Star Trek: 10 Things You Didn’t Know About Jonathan Archer
Come leap with us into the long road. Cue tambourines!
Captain of Earth's first warp five mission and (co-)founder of the Federation, Jonathan Archer is one of the most important people in human and interstellar history. Look what effect removing him from the timeline at the wrong moment had on the timeline — pretty much no more timeline, as anyone would recognise it.
If, on screen, the NX-01 and crew were most recently celebrated with 250 Frontier Day birthday bumps and antimatter fireworks from Admiral Shelby aboard the 1701-F, then, off-screen, fan reaction to Star Trek: Enterprise has been as tempestuous as the swirling gas clouds of Jupiter that followed, and Archer has undoubtedly divided more than the Borg Queen.
Critiqued, criticized, and cancelled at the time, then, like everything you never knew you had, reappraised upwards in the years after, Enterprise has achieved the popularity it never managed on its first flight. Archer himself has yet to make a now much-desired come back to the franchise in any form other than a tip of the (baseball) hat, and we only got to spend four seasons with him in the first place, but there's still plenty left to say about this trailblazing captain. So, let's take a look at some of the things you might not have known about Porthos' dad.
10. Star Trek: The Beginning
Having wanted another series set in the 24th century to follow on from Star Trek: Voyager, the folks at Paramount were initially rather hesitant about Rick Berman and Brannon Braga's idea for a prequel. "We needed to find something that got back closer to the beginning of what this whole franchise was about," Braga said in the season one DVD extra Creating Enterprise. If they hadn't, there probably wouldn't have been a Jonathan Archer or, at least, not the one we know today.
Moreover, it's highly doubtful Scott Bakula would have played whatever captain was in it. As the actor told William Shatner in The Captains, "I [wasn't] interested in the next captain…cy" and the "curse" of having to follow. Whilst Bakula did eventually accept (more on that next), and the prequel did, of course, get the green light, the studio still insisted, and without a shred of irony, that "something futuristic" be included in the form of the temporal cold war, as Braga revealed in the season DVD extra Time Travel, Temporal Cold Wars, and Beyond.
The end of Enterprise could have also seen a different kind of beginning for Star Trek in the abandoned, but fully drafted, film Star Trek: The Beginning. The story, completed in late 2006, was set four years after Terra Prime and featured (for the most part) an entirely new cast of characters. Captain Archer does get a fleeting mention, nevertheless. When asked about them, Archer and crew are said to be on Risa. I guess you've got to get your downtime sometime, even if the Romulans would prefer otherwise.
9. It Had To Be You, Bak-u-la
Quite contrary to the casting of other contemporary Star Trek captains — one wig flown in from London, one frustrated French Canadian, and a surplus of possible Siskos — it seems the studio and producers had their eyes on Scott Bakula for Captain Archer from the start, apparently not considering anyone else for the role.
Indeed, as Star Trek director James L. Conway stated in The Fifty Year Mission: The Next 25 Years, "Scott Bakula was the only actor ever discussed for Archer." Everyone else might have wanted him, and we've already hinted at this above, but it was Bakula himself, not wanting to follow in the footsteps of William Shatner et al., who needed a little more, but not too much, convincing to accept the part.
Bakula was already a Star Trek fan, having fallen in love with The Original Series whilst watching it in re-runs in college in the 1970s. It was, in part, his fandom that led him to turn down the part of Archer when first offered. It was only the idea of going 100 years before it all that hooked Bakula in. As he commented in the season one DVD extra Cast Impressions:
They said we'd like you to be the first captain on the first starship. I think they knew before they asked me that that was gonna get my interest, and I tried not to act too excited. They pretty much had me from that point on.
And the rest is history.
8. We've Been Talkin' 'Bout Jackson
Star Trek has always pondered over what to call its captains since the very beginning — from Robert April to James Winter (sometimes Spring) to Christopher Pike to James (R or T) Kirk, with plenty more names on that list of possibilities. For the original prequel that dropped the 'Star Trek' from Star Trek until its third season, there was perhaps already a certain degree of certainty - in a way. 'Archer' was shot out to space in and after Broken Bow, but, before any temporal cold war, it's his first name as the extraordinary everyman that was in flux.
The series bible for Enterprise states,
The Kirks and Picards and Janeways will one day have the benefit of the Captains who preceded them. But Jackson Archer is the prototype.
The NX-01 captain was then referred to in the diminutive 'Jack' as late as a revised version of the Broken Bow script dated 11th May 2001, before getting what almost counts as an upgrade to the real thing in the English language as 'Jon[athan]' before filming began.
The reason for the renaming was pretty basic. "It was just a clearance thing," as Scott Bakula told Cinefantastique in October 2001 (Vol. 33, no. 5). At the time, there was only one person in all the United States called 'Jackson Archer,' meaning the name couldn't be used, but there were twenty or more 'Jonathan Archers,' so that one was fine. Later, in the novel Beneath the Raptor's Wing, Archer got the (non-canon) middle name 'Beckett,' and it shouldn't be too much of a leap to see why!
7. Chuck Yeager, Han Solo, Water Polo
As inspirations for a character go, there's little more eclectic than a mash-up between the first person to break the sound barrier and a rebel with a heart from another galaxy. That was the Chuck Yeager/Han Solo mix imagined for Captain Archer by producers Brannon Braga and Rick Berman in the early stages of development for Enterprise.
Since the series was going back to the beginnings of Starfleet, the first foray into deep space with the warp five engine, a different kind of captain was required — less polished, more down-to-earth, and accessible with his sense of excitement and awe still intact. This was the "Han Solo quality," or a younger Harrison Ford, they were after, as Berman described it in the DVD audio commentary for Broken Bow.
As for the real-world other half of the equation, in the season one DVD extra Creating Enterprise, Rick Berman asked:
Where was The Right Stuff of Starfleet? Where were the Chuck Yeagers of Starfleet? Where were the people who truly made the first flights out into space?
If Yeager had humble beginnings and went on to do exceptional things, Captain Archer was arguably a little more elitist in the first place, especially in his pick of favourite sport — university water polo. The sport did feel closer to home than your Anbo-jyutsus, parrises squares, or even baseball in the holodeck ever could, but it certainly wasn't 'down-to-earth,' if such a thing is possible for someone who travels to the stars. One of Rick Berman's sons played water polo, however, so choices were made. Scott Bakula had also dabbled in it growing up.
6. Windy, Breezy, Prada, Props
Everyone on board a starship is important, from captain to crewmember, and this especially during Earth's first warp-five flight. Each has a vital role to play whether it's… Oh, who are we kidding? It's Porthos! Porthos is the best and most important good boy there ever was in Starfleet. Who else would be content with just a slither of cheese, even though he and Cheddar didn't get along! The first captain's pet on Star Trek, unless you count Livingston, Porthos was a constant and faithful companion to Archer throughout.
What you perhaps didn't know is that Porthos was played by three different dogs over the years: a male named Windy (probably all that cheese) in the first season, and thereafter two females called Breezy and Prada. Producers considered numerous breeds of dogs for the role but became enamoured with the beagle when they were brought in for 'audition'. The episode A Night in Sickbay also required two prop Porthoses — one for the super-hydration chamber and another for the quarantine box — designed and built by Harlow FX.
Forget his owner, Porthos was the star of the show. As André Bormanis (exec. story editor/writer) put it in the season four DVD extra Enterprise Goes to the Dogs: "She's a scene-stealer, so we try to use the dog sparingly. People have pitched any number of Porthos episode[s]." The four-legged pioneer was once even 'interviewed' by StarTrek.com, but it's way past April Fool's by now.
5. J'Accuse…!
Behind-the-scenes on Star Trek: Enterprise was a tale of two halves. On the one hand, cast and crew got on swimmingly, became pals (see Trinneer and Keating), and clearly loved working with Scott Bakula. On the other, the ship was barely out of drydock when a sword of Damocles appeared, waiting to fall. For a myriad of reasons still debated to this day, Enterprise lived under threat of cancellation from pretty much the second season onwards.
John Billingsley once pranked Bakula on set with a surprise pregnancy, shouting "J'accuse! J'accuse!" in hilarious fashion. In reality, by the end of season three, network UPN was pointing fingers at Bakula and his portrayal of Captain Archer, blaming him (at least in part) for the low ratings. As revealed in the Blu-ray special feature Before Her Time: Decommissioning Enterprise, UPN even made renewal for a fourth season conditional on Bakula's removal from the show, which Rick Berman refused to allow.
In The Fifty-Year Mission: The Next 25 Years, season four showrunner Manny Coto also claimed that whilst "we were always going to stick with Scott," he did recall that a debate was had about killing off Archer and bringing on a brand-new character to add some fresh drama to the fourth season. Thankfully, that was vetoed too.
4. What A (Future) Guy!
Whatever the network came to think about Scott Bakula, it's clear that the cast and crew were unanimous in their adoration of the man. He set the tone from the top for a healthy and fun working environment from the get-go, made sure to remember birthdays, introduced himself to every guest cast member, and shook everyone's hand at the end of the day.
The season one DVD extra Oh Captain! My Captain! – A Profile of Scott Bakula is almost radioactive with praise for the actor. Here is to quote but a few:
André Bormanis: "Scott Bakula is the nicest guy in the world. He is just [an] extraordinarily thoughtful, giving person."
John Billingsley: "He's just the nicest man I think I've ever worked with in this business, and I've been in it a long time."
Connor Trinneer: "The way in which he handles himself, it's textbook for getting along in this business and with other actors, and we all know other actors aren’t always the easiest to get along with."
In the show itself, there was a well-known, and distinctly shadier 'Guy' whose identity would have been revealed had Enterprise made it to a fifth season. As Brannon Braga stated on Twitter, "Archer as future guy was always the idea. Trying to repair a corrupt future by influencing his innocent past self." Several other season five ideas have been revealed in the years since cancellation — one of which that made it to the pitching stage was for the crew to meet Flint who then might have also known Captain Archer's dad, Henry Archer.
3. Magic Mirror
As mirror Archer goes on a mad power grab for the Empire aboard the Defiant, his prime universe counterpart (or at least an imagined version of him) becomes a reflection for all his failings. In essence, we got two Archers for the price of one. The clever conceit of future ship, parallel universe also provided an opportunity to give us, the audience, some canonical information we might not have gotten otherwise.
By now, we've all taken a long pause over the personnel files of both Hoshi Sato and Jonathan Archer as they are summoned up in the mirror that is the computer screen in the quarters of the Defiant's former captain. What never made it to air, however, was the second page of biographical information for both characters, penned by In a Mirror, Darkly scriptwriter Michael Sussman.
For Hoshi, that would have meant death at the hands of Kodos the Executioner on Tarsus IV at age 117. However, as Sussman said on Twitter in reply to TrekCore.com, "[it] didn't appear on screen, so not really canon. #HoshiStillDeadTho." Also in reply to TrekCore, Sussman posted the extra, unseen page from "Admiral" (retired) Archer's bio, from which we would have learned that he "died peacefully in his home in upstate New York the year 2245, exactly one day after attending the christening ceremony of the first Federation Starship Enterprise, NCC-1701." "I gather he survived in Kelvin Timeline," Sussman added.
2. Who's The Evilest Of Them All?
That mirror Archer's fate was left fairly ambiguous as he slumped to the floor at the end of In a Mirror, Darkly — maybe he just couldn't handle his champagne — was a deliberate move. As Manny Coto revealed at the Star Trek Las Vegas Convention in 2009, for Enterprise's hypothetical fifth season, discussions were had for a return to the Mirror Universe over four to five episodes as a "mini-series within a series." Brannon Braga also later revealed on Twitter that there was even talk of setting all of season five in the Mirror Universe.
For some, in the third season, Prime Archer already mirrored his otherworldly equivalent all too well. The season's second episode Anomaly contained the extremely controversial airlock torture scene of an Osaarian prisoner. Whilst there were those who defended his actions as those of a desperate captain trying to save billions, others decried it as the complete antithesis to the moral values of Star Trek. It certainly did feel more like how a member of the Terran Empire would have handled the situation.
It wasn't just the fans who were divided over the darker turn taken by Archer in season three's 9/11 allegory. Phlox actor John Billingsley also notably expressed his objections to the airlock torture scene and to aspects of season three in general that, to his mind, strayed from the ethos of Star Trek, and left him feeling "uncomfortable".
1. Leaving A Legacy
The pioneering Captain and crew of the NX-01 were thoroughly underappreciated at the time of first broadcast of Star Trek: Enterprise. Some blamed 'franchise fatigue,' others network scheduling, studio dramas, the temporal cold war, and that theme tune. Enterprise finally found the viewership it deserved in the streaming era, and Captain Archer himself has enjoyed somewhat of a renaissance in terms of his in-universe legacy, although we're still waiting for a more literal rebirth.
The re-appreciation of the character on screen began back in the J.J. Abrams' reboot when Scotty admitted to 'losing' "Admiral Archer's prized beagle" in a transwarp beaming experiment. (Surely not Porthos? Surely not?!) Later, in Star Trek: Discovery, Archer appeared on a list of most decorated Starfleet captains. He's also had three starships and a spacedock named after him, and most recently Star Trek: Lower Decks/Strange New Worlds got some crossover love in for Archer and the NX-01.
However, the only time Scott Bakula has reprised the role of Captain Archer — and not in canon — was for the 2006 video game Star Trek: Legacy alongside all the then series' captains. Arguably, he did appear in Star Trek: Online, but all of his dialogue was taken from episodes of Enterprise. Legacy is now very much in the spirit of things, and Scott Bakula is one of those actors who is open to a return to the franchise. Nothing has ever been confirmed, but the rumours continue to abound. Return or no, Archer's time really is finally here!