Ranking Every Thomas Harris Book From Worst To Best
Some novels you can really sink your teeth into... though, the flavors vary.
When the topic of notable authors of the horror genre comes up, it would be downright criminal to not bring up Thomas Harris as one of the true stand-outs. After all, the man not only created some truly disturbed characters, but most notably, he brought the legendary Hannibal Lecter into the world of fiction. Since the character first appeared in 1981, he has gone on to be a central figure in five major motion pictures, as well as a hit television series, captivating fans of horror the world over along the way.
However, there's far more to Harris' writing than just the fabled cannibal. When it comes to disturbing, gritty horror novels, the man is all but peerless. In many ways, he's sort of the anti-Stephen King. Whereas King has published dozens upon dozens of novels in his time, which ranged anywhere from brilliant to abysmally forgettable, Harris has only published five novels, which, save for one black sheep, were all varying degrees of brilliant. He would go on to become one of the single most respected names in horror as a result.
Much like anything else, some of his books were better and in some cases, much better than others. It's time to take a look back at how each installment in Harris' iconic portfolio stack up against one another.
5. Hannibal Rising
Despite how much of a legend he is, even Thomas Harris isn't immune to one hiccup on his résumé. However, it wasn't even his fault. He didn't even want to write the novel that would go on to become the aforementioned black sheep of his bibliography, but was practically held over a barrel until he did so.
The story goes that film producer Dino De Laurentiis flat out told Harris that if he didn't write an origin story for Hannibal Lecter, he would get someone else to do it instead. Harris, understandably, resented the idea of his greatest brainchild being given a backstory without his involvement and reluctantly agreed to write the book.
The ultimate result of this was Hannibal Rising, the disappointing novel that turned the long-speculated provenance of the enigmatic Dr. Lecter into a by the numbers revenge story. The book lacks a distinct identity and is a rather uninspired affair throughout. In one go, Hannibal Rising tarnished a good amount of the mystique that surrounded the iconic character.
All of that said, Harris should definitely be forgiven for this. From a technical standpoint, it's a still a very well-written piece of literature. Moreover, the reason it's so uninspired is because it was forced upon him. There's a big difference between inspiration for a story coming naturally to a writer and it being order. Still, it probably would have been better for everyone involved if this book never came to be.
4. Hannibal
While Hannibal Lecter was a key player in the first two Harris books, be it subtly in the form of subtext or overtly in the form of a psychopathic devil's advocate, he wasn't given the role of main antagonist until his third outing.
Hannibal, published in 1999, was an exceptionally morbid affair, which is to be expected from the author. And, all things considered, it's objectively a fairly solid piece of literature. It's well written, it's tense, it grabs your attention and doesn't let it go, and it provides moments of genuine shock, even by Harris' standards. However, it's also arguable that that last point actually works against the book at certain points, at least to a degree.
Some are of the camp that the melodrama in Hannibal was too overplayed and that it favored shock value over characterization, which, in all honesty, is just a matter of taste more than anything else. One main source of valid criticism is the book's ending. Many believe that the Clarice Starling's decision to join Lecter in Hannibal's conclusion was very much out of character and was simply included for the sake of having a twist.
While this argument does have a fair amount of merit to it, the novel that preceded the ending is very much an exceptional work that anyone would find riveting. Its questionable ending aside, Hannibal is a solid entry to Harris' series.
3. Black Sunday
Thomas Harris' very first published novel and the only one to not be a part of the Hannibal Lecter saga was a rather fantastic book in its own right, earning it a place smack in the middle of this list.
Black Sunday is a dark and deeply cynical book that is certainly not for the faint-hearted. It follows a bitter Vietnam veteran on a quest to commit a suicide bombing via blimp on Super Bowl Sunday at the stadium where the big game is being held.
Unlike the Lecter books, which are slower and more methodical in pace, Black Sunday offers more high-octane action throughout. It's the type of book that you can't bring yourself to put down, because you simply have to see what happens next as soon as possible. Moreover, the psychological aspects that Harris has made his trademark are here and as compelling as ever, especially in regards to the novel's deranged main character. It's just as disturbing as the Lecter series could be, but in a much more universal way.
Ultimately, the book concludes nicely with an open-ended grand finale that's more than enough to get the blood racing.
Every single author who has ever put their work out there for all to see has, or at least should have, tried to make a statement that would be remembered for years to come. And Harris definitely achieved that.
2. The Silence Of The Lambs
What can be said about The Silence of the Lambs other than that it's easily Harris' most famous work in addition to being one of the single most important novels in the history of the chiller genre?
Following the success of this book's predecessor, Red Dragon, Harris knew that fans wanted more of the good doctor, Hannibal Lecter, and that's exactly what he gave them. The primary conflict in the novel is still that between FBI agent Clarice Starling and sadistic serial killer Jame Gumb (aka Buffalo Bill),. However, Lecter is an incredibly integral third party.
Each character plays their role exactly as they should, creating a perfect storm of murder, mayhem, and insanity. Clarice is an FBI academy student looking to prove herself and keep a grip on her sanity, Buffalo Bill is a brutal murderer that befits Harris' disturbing storytelling, and Lecter is the all-important cannibalistic chessmaster. Hunting down Bill provides a genuinely tense story in its own right and the sheer amount of chemistry between Starling and Hannibal make the book that much better.
Harris made a name for himself thanks to his ability to portray psychologically damaged characters and this novel showcases that at some of its very best. This story is hardly anything shy of perfection and more than lives up to its legacy. It is a novel that will undoubetdly leave a mark on anyone who reads it.
1. Red Dragon
The Silence of the Lambs may have gone on to become the most iconic Harris story, but overall, it still falls short in comparison to its predecessor by just the skin of its teeth.
Red Dragon is a psychological crime thriller in its purest form, in addition to being packed to the brim with unique personalities. First of all, Will Graham, the book's main protagonist, is an absolutely brilliant character. His ability to empathize with murderers, combined with his ever-present, underlying fear of turning to the dark side himself makes him incredibly engaging. Clarice Starling is phenomenal in her own right, but Graham is just a touch more fascinating.
Meanwhile, Red Dragon's main antagonist is horrifically disturbing in all the right ways as well. Sure, comparing Francis Dolarhyde (aka the Tooth Fairy, aka the Red Dragon) to Buffalo Bill is a case of apples and oranges, but it's the character's unique motives as well as his far more erratic psyche that objectively make him the more interesting bad guy. And while Hannibal Lecter's part is very small in this novel, he still plays his role of devil's advocate perfectly and helps plant the seeds of doubt Will has about his own mental state. He may not always be in the book, but he is always inside Will's head. Less is more, as they say.
Not only is the entire book bloody and disturbingly brilliant from start to finish, but its ending is undoubtedly the most meaningful and thought-provoking of any Harris novel.
Every author has their magnum opus and while some consider The Silence of the Lambs as Harris', all things considered, that title belongs to Red Dragon.