10 More Video Games That Sold Millions (Despite Being Terrible)

Minimum effort, maximum gains.

Tomb Raider angel of darkness
Eidos Interactive

It's fair to say that Tears of the Kingdom's prolonged stay in the top 10 has restored a many a video game enthusiasts' faith in the industry. A joyous, feature-rich game that represents the current apotheois of open-world game design, TotK's success proves that, sometimes, the cream really does rise to the top.

Unfortunately, history also has plenty of examples of less delightful games that managed to rise up the charts and cause millions of gamers to gag on their clammy scumminess.

From Call of Duty rip-offs to disastrous ports, each game on this list managed to achieve a measure of sales success that far outstripped their level of critical acclaim. Shakespeare once asked "What's in a name?" and, had he emerged frozen from the ice into the modern day like a beruffled Captain America, he would have seen that the answer is "Quite a bit, actually".

As you'll see, many of the games on this list profited enormously from their connection with famous franchises - the first entry perhaps most egregiously of all...

?????? ?????? ?????????, ??? ????? ???? ?? ???? ??????? ????? ???? ??? ?????? ????? ?? ????????.???.

10. Goldeneye: Rogue Agent

Goldeneye Rogue Agent
EA

Goldeneye: Rogue Agent just about manages to scrape into this list with one million copies sold across all formats. Which is appropriate, because "just scraping by" seems to have been the overriding ethos behind its creation.

From 1999 to 2005, EA released one James Bond game a year. Given that rate of production it was inevitable quality control would drop at some point, and with Rogue Agent it plummeted like Sean Bean at the end of the movie this game takes its title from.

Everything about Goldeneye: Rogue Agent feels ????. From the decision to name itself after the most beloved (albeit poorly aging) 007 game of all time to the bland, identikit levels populated by brain dead henchmen, Rogue Agent bears all the hallmarks of a game churned out to make a quick profit.

EA's tenure with the Bond franchise did occasionally lead to magic (Everything or Nothing is still an absolute joy to blast through), but there's no doubt that the company's decision to milk the 007 brand produced as much trash as treasure, with Rogue Agent sitting squarely at the top of the landfill.


9. Sonic The Hedgehog (2006)

Sonic The Hedgehog 2006
Sega

Sonic the Hedgehog (2006) is the one where Sonic's corpse is brought back to life after being kissed by a human princess.

Right, entry over! Moving on to #8... (???? ?????, ???? - ??????? ??????????? ??????)

Fair enough! Let's give Sonic his mandated 180-word shoeing.

In a franchise that has seen its fair share of clunkers since Sonic the Hedgehog's release (Sonic and the Black Knight, Sonic Forces, Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric), it's almost impressive that the 2006 entry is still seen as the absolute nadir of the series.

Needless to say, that reputation is fully deserved as STH 2006 is utterly abysmal at everything it attempts. The storyline is overstuffed, overwrought nonsense involving Gods, time travel and interspecies necrophilia; the camera and glitchy controls actively conspire to send you plummeting to your doom at least once a level; and loading screens are... absurdly... prolific.... and... ridiculously... lengthy... and... irritating... to... sit... through.

Incredibly, Sonic 2006 came out hot on the heels of the equally dreadful Shadow the Hedgehog, which was released only a year prior. Not many series could survive such a devastating one-two punch to their reputation, but such is the power of the blue blur that he's still going strong in 2023. Guess that princess' kiss really was magic!


8. Tomb Raider: The Angel Of Darkness.

tomb raider angel of darkness
Square Enix

Poor Core Design.

While Sonic Team survived producing disaster after disaster, one bad game was all it took for Tomb Raider's original developers to collapse like the final levels of Tomb Raiders I, II and IV. (For a supposed archaeologist, Lara Croft is astonishingly bad at preserving her historic finds).

To be fair to Core, they realised that the Tomb Raider formula had become increasingly stale over the past five entries. Angel of Darkness was meant to be a new direction for the franchise as a whole, but said new direction came perilously close to turning the franchise away from the promised land and straight to the island of irrelevancy (Yes, that was a Bloodline reference).

Putting it kindly, Angel of Darkness was a brave failure. ???? of the new features worked - the RPG mechanics were half-baked, the controls were an unsatisfying halfway house between the d-pad focused classic Tomb Raiders and modern analogue stick controls, and the stealth mechanics would have been risible in the early nineties, never mind 2003.

Despite selling just under 3 million copies, Angel of Darkness' critical pasting meant the franchise was passed to Crystal Dynamics, who provided some impressive course correction with their own (highly under-rated) Tomb Raider trilogy. Core Design, meanwhile, were quietly shuttered a few years later.


7. Medal of Honor: Warfighter

Metal Of Honour Warfighter
EA

Medal of Honor's fall from grace was a sad sight to see.

EA's series of WWII focused FPS games were hugely popular in the early noughties, with Frontline and Rising Sun combining to sell upwards of 15 million units. Unfortunately, in 2007 a Call of Duty-shaped bomb fell from the sky and obliterated gamers' interest in EA's franchise.

EA fought back with 2010's Medal of Honor, a modern warfare based reboot that shamelessly pilfered from Activision's juggernaut franchise. Medal of Honor's copying from Call of Duty's homework may have been brazen, but it clearly worked as the reboot sold around 5 million copies. Unfortunately, EA failed to make lightning strike twice with the follow up.

Warfighter was a rushed mess of a game. The shooting felt weak and unsatisfying, the campaign was comfortably the worst in franchise history, and the game released with a boatload of technical glitches (such as enemies and allies alike flickering in and out of sight like Predators with wonky camouflage). Despite this, Warfighter still managed to sell 3 million copies across all formats. Unfortunately for it - and the series at large - Call of Duty: Black Ops II sold 31 million copies.

EA saw the writing on the wall and admitted defeat, quietly closing the door on what had once been one of their biggest moneymakers.


6. WWE 2K15

Triple H Blood Wwe 2k15
2K Sports

This probably isn't the WWE 2K game you were expecting to see here.

WWE 2K20 will forever be remembered as one of the biggest disappointments in gaming history, and its publishers have tacitly acknowledged that fact by refusing to release sales data for it. They have, however, released sales for WWE 2K15, which means we know that 3 million WWE fans experienced one of the biggest backwards steps in franchise history.

After the truly excellent WWE 2K14, expectations were high for what was being billed as the first truly next-gen entry in the WWE 2K series. Sadly, all that effort spent on making sure the wrestlers' baby oil glistened just right meant that work in a lot of other areas was left undone.

A ?????????? amount of content from the previous year's entry was left on the cutting room floor. The roster size had shrunk alarmingly, from 83 wrestlers to 60; entire match types went missing; custom-made stories were out; and, inexplicably, you couldn't create female wrestlers any more, meaning you were stuck with the whopping ????? female talents that released on disc.

With WWE 2K15 being a disappointment and 2K20 being a disaster, if the pattern holds it'll be interesting to see what type of calamity 2K Games unleashes on the world with WWE 2K25!


5. Anthem

anthem game
Bioware

This one took a bit of research.

EA have never officially revealed Anthem's sales data, but thanks to the fine folks at SuperData Research it's public knowledge that Anthem made $100 million in digital revenue in its launch month, only $3.5 million of which came from in-game purchases. As such, you can reasonably intuit that Anthem sold well over a million copies. Furthermore, by actually playing it you can also ascertain that Anthem was lucky to sell over ten ???????? copies, let alone a million.

For a game about bombing around lush sci-fi vistas in Iron-Man style power armour, Anthem is unspeakably dull. Once you've spent the dozen or so hours it takes to polish off the campaign, all you're left with is a ceaseless, joyless grind of bashing overly familair enemies in increasingly dull locations.

The fact that you can apply the previous sentence to any number of Live Service failures over the years (The Avengers, Babylon's Fall, Godfall) shows why Anthem failed. It was yet another mediocre entry in an overstuffed market, and soon found itself occupying one more casket in an increasingly packed graveyard.


4. Need For Speed: Payback

Need For Speed Payback
EA

Goodness, EA have shown up rather a lot on this list, haven't they? It's equal parts disturbing and impressive that one company can produce so much crap while raking in so much money.

The fourth and final EA game on this list, Need for Speed: Payback represents an interesting contrast to Medal of Honor: Warfighter (a fellow EA stablemate). Like Warfighter, Payback represents the absolute nadir of its respective franchise. Like Warfigher, Payback somehow sold upwards of 3 million copies. Unlike Warfighter, Payback didn't represent the end of its franchise as Need For Speed games are still going strong to this day, with last year's Need For Speed Unbound being something of a series highlight.

Truthfully speaking, it's a relief that Need For Speed is still going. When it's on form, it's arguably the greatest arcade racing series in the world (Burnout fans may disagree), and it didn't deserve to go under because of one bad game.

Having said that, Payback was a ?????? bad game.

Payback unsuccessfully married the series' high-octane racing with one of the blandest open worlds ever created, and further self-sabotaged with the introduction of insidious micro-transactions. Both additions, somewhat ironically, slowed the game's pacing to a crawl and ensured that Payback was best left in the franchise's rear-view mirror.


3. Pac-Man (Atari 2600)

pac man atari 2600
Atari

In the old days, reviewers used the phrase "Arcade Perfect" to describe a home console game that almost perfectly replicated its arcade version. Pac-Man on the Atari was very much on the opposite end of that scale.

Just look at the photo adorning this entry for proof. Even the most neophyte gamer should have some idea of what Pac-Man is meant to look like, and that beige-and-blue monstrosity is not it. It's the very definition of "We have Pac-Man at home" and, unsurprisingly, it plays as terribly as it looks.

Such was the Atari version of Pac-Man's all-encompassing ineptitude that it, along with the legendarily terrible licensed ET game, is often blamed for the video game market's infamous crash in 1983. Over 8 million people bought Pac-Man on the Atari, and it's all too easy to imagine every one of those eight million thinking "Well, I'm not making that mistake again" before swearing off video games for good and going on to live a life of religious fulfilment (to borrow a phrase from the incomparable Leslie Nielsen).

Some games may have got their franchises cancelled, but Pac-Man is the only one that almost caused the death of the entire industry.


2. Wii Play

Wii Play
Nintendo

In WhatCulture's first look at terrible games that sold ludicrously well, the article used the tagline "It's not what you do, it's how you market it." In the case of Wii Play, it was less "...how you market it", more "...what you bundle it with".

Wii Play sold close to a whopping 30 million units not because of its quality, but because it came bundled with the Wiimote - the controller for Nintendo's hugely successful Wii console. Given that the Wii was at its best when you had friends and family together, swinging their Wiimotes with wild abandon (not a euphemism, we hasten to add), you can see why Wii Play sold so well. "A free game to go with a much-needed extra controller? How bad could it be?"

Sadly (and predictably), the answer to that question is "Very bad indeed". Wii Play wound up being a total waste of both the plastic it was printed on, and of the 5 minutes Nintendo apparently spent developing it.

A collection of half-baked minigames that would be shamed by even the most basic free app-store download, Wii Play unfortunately acted as a precursor to the tidal wave of shovelware that would eventually consume the Wii. To be fair, Nintendo had only themselves to blame - if one of their own games was a half-baked mess like Wii Play, they were hardly in a position to complain when other developers delivered titles of similar "quality".


1. Pokémon Scarlet & Violet

Pokemon Scarlet Violet glitch
Nintendo

It's easy to pretend that the above screenshot acts as an artistic representation of Nintendo's eye-popping reaction to Pokémon Scarlet & Violet's sales numbers. "Really? That many people bought a blatantly unfinished game? Why the hell did we spend so long tweaking Tears of the Kingdom?!"

Make no mistake, Pokémon Scarlet & Violet may be the least objectively terrible games on this list (now there's a box quote for you), but Nintendo should never have released them in the condition they were at launch. And 22 million gamers (and counting) certainly shouldn't have awarded such a slapdash effort by spending their hard-earned cash on a product that felt like a bug-filled beta test.

Fans forgave Pokémon Legends: Arceus for its shakey performance because it tried something new with the Pokémon formula, but Scarlet & Violet - both mainline entries in the Pokémon franchise - should never have been allowed to tarnish the brand to the extent they did upon their release.

Sadly, such is the power of Pokémon that tens of millions of gamers have willingly parted with their cash to spend more time in its one-of-a-kind world. Even when said world has a habit of popping in and out of existence, or slowing down to a crawl at a moment's notice...


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name's Iain Tayor. I write about video games, wrestling and comic books, and I apparently can't figure out how to set my profile picture correctly.