10 Video Games That Aged Badly For Surprising Reasons

Have you played GoldenEye since 1997?

Goldeneye 007
Rare

We've discussed movies that didn't stand the test of time because of surprising reasons - but surely those same things won't drag down our precious video games too, right?

Sadly, some games just don't stand up to what they once were. Actually... most games don't, in all honesty.

Gaming technology has progressed at breakneck speed. Mega Man 1 is nothing compared to MegaMan 3, Total War: Three Kingdoms blows away the original Shogun: Total War like a medieval musket loaded with buckshot, and Dynasty Warriors 7 is... well okay, DW3 was the greatest in the series and you can't change my mind on that.

But we're not just going to pick on old games for being old, looking old or not using all the buttons on the controller.

Stardew Valley might not use the most advanced 3D graphics, but is definitely going to weather the foreseeable future - as proven by the furore over the developer announcing a possible sequel or tie-in.

No, the following titles don't stand the test of time because they don't hold up to the elevated status they helped create. Some have a fatal flaw that we all overlooked, or maybe someone behind the game's development rocked the boat in a negative way - the reasons can be pretty wide reaching.

10. Kratos' TERRIBLE Motivation - God Of War

Kratos Rage
Sony

When we were teenagers the violent Spartan man-child that was Kratos was the coolest guy ever. And now, fifteen years later - especially with a more mature Kratos in the latest game - we see that the original games were just full of teen angst and sex. Nothing elucidates the difference between a 'mature' rating in games and actual maturity more than the original God of War games.

Similar games of this nature, like Grand Theft Auto and Duke Nukem, can stand the test of time a little better than Kratos' original series can.

At least in Grand Theft Auto the main character has real motivations that push them toward violence and Duke Nukem is a caricature, but Kratos is presented as being an inspirational badass.

That's part of what made the latest Duke Nukem game fail – unlike Kratos, Duke never really matured and never stopped being an angsty, offensive to be noticed, kid in a bodybuilder's frame. While Kratos became meta, Duke just became that guy from high school who still wears his letterman jacket and talks about prom like it was yesterday.


9. That Control Scheme You Totally Forgot About - GoldenEye 007

Goldeneye 007
Rare

Everyone who owned an N64 knows the greatest first-person shooter was Golden Eye. Years before Halo, years before Call of Duty or Rainbow Six were passable games, there was Golden Eye; a movie tie-in that was not only satisfactory, but downright good.

With a few controllers your whole crew could get together and enjoy a night with crisp controls and great level design. Well, at least as long as one of your friends didn't play as Oddjob. Rare did a fantastic job with GoldenEye - one that can never be beaten, right?

Has anyone actually gone back and played this game recently?

How did we ever play a shooter that didn't have solid vertical aiming? And the campaign AI? You thought escort missions were bad now, let's go back to 1997 and try escorting Natalya to anywhere that isn't immediately in front of your own rifle. By the fifth reload of the level you're actually gunning for her just out of spite - and you may as well, it's way easier to hit her than it is to hit the enemy.

Cane we escort Oddjob, instead? At least we won't have to worry about friendly fire.


8. Tank Controls To Raid A Tomb? - Tomb Raider

Tomb Raider Lara Croft
Core Design

The first thing anyone points out is Lara Croft's crazy design, created by graphical constraints and somebody getting freaky with a "chest slider". But remember that in 1996, three years before Final Fantasy 8 came out with Squall having assorted pixels for a face, Lara had lips, eyes, and a nose on her polygonal face.

So, pyramid chest aside, what makes the classic Tomb Raider games so terrible now?

Seriously, how did we ever play these games as children? The controls are atrocious. Tank controls, the inability to strafe properly – at least without doing backflips and cartwheels – and no choice but to auto-aim at whatever Lara decides is the prime target. We've piloted machines in World of Tanks that handled better than classic Lara Croft – and those things were actual tanks.

With the releases of modern games in the franchise like Rise and Shadow of the Tomb Raider it makes us wonder how we ever played the original. The garbage controls are just ridiculous.

Honorable mention to Resident Evil - we didn't forget you - though one could argue the tank controls contribute to the helplessly overwhelmed feeling you're supposed to have playing Resident Evil. These controls don't help Tomb Raider in any way.


7. The "Hero"'s Actions Have NOT Aged Well - Homefront

Homefront 2011
THQ

Homefront was one of those 'better than it deserved to be' kind of games. A fairly solid shooter, even if it didn't have much in the way of bells or whistles. Mostly just a linear FPS, it was the story of a guy caught behind enemy lines, living in an America half-conquered by North Korea. Aside from the insane story, the game is tough to stomach with modern politics on the mind.

The real hero of Homefront is not the player, but rather Connor: The in-your-face, drill sergeant-esque rebel captain.

The story of the game is basically Connor's character arc from a douchey bag of hatred to a heroic martyr for the cause. Keep in mind that Connor dislikes the main character from the outset - which makes absolutely zero sense - Connor and the main character are both US marines. A group known, for better or worse, for sticking up for each other.

He is racist, bigoted, and a complete jerk who is just upset his societal luxuries have been revoked – and the game does everything it can to point out that he's the good guy and, though he's a little offensive, he's in the right. Actually him being offensive is kind of the point - he's not 'PC', because he's a 'real man'.


6. A Wildly Offensive Man Made A Family Game - Minecraft

Notch Persson
mxdwn.com

Minecraft was never supposed to be graphically amazing, it was never designed to be a modular version of Dark Souls, it was never a technological powerhouse and was never designed to be. So what could possibly make it age poorly?

Its creator.

Minecraft has become somewhat of the perfect family game – one safe for kids or grandparents to play, and to even play together. So it is always a huge downer anytime the creator of Minecraft, Markus Persson – better known by his moniker, Notch, comes up in conversation.

Unlike Minecraft, Notch is absolutely not family-friendly.

He has aired such social grievances with the world as calling the pursuit of equal rights for women a 'social disease', calling victims of sexual harassment and assault vulgar slurs, and saying that people who were opposed to 'Straight Pride' “deserve to be shot.”

With regular rants against homosexuality, women, non-white people and transgendered people (basically anyone who isn't a land-owning white male) it's no surprise that Microsoft, which paid his company 2.5 billion dollars for Minecraft, has distanced themselves entirely. Microsoft even refused to invite Notch to the tenth anniversary celebration.


5. It Was Basically An Interactive Slideshow - Myst

Myst PC
Brøderbund

Myst was once the game that epitomized beauty and simplicity in games – well, maybe not simplicity if you were tone-deaf and trying to solve that musical puzzle, like me. Arguably a precursor to the modern 'walking simulation' along the likes of Dear Esther, Gone Home, The Stanley Parable, and Firewatch.

Myst forced players to walk around an island and teleport to other areas and solve puzzles to unlock pages from missing books. Each location was comprised of pre-rendered, still images. While cutting edge for computer graphics at the time, nowadays it seems so inflexible and underwhelming.

If we're going to play a walking simulator, we at least want to be look around and, you know, walk. Compared to modern walking simulators, classic Myst just seems like a slideshow of someone else's vacation. "And next I jumped into this book and whoo-boy I was on a pirate ship!"

Yeah, yeah, we get it - it looks like it was great fun. But we don't want to see the visions of fun had, we want to have the fun ourselves. We want to look around and see the architecture and flora of the realm.


4. Plagiarism Is Bad, No Matter How Awesome It Sounds - Dragon Ball Z: Budokai

Dragon Ball Z: Budokai Tenkaichi 2
Spike

The Budokai series of Dragon Ball Z games were solid fighting games that were fun, interesting, and had great cel-shaded visuals. Sure the games had terrible balance, but said lack of balance was canonical. So what could possibly ruin such a great game's reputation nowadays?

The great music.

How does great music make a game age poorly? Because Yamamoto Kenji, one of the long-time composers for the Dragonball franchise, was accused of plagiarizing other songs in 2010.

We're not talking about sampling some classics, we're talking about lifting whole bars from already great songs. If not for the fact that some of the songs are pretty obscure things, we can't believe it took as long as it did for the plagiarism to be found out.

Toei ultimately sacked the famous composer and replaced much of his music from the Budokai series in later releases. But playing the old originals now and hearing that banging soundtrack just makes you think about the end of a man's career.

The fact that the tracks are bangin' don't help matters - just listen to the originals he ripped-off when you get the chance.


3. Nostalgia Made The Reboot Obsolete - Monkey Island: Special Edition

The Secret Of Monkey Island
Lucasarts

LucasArts' classic Monkey Island series is well regarded - and for good reason.

The humor and solid writing, you can't forget the fact that the game was waaay more forgiving than most adventure games of the era. Unlike Sierra's other titles - where you can lose Police Quest because you didn't walk around a car, died of thirst on planet Kerona in Space Quest or didn't catch a cat in King's Quest - the Monkey Island series was forgiving.

For many people who grew up with the Monkey Island games in the '90s, they had an air about them - which is why we're actually talking about the 'Special Edition' remake from 2009.

For so many people the original game is iconic, and even though there were graphical, audio and gameplay improvements to the remake, many people still prefer the original version.

It's definitely a strange situation when a reboot is made totally moot because of nostalgia. A vocal portion of the audience actually prefers the original, lower-quality version of the game, and called for simple ports over the full reboot.

Some going so far as to call the HD visual upgrade unnecessary and unwanted.


2. A Game That Literally Feels Like A Job - Shenmue

Shenmue Outrun
Sega

Shenmue is, quite honestly, the OG when it comes to open world games. People operating in an open world on a persistent clock, a proper timetable of events, and the ability to feel like you were a person in a living world. The same things that Skyrim got credit for doing so well were done in Shenmue long ago.

Of course part of that world was working a job for cash. Another part was walking for literally hours through beautiful Chinese countryside while talking to a young girl. The problem with Shenmue's open, interactive world is that, unlike Skyrim or the Yakuza series', Shenmue has little reason for all of its interactivity.

Sure you can play old Sega arcade games, but 'can' and you 'should' are two VERY different ideas.

Yakuza has old Sega arcade games in it, too - and there are actually quests pertaining to playing them, complete with full multi-point side-story miniquests to complete. Talking to folks in Skyrim gets friends, adopted kids; talking to people in Shenmue gets you information dumps.

But Shenmue? Shenmue is walking through the forest, talking about a tree, after you kept still in a barbershop and drove a forklift for a bit.

It was technically impressive by definition at the time, but now? Nowhere near as much.


1. The Beginning Of The Microtransaction Market - Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

Oblivion Horse Armour
Bethesda Softworks

Skyrim took the best parts of Oblivion and rolled along to improve them, or at least reuse them, leaving most of the detritus behind. And Oblivion certainly has its fair share of issues, nobody can realistically deny that - but many still cling to the fact that its a great game.

Occasionally you'll even find an Oblivion snob who will tout the earlier game's greatness over Skyrim's quality.

But when you're not underneath bridges looking for literal trolls you can easily remember that Oblivion was basically the start of the paid DLC market. Until Oblivion most games that had ample microtransactions were 'freemium' games that you could pick up for free, or at least cheap, and buy cosmetics or even powerups.

Second Life was one of the earlier models that allowed folks to spend real money for in-game things. Microsoft allowed microtransactions on X-Box Live to get little things for 360 games.

And then in 2006 came Bethesda's 'Horse Armor Pack' for Oblivion. Bet you forgot about that, huh? Largely considered the trend-setter that eventually gave us loot boxes and similar functions.

Oblivion started all that and when we look at our pretty horse armor we can't help but remember - we helped shape this world by accepting this new idea.


Contributor
Contributor

Author of Escort (Eternal Press, 2015), co-founder of Nic3Ntertainment, and developer behind The Sickle Upon Sekigahara (2020). Currently freelancing as a game developer and history consultant. Also tends to travel the eastern U.S. doing courses on History, Writing, and Japanese Poetry. You can find his portfolio at www.richardcshaffer.com.