10 Exact Moments Where Video Game Immersion Was Shattered

There's only so many times you can watch an NPC run into a wall.

Heavy Rain Thumbnail
Quantic Dream

Immersion, in pretty much any creative medium, is key. If you don't believe that Star Wars can have space battles and green milk-squirting aliens, the magic of the series will be lost on you. If a Hobbit's hairy feet seem too weird to you, the dragon-chasing antics of the book and films are likely to also be more irritating than entertaining for you.

However, because many video games run on slightly more surreal concepts, they rely on immersion far more. When you can play as a purple talking dragon or bipedal bandicoot and still feel invested and interested in the franchise, you know some developers did a damn good job.

Because games don't have to be perfect to maintain immersion, as a whole bunch of RPGs have shown us that plenty of weird alienating things can happen and you'll still love them. However, as the outcast child Fallout 67 has taught us well, there's a limit to our tolerance for shenanigans and issues in games.

When you're looking for a little old fashioned escapism, you don't want it sabotaged by the game itself, which doesn't seem like a crazy desire.

10. Being Over-Encumbered

Skyrim Over-encumbered
Bethesda

Finishing a challenging quest, picking up your loot and then realising your movement speed has slowed to a snail's pace is an incredibly common experience in video games, and an incredibly painful one.

Now, it's worth saying these systems aren't put in for no reason. If you were allowed to collect everything you could without limit, most Fallout players would keep a hundred pieces of power armour in their inventory because nobody was stopping them.

However, it's also undeniably frustrating to have to throw out twelve cabbages or a ton of weird junk you were planning on selling later just because you need to get your backpack lighter. People play video games, generally, to have fun, not to have to crunch the math on how many bat wings it takes to be twenty kilograms lighter.

Also, you'll often find yourself unable to part with anything, which leaves you on a fun, totally relaxing quest where you have to slowly crawl seven miles to sell all the valuable but useless junk you have sat in your overloaded inventory.


9. Saving Reminders

Pokemon Save Game
Game Freak

Being reminded to save is both a blessing and a curse in video games. On one hand, not being reminded by a game means there's a good chance that, if you die, you're going to be set back possibly hours ago when you last saved your game, which is a painful, painful fate.

But on the other hand, there is definitely a line in the sand as to how often is acceptable to be reminded. Get a game that constantly bothers you about saving, and you can't help but feel like you accidentally bought yourself some extra chores to be nagged about doing constantly.

This is even worse if a character explicitly tells you to save, because suddenly this collection of pixels if your new parent, and a very nagging one - especially when the game could have just implemented auto saves instead.

Paradoxically, this can actually encourage you to not save out of some strange feeling of spite, meaning not only has your immersion been painfully broken, but there's also still a chance you'll die having last saved three hours ago. The only thing bitterer than dying without saving is dying without saving whilst knowing the game screamed at you about it every chance it got.


8. Repetitive Voice Lines

Heavy Rain jason
Quantic Dream

"JASON! JASON!" sound familiar?

If you are one of the few lucky people to not know where that banger of a line comes from, it's time to spoil that kind hand that fate has dealt you. This line comes from an infamous scene in Heavy Rain, wherein you - playing Jason's father Ethan - run around a mall shouting for your lost son.

Doesn't sound all that funny, right? Well it's not supposed to be, but because approximately three voice lines were recorded for it, Ethan brokenly repeats them half a dozen times during this section of the game, which quickly becomes accidentally hilarious.

This is perhaps the best example of why recording sufficient voice lines are important for a game. While certain scenarios don't require more than one line repeated, serious moments can quickly become totally surreal if there isn't a wealth of different dialogue to hear - especially if said dialogue is one word repeatedly shouted.

In a time where Telltale-esque choose-your-own-adventure games are becoming steadily more popular and big budget, we can only hope more and more focus goes on showcase a game's voice actors and their skills - instead of accidentally making them into a meme.


7. Being Told What Button To Press (By A Character)

Mario Luigi Superstar saga
Nintendo

It's helpful when a game tells you what to do, that's for sure, as nobody likes bumbling through the tutorial of a game unsure what to do.

There are examples are being told what exact buttons to press that just feel right, too; like Cuphead's cartoony intro that takes you through all your moves, or Dark Souls' nice little habit of putting helpful info in your way via messages on the floor.

These innocuous tutorials are significantly superior to the alternative: characters explicitly telling you what to do. When a fictional character who should have no idea about your controller tells you to press a certain button to do a certain thing, it feels more than a little strange, because it fully breaks the fourth wall in dramatic fashion.

This happens in some undeniably great games, such as the first Metal Gear Solid, but even then it takes you slightly out of your immersion, because it feels like the characters in the game know you're playing it - and also think you have no idea what you're doing. And while this work to some degree in MGS1, because the whole thing is suitably meta, it doesn't for a lot of other games that try the same shtick.

Mercifully, this is usually at the start of a game, so you have time to forget about it.


6. Broken Lock-Ons

Sonic Lock on
SEGA

In a lot of games, a lock on system is basically vital. It both lets the game know what enemy you are specifically trying to attack - so you don't end up just auto-aiming into whatever is closest - and also allows you to properly focus on one foe without getting sick from the camera roaming around wherever it wants.

It's a great system - right up until it's not. If you get a game where the lock on randomly swaps between enemies, or god forbid randomly deselects, you can feel personally victimised. It's frustrating to feel as though you as fighting against the game while trying to play it, and this feeling is never more potent than when you can't even hit the thing you're trying to.

Many games have developed ways around this by allowing you to customise how lock-on works in your game settings. But far more are sort of happy to leave you to it, and while it's not a cardinal sin for a game, it's definitely annoying enough to make whatever sense of immersion you had gently evaporate.


5. Slow Environment Loading

Skyrim Intro
Bethesda

In the current age, we are blessed with games so glossy and well-crafted that they look almost more real than real life. Better yet, games that have slightly outdated graphics are often treated to visual upgrades or mods, allowing players to go through old favourites with new modern day graphics.

And so, in a sense, we are spoiled. But even as spoiled as we are, one curse still pervades: the curse of environment loading.

While in many cases it can't be helped, it's uniquely jarring to appear in a new area and see it still be a blurry unrendered mess. Though you can mercifully often wait this out, it still reminds you that you are essentially playing through a series of loading screens, which isn't exactly easy to forget.

Importantly, this can happen in a scenario where you can't just hang out until everything loads in, which is even more jarring because you're now barrelling through a landscape that is going to spend even more time loading it because now you've had to frighten the poor thing.


4. Invisible Walls

Legend of Zelda Breath of the Wild
Nintendo

Now, this isn't really the fault of many games that incorporate it, because not every game can just keep creating land in front of you Minecraft-style.

But it's also undeniable that running nose first into the gaming equivalent of a glass door is always a bad time for your sense of immersion. It reminds you that, as much as you're having run right now, you are doing so within carefully confined walls that you have to stay within, unless you want to fall through the map for your sins.

It's an especially cruel gesture when it happens not at the edge of a map, but almost arbitrarily in a certain area you can't scale or go through because... well, just because. That's what makes random invisible walls so jarring: because sometimes they just don't make sense to someone who wasn't involved in development.

This also goes for certain areas opening up, as often if you're exploring a game without having done the main quest you'll discover a locked or inexplicably sealed area that you automatically realise is a part of the main storyline.


3. Unpredictable Button Prompts

LA Noire Cole Phelps Interrogation
Rockstar

If there was one thing that prevented L.A Noire from being the best detective game of all time, it was that, occasionally, the voice prompts you could choose between would be the wildest things on god's green Earth.

Since the developers had to try and explain several lines of dialogue that Cole would say in a word or two, they often very much didn't match what you would say, resulting in you picking an option you would have never chose if you'd fully known about it.

There's no stress quite like picking an option that seems like a reasonable choice, and then seeing your boy Phelps accuse an old lady of being secretly Hitler and then supplex her over her dining room table.

This isn't just true for L.A Noire though, but also many, many other games. Finding yourself accidentally betraying characters you sought to help makes you totally lose your immersion, as the game has taken what you thought you were going to do, and provided you with something totally different.

L.A Noire was a great game, but many likely lost their connection with it the first time Cole Phelps flipped the script on them, and we can't really blame them for that.


2. Bad AI

Ride to Hell: Retribution
Deep Silver

It's safe to say that programming good AI is the most important part of a game. Whether it be realistic behaviour in NPCs, interesting fighting patterns of bosses, or even an effective AI sidekick, effective and clever AI programming really goes a long way.

Anyone who was brave enough or foolish enough to play Ride to Hell: Retribution understands this all too well. Held up as a bastion of what not to do in a game, Ride to Hell fails most powerfully on the clunky, confusing behaviour of its characters, with enemies that are as likely to come fight you as they are to run into the nearest wall forever, and side characters that have all the personality and movement of a teaspoon. And that's kind of harsh on teaspoons.

Though this is almost endearing in games like Fallout and Skyrim - because we understand that games on a certain scale aren't going to be perfect - but it's still more than a little jarring every time you see an NPC walk over a chair or into a wall right in front of your eyes.


1. Microtransactions

Dungeon Keeper microtransactions
EA

Look, we all saw this one coming, and for damn good reason. There is very little that throws you out of a sense of immersion quite like being asked for your credit card or bank details, especially in order to obtain something that isn't a necessary part of the game.

Not only does this take you out of the experience because you have to remember what's in your bank account, it also takes away much of the sense of achievement you usually get through getting good at a game. After all, getting rare skins, cards, or even achievements feels cheap when you know you could have just bought them in the first place.

Secondly, it's such a sketchy practice that it sort of makes you question whether you actually do want to keep playing the game, which is basically the most removed you can be from immersion.

Instead of wondering what cool thing you can do next, you're left trying to figure out if you can get through the game successfully without paying hard-earned real world cash, which sucks on several levels.


Watch Next


Can You Handle Our Insanely Hard Video Game Quiz?

Xbox Menu
Microsoft

1. When Microsoft Launched The Xbox, What Did They Say Was The Meaning Behind The Animated Green Goo On The Dashboard?

Contributor
Contributor

I like my comics like I like my coffee - in huge, unquestionably unhealthy doses.