The Elder Scrolls VI: 10 Essential Things It Must Learn From Skyrim

How do you top one of the greatest games of all time? Easy...

It goes without saying that as soon as Bethesda announced they were doing their own conference at E3 this June, the walls themselves cried out "FALLOUT 4!", it's been that long. However, although there's much to be picked apart when it comes to the franchise Bethesda took from Black Isle Studios, their own creation, Elder Scrolls, is arguably more anticipated, being they've always handcrafted every part of it from the ground up across the last couple of decades. So far their biggest achievement has been 2012's Skyrim, a game so packed to the brim with things to do, see and take in it was genuinely jaw-dropping. The world the team created back then had an interdependency all its own, giving off a sensation that you were a very important cog in a universe of possibilities just waiting to be tapped into. Going forward though, how do you top that? It's not a question so easily answered, especially not when you're the guys behind it all in the first place - having given years of your life to a project only to then be faced with the idea of pushing the boat out even further. However, although patches and gameplay tweaks were rolled out in the months and years following Skyrim's release, there's still plenty more refinements to be made before actually playing Skyrim feels as good as it looks - here's just 10 candidates for things that need a total overhaul.


10. Animation - Make Third Person Feel Worthwhile

This is the 'Final Fantasy VII problem' all over again; that notion of when building a suitably gargantuan world, something has to take a hit to let it all run remotely smoothly. For FF VII it was the now-legendary blocky graphics, and for Skyrim it's the animations in general. Third person in particular has been a mainstay of the series for years, but can you honestly say it feels like the 'right' way to play, as oppose to looking like some mod you're forcing the game into, only to flip back to first whenever a fight occurs? Playing Skyrim with the camera behind your character lets you really understand your place in the world, not to mention ogling at all the pieces of armour or items you've got dangling off your person. If the option to switch things up into third-person is going to exist at all, it really needs to feel natural, and not just that you're essentially still in first with an avatar plonked in the middle of the screen.

9. Lose The Enemy Scaling

Somewhat of a myth within Bethesda's worlds, the idea of enemy scaling usually revolves around making sure your character is always faced with something of a challenge - preventing obsessive players from grinding in one place, South Park-style before then cakewalking the rest of the game. In Skyrim things were handled a little differently, with certain caves reportedly scaling (and then locking) to whatever level you were when you entered them, allowing the enemies within to provide the requisite challenge. Still, scour any number of forums and you'll find people complaining that this idea wasn't implemented very well in the final game, or that it doesn't exist at all. So instead, a better idea would be to forever have certain parts of the map 'off-limits' in terms of their difficulty, letting a certain creature or area have a reputation within the game's lore forever set to a certain level of difficulty that would really make for bragging rights if a low-level player conquered them. Tackling these hefty creatures later in the game would be a great indication of how far you've come level-wise, and could tap into some Dark Souls-levels of satisfaction when you finally take them down. It might be something of a step back for general game design considering the potentially great idea of individual character-scaling set previously, but it's worth sacrificing that for a better sense of overall progression as you spend more time levelling up throughout.

8. Combat Needs A Complete Overhaul

Although the combat in Bethesda's games in general over the last few years has been a little spotty (Fallout was scarcely played as an FPS, more an action-RPG with FPS elements), Skyrim's up close n' personal melee attacks rarely feel like they connect with the right level of impact. The likes of the slow-motion camera cutaways went a little way to letting you somewhat revel in what it looks like when a two-handed sword the size of a small car meets the body of a tiny goblin-like Falmer, but nearly every encounter can be won by simply bashing the attack button and healing whenever your life gets too low. For larger creatures or something like a certain region's royal guard, there should be specific 'tells' you can watch out for when facing them, not to mention tying in the animation point from earlier, it gives options for attacks you might need to charge or wind up, making sure you connect at just the right moment for maximum damage. At the minute melee combat in these games feels like two parties just firing off animations at each other, rather than anything resembling an actual duel.

7. Lose The 'Over-Encumbered' Stat

Forever a talking point that divides fans, there are those that wish for the idea of being 'over-encumbered' (carrying too many items to move fast) to stay as it's a signature Elder Scrolls feature that forces you to manage your inventory better, versus those who forever see it as a bane when thinking about going off on a random adventure. In the end this idea of putting a limit on your inventory space really doesn't work when part of the game's design and appeal is routed in exploration, and even if that means giving followers or your steed whatever you've found (or getting a spell to allay the stat altogether) with the idea being that things would turn up in your house later, it'd go a long way to solving the problem. As much as hardcore role-players love in-world realism of not being able to juggle a handful of spears and dragon bones all at the same time, there has to be a balance for newcomers considering how large the series has become, and let's face it - not being able to take home the riches of your most recent quest always just straight-up sucks.

6. Make Dragon (Big Bad Random Boss) Fights Enjoyable Every Time

It would be heresy to say the dragon fights in Skyrim 'weren't all that' - they very much were, and a bag of flame-tinged potato chips - but all the same, did you really evolve your playing style over the course of the game to tackle them better? Chances are once you got over the spectacle of reliving your own personal 'Gandalf/Balrog moment', it was business as usual in terms of dodging their life-sapping breath attacks and wading in with your weapon in between. Tying into the aforementioned points about animation and enemy scaling, if you get set upon by something like a dragon (or whatever hulking beast looks set to have your hairline for breakfast in TES VI) there should be more to felling them than just doing the dodge n' stab-dance throughout. The clashing of spear-like teeth on shield should be a block well earned, and the counter-attack should be something that makes or breaks the fight in a constantly-shifting pendulum swing of a duel, not a mad scramble to find cover in a screen-covering attack that'll toast you to cinders in seconds like in the past.

5. Proper Cutscenes

Something any majorly narrative-focussed game tends to have are properly shot and directed cutscenes, although taking a page out of Half-Life's book, TES has forever let dialogue exchanges and animations play out whilst you retained your first-person view - albeit leaving you free to wander around on occasion. This does play into the more off-kilter humour the series has become known for, where you can leap aboard someone's lap in the middle of the King's court as they things are addressed, or insist on walking around with a handful of eyes tracking your every move. Cinematic cutscenes would help immensely with both the main questline in the game getting the requisite weight it deserves, establishing a string of memorable characters throughout. It's definitely novel to ensure the viewpoint stays wherever you left it as things unfold like before, but you can't deny that with the appropriate care given to proceedings it would elevate the entire experience into far better territory.

4. More Big Name Voice Actors

Speaking of cutscenes, why not flesh out the production budget and wrangle up a selection of legendary vocal chords to pad out the world? It seems ever since Rockstar made their bold claim with GTA IV that 'people only hear the actor, not the character' that everyone previously thinking of getting celebrities involved in their games ended up letting it fall by the wayside. Skyrim had a few notable names like Max von Sydow and Joan Allen, but no one on the level of Oblivion's Patrick Stewart. The Elder Scrolls series should feel every bit as weighty and important as any fantasy-styled silver screen brethren, and part of bringing that to life is just as much through the script as through those voicing it.

3. Better HUD Help With Enemies

So picture the scene; you're slowly creeping up on a mountainside encampment, bow strained and at the ready as you scout out what enemy forces appear to be walking around... Creeping forward ever-slowly you make a mental note of what looks to be a patrol pattern (it's not) for a particularly easily-targeted skeleton, only for a random arrow to skewer you from afar, as another creature has become alerted to your presence, lobbing a bolt your way as a rather timely 'Hello'. You've probably been through this if you play anything of a ranged character, and even if not, Skyrim's way of presenting enemies as red dots - regardless of height, size or relation to you - on the overhead bar is obfuscating to say the least. More often than not fights dissolve into scarpering behind rocks or foliage as you have to just assume whether or not you're within someone's cone of vision after being alerted, realising an enemy is closing in on you if their blip starts behaving more erratically. Of all franchises, Elder Scrolls needs to take a page out of Far Cry's book and twin established patrol patterns and visual cones for the A.I. with a tagging system of sorts so you can track where enemies are as you head in. Even if this was made spell-dependant, it's an essential feature that would improve the ease of tackling outposts and areas from afar tenfold.

2. Make Horses A Better, Faster Form Of Transport

Nabbing a steed to traverse the world is something seen everywhere from Ocarina of Time to Shadow of the Colossus, and in both those games it gives a much-needed boost to your traversal across the game world. In Skyrim, however nabbing a horse felt like a marginal improvement on walking speed - assumedly to still let you breathe in the world around you. The thing with creating a world plenty players genuinely want to drink in, is balancing that initial fascination with the fatigue that can set in when walking through the same areas over and over. The mid-point would be letting you unlock various mounts across the game - or something like a horse that can be levelled up accordingly - to allow for a bridge between both these approaches. Most of the time if the gamer has forever resorted to Fast Travel'ing everywhere, the world designer has failed. Bethesda have always been on the better side of that divide with TES, as from Morrowind to especially Skyrim, you'll come across a million memorable things if you walk to a destination instead of skipping it - but all the same something that gives you the sensation of on-foot exploration that's also fast enough to feel like you're not missing out on just starting the next quest would be ideal.

1. Fix The Bugs

The most obvious one - but the point that if it wasn't included would be the first thing to shoot up in the comments below; the occasionally very spotty final states Bethesda release their games in. Many fans have just accepted this as par for the backwards dragon-flying course, saying it gives the team's games a sense of individuality and character - although even when reading that you can sense a certain stench of bullsh... hokum. The fact of the matter is sure, character model-based glitches where goats fly off into the distance and quest-givers get stuck in the floor are always hilarious, but when your save file increases in size to the point where it won't load or a certain person you're escorting refuses to move with you - it's genuinely game-breaking. In a world the size of whatever TES VI turns out to be it's more than understandable that when it's given to tens of thousands of players they're going to discover things the team just didn't have the manpower to find, but things like main characters remaining in one place and save states being reliable is some EA's Battlefield-level of nonsense Bethesda can hopefully steer well clear of. What do you want to see Bethesda improve upon from Skyrim? Let us know in the comments, and be sure to like the Facebook page!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.