10 Risky Changes That Would Make Assassin's Creed Great Again

It'll be difficult... but not impossible.

Assassin's Creed
Ubisoft

For the past few games, it’s hard not to agree that Assassin’s Creed is stagnating - if not on life support. Falling into the same cookie cutter problems that so often affect the games industry,despite their attempts to revitalise the series, Ubisoft have been fighting an uphill battle.

From the dull bore of Connor’s monotone stunt as an assassin, to the buggy arrogance of Arno, it hasn’t exactly been plain sailing. And its no easy task reliving the original Assassin's Creed and the brilliance of the Ezio trilogy, either.

But with Ubisoft postponing their next Assassin’s Creed for at least another year, maybe we are seeing some room for much-needed improvement in the series. Regardless, there are several ways to improve Assassin's Creed from top to bottom, and instead of tiny tweaks to the formula, I’m suggesting Ubisoft go big and risk everything to bring the series back to the its true glory.

--

10. Overhaul How The Map Is Unlocked

Ubisoft

Bear with me on this one. Assassin’s Creed spearheaded the sandbox trope of climbing towers to reveal portions of the map. Which isn’t a bad method of revealing specific events on the map and giving the player a look at the surrounding scenery. Viewpoints are one of the most satisfying things in the game. The sweeping camera and beautiful landscape of history and rousing music is sensational.

But with that, comes the map. Each viewpoint reveals everything in that area. Everything. There is no exploration, only choosing the next thing to do. You end up just picking your next objective and running for it, not actually exploring and discovering the deep and intricate world Ubisoft have built.

I say, get rid of that map. Keep the viewpoints, but have them only reveal points of interest, buildings and the such. Give the player a reason to walk through the streets and find some being robbed, before discovering that the thieves are part of a massive underground syndicate, starting a side-mission to dislodge their control.

Don’t show everything. Let us have those moments of surprise encounters and unique scenarios. Unity and Syndicate took steps towards this with random encounters in the city as you were running around, but even that was pretty pitiful. Random groups of guards aren’t random encounters Ubisoft…


9. Ditch The Modern Day Storyline

Ubisoft

Playing the first Assassin’s Creed and being flung into a modern story set in a stunning white laboratory was a surprise inclusion nobody saw coming. It was an interesting dynamic, a welcome inclusion, and it broke up Altair's assassin gameplay quite well.

However, as the games continued, it lost focus, slowly becoming a necessary inclusion that was ultimately dull and boring.

Not to mention the fact that it lost itself entirely after the ending of Assassin’s Creed III, opting to go with first-person hacking puzzles instead of a coherent narrative. By the time Unity and Syndicate rolled around it was resigned to menus and cutscenes - kind of phoned in, to say the least.

So get rid of it. It’s a bold move that would remove the weakest parts of the game, and true, it is considered an integral part of Assassin’s Creed as a franchise, but until Ubisoft can decide what they actually want to do with this modern day component, at least remove it entirely for one game.


8. Or Go Big With A Newer Timeline

Assassin's Creed modern day
Ubisoft

On the opposite end of the spectrum, Ubisoft could commit to the modern-day storyline, making it a major component to the full game - maybe even make it the entire game. It might be difficult to get behind depending on where you stand on time period favouritism, but would refined how we interact with these portions of the game.

If Ubisoft don’t want to commit to such a thing, at least have a free roaming area with its own side-quests and objectives. Perhaps split the game down the middle, half in the past and half in the present. The two timelines could interact, say with information learnt in the past affecting places you can access in the future.

Not to mention, we have a few interesting modern day characters that are there to play with - the assassins introduced through Syndicate and Unity, as well as the old favourites, Shaun and Rebecca, the Templars that are in Rogue, the nameless and faceless protagonists of the modern day portions of Black Flag and Rogue.

There is a world there with stories to be told, but as yet, it's not being used.


7. Explore The Precursor Race In Full

Assassin's Creed 2 Minerva
Ubisoft

One of the more intriguing concepts of the Assassin’s Creed universe is the Precursor race. Beings more powerful and advanced than the humans - to the extent they were recognised as Gods by the Roman Empire. Not to mention that they created the precursor artefacts, the Apple of Eden, the Papal Staff, that sword from Unity and The Shroud. But with them being such a big part of the story, we actually don't know a whole lot about their intentions or way of life.

But could you imagine an Assassin Creed game set in the Precursor timeline? It could follow the humans as they rebelled, or you could even play as a precursor assassin. Maybe the Templar/Assassin conflict doesn’t reach that far back, but it’s worth a shot.

The powers and abilities that could be explored with a precursor setting could provide the new edge to the gameplay that Ubisoft have been searching for.

Not to mention you could chill with Adam and Eve. I mean, Napoleon and Da Vinci were cool, but the original humans?


6. Let Us Choose Assassin Or Templar

assassin's creed rogue
Ubisoft

Assassin’s Creed suffers heavily from replayability issues. Chances are you play it through once, and maybe a few years down the line if you've forgotten all the major story beats, you could start anew.

With that in mind, what if - when starting up a new game - you had a few missions (maybe even Sequences) before you are forced to choose between the Templars or the Assassins? Two different paths through the game, each with their own story choices, creating a more diverse playing experience. It's more work on the development side, but these twin stories could intertwine and ultimately conclude with multitude of varying endings, Witcher 3-style.

It would give you reason to play the game at least twice, and offer up a lot more to do across the board. Y'know, instead of collecting yet more Animus fragments *shudder*.


5. A Changing World

assassin's creed unity
Ubisoft

I really wish that more games could have the courage to have their worlds change dramatically. Have players affect their surroundings in a massive way. An example that comes to mind is Dark Souls, and Anor Londo. Killing Gwynevere reveals the illusion of the city and the entire area changes into its true twilight form. The player is forced to live with that, and there is no way to change it back, beyond starting a new game.

A game as gigantic as Assassin's Creed should shift and work around the player, their actions having meaningful impact on the world around them. If the player decides to kill a pivotal character, that's okay, the world should react and change, not stand oblivious to its existence.

Similarly, as the player progresses through the story, narrative events should do the same. Should a King be killed and a monarchy dissolved, the world shouldn't continue as if its just another day. There should be panic, riots, protests. AC: Unity had such things, but they were more just set-dressing than anything consequential.

The world should noticeably be impacted after any of the aforementioned events. Simple as.


4. The Nemesis System

Monolith

One of the open-world sandbox features that I really wish would have caught on a little more is the nemesis system from Shadow Of Mordor. It was the perfect system to make your actions hold weight and give the enemy a face, instead of the just being enemy #4057394.

Bringing that into Assassin’s Creed in the form of guards and in combination with the previously described changing world would be a godsend. Guards you mutilated and left for dead would hunt you down and start witch hunts if you killed someone, turning the city against you in a personal vendetta. They would force you to counteract and take them down permanently, as well as watching your back during any number of quests.

I'm not at all saying Assassin's Creed should replicate Shadow of Mordor in full, but having the system in the background, fuelling the main story and giving the guards of the city a little more personality. A lot of games have the problem of their standard enemies being simple cannon fodder, but the nemesis system fixes that and could make a lot of games better, Assassin's Creed included.


3. Consequences

Ubisoft

Taking the idea of choices, the nemesis system and a changing world, you could add in the idea of consequences and make a game that could be revolutionary. I’m not meaning small consequences like notoriety, I mean really big, 'can't undo' shifts in the narrative landscape.

Picking your targets and 'style' of assassination should influence how you appear in the world. Whether you get caught, how public that gets made, how brutal you are, if you are seen anywhere near the target at all - everything should all shape the world around you.

Permanently increased patrols, a permanent notoriety, perhaps certain NPC’s you trusted would turn on you, turning you over to the authorities. Having to weigh the pros and cons of an easy but public assassination or a difficult but sneaky approach should make each encounter a more arduous decision.

It could work both ways. Perhaps defamation is what you want, and you want to start civil unrest and mistrust in the public by killing a high profile and loved target. By doing it publicly, you could start riots as people blame the guards and security - just think about it, the possibilities for interactivity would be far more resonant than anything we've seen so far.


2. Making It About Stealth

assassin's creed syndicate
Ubisoft

There are nine major titles in the Assassin’s Creed series, and each one doesn’t stray far from the usual gameplay outline. That’s fine. It’s a proven core concept that the series has tweaked and perfected through its time and has influenced and number of other game series with its design.

But does it fit an assassin?

Overhauling the entire system to gear towards a more stealthy approach could be what saves the series. Making stealth the focal mechanic instead of the combat is the key to an 'assassin' game, surely?

Have serious repercussions to getting caught and have weapons and tools that cater towards going undetected, instead of being able to get out of a situation.

The combat is as refined as its ever going to be, and the currently implemented stealth mechanics are all put there around said melee combat. It should be the other way around. Assassin's Creed should inherently be about stealth, simple as.


1. Make An Assassin Game!

Assassin's Creed characters
Ubisoft

The main and focal problem with the Assassin’s Creed series is that it has slowly drifted farther and farther away from letting you actually embody an assassin. The first AC was a little heavy-handed with its mechanics, but it had the feeling of being an assassin.

You got given a target, researched them, and when the time was right you used the information that you - as the player - had found to take them out. Simple.

As the games progressed, they drifted away from that core mentality, instead having the player 'shape history'. And in their attempts to force every major historical event, this notion of slinking through the shadows was lost.

Its starting to feel like Ubisoft are using the Assassin's Creed name to make non-Assassins Creed games. Black Flag was more 'pirate adventure' than assassin, Syndicate more 'melee gangster brawler'. They need to stop making games that focus on the secondary aspects, and literally double down on the name right in front of them: Assassin.

I say, they Ubi back to their roots. Pick a historical time period and make it all about the assassination as a methodology. Revitalise the stealth aspects and make the game about hunting down your targets, gathering information on how to pick them off.

You can still have a story, but tell it through the gameplay, and don’t shape the gameplay to the story. In short, just make an assassin-based game!

--

What big and bold moves do you think would make Assassin's Creed great again? Let us know in the comments!


Contributor

I like video games, writing and writing about video games. Expect sarcasm and the dry wit of a Brit. And the occasional rant of a unhappy Scot. You know... the usual.