9 Most Sadistic Evil Playthroughs In Gaming

Give in to the Dark Urge.

baldurs gate 3 dark urge
Larian Studios

It’s good to be bad. Too long have we suffered under the consequences of not being a sweetie pie, friend to all, and endlessly self-sacrificing pillar of the community in video games. Sometimes you need to let off steam, or in the case of these games, let off a chernobyl-grade explosion. 

Well, if you wanted to do that to the absolute extreme then these playthroughs would be for you, though, be warned, these aren’t your average Dark Side Jedi, anti-hero, or morally grey playthroughs. Most of them are downright despicable, housing antics that would probably get them thrown into the brig of refused classification titles if the people who made those decisions knew just how nasty they let players get.

Fun fact, Australia didn’t have an R18+ rating for games until 2013 so anything that didn’t make it into the M category couldn’t be sold or imported into the country. Which is interesting given that in the 1800s we played host to 160,000 criminals from the UK. Irony.

We’re skipping over some classics bad guy playthroughs this time around like Tyranny, Fallout, Dwarf Fortress, and Prototype but there’s plenty of deeply disturbing content from here on out so suspend your moral sensibilities and get ready to repeat “it’s okay, it’s just a game”, it’s about to get really messed up.

9. Fable 3

Fable 3 Crawler
Lionhead Studios

When you mess with the bull you get the horns, and similarly when you act like an unhinged maniacal villain in Fable 3 you also get the horns. 

Fable 3 is a game that’s particularly effective and not just letting you do naughty things but also making you feel like the embodiment of evil who is having an impact on the world around you just by being your naturally despicable self. You get real ugly, people run away from you, probably because you keep murdering them, you quite literally eat live baby chicks, and you end up as a despot who establishes child labour and implements totalitarian measures like demanding exorbitant taxes and exploiting the locals for their goods. The other Fable games also have their wild moments of letting you go all out evil so this entry stands in for the whole series.

Each game lets you properly embody a moustache twirling cartoon supervillain and in this case, you are bad and you are drawn that way.


8. Undertale

Undertale Flowey Evil
Toby Fox

Undertale’s reputation as a game that not only lets you choose pacifist options but also play the entire game without taking a potential foe’s life is pretty well known at this point. 

It’s also a game that lets you go full sadist with the genocide route that, well, does what it says on the tin.

If you want to be crowned the scourge of the Underground you’ll have to properly break bad and kill literally every possible monster in the game, an undertaking that has you not only taking out every monster you come across but pain-stakingly seeking them out to make sure none escape your game-long wrath. This includes all the cute doggies which is where this route gets extra messed up. You’ll also see fun changes in the way characters react to you and the things you can do in the game world like when checking Toriel’s cupboard your text won’t notify you of the cookie cutters for gingerbread monsters but instead read, “Where are the knives.” Yikes. And then you end up doing a murder on her, naturally.

Sparing even a single boss or failing to exhaust the kill counter in any region has you forfeit the pure evil run so at least no one could accuse you of not being committed. Although perhaps you should be committed for your bloodlust. The psych ward kind.


7. RimWorld

Rimworld game
Ludeon Games

If you’ve forgotten that the title of this list isn’t great or satisfying evil runs but specifically deeply disturbed and sadistic ones, then RimWorld is here to steer us back away from any semblance of morality. Slavery, cannibalism, the physical maiming of your populace, brainwashing, brutal cults with a penchant for human sacrifice, RimWorld has it all. 

Sure, you can not do all those things but if you want to be a demonic dictator then if you can dream it, you can do it. 

Of course, you’ll want to ponder exactly what kind of evil society you’d like to create. On the one hand you can go full Supremacist where people don’t bat an eyelid at your world littered with corpses or you can craft a society that I can only properly associate with the Reavers from Firefly. If you don’t know that reference, basically we’re talking about people who are big on murdering, wearing the skin of their victims, slavery, and pretty much any unsavoury thing that comes to mind. If The Sims went insane and the entire game existed with the mentality of taking a ladder out of a pool just to watch your little guys die then that’s where you’ll be at when playing evil in RimWorld.

You can’t go full Repo Man and remove the still beating heart from somebody’s chest in The Sims, nor can you make a fun hat out of human skin, but that’s why RimWorld takes this particular cake.


6. Baldur’s Gate 3

baldurs gate 3 raphael
Larian Studios

Modders saw a lot of opportunities to positively tweak their experience in Elder Scrolls games. Among the classics of graphical upgrades and streamlining UI, they also took it upon themselves to address what must have been a drastic oversight during the game’s development where the team decided you couldn’t be able to kill kids.

Fortunately, history didn’t repeat itself when Larian made Baldur’s Gate 3 because kids are back on the menu. That reference doesn’t work, you can’t eat them, but you sure can kill them. The goblin ones, anyway.

There are some conflicting accounts on how intentionally or accidentally killing the goblin little ones made people feel. Some were guilt-wracked while others, like me, were like “my last save was too long ago and those kids were annoying anyway.” Evil in Baldur’s Gate 3 doesn’t begin and end with pedicide, though.

I swear the word is actually pedicide, I looked it up.

The most story-centric playthrough assuming you don’t choose one of the premade characters is that of the Dark Urge, a person consumed with the urge to kill whose desire to take lives was driven just by the love of the game. The murder game. You’re also big into Bhaal, the god of murder, and this is just the beginning of the playthrough. If you want to surrender and go full sadistic serial killer you absolutely can, dragging your companions down with you, murdering people in cold blood, helping the bad people enslave, maim, and otherwise terrorise decent people and elevate nasty ones. 

While playing Dark Urge gives you access to disturbing nighttime antics, uber violent dialogue, and thoughts of brutally maiming your nearest and dearest, not to worry as you can still be a homicidal maniac as any character. 

Said maniacal activities include but are not limited to: kicking a squirrel, massacring a marginalised group of people, hijacking people’s thoughts and making them do stuff, brainwashing a gnoll to cannibalise his friends and then himself, throwing people, throwing children, throwing people at children, throwing children at other children, and so on.


5. Planescape: Torment

Planescape: Torment
Black Isle Studios

Critically acclaimed and criminally underplayed, most people are aware that Planescape: Torment is a celebrated RPG but not everybody knows that when it comes to its evil playthrough options, you can be downright diabolical. Or catastrophically chaotic. Or superbly sadistic. 

All of this to say, you’ll be even more evil than Thanos with an itchy thumb. Or people who bring kids to a pub.

Planescape: Torment is unique in that it was one of the earliest RPGs to heavily feature player decisions and enable you to resolve quests by talking the talk instead of stabbing the stab. That said, there’s plenty of ways to be sadistic without getting your hands dirty but you’re more than welcome to do both. You can quite literally sell your party into slavery in exchange for cool gear, manipulate everybody to do your bidding and get what you want, murder people just because you feel like it, threaten and lie like your life depends on it, and just embody a ruthless and violent force to be reckoned with.

That’s the tip of the iceberg but Planescape is a good example of what happens when you combine great writing with a willingness to get super dark.


4. Crusader Kings

crusader kings 3
Paradox

Another game that scales in evilness to be as twisted as you want it to be, Crusader Kings titles may appear to be noble tales of expanding your house across the known world to grab extra land and establish your legacy but anyone who has played it knows that things get pretty wild pretty quickly. This is true even for those who aren’t intending to use the strategy game as some kind of proving grounds for their destiny as one of time’s greatest power-hungry psychopaths. 

The thing with Crusader Kings is that it’s a pretty slippery slope. You’ll start by coyly clicking an option that screws over a neighbouring house or taking advantage of your people’s good will and then all of a sudden you’re plotting to murder your own child because they turned out a bit crap. 

Crusader Kings is almost terrifying in the way even the most moral will abandon their values. You’ll often arrive at a point where war is obviously the most useful option, but there are also far more underhanded and insidious actions like paying people off to slyly murder your enemies or engage in some light torture of a vassal until your victim goes insane. Then there’s the old middle ages classics: seducing or impregnating your own family members, gouging out eyes, chopping off peens, torturing prisoners, you get the gist. 

The sadism hits another level in Crusader Kings because it’s not just an option, it’s often the best option, as being a ruthless unhinged murderer tends to get you further than if you’re a nice honourable guy. Just look at Eddard Stark. 

The most disturbing part of the game is it makes you kind of understand the logic behind history’s nastiest despots. Although maybe not so far as to understand cannibalism and human sacrifice which Crusader Kings also gives the all clear to. The second game does let you spread Satanism as the Antichrist at which point your government type changes to Empire of Terror. And you can throw the Pope off a balcony.

You can also say mean things to people. And hook up with the Pope. They’re not really sadistic but I feel like they need to be said.


3. Black & White

black & white game
Lionhead Studios

Black & White is a 2001 game made by Fable mastermind Peter Molyneux that has been largely forgotten over the years which is a shame because it was really solid. It also let you play god and left it up to you to decide what kind of god that was going to be.

For the purposes of our list, I’m going to assume you decided to be the malevolent and dastardly kind.

We’ve already talked about Molyneux letting you be bad via the means of Fable but the freedom of the god game genre opens doors to sadism that the RPG genre simply doesn’t have at its disposal. These doors include those tied to the creature you train and grow as you play. Curiously you can choose to be good and have your creature reap mayhem or vice versa. 

Or you can both head down the path that makes your temple look like it’d fit right in on the main street of Hell and your beast ends up as some bastardised yucky final form of what was once a regular animal. 

The game also features torture, cult sacrifices, familicide, withholding food from your people, making your monster a murder machine, and enough nasty options to make a dark side jedi start thinking “that’s a bit much.”


2. Stellaris

Stellaris Colossus planet killer
Paradox Interactive

There’s an argument to be made that RimWorld is a straight up war crime simulator. Although, that argument could really be made for a healthy handful of games on this list. That said, 2016 4X game Stellaris lets you commit atrocities across galaxies so pretty much every living thing can suffer under your sadistic whims. If that’s not enough to qualify for one of our top spots, I don’t know what is.

With the mechanical scale and f-ed up features of Crusader Kings and the unhinged freedom of RimWorld, Stellaris is uniquely positioned to make any parent gravely regret buying this game for their kids.

While there have been plenty of games on our list where you can do incredibly vile things, Stellaris enables a level of brutality that many gamers would say pushes the envelope a bit too far. Like, well off the desk and into the realm of planet-wide genocide via the means of orbital strikes, and turning an entire race into slaves, or turning an entire race into food. Or both, I guess. Like I said, a pretty significant trip for the envelope. 

You take on the role of a premade or custom civilisation and naturally some are more geared for evil than others. It’s a bit like how in Twilight Imperium I like to play The Nekro Virus which is just a straight up galactic threat. 

Though it’s less visceral than some other sadistic game playthroughs, the more sickening things you can do in Stellaris are the ones that affect entire planets either by causing mass destruction leaving survivors stranded, grieving, or starving, forcibly enslaving people into following your religion through brainwashing, or causing planet-wide natural disasters. Stellaris appears to be a fairly innocuous if complex 4x strategy game but under the hood it houses just about every evil possibility you could ever imagine unleashing on an unsuspecting universe. 

It’s enough to make you a bit queasy. Although that could be because my dinner was half a block of cheese and a bunch of red licorice. Let’s find out by jumping into our last entry in this list of awesome, yucky, and deeply messed up playthroughs.


1. Kenshi

kenshi game cannibals
Low-Fi Games

Kenshi is a 2016 real-time strategy RPG that focuses on player freedom and met with a lot of love from both critics and the general public. It’s also notable for having been made by one dude over the course of twelve years. The game is enormous in terms of scale, possibilities, and customisation. You’re thrown into the post apocalypse up against the elements and a brutal world that’s prepped to chew you up and spit you out so it’s bound to make people get a little cold-hearted at best. Or full-on sadistic sociopath at worst. The world is really your oyster ultimately and as a post apocalyptic playground you can do whatever you want. You can, of course, decide to be a chill trader or nobly set out to abolish slavery, or you can be a slave trader and make money that way. If that’s already got your “yuck” reaction going, we aren’t stopping there. In the torture realm alone you can have your new recruits train up their combat skills by beating up captive NPCs, unalive your enemies by watching beasts devour them, or perhaps you’d like to invest in a Peeler Machine.

This does what it says on the tin except instead of doing so with, like, a mango, it does it with whatever human you decide to put in it. 

If you’d like to subcontract said killing you can always shift people you don’t like into the hands of cannibals, yes of course there are cannibals, or the savage Fogmen who attack people and then bring them back to their camp for your classic hivemind activity; the ritualistic eating of a live captive. Just a regular Saturday night. It takes a long time to become powerful in Kenshi as it’s relentlessly difficult and you’ll need to navigate the systems of exploration, progression, recruitment, town-building, combat, and survival. Not to mention its curious damage system where you and your foes can permanently lose limbs. 

Once you pull that off, though, you’ll find that your opportunities for executing heinous atrocities the world over are boundless, so isn’t that nice? I think we all need a montage of cats going for jumps onto kitchen islands and then noping out at the last second to recover from this list.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jess has been a journalist and content creator in the games industry for over 15 years and has been WhatCulture's resident Australian import and sorry cop since 2020, upping the quotient of swearing and apologising in WhatCulture Gaming's annual blooper videos considerably. She previously worked at GameSpot for 10 years, most notably hosting GameSpot News in addition to E3 live shows, and PAX panels. She regularly livestreams a variety of games on her 'jessmcdonell' YouTube and Twitch channels and hosts the 'Do It On The Day' podcast. She has won awards for her news and feature work in gaming as well as an accolade for her comedic writing (likely an admin error). She can be found on X at @jessmcdonell and Instagram at @jessicamcdonell sharing her current videogame fixations, industry insights, and videos of her cat, Karma.