8 Remasters That Made Video Games WORSE
When "revisiting a beloved property" is a "total cash grab".
HD ports, remasters and remakes have been becoming increasingly popular in the video game industry for a while now.
For many players they provide an opportunity to play their favourite classics with greater clarity, or experience them as the creators originally envisioned. For others, it's a worrying sign that the industry is running out of ideas, and such nostalgia trips hark back to a time before modern gaming practices were as staid and exploitative as they are now.
Some of these shiny new updates have been met with acclaim, with Ōkami and Shadow Of The Colossus earning well-deserved success after initially flying under the radar. Fully fledged remakes such as Resident Evil 2 and the upcoming Final Fantasy VII have allowed creators to expand upon their old titles too, unbound by the limitations of early consoles, delivering experiences far deeper and more effective than before.
However, not every remaster honours or builds upon its source material with such success.
Some titles, while adequate, do not offer anything new, and their extra sheen can cause dated aspects to stand out further. Others end up as total botch jobs, charging players for titles so rife with technical issues and bad design choices, they end up hankering for the originals themselves - defeating the point of a "remaster" entirely.
8. The Secret Of Monkey Island: Special Edition
Before bashing the Monkey Island Special editions for their inferior quality to the originals, they do deserve a great deal of praise for having introduced a new generation of players to the wonderful Lucasarts adventure classics. Followed by remasters of Grim Fandango, Day Of The Tentacle and Full Throttle, a series of oft-forgotten gems have had life breathed into them anew.
However, while The Secret Of Monkey Island: SE (and its remastered sequel LeChuck's Revenge) has brought classic Monkey Island titles back to the public eye, its overall quality is less than ideal.
The controls, retooled to accommodate Xbox controllers, are terribly finicky and don't suit an adventure game in the slightest. The all-new voice acting - save for Dominic Armato's Guybrush and Earl Boen's LeChuck - is frequently poor, with many beloved characters'... characterisation missing the mark.
The more detailed, cartoon art style doesn't feel right either - despite the games' original sprites simply being tiny collections of pixels, they managed to convey significantly more personality than fully-fledged drawings do here. On the other hand, the hand-drawn backgrounds are beautiful and add some much-needed detail, with the re-orchestrated music being a joy to listen to.
There's a lot to recommend, but you're still better off firing up SCUMMVM and trying out the originals.
7. Final Fantasy VI - IOS And Android
The iOS and Android "remaster" of Final Fantasy VI definitely isn't the worst Final Fantasy title on mobile platforms - that dishonour would go to All The Bravest, their mobile-original so riddled with greedy microtransactions it might as well have held players at gunpoint.
However, we're talking about remasters here, so Final Fantasy VI it is. Admittedly the same had been done to Final Fantasy V before this, but FFVI is far and away one of the most beloved entries in the franchise, so its graphical butchering is all the more galling.
Final Fantasy VI was a gorgeous looking SNES title, showcasing some of the most lovingly rendered art in gaming history. When the mobile port was released with all-new artwork, it was shockingly bad. The bland hand drawn backgrounds lacked character, and as for the characters, well... their sprites had been cleaned up to look like pixel-art-but-not-quite, and against the game's backdrops they looked like out-of-place little cardboard cutouts.
The whole game had an amateurish look to it, like something you'd see knocked up quickly in RPG Maker rather than a product from Square Enix, one of the most renowned and influential studios in the world.
It's almost as if it was a low-effort cash grab or something.
6. Bully: Scholarship Edition
In July 2007, riding high on the success of their schoolyard hi-jinks simulator Bully, Rockstar Games announced a remaster to bring the game to the new generation of consoles - only the Xbox 360 and Wii, however, and for some reason not the PS3. Later being ported to PCs as well, Bully: Scholarship edition boasted audiovisual enhancements and more missions, lessons and unlockable items.
And it was rubbish.
While the game's audio was admittedly of better quality, the "graphical enhancements" included some baffling changes to character models - Jimmy himself included - which were truly ugly and a little creepy. Some of the new lessons were welcome, but didn't feel like pivotal additions.
Worst of all, of course, were the remaster's many technical issues. Scholarship Edition was notorious for running poorly and crashing on older Xbox 360s due to a lack of adequate testing, and the PC port was considered shoddy and untimely.
Many of the extra missions were simply content cut from the original PS2 release for not being up to standard, so that says it all really. They were also known for frequently soft-locking the game. Bang-up job, Rockstar.
5. Assassin's Creed: The Ezio Collection
Of all the Assassin's Creed titles churned out over the past decade or so, one of the most fondly remembered by fans is Assassin's Creed II and its 2 follow-ups. Despite the gameplay now feeling dated and clunky compared to the more refined mechanics of later games, this was Assassin's Creed before it started feeling cynical and phoned in.
What better way to celebrate Ezio Auditore's adventures then, with a cynical, phoned in remastering of his trilogy of titles? Assassin's Creed: The Ezio collection, while conveniently wrapping all 3 titles into one neat little package, brings nothing new to the table.
Aside from some higher-res textures, the game in many ways looks worse - atmospheric effects such as fog and volumetric lighting are missing, causing the environments to lose a lot of their depth, and the original games' colour grading has been toned down, sacrificing the games' character for the sake of broader colour depth.
The fact that the collection was locked to 30fps on modern consoles also seemed an odd choice, as the PS4 and Xbox One would have easily handled and benefitted from slicker 60fps gameplay.
4. Flashback
Delphine Software's 1992 cinematic platformer Flashback was a punishingly difficult, yet unique and laudable title. At the time, its methodical puzzling and platforming gave a sense of realism, setting it apart from its contemporaries Mario and Sonic. The game's story was also well received for its pacing and gradually unravelling mystery.
Paul Cuisset, Flashback's director, decided to remake the game in the early 2010s, with his studio VectorCell due to interest from fans in seeing the franchise revived.
However, VectorCell managed to do it in just about the worst way possible, stripping away everything that had made the original unique and creating a vapid platform shooter that was, ironically, utterly forgettable.
The remake's platforming was simplified significantly, demanding none of the care that had once been required of players. A heavier emphasis on much easier combat turned the game into a generic run-and-gun shooter for a lot of its runtime, and 2.5D environments were insipid in comparison to the original's beautiful hand-drawn backdrops and rotoscoped animation.
With an expanded story came some truly bad writing to boot, with a lot of the original plot points revealed early on and all mystery lost. The reworked protagonist himself, however, was the worst offender.
At one point early on in the game upon picking up a new item, he says, "Awesome sauce".
Says it all.
3. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD
Make no mistake, the Tony Hawk's series is dead. Thoroughly dead and beginning to smell because for some reason because its publishers refuse to give it the burial it deserves.
Once a landmark franchise boasting such entries as Pro Skater 2 and the Tony Hawk's Underground titles, the series began circling the drain with lacklustre ripoffs of the increasingly popular Skate and woeful garbage such as the gimmicky peripheral-based Ride and Shred.
One final death rattle before the rigor mortis set in with the abominable Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5 was Tony Hawk's Pro Skater HD, an amalgam of the first 2 THPS for the Sony Playstation. A good idea on paper, its execution was extremely disappointing. The game did not feature any tricks or features from any later titles, and it lacked even basic core THPS features such as a park editor or local multiplayer.
For newcomers to the series, it felt sparse, clunky and unrefined, its lack of features comparing unfavourably to modern games. The experience was even worse for classic THPS fans, as the game simply felt threadbare - once again undermined by a distinct lack of content that had made the older games so widely cherished.
2. Warcraft III: Reforged
Blizzard Entertainment is known for having effectively cornered the MMORPG market with the legendary World Of Warcraft, crushing all known competitors under its overdesigned +20 Boots Of Pulverisation. However, the studio first cemented its revered status with the 2002 real-time strategy Warcraft III: Reign Of Chaos.
Introducing the series' now trademark cartoony 3D art style, Reign Of Chaos received universal acclaim for its exceptionally well-balanced gameplay, and a simple yet effective interface, making the game both enjoyable for newcomers and RTS veterans alike.
When Blizzard announced Warcraft III: Reforged, a remaster of the seminal title, it was met with a great deal of excitement, promising to tell its epic origin stories "more stunning and evocatively than ever before". Of course, when the game was finally released in January 2020, that excitement gave way to hatred. Reforged was plagued by bugs from the outset, and its changes in gameplay and massive, invasive user interface was roundly decried.
Not helping was a lack of many features promised by Blizzard in the run-up to release.
Worst of all, however, was a patch enforced on Reign Of Chaos that introduced many of these unwanted new features to the game, therefore ruining the experience of even the excellent original.
1. Silent Hill HD Collection
Although since the mid 2000s, the Silent Hill franchise has seen a gradual decline in quality culminating in the cancellation of a reboot that would have saved it and a pachinko machine where its headstone should have been, its early entries are some of the best titles that video game horror has to offer.
During the 7th generation of consoles, when HD ports of last-gen titles were gathering momentum, Hijinx Studios set about bringing seminal PS2 titles Silent Hill 2 and 3 to modern consoles - and they ballsed it up as spectacularly as anyone could.
The Silent Hill games are known for their visuals being scratchy and lo-fi, with a thick fog hanging over the town that obscured visibility and an aggressive film grain filter further adding to that sense of unease. The fog in the HD ports is reduced to barely a few wisps, and the grain is gone entirely. Little to no texture or modelling work has been performed, so the lack of fog or grain simply throws the dated models and environments into sharp, painful relief.
Coupled with its clumsily upscaled and stretched cinematics and unnecessarily re-recorded voice acting, the Silent Hill HD Collection is an embarrassing, lazy port, and fatally undermines everything that makes Silent Hill special.