10 Most Undeserving Players Who Appeared 50 Times For Newcastle

Not every milestone maker is deserving.

It might not seem such a massive achievement beside Alan Shearer's 404 Newcastle appearances, but reaching the 50 Club is one that should still be applauded. Playing that many times in front of the braying, adoring Geordie faithful tends to have a lasting impact on both player and fans, and for the most part those players should undoubtedly deserve to have reached the milestone. Unfortunately, that is clearly not always the case as lack of investment or poor judgement have meant that inferior, unworthy players have stayed around well beyond the point they should have been sold. When those players make it to 50 appearances, it feels like a betrayal - sometimes an abomination, depending on the player. Even under the 50 game threshold there are some players who have managed to put in an astonishing number of performances: Wayne Fereday played 33 times in the league, Andreas Andersson managed 32 games in total and John Karelse somehow got to 3 appearances. Even Lionel Perez's zero competitive appearances seems like too many. But there is something of an endorsement of a player's skills in the 50 game milestone - it feels like the point at which their worth to the club is assured, and ensures that they're allowed into the official history books. Sadly, some of those players probably don't deserve to have a legacy at the club...

10. Nile Ranger - 62 Appearances

If Nile Ranger proved anything during his time at Newcastle, it's that second chances shouldn't be given to every potentially talented young footballer after they've done their level best to already ruin their career. Having been released by Southampton after being locked up, Ranger came to Newcastle with a clearly lofty opinion of himself, and the attitude of an established Premier League striker (as well as of a thug). His talent was obvious - he'd been in blistering form for the Reserves, and when given a chance to impress in cameos for the first team he looked the part. Sadly though, his attitude and behaviour off the pitch ruined all of that positive feeling, and he should have had his contract ripped up considerably earlier than it eventually was. He was a head-ache, a PR disaster and a toxic influence no matter how you looked at it, and the fact that he managed to play more than 60 times for the first-team (50 of them as a substitute) is nothing short of a disgrace.

9. Jean-Alain Boumsong - 59 Appearances

It's no wonder really that the powers that be saw something suspicious in Boumsong's move from Rangers to Newcastle: not only had he signed for a massive fee having been available to Rangers for nothing the summer previously (becoming the latest player bought from the club by Graeme Souness for a suspiciously inflated price) he also appeared to be without any of the skills required of a Premier League footballer. Despite showing flashes of brilliance, Boumsong proved himself to be inferior even to Titus Bramble, which is impressive going, and his reading of the game and inability to deal with pacy or powerful strikers made every accusation aimed at Newcastle's shaky back-line was entirely well-placed. In truth, he should have played no more than half a season's worth of games, but the £8m fee meant Newcastle were unlikely to cut their losses without a fight, which meant that the future Juventus player managed to creep above the 50 game mark. Somehow, after leaving Newcastle he proved to be a reasonable player.

8. Stephen Carr - 107 Appearances

First thing's first, Steve Carr is some way away from being the worst player Newcastle have signed - he's not even the worst right-back who has played for the club in the Premier League, thanks to some incredibly odd decisions (like signing Lamine Diatta) - but he was the epitome of the unspectacular. That would have been fine if he was being considered as a place holder in the first team: a stop-gap until someone else came in - but that simply wasn't the case. Signed as one of the final decisions in Sir Bobby Robson's tenure at Newcastle, the £2m man had been a revelation at times for Spurs, but an injury in 2001 kept him out for over a year, and though his form apparently attracted the attention of Man Utd, he simply did not return the same player. He was solid yes, and he did score one memorably thunderous goal, but the attacking flair that had been so obvious in his younger days was suppressed by injuries (and probably the threat of them), and for the last few years of his Newcastle contract he was in and out of the team. He should really have been nowhere near the first team after his first season and a half in all honesty, but the lack of options to cover (the club was forced to turn to Solano eventually) meant he was pretty much protected.

7. Gabriel Obertan - 55 Appearances

The former Man Utd player is nothing short of an enigma: signed from the Champions by Alan Pardew who wanted to give him another opportunity to show the skills that had compelled Sir Alex Ferguson to buy him in the first place, the Frenchman has been worryingly inconsistent ever since. As his manager has been saying recently, his ability isn't really up for question: he's undoubtedly a talented player with pace and the ability to go past players, but he is a little one dimensional and way too often when plan A fails, he simply disappears out of games. And even more frustratingly for a player with such pace and energy, he has spent way too much time looking like he's really not that bothered about trying. In the past two years, the Frenchman has made just ten league appearances for the club, and you have to suspect that if anyone was interested in him he would (and should) have gone well before he was able to get anywhere near 50 appearances.

6. Alessandro Pistone - 63 Appearances

Newcastle's record with foreign imports has been a mixed bag, but they should probably have learned from their failures in the Italian market so far: Davide Santon has faded (thanks mostly to Alan Pardew), Francesco Coco lasted one game and Alessandro Pistone was more memorable for a Christmas present prank than anything he did on the pitch. Rather notoriously, Pistone was given a sheep's heart during a Secret Santa ceremony at the club's Christmas party, to replace the one missing from his chest, and that said exactly what needed to be said about his performances. He was a mostly bland player, too easily kicked or pushed off the ball, and he has the unfortunate honour of being the subject of Ruud Gullit's only good decision at Newcastle, when he stripped him of his number and made him train with the kids. As an indication of exactly what Newcastle fans value most, after the Italian broke his leg in a fierce derby match, he was welcomed back to St. James' Park the following week as if he were some sort of conquering hero. All because he'd put his physical health on the line against Sunderland (when the reality was, he was simply, cynically fouled) - that is hardly enough to justify how he made 63 appearances.

5. Clarence Acuna - 59 Appearances

Chilean terrier Acuna is fondly remembered by Newcastle fans for the story that emerged about his being arrested for drink driving while dressed as Captain Hook, as well as for a single barn-storming performance against Arsenal that helped break the long-running London hoodoo. Beyond that, you'd be hard-pressed to remember him doing anything else in black and white. Some might suggest that the tough-tackling midfielder was something of a cult figure, but in truth, he just wasn't really Premier League quality, and the "cult" label would only protect him from due analysis. He came with a reasonably impressive reputation having amassed 50 caps for Chile, but he never really found his feet in England over four years, and in truth when he was released for family reasons after four years, it was at least two years longer than he should have stayed at the club.

4. Shola Ameobi - 397 Appearances

The Mackem Slayer might have been considered Mr Newcastle by Alan Pardew before he was released this summer, but if Kevin Keegan had had his way, the rangy striker would not have been at Newcastle for the last 5 or 6 years of his contracted time. Keegan was the only manager over the course of the nearly 20 years Shola played for Newcastle to recognise the fact that the striker simply wasn't good enough, and rather than allowing him to pick up hundreds of substitute appearances, he simply decided to get rid of him. Sadly for him, Stoke didn't fancy Shola after a short loan and he came back to the club before Keegan was constructively dismissed and Newcastle were relegated. And by then, any chance of suitors for his signature were even scarcer. There's no denying the fact that Shola was a good servant to the club, but then like Alan Pardew what choice did he have: he was over-achieving on Tyneside, and the fact that he managed to make 178 appearances as a substitute says everything about how the club viewed him. That he got to almost 400 appearances for the club is utterly astonishing, but fair play to him.

3. Nikos Dabizas - 176 Appearances

The Greek player was another in a long line of Newcastle defenders who couldn't actually do the primary job he was supposed to do: yes, he was good at attacking set-pieces, and popped up with a few goals here and there, but when it came to defending the same situations he looked like a fish out of water. Up a tree. On a bicycle. Dabizas gained something of a cult following because he had an uncanny knack of making it look like he was really trying, but there is good reason why he suffered the embarrassment of once being substituted midway through the first half of a pre-season friendly: he just wasn't very good. For all of his industry and effort, Dabizas' opinion that he was a Philippe Albert style classy defender with an eye for starting attacks was fatal for the rest of his fellow defenders. Players f his calibre should last a season at most at teams looking to compete at the top of the league: at Newcastle, Dabizas lasted 6 years and more than 170 appearances. Interestingly, as with Hatem Ben "Arthur", for some reason a significant portion of Newcastle fans had real trouble pronouncing his name properly, preferring the not at all accurate "Dabeedas".

2. Mike Williamson - 136 Appearances

At times, Mike Williamson can look like a brilliant reader of the game: he is capable of exceptional interceptions and blocks, and his effort certainly cannot be knocked. Unfortunately, when it comes to almost every single other characteristic that is required of a centre-half, he falls some way short of where Newcastle should be right now. Despite being tall, he cannot direct his headers, or add power through his neck, meaning his clearances are a lottery and the continued use of him as the target man for set-pieces is illogical. He's also slower than treacle rolling down a hill, and when his positional sense isn't great (he tends to rely too heavily on Fabricio Coloccini for guidance and ends up getting shown up if the captain is off form) that means recovering from bad starting positions is simply never going to happen. In truth, Willo is probably no more than a first choice Championship player, or a fourth choice option at a club like Newcastle. He has however now made 136 appearances for the Magpies and that will not change any time soon.

1. Titus Bramble - 147 Appearances

Some might say that Titus Bramble is the most unfairly criticised player in the history of Newcastle United: after all, he was signed by Sir Bobby Robson, suggested as a future England international and came with a not inconsiderable price tag. The people who make that claim clearly didn't watch a great deal of the former Ipswich player in a Newcastle shirt, because every criticism levelled at him was entirely on the nose. Annoyingly, he was capable of great feats of individual achievement, like scoring that scissor kick against Chelsea in 2006, and occasionally he would have great spells of defensive football. But then like the walking hand grenade he was, he would spectacularly combust and take the rest of the defence with him: his decision making was terrible, and his ability to make the worst possible mistakes was the stuff of legend. He should have been cast off as a failed experiment in seeking potential, but instead his skills were rewarded with almost 150 appearances for Newcastle. Which of these players is the least worthy of having made 50 appearances for Newcastle? Share your favourites in the comments thread below.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.