Mafia 3: 8 Big Things It Got Wrong
The soundtrack might be swinging, but not everything is rosy in New Bordeaux.
Since its release, Mafia 3 has topped the gaming sales charts and has gained a following of dedicated fans, and it’s easy to see why:
The compelling story, interesting characters, unique setting, historically-accurate social tensions and the killer soundtrack all help it stand out from its competitors in the crowded third-person sandbox genre.
Hanger 13 - the fairly inexperienced studio behind the game - have been ambitious with many aspects of this newest entry in the beloved series; trying to make it as different as possible when compared to a landmark franchise such as Grand Theft Auto.
However, when trying to be this ambitious, there’s always a chance certain elements will fall short of the mark. Or to put it another way, there’s always the risk that in striving to nail newer, more innovative game mechanics, the more basic parts can get overlooked.
Unfortunately, here are the things that Mafia 3 got wrong.
8. Frustrating Environment Design
The city of New Bordeaux, based off the real-life city of New Orleans, is simply incredible. The detail that has gone into the different neighbourhoods is awe-inspiring, and really helps Mafia 3 stand out from its rivals.
Sadly, travelling around this beautiful city doesn’t always go smoothly.
There are a lot of areas with fences, walls with only one or two entrances, meaning if you go quite far in - usually when looking for collectibles - you have to run all the way back to a particular entrance to get back out. The map doesn’t show many of these barriers either, meaning you can run towards a section of an area thinking it’s open-ended, only to find a wall in the way with no door.
This wouldn’t be as annoying if you were able to just jump over fences, but Lincoln has a hard time climbing over a lot of ledges and walls that you would otherwise assume he should get over.
Lincoln’s climbing truly becomes rage-inducing when you end up in water. If you crash your boat or just jump in the water for a shortcut, you can often end up having to swim for ages just to get back onto land, thanks to only a couple of specific ledge-heights being the ones you can pull yourself onto.
7. Objective Tracking Is Poorly Executed
With so many different missions available at the same time, Mafia 3 really needed an easy method of tracking everything you need to do.
Whilst the menus in the game certainly look stylish, actually using them isn't very straightforward. The missions are split up by rackets, each with several sub-tasks that need to be completed. But the sub-tasks all fall under the same mission task list, so tracking which one you are currently doing can be tricky, especially when you only need to do a few of the sub-tasks to complete the main mission objective.
This extends to tracking collectibles, as the only way to know how many you’ve collected is via a percentage on the menu - (which isn’t entirely accurate.
For example, there are eight different types of Communist Poster, but multiple copies of each one. However, the tracker only counts the type you’ve got, meaning it can show 100% completion when you haven’t actually collected them all.
There’s nothing telling you the exact number you’ve collected or have left to get, or how many of a particular collectible are left in a certain district, despite this being a common feature in other games. This is made all the more frustrating, because the collectibles in Mafia 3 are actually worth collecting.
6. Weapon And Ammo Limits
In an attempt at realism, Mafia 3 only lets you carry two weapons at a time; a handgun and a large weapon (a choice of shotgun, assault rifle, large rifle or a special weapon).
Whilst this is the standard for many recent FPS games, the majority of open world sandbox titles let you carry several weapons at a time. Having to choose which firearms you want to use before each activity gets frustrating, as you just want to be able to carry all types instead.
It’s not like there’s a realistic animation of Lincoln carrying the rifle and taking it from his back to use, either; it just disappears into the ether like all other sandbox games, so there’s no real reason why you’re limited to just two.
Max Payne 3, this ain't.
If ammo was plentiful, then the two weapons wouldn’t be so bad. But all weapons have very limited ammo, meaning you really have to get your aim spot on, especially when the enemies can often take a full clip to put down.
Enemies do drop plenty of ammo, but if you find yourself pinned down in a corner, you can easily completely run out, resulting in a quick trip to the loading screen and your old friend, the last checkpoint.
5. City Businesses Don't Do Anything
Mafia 3 is full of shops, diners, garages and bars that make New Bordeaux feel like a living, breathing city. So it’s a shamen that these various businesses have absolutely no impact on the game whatsoever.
They might be interesting to explore first time around, but none of the shops or bars have any gameplay value. At all.
The only thing they're used for is to rob them or to pick up collectibles that have been left behind. The only difference is their appearance and the ones that have ‘No Colored’ signs outside. This is an interesting inclusion as it contributes to the racial framework and inbuilt tension across the game, but in reality, all that happens is the owner of the business will shout at you until you either leave, or they call the police.
The most frustrating part about all this is that major businesses are included as icons on the map, alluding to some functionality and making it feel like you're missing something obvious. If Hanger 13 had added some side activities involving these businesses, they may have had some real purpose, but as it stands, nada.
4. Friendly AI Can Be Irritating
Computer AI is always a difficult thing to get just right. You want engaging enemies that you can't just slaughter without any challenge, and you also want friendly characters who are genuinely useful.
The enemies in Mafia 3 are fairly intelligent, with sentries running to call for backup if they spot you and most enemies going for cover when a shoot-out starts.
The main issue with the AI is with your associates, who you can call in to deliver guns, cars and to collect your money. For some reason, the gun runner always seems to park in the middle of the road, regardless of where you call him from. It's just weird more than anything, as Lincoln is buying illegal weapons from a bright orange van parked in the middle of traffic, but it gets really annoying when you’ve called during a shootout and have to run all the way over to him.
Good luck trying to call any associates when out in the Bayou, as they will often park up in an area that you are nowhere near, meaning the one minute timer will run out before you’ve gotten there.
3. Choosing Non-Lethal Takedowns On The Menu
As games have matured and started continue to focus on realistic characters and stories, many players like choosing the pacifist option when playing, preferring to knock out enemies and use stealthy tactics, rather than going in guns blazing.
In Mafia 3, however, the ability to choose between lethal and non-lethal takedowns has to be selected from the ‘Options’ menu.
A gameplay feature as basic as this, something that games like Deus Ex, Splinter Cell: Blacklist and Metal Gear Solid V let you decide via a simple button press, should not have to be turned on and off every time via the pause menu. The game doesn’t reward or punish you for choosing between killing enemies or knocking them out, but from a gameplay perspective, it’s nice to be able to choose on the fly, especially when it’s a basic button prompt that activates the animation.
Surely they could have used Triangle/Y for non-lethal takedowns, seeing as that button is only usable when near a ledge or wall?
2. The Police Are Useless
The police in Mafia 3 pose very little threat. When a witness is triggered after stealing a car, by the time they’ve run to a phone and called the police, you are usually already miles outside the police search zone before it appears on the map, meaning the risk of creating a witness by committing a crime is meaningless.
The ‘suspicion’ warning that appears when police go past Lincoln is a nice touch, as it alludes to the attitudes of the 1960s era where police were unfairly suspicious of most black people. However, even this feature isn’t used properly. When you drive past a police car, the warning will appear on screen, but unless you stay within the meter for ages, nothing will happen. You can pretty much go speeding right past police officers, drifting around them at traffic lights, and they won’t react.
If you do manage to get chased by New Bordeaux’s finest, losing them doesn’t take much effort - just a couple of turns down side streets and they can’t keep up.
Sometimes, if you take a sharp turn hard enough, the car following you can flip, roll and explode all by itself (which is pretty cool to see, to be fair). Still, Mafia 3’s law enforcement never poses much of a threat, which removes some of the challenge and makes the very idea of law enforcement nothing more than a minor annoyance.
1. Limited Gameplay Variation
The main appeal of open world games is that there is always a lot to do. Games like Skyrim and Grand Theft Auto are well known for having so many side activities available that people never get around to doing the actual story missions. Mafia 3 isn’t one of those games.
Some people might praise Hanger 13 for focusing on the story (which is amazingly mature, intelligent and compelling) instead of padding the game with pointless side missions, but they didn’t need to remove side activities completely. There are some optional missions, but these consist of either going to an area and killing people or going to an area and stealing something – that’s it.
The game needed at least some side activities to participate in. Anything really; a fight club, shooting ranges, races, helping citizens in your home neighbourhood – just something separate from the main campaign. Critics slated the open world Mad Max game for having too little to do in such a big space, but Mafia 3 has even less.
With so much detail going into crafting the vibrant city of New Bordeaux and so much potential for side quests and activities, having virtually nothing outside of missions and collectibles is one hell of a standout negative.
--
Do you agree? How have you found Mafia 3 since launch? Let us know in the comments!