There's probably no older musical tradition than that of the story-song. Since the dawn of time, minstrels and balladeers have written and sung songs that recited history, immortalised tall tales, and provided a way to make sure that timeless stories would never be forgotten.
The tradition of the story song has endured throughout the centuries. The idea of using music to enhance a story is one that continues to entice singers and songwriters. The stories that lie at the centre of such songs are fondly remembered by all who hear them; ask any country music fan to tell the story behind "A Boy Named Sue" or a rock fan to summarise "Born In The U.S.A." and you'll get a perfect recitation.
With Hollywood's constant pursuit of well-known properties to adapt into films, you'd think that story songs would be well-tapped as film material. That's not the case, however; rather, they've been largely ignored. With a few exceptions, movie studios have shunned the story song. It's time that changed.
This article will discuss ten story songs that would make great movies. There's only one criteria for this list: that the song never have been made into a film (which is why you won't find story tunes like Bobbie Gentry's "Ode To Billie Joe" or Gene Pitney's "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance" here).
10. Laurie - Dickey Lee
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G_NnUCxNmPw&safe=active In the early-to-mid 1960s, there was a rash of depressing rock n' roll story songs, all revolving around the untimely deaths of young hot-rodders and/or the teenage goddesses who loved them. Most of the songs (justly) get a lot of mocking, but some of them are really good (like J. Frank Wilson & The Caveliers' "Last Kiss" and Jan & Dean's "Dead Man's Curve"). This subgenre still maintains a cult following, and has even inspired some homages, such as Meat Loaf's "Bat Out Of Hell." Many artists tried their hand at the death-of-teens subgenre, but none visited said subgenre as often as Dickey Lee. Lee built his career on rock n' roll death songs, recording such songs as "Tell Laura I Love Her" and "Patches." The best of Lee's death songs, however, is "Laurie." "Laurie" is Lee's interpretation of the "vanishing hitchhiker" legend. You know the one: a teenage guy is headed to the prom when he sees a beautiful girl hitching a ride. The boy picks up the girl and takes her to the dance, where he promptly falls in love with her. On the way home, the girl shivers with cold. The young man offers the girl his sweater, which the girl accepts. The boy drops the girl off at home at the end of the night, only to realise later that the girl still has his sweater. He returns to the girl's house the next morning to retrieve his sweater, only to be told by the girl's parents that their daughter died years ago. The boy goes to the cemetery to investigate, only to find his sweater lying on the girl's grave. The story that "Laurie" tells isn't a new one, but the way the song tells the story makes the song special. The song boasts a classy, atmospheric arrangement, made up of a bass guitar, drums, what sounds like a harpsichord, guitars, and a choir, that gives the song a very melancholy tone. The arrangement also calls up feelings of teenage puppy love. A film adaptation of "Laurie" would keep the atmospheric feel that the song evokes. The film would be set in a '50s-sitcom sort of town, the last kind of place where you would imagine anything supernatural happening. One would cast the most attractive guy and girl one could find, keeping with the '50s-esque style. The script could be taken from the lyrics without embellishment, since they tell the story thoroughly. "Laurie" probably wouldn't make a good feature-length film, but it could make for a good thirty-minute short. It's time that one was made. By the way, if you want an interesting twist on the hitchhiker legend, check out David Allan Coe's "The Ride," in which a hitchhiker is picked up by the ghost of Hank Williams, Sr. I love both songs, but I love "Laurie" a little more.
9. The Legend Of Wooley Swamp - The Charlie Daniels Band
http://youtu.be/qMz4MA2X-98 Our second song is another ghost story, but it's grittier than "Laurie." It's arguable that nobody in recent years has produced more wonderful story songs than The Charlie Daniels Band. I've been a fan of Daniels and his band ever since I first heard "The Devil Went Down To Georgia," and since then, every other song I've heard by the group has only increased my love. I knew that I had to include one Charlie Daniels song on this list, but it was murder choosing which one. Ultimately, my debate came down between two songs: "Uneasy Rider" and our song in question. I ultimately came down in "Legend"'s favor, however, because, while "Uneasy Rider" is one of the funniest songs ever recorded, it doesn't have enough story to sustain a film. "The Legend Of Wooley Swamp," however, provides us with a structure for a feature-length film plot, even if it would need a little filling out. The song's story revolves around the Cable boys, a group of juvenile delinquents who descend into Wooley Swamp to murder Lucius Clay, an old man who hates everything but his money, which he stuffs in mason jars and buries, only to dig it up in the middle of the night and roll around in it. The Cable boys arrive at Clay's shack, finding Lucius revelling in his money. The boys beat Lucius to death, throw him in the swamp, take the money, and run. However the path that the boys took into the swamp has turned to quicksand. The boys sink as the sound of Lucius' laugh fills the swamp. Taken by itself, the story you read above wouldn't be enough to fill a film. The chorus, however, hints that there's more to the song than what we hear. Daniels sings about hearing the legend of Wooley Swamp, but he also sings,
"But I couldn't believe it. I just had to find out for myself. And I couldn't conceive it 'Cause I never would have listened to nobody else. And I couldn't believe it. I just had to find out for myself."
In other words, the singer is planning to visit Wooley Swamp himself, to find out if the legend that Lucius Clay haunts the swamp is true.
The chorus' implied story completes a feature-length film structure. The first act could set up the story, with the singer and a bunch of other kids being told ghost stories. The second act would consist of a story-within-a-story, with us watching the story of the Cable boys' and Lucius Clay's death while the ghost story-teller provides voice-over. The third act would be the singer and his friends descending into the swamp, determined to prove the legend false and finding that it's true.
8. Excitable Boy - Warren Zevon
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z4-pexSVWzM Warren Zevon was a breath of fresh air in the music scene of the 1970s. The California music scene was crawling with such artists as Jackson Browne, Laura Nyro, and the Eagles; in other words, the scene was dominated by artists who seemed to be devoted to recording emotional tunes that were meant to make you think while making you feel comfortable. Zevon's work made you think and they were emotional, but Zevon was out to make his listeners uncomfortable. Zevon possessed a dark sense of humor that his contemporaries lacked, allowing him to produce funny, warped tunes that packed a powerful punch. (By the way, Jackson Browne must also have had a dark sensibility hiding inside of him, since he produced Zevon's two best records: "Warren Zevon" and "Excitable Boy.") "Excitable Boy," one of Zevon's many great story songs, comes from his third album, which shares its title with our song in question. The song tells the story of a teenage boy with uncontrollable impulses. The boy's impulses grow more intense with each verse: the first verse details a family dinner, during which the well-dressed boy grabs the pot roast and smears it on his chest. His loving family shrugs off this strange incident, terming the young man as an "excitable boy." The boy becomes even more excitable in the second verse, where he attacks a movie theatre usher. His family pretends that this event never happened. The young man's actions become harder to ignore, however, when he rapes and murders his prom date. The boy's family sends him to a mental institution, saying that he's nothing more than an excitable boy. After ten years, the boy's released from the institution. Upon his release, the young man goes to the cemetery, steals his prom date's body and builds a cage with her bones. We leave the boy's story here, with the echoes of the family's standard excuse, "excitable boy," ringing in our ears. In most recording artists' hands, "Excitable Boy" would have been a grim tune about murderers and their psychological underpinnings. Zevon, however, pairs the lyrics with a jaunty rock n' roll melody that turns the song into a danceable, funny tune. Any film adaptation would have to tread the line between humour and horror. I'm thinking that "Excitable Boy" would be a perfect project for the Coen brothers; the style of such films as Raising Arizona, Fargo, or O Brother, Where Art Thou? would jibe perfectly with the style of Zevon's music.
7. Bob Dylan's 115th Dream - Bob Dylan
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1VS--6IugAc It's hard to pick just one Bob Dylan story song. Like Warren Zevon & Charlie Daniels, Dylan produced such a wealth of great story songs, like "Hurricane," "Tangled Up In Blue," & "The Lonesome Death Of Hattie Carroll," that choosing just one seems like a travesty. I ultimately chose "Bob Dylan's 115th Dream" for two reasons: (1) because it's my favourite Dylan song, and (2) because its story is more cinematic than any other Dylan story-song. The song's story is a fever-dream (or acid-trip, if you prefer) version of American history. Dylan's song unfolds from the point of a view of a young sailor, who, along with Captain Arab, is among the first sailors to arrive in America. Arab & his crew are arrested immediately upon coming ashore, on the charges of "carrying harpoons." Our protagonist escapes from prison and sets out trying to acquire the bail he needs to free his fellow crew members. Along the way, our young sailor marches in a picket line, causes a restaurant explosion, has his boots stolen, and is beaned by a bowling ball falling from the sky. Ultimately, the sailor decides to leave America, leaving his captain and fellow crew members to fend for themselves. On his way out to sea, he meets Columbus and wishes him luck. Like "Excitable Boy," a film adaptation of "Bob Dylan's 115th Dream" requires a director with an off-kilter view of life. Perhaps the Coen brothers would once again be appropriate. At any rate, in order for the film to be as funny as the song, the movie shouldn't wink at the audience but treat everything that it shows us as if it's the most normal stuff in the world.
6. Ghost Riders In The Sky - Frankie Laine
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dy9AsO6argQ I think it's safe to say that "Ghost Riders In The Sky" is immediately recognisable to every country-music fan. The song has been covered by just about every country singer since the 1950s, and for good reason; the story that "Ghost Rider's" lyrics tell is haunting & compelling. "Ghost Riders In The Sky" tells the story of a cowboy out riding during a storm. He stops to rest, only to be graced by a vision of a herd of red-eyed cows stampeding across the sky. The cows are followed by a band of gaunt, ugly, sweaty cowboys. The ghostly cowboys moan (the famous "yippie-ai-aaay" chorus) as they ride. As our cowboy protagonist watches, one of the ghostly cowboys calls his name. The ghostly cowboy tells our protagonist that he must change his ways, or else risk spending an eternity with the ghostly riders, "tryin' to catch that Devil's herd across these endless skies." The song's story would need to be expanded to make it fit a feature-length film structure, but "Ghost Riders In The Sky" could be the inspiration for a cowboy-themed supernatural story. The song's protagonist would be an outlaw, on the run from the marshal and his posse for, say, murdering a man. During his attempted escape, he sees the ghost riders and receives their warning. The outlaw dismisses the vision and continues in his way, murdering another man. The outlaw is then pursued by the ghostly riders as they come down to earth to claim another of their own.
5. The Wreck Of The Edmund Fitzgerald - Gordon Lightfoot
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hgI8bta-7aw It's rare that a story-song tells such a complete story that no embellishing is needed to transfer the story to film. Gordon Lightfoot's 1976 tune "The Wreck Of The Edmund Fitzgerald" is one of the exceptions to this rule. Lightfoot's song tells the true story of the last voyage of the SS Edmund Fitzgerald, a freighter that sank on Lake Superior on November 10, 1975. On November 9, The Edmund Fitzgerald set sail, bound to a Detroit steel mill with a cargo of iron ore pellets. There had been a weather report stating that there would be a large storm within the next couple of days, but the report stated that the report would not cross over Lake Superior. While briefly meeting with another freighter, however, the crew of the Edmund Fitzgerald learned that the storm had shifted and now would be crossing the lake. The Fitzgerald's crew decided to take an alternate northward route, hoping to avoid the worst of the storm. This tactic didn't work; the Fitzgerald encountered a winter storm, with winds rushing by at the speed of 52 knots (60 mph; 96 km/m) and 10-foot-high waves. The Fitzgerald began taking on water and started to list. The Fitzgerald's crew lost the use of their instruments, including their navigation beacon. A few hours later, the Fitzgerald sank. Gordon Lightfoot took a few artistic liberties when penning his song's lyrics, but the changes only serve to make the facts more dramatic. The song (and the story behind it) is ripe to be adapted into a powerful sea story, something in the vein of The Perfect Storm.
4. Meeting Across The River - Bruce Springsteen
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jTbX2LYZx2A Technically speaking, Bruce Springsteen's "Meeting Across The River" isn't a "story-song," since it doesn't tell a fully constructed tale. Rather, it gives us a glimpse of a scene that takes place in the midst of a story. However, the lyrics and music imply so much that it fills in the gaps that the lyrics leave. Therefore, I feel that "Meeting"'s inclusion on this list is justified. More importantly, it's one of my favourite Springsteen tunes, and I'll take any excuse to write about it. The lyrics follow a man as he tries to bum a ride from his friend Eddie. Our nameless protagonist needs to get across town to meet a mysterious man. Said mysterious man wants to cut a deal with our hero, and our hero offers to cut Eddie in on the profits if he gives our hero a ride. The protagonist seems to be nervous about this meeting; he tells Eddie to keep his mouth shut, implying that the man waiting across town is uptight & dangerous. The lyrics imply that our hero has been in trouble before, but he promises Eddie that if this deal goes well, he'll give up his life of crime forever. The protagonist tells Eddie to dress nice and to make himself look like he's packing a gun. The song ends with the protagonist again promising that he'll go off with his girlfriend and abandon his life of crime if this deal goes well. "Meeting Across The River"'s lyrics are vague, but, paired with the film noir-esque music, they imply a great deal. The somber feel of the song suggests that the deal that our hero and Eddie are anticipating (a heist, according to original pressings of Born To Run's album track list) will not go as planned, possibly resulting in the death of our heroes. The lyrics also imply that our nameless hero is a small-time crook who has gotten in over his head. Eddie seems to be a close friend of our hero; he might be a little wiser than his buddy, but not much. "Meeting Across The River" could be the basis for a great noir film. The film could open on our hero attempting a robbery. He fails and is sent to jail. The hero gets out of prison. The hero's girlfriend tries to help her guy get back on his feet; their relationship is strained, however, when the hero hocks his girl's radio. The girlfriend threatens to break up with our hero. Our hero, in a last-ditch effort to save his relationship with his girl, agrees, with his friend Eddie, to join a heist crew. The heist goes badly, resulting in the death of all involved, including our hero.
3. Shooting Star - Bad Company
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0kEDa6bXnA8 Cautionary rock n' roll tales are as old as the rock genre itself. All of us can recite at least one of the myriad stories of rockers who lived hard and died young (people like Janis Joplin, Jimi Hendrix, Jim Morrison, etc.). We've also taken in many fictional stories of doomed rockers, including Jan De Bont's 2005 film Last Days and Harlan Ellison's 1961 novel Spider Kiss. Several rock bands have also recorded their own variations on this well-known story. The best of said variations is Bad Company's 1975 story-song "Shooting Star." "Shooting Star" tells the story of Johnny, a boy who falls in love with rock n' roll music after hearing The Beatles' "Love Me Do." Johnny buys a guitar and teaches himself to become a rock guitarist. After becoming proficient with his guitar, he joins a rock band, which begins to have some local success. After a while, Johnny and his band decide to move to a different town and cut a record. Johnny leaves home, much to his mother's dismay. Johnny and the band do cut a record, which shoots to the top of the charts. Johnny and the band are suddenly the hottest commodities in the music industry. Johnny begins to enjoy all the vices that come with being a superstar. Unfortunately, said vices get the better of Johnny. He eventually dies, having overdosed on the deadly combination of sleeping pills and whiskey. As we've mentioned the terrain that "Shooting Star" trods has already been explored on film, but there's no reason it couldn't be explored again. I see this film having the same style as David Chase's 2012 film Not Fade Away: a coming-of-age story with a rough side. Johnny would be a small-town teen with dreams of changing the world with his earth-shattering music. Johnny and his band cut their first record with those ideals, but the huge success of their album sends the group down the path of vice and greed. Such a path ends in tragedy, as Johnny succumbs to the same fate that awaits him in the song.
2. The Night The Lights Went Out In Georgia - Vicki Lawrence
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wpd5xb1iKS4 I'm bending another of my rules here, since there's technically already been a movie made based on Vicki Lawrence's 1972 song. However, the 1981 film uses none of the song's plot. Therefore, I feel that the song's place on this list is justified. "The Night The Lights Went Out In Georgia" begins as a young businessman returns to Candletop, Georgia, after a long business trip. The businessman stops at a bar, run by his friend Andy, for a drink before he goes home to his wife. Andy greets his friend with bad news: the businessman's wife has been sleeping with several other men, including Andy himself. The businessman leaves the bar and goes home. The businessman's wife is out, but that doesn't matter; the businessman goes and finds what he came home for: a gun. The businessman goes to Andy's house and finds Andy's dead body. The businessman flags down a passing cop, who immediately arrests the businessman for Andy's murder. The businessman is arrested, tried, convicted, and executed in one night. The most striking (and chilling) part of the song, however, comes after the businessman is killed. You see, it's at this point that the song's narrator, the businessman's sister, reveals that she's the one who killed Andy. She didn't stop at Andy, either; the narrator also killed her brother's cheating wife. A film adaptation of Lawrence's song (one that stays true to the lyrics, that is) could be an excellent mix of Southern Gothic and noir. Any film set in the southern United States needs to be atmospheric, instilling the film with the flavor that characterises the region. One of the characteristics of the southern states' legacy is the wealth of dark, twisted stories that come out of the area. "Georgia" fits into this tradition perfectly. The song's lyrics also display the cynicism that defines the noir genre.
1. El Paso - Marty Robbins
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kIHRgisdbeY Marty Robbins is one of the most underrated figures in the history of popular music. Although Robbins' influence on country music is given a fair amount of attention, his shadow also stands over a large part of pop music. Robbins' songs have been covered by artists as diverse as the Grateful Dead and Elvis Presley, and several bands (including The Who & the Beasts Of Bourbon) have recorded songs that revere him. Robbins has even experienced a recent resurgence in popularity, due to the use of our song in question in Breaking Bad's final episode. Robbins' crowning achievement was probably his 1959 album Gunfighter Ballads And Trail Songs, an album that shot to no. 6 on the Billboard 20o charts, went platinum, and is currently included on the famous list 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. The album is Robbins' definitive statement on the story song, a genre that country music really defined. Every track on the album is a gem, but the best, and the most famous, is "El Paso." "El Paso" tells the story of a cowboy who falls in love with Feleena, a Mexican dancer who works in Rosa's Cantina, a tavern in El Paso, Texas. When a younger cowboy makes advances toward Feleena, the protagonist guns down the younger cowhand in a jealous rage. The older cowboy flees El Paso, fearing retaliation from the dead cowboy's friends. The cowboy hides in the "badlands of New Mexico" for a while, filled with fear for his life. Even more biting, however, is his love for Feleena. Said love eventually drives the cowboy back to El Paso, where he finds the dead cowboy's friends waiting for him. The cowboy is shot while riding to Rosa's Cantina, but he manages to live long enough to fall into Feleena's arms. Feleena gives the cowboy one last kiss before he dies. The story that "El Paso" tells is one that we've heard dozens of times. Curiously, however, we're willing to give westerns the benefit of the doubt in the cliche department. Maybe that's because we think of the Old West in legendary terms, and the old western tropes help stories of the era keep their larger-than-life feel. At any rate, "El Paso" is ripe for film adaptation, especially since the lyrics present a complete story. No embellishment is needed to make the story right for a film. "El Paso" would be perfect material for a melancholy Howard Hawks- or John Ford- style western film. Well, there you have it: ten story songs that deserve notice from Hollywood. What songs have we missed? Let us know below!
Alan Howell
Contributor
Alan Howell is a native of Southern California. He loves movies of any and all kinds, Hollywood, indie, and everywhere in between. He loves pizza, sitcoms, rock and pop music, surfing, baseball, reading, and girls (not necessarily in that order).
See more from
Alan