with great graphics. I would be a stupid fool if I refused to play any game that featured fancy-pantsy polygons instead of good old-fashioned 16-bit pixel art. But in a world where breathtaking, hyper-realistic graphics are de rigeur, people are forgetting that great graphics aren€™t required to make a great game. The most recent iteration of Tomb Raider is gorgeous. Crystal Dynamics did a superb job of creating beautiful environments, characters, and cutscenes. But did I think the game was fun? Not really. I thought it was repetitive and scatterbrained, not to mention it implemented the dreaded health regeneration technique I mentioned previously. (For a researcher who€™s never had anything bad happen to her, Lara Croft can sure take a machete to the throat like a champ). I had an infinitely better time playing Animal Crossing for the Nintendo Gamecube, which I still boot up every once in a while.
This has a lot to do with personal preference. Regardless, even though Tomb Raider had a larger budget, a bigger development team, and the luxury of being a part of a celebrated franchise, Animal Crossing (which was initially in development for Nintendo€™s aging N64 console before being quickly tuned up and slapped on the Gamecube) provided a much more memorable experience for me.
Is it sad that I remember that Tom Nook pays 3,000 Bells for a Red Snapper? Probably. But the fact that I connected so deeply with Animal Crossing and not a Triple-Distilled, Grade-A, Premium-Cut cash cow like Tomb Raider proves that sometimes graphics and performance should take a backseat to solid, cohesive gameplay.

8. Hype Can Be A Bad Thing

Duke3DBLOG--article_image I like to pretend I have an eclectic, esoteric taste in video games. But that's a lie. For every obscure video game I have on my shelf, there's a massively successful heavy hitter next to it. I mean, Katamari Damacy is sandwiched in between Grand Theft Auto and Portal 2, for Pete's sake. I'm a victim of hype just like anyone else. Sometimes I end up really liking the game (Bioshock Infinite, Borderlands 2), but most of the time it's $60 thrown out the window (Marvel vs. Capcom 3, Resident Evil 6). The problem with hyping up a video game is that for every budget-busting, live action TV advertisement, people ascribe value to that product. "Wow," they think, "this game is everywhere. It must be really awesome!". This isn't always the case. Remember Duke Nukem Forever? People waited more than a decade for this game, and as the release date drew closer, he had full-spread magazine ads, life-sized cardboard cutouts, and commercials on primetime television. But the game itself didn't even come close to living up to the expectations fans had drawn for it based on the publicity generated by ad campaigns. The new Tomb Raider fell victim to this same over-hype/under-performance situation that killed Duke Nukem. It was critically acclaimed and moved 3.4 million units during the first month of its release, giving developer Crystal Dynamics their most profitable launch in the history of the company. And yet, it failed to meet the projected 5 million units. Predicting a huge quarterly loss, Yoichi Wada resigned as the CEO of Square Enix, a position he had held for 13 years. In essence, hype is a toss up. It can either drum up excitement to boost sales or create expectations that simply can't be lived up to. As the old saying goes, "Any publicity is good publicity". Well, yeah, I guess. But watch how long it takes to alienate a fanbase when you tell them you're selling them a diamond when it turns out to be a pile of crap.

7. Games Don't Need To Be Hundreds Of Hours Long

Skyrim I think I played Fallout 3 and Fallout: New Vegas for a combined total of 400 hours or so. I logged another 100 in Skyrim. That's a downright embarrassing amount of time to spend doing something that's fundamentally useless. While I was playing them, a correlation occurred in my mind that went something like this: €œI€™ve spent so much time playing these games, they must be in my Top 5 favorite games of all time!€ Only after I had distanced myself from those games did I realize that in reality, those games really weren€™t going to displace Skies of Arcadia or EarthBound in my Top 5. The only reason I had spent so many hours in-game is because I€™m a neurotic completionist, and I wouldn€™t stop until I€™d found every damn bobby pin in all of New Vegas. I wasn€™t playing because I was genuinely enjoying myself, but rather just because it was there. It€™s like a fat guy at a restaurant who was full 6 or 7 bites ago, but feels the compulsion to clean his plate because there€™s still food on it, even though he€™s damaging his body.
Games brag about play hours all the time. Skyrim boasted about having over 300 hours of playtime. I made the most of those hours, but at the end of the day, it was just another predictable story with forgettable characters. Not only that, but I was doing the same thing over and over again. It got to the point where I could walk into a dungeon, discern which bodies on the floor were going to jump up and attack me, and plug them each with a super-powered enchanted arrow before they got up. Rinse and repeat until you reach 300 hours or whatever. By contrast, the recently released Bioshock: Infinite has a comparatively paltry 15 hours of play time, except that it packs each of those hours with varied environments, unique weapons, distinct characters, and brilliant plot twists to cement its place as one of my favorite games of all time (which, for a post-2007 video game, is pretty remarkable). See, just because a game has a ridiculous amount of play time doesn€™t mean that each of those hundreds of hours contains meaningful content. It basically boils down to this: If you're going to spend $60 on dinner, would you rather eat a perfectly cooked, delicious filet mignon, or an all-you-can-eat microwave chicken tender buffet?


6. DLC Can Be A Waste Of Time For Developers And Consumers

mass effect 3 ending Believe it or not, games used to be released without any additional content. Developers didn't obsess over releasing additional levels or alternate costumes. Players were grateful and satisfied by the singular product that was produced. Now don€™t get me wrong, the compulsion to say €œThat thing you gave me was awesome, and I want more!€ is perfectly logical, but the fact that game companies are now expected to release scores of supplemental content is a huge stigma for modern gaming.

A logical retort to this is, €œIf you don€™t like DLC, then don€™t buy it!€ and I would say, €œOkay then, I won€™t.€ But sometimes, and Capcom knows what€™s coming, the content that people are paying money for and €œdownloading€ is already on the disc itself. You€™re not actually receiving new content, but rather you€™re paying 20 bucks for a tiny little file that allows you access to data that is already stored within the base game that you've already bought. That€™s like spending $200,000 on a house, and then spending $100,000 on the keys to get in the door. It's a sinister way of squeezing money out of people that don't know better.

It's not the concept of DLC that I have a problem with, but rather the actual content that developers are charging money for. I have no problem buying some of the Borderlands 2 DLC, because I know I'm going to get some genuine enjoyment out of shooting up more Skags with my friends (who are sitting next to me on the couch and aren't racist teenagers. More on that later). But costume packs that just swap colors around? An alternate ending for Mass Effect 3 that you have to pay for because the default ending was terrible? Instead of releasing half a game and cramming it with goodies later, game companies should spend their time and money on releasing a solid product that doesn't need to be held up with downloadable crutches.

5. Games Were Actually Released When They Were Finished

Half-Life 2 is one of my favorite games of all time. The gameplay is perfectly balanced, the shooting is fun, the puzzles are stimulating, and you can basically pick your own immersion level as you play through the game. There was a six-year gap between the original Half-Life and the acclaimed sequel, and despite a complicated console port and source code leak during development, Valve worked tirelessly to create a quality product that would be hailed by some as the greatest video game ever made. I didn't mind the wait, and I'm looking forward to the next game in the series. Fast forward to 2012. I'm playing through the verdant world of Skyrim on the Xbox 360. Sure, some NPCs spawn inside rocks and wooly mammoths might inexplicably fly straight up into the air, but I can understand why an established developer would want to release a huge game with a few glitches and fix them later. However, after a certain update through Xbox Live, my game stopped...working. It froze immediately after I booted it up. I spent hours researching fixes and workarounds, but to no avail. All I could to do was wait for the next update to come down the pipes and fix my problem, which it did. After a month.
Thanks to the advent of online services, game companies can release a game that is so rife with sequence breaks and exploits that it renders the game borderline unplayable (or in my case, technically unplayable). Would you buy a half-finished, moth-eaten blanket if you were promised a couple patches every once in awhile to make it functional? No. A normal person would want a complete, finished product that serves its pupose with minimal hangups. It was done before PSN and Xbox Live, and it can done again, as long as the company takes the time to craft a quality product.

4. Voiceovers Are A Blessing And A Curse

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rj8nHy6aA6E Modern gamers love their voiceovers, and why shouldn't they? You've probably played video games in an era were text boxes were king, and "voiceovers" were limited to Link screaming "Hyaaa!" over and over again (a condition that he has yet to overcome. I hope he never does). Games have come a long way since then, and voiceovers are becoming more and more prevalent in the modern gaming environment. Conceptually, this is a good thing, because it means you don't have to strain your tiny little brain by reading text. But sometimes, voiceovers cause just as many problems as they solve. Video games are meant to be an immersive experience. Ideally, you would forget about the Cheetos dust on your shirt and your mounting college loan debts for a few brief, glimmering moments and become Booker DeWiit, cynical trans-dimensional face-shredding extraordinaire! The real world melted away while you focused on getting Elizabeth out of Columbia in the most complicated way possible. The problem is that Booker and Elizabeth like to have conversations about quantum physics in the midst of a vicious firefight, and if you've ever tried to have a debate while automatic weapons are discharging from every direction, you'd know that it's a little difficult to hear. Now, let me be clear, in modern times, voiceovers are a huge part of characterization, and if Booker and Elizabeth didn't actually speak, the game would feel hollow. I'm glad most games have voiceovers, but it's the actual implementation of voiceovers that I feel can be improved. I have to turn on subtitles because I can't freaking hear the characters as they ponder morality in the middle of a warzone. Voice quality is also an issue. I'm a huge fan of the Metal Gear series, but Raiden's voice actor Quinton Flynn could not be more irritating. Sure, iffy writing can be a tough hurdle to clear, but in Metal Gear Solid 4, his performance is so grating and canned that I wanted Snake to put him in a sleeper hold and stuff him in a locker until he promised to be more convincing. The Elder Scrolls series is also a repeat offender, but for a different reason. In Skyrim, it feels like Bethesda only used 5 different voice actors. This is an issue because you can actually speak to a citizen about killing bandit leader, and then when you confront the villain, you find that he sounds exactly like the man that you received the mission from.
Voiceovers are here to stay. I really don't think there's going to be some Text Box Renaissance in the near future, and truthfully, I'm okay with that. But instead of slathering every corner of a game with mediocre voicework (Metal Gear Solid 4, Skyrim), companies should focus on key interactions that will be enhanced by a moving vocal performance (Yakuza 4, Baten Kaitos) while maintaining quality text conversations during minor interactions and exchanges.

3. Gathering Resources Used To Be A Challenge

This is related to the first point I made about health regeneration. If I were to say to the frothing masses of gamers, €œGames aren€™t difficult anymore€, I€™m sure someone would bring up Demon€™s Souls and how ridiculously impossible it is. Yes, it€™s a tough game to complete, but it€™s tough in the same way that bending a crowbar by repeatedly hitting yourself in the testicles is tough; it just leaves you frustrated and you wonder why you€™re even doing it in the first place. My point is that modern gamers are coddled by constant health, ammo, and mana pickups to ever have to worry about dying, or being inconvenienced in any way, really. The first Bioshock suffered from this imbalance. I was tripping over medkits every ten feet, and if I needed to use them all during a fight, I wasn€™t worried because A) If I lived, I could just walk down the hall or to a vending machine and get fully stocked again, and B) If I died, I would be revived at no cost or penalty. This problem plagues most shooters and adventure games, since every enemy you kill drops a weapon that provides you with a full magazine. This saturation of resources kills the challenge of a game, and the unbalanced gameplay that pervades most new releases is a far cry from the old-school, hard-scrabble games that established the industry.

2. Local Multiplayer Is A Lost Art

rhrhr Some of my most cherished childhood memories occurred in a tiny corner of a television screen. Back in the 90s and early 2000s, pretty much every game that was released contained some sort of local multiplayer aspect, even when it didn€™t make any sense. For example, the single-player campaign in Donkey Kong 64 revolved around the eponymous hero freeing his captive friends and saving his home. But the 4-player splitscreen multiplayer mode pitted each of the plucky primates against each other in a massive arena to fight to the death. Logical? No. Fun? Absolutely. Now that all consoles have online connectivity, the concept of local splitscreen multiplayer has largely fallen by the wayside. That's not to say that all developers have abandoned splitscreen modes, because Halo and Call of Duty have actually done a great job of keeping local multiplayer alive. I'm saying that the splitscreen multiplayer mode is slowly dying, which is sad because it's infinitely more enjoyable to have someone else in the room sharing the same experience than to listen to racist, homophobic 10-year olds rant about having sex with my mother.
Companies are spending less time and effort on implementing a quality splitscreen experience and more time on maximizing profit by making players pay for services and gimmicks that weren't necessary 10 years ago. I€™m looking at you, Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate. I really enjoyed playing Monster Hunter Tri on the Wii. I even enjoyed the online multiplayer aspect, too. I even thought about buying a Wii U exclusively for the revamped version, since I heard it supported local multiplayer and I had a close friend who was dying to play along with me. Then I did some research, and found out that in order to play local multiplayer in a video game made in 2013, I would have to buy a Wii U, a Wii U copy of Monster Hunter, a Nintendo 3DS, and a 3DS copy of Monster Hunter. That€™s an investment of over $600 just to play the same game in the same room with someone else. Not only that, but the sad sack that has to play on the 3DS can€™t even play on a proper TV screen. So, apparently, it€™s more important to modern game companies to invest in €œnew technology innovations€ rather than split a screen and have two friends sit next to each other on the couch and fight dinosaurs together.

10. There's A Fine Line Between "Innovation" And "Gimmick"

sonic An innovation is a groundbreaking concept that usually has never been seen before. A gimmick is a selling point that is highlighted by a producer in order to generate interest in a product. Basically, an innovation is what made games like Journey so revolutionary and a gimmick is what single-handedly destroyed the reputation of Sonic the Hedgehog. Yeah, the Kinect is a cool gadget, but I can't be immersed in a video game while moving all my furniture out of the way and flailing around like a spastic gremlin. The Kinect is a gimmick, and gimmicks are a solution to a problem that doesn't exist. I€™m not going to dust off my soapbox and wax poetic about the merits of the indie game genre, but I will say that being a part of a smaller, less capitalistic development team naturally leads to more organic and inventive ideas (Katamari Damacy, Ikaruga, Rez, etc).

Gigantic gold-plated franchises usually get stale after a while, which is usually when gimmicks are introduced as a means to stimulate bored fans, and get the attention of new ones. Tony Hawk did it with Ride, which came with a plastic skateboard peripheral loaded with low-quality accelerometers. The Nintendo did it with the Wii U, which features a touchscreen on the mammoth-sized controller that allowed you to look at inventory menus on a controller instead of a TV. And don€™t even get me started with zombies.

Want to play a tired tactical warfare FPS with zombies? Get Call of Duty. Want to play as an ex-mercenary cowboy who has to rescue his family€and then fight zombies? Get Red Dead Redemption. Even the first Borderlands, which I consider to be the best thing to happen to first-person shooters in ten years, had a zombie-related DLC. Modern gamers need to understand that innovation, not gimmicks, paves the way for a truly great experience, one that sticks in your memory and changes your perspective of what a video game can truly be. A player needs that moment of €œWhoa, I€™ve never seen that before€ if the game is going to stand out in a homogenous market.

And there you have it. Those are the ten subjects that I feel modern gamers should reflect on so they can avoid ignorance, lazy game companies, and other demons that have been spawned due to greedy marketers and useless products. Hopefully, by understanding why and how video games have become what they are, we can appreciate what they used to be. This was my first article contributed to WhatCulture.com, so constructive comments appreciated. I really tried to remain balanced and honest, but I'm sure I made someone mad, which was not my intention. These are simply my opinions and you are more than welcome to disagree with them. Thank you for taking the time to read it, and I hope you'll read my future articles as well. -J

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Eller likes a lot of old video games, and some new video games. Follow him on Twitter (@JordanEller) for updates about articles, but mostly silly jokes.