Ranking EVERY Xbox Game Studio From Worst To Best

Do Bethesda go to the top of the pile??

xbox bethesda doom
Xbox

The gaming community is still recovering from the earth-shifting news that Microsoft acquired ZeniMax Media/Bethesda Softworks for a hefty $7.5 billion price tag, but let’s not forget this seems to be the culmination of a three-year buying spree for Xbox.

Throughout the generation, a major advantage for Sony has been its muscular first-party content. Microsoft’s family of developers was considered in the underwhelming category, with only a handful that existed to focus on tentpole franchises (e.g. Halo, Gears, and Forza) …and that was it.

Then things changed.

A regime switch in 2017 has had Phil Spencer take a position as Vice President of the gaming division, offering talented studios complete creative freedom and healthy funds to join the house of Xbox.

With most of the deals fairly fresh, the dividends are yet to pay off. Especially in the case of Bethesda, which holds a large archive of IPs and studios that need to step through a year worth of red tape. However, the result is that the in-house collective shot up from a lukewarm stable of seven first-party studios to twenty-two incredibly exciting ones.

Now that the dust has settled on this mad acquisition phase, it’s an opportune time to sift through Xbox’s incredibly powerful family of in-house developers and see how they compare to each other, plus what fresh stuff they are currently working on?

22. The Initiative

The Initiative
Microsoft

Past Highlights: Nothing...as yet

In Development: An unknown triple-A project

Created by Xbox from the ground up in 2018, with the 'initiative' to build the type of AAA story-driven exclusive games that are more common on PlayStation consoles, as well as support their first-party brethren. Essentially, it's to be Microsoft's answer to Sony Santa Monica.

We can assume it will be something special due to the staff rooster reading like a checklist of all-star game talent: Darell Gallagher (producer of Tomb Raider reboots), Christian Cantamessa (lead writer/designer of Red Dead Redemption), Drew Murray (game director of Sunset Overdrive), and Brian Westergaard (lead producer on the God Of War reboot), just to name a few...

That's all well and good, but as of yet, they've got nothing to show, not even a logo or teaser for their in-development first project...hence why it sits at the bottom.


21. Alpha Dog Games

Recent Release: Wraithborne

Past Highlights: Monstrocity: Rampage, Ninja Golf

In Development: Unknown Bethesda mobile project

This Canadian mobile gaming studio packs a genre diverse backlog such as action RPG Wraithborne, and Kaiju-inspired tower-defense game Monstrocity: Rampage.

Last year, Bethesda bought them. It's a move that makes sense due to the publisher's re-occurring interest in the mobile scene (e.g. Fallout Shelter, The Elder Scrolls: Blades).

It does make for an odder fit for the Xbox family though, as the company has had little interest in this field (unless you count xCloud streaming). We can assume they will remain under the Bethesda management umbrella and we won't see Halo android games any time soon.

The company has the potential to do some fun things with Bethesda IPs, however, they look quite small when compared to the other big dogs on this list.


20. Undead Labs

State Of Decay 2
Undead Labs

Recent Release: State of Decay 2: Juggernaut Edition

Past Highlights: State of Decay

In Development: State Of Decay 3

Bought by Xbox in 2018, Labs specializes in the zombie survival games, the State of Decay franchise.

The first installment released on Xbox 360, it was flawed and a little rough-around-the-edges but had enough enjoyable concepts amidst its lower points, and grew a small cult following with gamers hopeful the next go-around would be improved.

There was less sympathy when the sequel dropped on Xbox One though, as it felt just as janky, compromised, and graphically low-fi as the first. The recent Juggernaut Edition redeemed some of the issues, but it still a clear-cut disappointment.

Now that Labs are full-time employees of Microsoft, one hopes they can deliver the refined and polished experience the franchise has the potential to be...here's hoping.


19. Compulsion Games

We Happy Few
Gearbox

Recent Release: We Happy Few

Past Highlights: Contrast

In Development: Unknown

Bought by Xbox in 2018, Compulsion is a fairly young Canadian studio that has released a handful of interesting if flawed games.

Contrast, a platformer with intriguing mechanics and gorgeous design, and We Happy Few, a unique open-world title with a great premise. Both are distinct games with original ideas behind them, but also felt lacking in compelling gameplay...which led to lukewarm sales.

Still, their alliance with Microsoft gives reason to perk up, it's a studio filled with individual talent and massive potential but struggled to get a foothold as an indie dev.

With the recent news that they are expanding their workspace and staff for a brand 'new universe', the next one could finally see their ace ideas get the proper development time and production value to see it through to its full capability.


18. Roundhouse Studios

The Quiet Man
Square Enix

Recent Release: (as Human Head Studios) Rune 2

Past Highlights: (as Human Head Studios) Rune, Prey (2006)

In Development: Unknown

Technically a brand-new studio founded by Bethesda, they are actually a newly monikered version of Human Head Studios, the veteran studio that went defunct in 2019, but was then bought and saved by ZeniMax immediately after.

As Human Head, they hold a spotty, if lively, track record. Highlights include the Viking action/adventure Rune, and the distinct cult hit Prey (2006). Low-lights include the half-baked Rune 2, and the hilariously awful The Quiet Man.

They actually might be best remembered for a game they didn't make, Prey 2, an ambitious Blade Runner-inspired follow-up that put you in the shoes of an intergalactic bounty hunter. Some dramatic shenanigans led to the game being canceled, and Human Head was on the ropes financially ever since.

I think it's safe to say they have stability now though, with not only Bethesda as a sugar daddy...but now also Xbox.

While their backlog is fairly hit-and-miss, it's also a studio that didn't get a fair shot, with a new clean slate, the ball is in their court to finally prove their full worth.


17. ZeniMax Online Studios

elder scrolls online
Bethesda

Recent Release: Elder Scrolls Online: Stonethorn

Past Highlights: Elder Scrolls Online

In Development: Expansions for Elder Scrolls Online

Founded over a decade ago by ZeniMax Media, with the main purpose of building a massive MMO using Bethesda's Elder Scrolls franchise.

After being a half-decade in development, Elder Scrolls Online dropped in 2014 to average reviews. The release was rough, with bugs aplenty, and not a whole lot to do in the campaign.

However, the studio managed to turn the tides by redeeming it into a smooth experience and pumping out fantastic expansion packs, growing it into one of the most robust MMOs on the market.

Due to this, the dev seems to have only really hit its stride in the last few years and hasn't really shown much diversity outside of supporting ESO.

Also, how they will fit into Xbox is a mystery? It's a safe assumption they will remain doing what they do...but perhaps all expansions will go to Game Pass?


16. 343 Industries

Halo 4
343 Industries

Recent Release: Halo 5: Guardians

Past Highlights: Halo 4, Halo: Master Chief Collection

In Development: Halo: Infinite

After Bungie separated from Microsoft (but left the Halo IP), 343 were created with the tough job of continuing the adventures of Master Chief and co.

With that in mind, their first effort of Halo 4 was never going to hit expectations, but they did give it a worthy shot: a solid (if safe) campaign with gorgeous graphics, plus an involving plotline with new enemy types (finally).

The studio has had less luck since though: a buggy launch for Halo: The Master Chief Collection and a disappointing result for Halo 5: Guardians. Now, their highly anticipated comeback project, Halo: Infinite, has been hit by delays, production woes, and underwhelming gameplay showcases.

Still, the verdict is not out yet, and with Microsoft extending dev time, we could still get a fantastic Halo game from all this...fingers crossed.


15. World’s Edge

Age Of Empires IV
Microsoft Studios

Recent Release: Age of Empires III: Definitive Edition (with Tantalus Media)

Past Highlights: Age of Empires I & ii: Definitive Edition (with Forgotten Empires)

In Development: Age of Empires IV (with Relic Entertainment)

Back in 1997, Microsoft's pushed into PC gaming with the RTS franchise Age of Empires, a rich and strategic delve into fascinating historical eras, that spanned three championed titles.

However a little over a decade later, designated developer Ensemble Studios shuttered its doors, and the franchise lost its focus and respected position.

With the announcement of the long-awaited Age of Empires IV, so came the reveal of World's Edge, a dedicated studio that will act as 'caretaker' to the franchise as it developed several titles simultaneously.

So they aren't a full-blown in-house dev, but more the equivalent of a Showrunner on a TV show: they hold the creative vision and direction of the property and work with other talented individuals to make it happen. In this specific case, by sharing assets, co-developing, and providing supporting tech.

So far, they've just shepherd a series of slick and enjoyable remakes of the original trilogy. However, the true test of their talent will be the much-hyped (and long-awaited) fourth installment...let's hope they pull it off.


14. Mojang Studios

minecraft dungeons
Mojang

Recent Release: Minecraft Dungeons

Past Highlights: Minecraft

In Development: ... more Minecraft?

In 2011, Markus Persson (and his company Mojang) released the pixelated open-world game of Minecraft in a pre-alpha release. That niche indie experiment would go on to be the worldwide phenomenon your nephew is currently playing on his parent's mobile phone.

Persson eventually sold the company and IP to Microsoft in 2014, but the exclusive ownership has not prevented it from coming to every platform known to man - including rival consoles like PS4, Switch, and very recently, the PSVR.

Mojang is basically the Minecraft company though, with not much dev diversity in their backlog...sure, they've made other games, but you'll be hard-pressed to name them (hint: Caller's Bane).

Recently though, they had a chance to do something different, albeit within the franchise, with Minecraft Dungeons, an incredibly fun and family-friendly spin on Diablo.

So while they are an essential cash cow for Xbox, relegated to endless updates, they might have more welcome experimental opportunities, showcasing their versatility, in the near future.


13. InXile Entertainment

Wasteland 3
InXile

Recent Releases: Wasteland 3

Notable Games: Wasteland 2, Torment: Tides Of Numenera

In Development: Frostpoint VR: Proving Ground, unknown RPG project

Bought up by Xbox in 2018, inXile is made up of several key members from the highly regarded, but defunct, Interplay Entertainment.

They've been kicking around since 2004, coasting at failed blockbuster attempts (Hunted: The Demon's Forge) and quick and easy jobs-for-hire gigs (Super Stacker).

Kickstarter led to a major rejuvenation for them though, with proposed projects, Wasteland 2 and Torment: Tides Of Numenera, hitting landmark high funding goals. This was due to the pitched return to the retro aesthetic of the isometric RPG genre - something it did in a divisive warts-and-all approach.

The recent Wasteland 3 was much more successful though, helped by a healthy dev budget from Xbox, they hit a great balance of the depth and freedom of the old-school RPG, while refining the experience successfully for a modern age.

They are currently experimenting in VR with Frostpoint, plus have two unannounced RPGs in early stages. While their track record is uneven, their Xbox accompanied the future looks to be very exciting indeed.


In this post: 
Bethesda
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

is a working dad by day and a determined gamer by night. He’s paid his dues in both the gaming and film industries, and this year his first feature film as screenwriter, the Polish slasher flick "13 Days Till Summer", played at Fantastic Fest and Sitges Film Festival.