10 Hard Rock Bands Who Kept The Same Lineup

The Art of Staying True.

Aerosmith wiki
Mate 2nd Class Rob Rubio / Public domain

A band is like being in a marriage. Across a career's worth of music, these members have to depend on each other, get along with each other, and remain faithful to their significant others til death do you part. While many bands have called up divorce lawyers more than a few times, there's something to be said about groups that have stayed the course.

When it comes to hard rock bands, it's almost expected that a band have a few hiccups in their internal relationships. For as great as the bands are, there's always that band member who drinks too much, betrays the rest of the group, or just can't take the pressure of the lifestyle. On the other hand, there have more than a few bands who have soldiered on with their original lineup regardless of what obstacles lay in front of them.

Have there been a few bumps in the road? Sure, but what band doesn't have that. Even through the roughest times, these bands have found a way to come back together until they physically couldn't do it anymore. It's easy to just fire the stick in the mud, but every single one of these acts have members who are in it for the long haul.

10. Cream

By the mid-60's, the British rock scene was bursting with some of the best blues musicians of the era. While the sound was usually coming from the muddy banks of the American South, these guys from England were studying the gospel of Robert Johnson and Howlin Wolf and putting their own spin to it. The blues may have been a good starting point, but Cream took the blues sound and dipped it in acid.

For as much noise as the band makes on record, it all came down to only three people to create their fury. Eric Clapton is normally pegged as the muscle behind the band thanks to his fiery lead work, but the tunes wouldn't be half as heavy without Ginger Baker delivering one of the most ferocious back beats in hard rock. Just right of center was Jack Bruce, whose broad musical palette and soulful vocal delivery gave the band just the right amount of accessibility to make their tunes irresistible on radio.

It seemed like a three-piece would give everyone equal footing, but the tension between the band members led to them calling it quits in the late '60s, with Clapton moving on to a stellar solo career. Though Clapton has had a handful of Cream classics pop up in his live catalog, what these three created as a unit is impossible to reproduce.


9. Alter Bridge

There's a certain type of rock fan who was absolutely gutted when Creed ended up going their separate ways at the dawn of the 2000s. Right when nu metal started to become the new norm, this post grunge act was keeping the heart of rock alive, albeit with the nasal whine of Scott Stapp. The age of hard rock seemed to be over, but the band's reinvention as Alter Bridge has proved to be much more fruitful.

Though the band already had some great chops back in the late '90s, this new outfit shows them operating on a much more visceral level, with riffs and tempos that are much more metal-tinged than Creed could have ever hoped to be. In lieu of Stapp's typical yarl, Myles Kennedy has turned into one of the greatest hard rock singers of the modern age, with one of the broadest ranges in the entire game.

From the guttural lows to near-operatic high notes, Kennedy gave the band a shot in the arm and led them to classics like Blackbird and ABIII. Even when not operating under the band name, each member is able to flex their chops in solo projects, with Mark Tremonti's namesake solo band and Kennedy working with Slash. Rock may not be in the spotlight anymore, but acts like Alter Bridge are proving that it's nowhere near on its deathbed.


8. Rage Against the Machine

Rage Against the Machine were a four-piece firebomb when they emerged on the rock scene in the early '90s. Instead of trying to ape the alternative grunge style that was prominent at the time, these guys were true freaks of nature that combined rap, rock, metal, and everything in between to create tunes of pure aggression.

For as much power that's behind these tunes, each member ended up carrying their weight equally, with drummer Brad Wilk's classic rock style of drumming blending perfectly with the almost mathematical funkiness behind Tim Commerford's bass. However, the true sonic madman behind the band was Tom Morello, who brought a technical complexity to Rage's tunes while inventing new effects and noises that no one had ever heard before.

The instrumentals were already solid as a rock, but the sound became pure steel once Zack de la Rocha stepped up to the mic. Blending rapping and almost spoken word, Zack's delivery produced some of the most raw vocals of the time on tracks like "Freedom" and "Bulls on Parade," where he brought out every sort of political injustice that afflicts our world right now. Even when the band splintered into different factions, there was never a conversation to replace anyone in Rage. For as much frustration they directed at each other, the band always stood as one of the firmest brotherhoods of anger.


7. Motley Crue

Hair metal seems to be looked at as one of the goofier incarnations that the world of hard rock has ever seen. With bands popping up left and right looking like David Bowie wannabes and playing pop friendly ballads, this was not what your average metalhead really anticipated. There was a lot of boring party bands to go around, but Motley Crue stood apart as one of the most elaborate acts in the genre.

From the time that they first started, every member brought a distinctive edge to the band's sound, with the bark of singer Vince Neil leading the charge. While the rhythm section of Tommy Lee and Nikki Sixx were known as some of the masterminds behind the band, guitarist Mick Mars was one of the most overlooked guitarists of the decade, providing a bluesy counterbalance to the band's usual pop tunes.

That's not to say the band didn't have their fair share of ups and downs, with Vince Neil being temporarily replaced with John Corabi and Tommy Lee being replaced by Samantha Malone on different occasions. However, the only time the band's sound becomes magical is when all four members come together to make their signature brand of decadent rock and roll. Sure, they may fight like brothers, but if the Crue is not together as one, musical cracks will always appear.


6. Queen

A lot of people tend to think that Queen wouldn't have risen to prominence if not for Freddie Mercury. Given his status as one of the greatest frontmen of all time, it's hard to see the band having any staying power without him up front. Mercury may have had the spirit of the band in him, but what made Queen unique is the power of four musical masterminds working in sync.

Just beside Mercury's operatic tone, Brian May constructed some of the greatest guitar parts in rock, making guitar concertos on nearly every record. People tend to just leave it at that, but Roger Taylor was the real rock and roll side of the band, with a raspy voice that gave the band's album tracks an added edge. There isn't usually that much love for John Deacon outside of the bassline in "Another One Bites the Dust," but his songs like "You're My Best Friend" and "I Want to Break Free" are still known as some of the band's biggest hits.

When Mercury passed away from AIDS-related complications in 1991, the band disbanded knowing there was no way to replace him. Though they often pop up with people like Adam Lambert and Paul Rogers, the remaining band members always play as a tribute to their friend and bandmate rather than an artistic progression.


5. System of a Down

There are only a handful of bands that you could say had lightning in a bottle. Only once or twice a generation, a band comes along that is so singular in their sound that they seem to transcend the confines of their respective genre. People probably didn't expect that out of the nu metal craze, but System of a Down were the counterpoint to the whinier side of hard rock.

With albums like Toxicity and Mesmerize to their name, the band created some of the most engaging nu metal ever, as they make bold indictments about everything from drugs to politics to the broken prison system. It's easy to get lost in the guitar riffs from Daron Malakian, but Serj Tankian's vocals are some of the most delectable musical pieces of the 2000s. It may seem a bit nasally at first, but Tankian's accuracy of pitch is almost mind-boggling.

Even in the rhythm section, Shavo Odadjian and John Dolmayan help propel the band forward, creating riffs as well as transitioning from hardcore punk heaviness to slow and controlled in no time at all. Though the band has been active off and on for decades now, there's no getting around the chops each of these members possess.


4. Muse

Alternative rock seems to fit in the comfortable middle ground between hard rock and the mainstream. For every fan who loves The Beatles but is not ready for something like Slayer, they normally find their bridge into heavier fare in the alt rock genre. It may have a middle ground tone, but Muse have been one of the most thunderous bands going in alternative rock today.

Covering everything from classical to arena rock to even Western sounding material, there's almost nothing that is off the table for this band to take on. The colossal sound of the band gets all the more impressive when you realize it's only coming from three guys. With Matt Bellamy being the real musical force on guitar and vocals, the rhythm section of Chris Wolstenholme and Dominic Howard is immense, with Wolstenholme's basslines anchoring everything down and Howard flexing his musical chops on everything from a metallic kit to a digital sampler.

Above all else, the band also seem to be on the best of terms even after two decades in the business. For as much band drama you hear from the heavyweights of the genre, these guys are still making fantastic hard rock music just for the pure joy rather than the ego.


3. ZZ Top

Most of the hard rock of the late '60s and '70s were basically the blues filtered through... something. Whether it was Cream taking it into the psychedelic sphere or Aerosmith infusing it with the rhythmic structure of funk, almost every other band was trying to find ways to mold the blues into something much more interesting. Then again, sometimes it's better to just bow down to the almighty genre of heartache.

Though many people could probably call ZZ Top a bit monotonous with their sound, the swagger they have built up over four decades is nothing short of incredible. With only three people in their ranks, every single instrument fits neatly in its place, with Dusty Hill's throbbing bass keeping everything grooving while Billy Gibbons' leads draw a straight line through the song. Even in their old age, both frontmen have kept their voices intact, trading in their younger shouts for a gritty drawl that washes over your ears like whiskey.

The blues are nothing without the rhythm though, with some of the best beats of Texas swing being pumped out by Frank Beard, the only beardless man of the bunch. Still bringing the sound of the blues into the mainstream, time has been very kind to ZZ Top's Southern fried hard rock.


2. Aerosmith

As the British Invasion still had a firm hold on the rock scene, Aerosmith lobbed the ball right back at the UK with their unique brand of bluesy riffage. Across the '70s, the band laid claim to the hard rock throne with songs that had just the right balance of melody and grit to make believers out of pretty much anybody. There have been some dips along the way, but these guys have always held together as one of rock's original street gangs.

Steven Tyler is obviously the most identifiable of the bunch, with his undeniable charisma and feral shriek across the band's songs, but Joe Perry has always been right by his side, delivering leads that were Keith Richards by way of James Brown. Though many bands could make their millions off of that duo alone, the self proclaimed "Least Interesting Three" are still just as important.

While Tom Hamilton and Joey Kramer keep everything intact with some of the most solid funk rhythms, Brad Whitford is the real unsung hero of the band, with leads on tracks like "One Way Street" being almost on Jeff Beck's level. Tensions did end up causing fractures in the early '80s, but the original lineup came back together after the thought of going on proved to be impossible. It's debatable whether or not the band are still at the top of their game, but Aerosmith are still flying the flag as one of the most enduring rock bands of all time.


1. Led Zeppelin

More often than not, most bands have a singer or guitarist as their shining star. For as much adulation as the band collective gets, there's always that one member who is known as the linchpin of the entire plan. Led Zeppelin on the other hand have a unique dynamic in that one band member is all of them.

From the moment Jimmy Page started putting together the skeleton of the band, things were destined to become big, with his guitar style launching the era of riff rock. Standing up front was Robert Plant, whose vocals had the intensity of someone like Little Richard mixed with the bluesy fire of someone like Janis Joplin. For as content as he was to lay in the background, the band would also not be where it is today without John Paul Jones, whose bass and keyboard lines gave their records an almighty sound.

Surely the drummer is dispensable right? Some may be, but John Bonham sure isn't one of them. From the subtle tapping on "Ramble On" to the pure thrashing he gives his kit on "Moby Dick," Bonzo was one of the most powerful people ever to pick up a pair of drumsticks. Upon his death in the early '80s, there was no question as to why Zeppelin had decided to call it quits. The internal telepathy of the band had been lost forever.


In this post: 
Aerosmith
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97