Star Trek: 10 Most Shocking Returns
Our eyes opened wide as these familiar faces shocked us with their returns to Star Trek.
Characters leave, and characters come back. This is a trope as old as any franchise, with Star Trek being no exception. Whether Khan shocked the audience (who had conveniently missed the title of the film) or Tasha Yar threw them for a time loop, unexpected returns can be a lot of fun.
While this list is going to focus on those returns that have shocked us since 2017, the Star Trek universe has often used the big twist return to its advantage. As with both examples above, there have been family fall-outs, vanishings, and rescues across the galaxy. Sadly, some characters have yet to return (looking at you, Jadzia), though Star Trek has often taught us to never say never.
Some of the examples here came so out of the blue that we can safely say they weren't on anyone's bingo cards. Sometimes, one learns things that go on behind the scenes of a show, and then one wonders how there could ever be a chance of a return. There is at least one example here of such a huge surprise, not just because of the length between appearances, but because conditions on the set (at the time) were far from positive. Frankly, there are those times when returns can feel like a long-overdue apology to the performer.
There are also those other returns that were shocking in that they were resurrections of stars who had passed away. Though this is something that must always be handled carefully and respectfully, Star Trek has thankfully managed to achieve both.
With the franchise currently in a cooling-off period, these returns may be the biggest surprises for some time to come, but who knows? We may soon be starting our sequel list already!
10. T'Pol (Star Trek: Lower Decks)
This return was one of the most pleasantly shocking surprises in recent Star Trek history. When These Are The Voyages aired in 2005, Star Trek: Enterprise came to an ignoble end, going out with a whimper rather than a roar. In the interim, the franchise moved away from the NX-01 (despite some fun references in the Kelvin timeline and the newer live-action streaming shows)
While there is much talk of a potential continuation of Archer's story in Star Trek: United, most of the crew of Enterprise hadn't been heard from again, bar a holographic cameo from Trip Tucker in Holograms All The Way Down. Jolene Blalock had barely appeared at any conventions or Trek events since her run as T'Pol came to an end. She had also been openly critical of both the show's finale and some of the behind-the-scenes decisions around her character.
Mike McMahan teased some big swings in the final season of Star Trek: Lower Decks, and with T'Pol's return in Fissure Quest (alongside Harry Kim(s), Garak, Bashir, Lily Sloane, and even Curzon Dax), he did not disappoint. McMahan explained that to convince Jolene to return, he penned her a letter explaining how beloved her character was, as well as the respect he intended to depict her with, comedy show or no.
It worked, leading to an enormously enjoyable episode overall. The episode felt like a healing of sorts, ensuring that T'Pol's final appearance (for now) was no longer relegated to a hologram aboard the Enterprise-D.
9. Ro Laren (Star Trek: Picard)
Much has been said about the ending of Imposters, yet the return of Ro Laren was a completely unexpected twist. Her last appearance in Preemptive Strike saw her leave Starfleet to join the Maquis, only for that organisation to be destroyed by the Dominion in Deep Space Nine. All indications pointed to Ro being dead and gone, despite the fans' cries.
Michelle Forbes, striding through the corridors of the USS Titan-A, was shocking, now decked out in a Commander's bars and uniform. In a series that had teased the return of the Changelings, nails were bitten, and seats were very much on edge. However, proofs were given, emotions were high, and the long-awaited reunion between Ro and Picard took place on the holodeck.
Star Trek: Picard's third season saw several returns to the franchise, with this being among the most surprising. Though her screentime is brief, Forbes proves that she can command the stage with as few words as she chooses in any given scene. While her departure from Star Trek wasn't a bitter one, her rejection of a starring role in Deep Space Nine (the role that would then morph to become Kira Nerys) suggested that she was finished with the franchise.
Imposters proved, thankfully, that this conclusion was incorrect. While we will never give up hope on a second return (no body, no death), it was incredible to see her one more time, ridges and all.
8. Trelane (Star Trek: Strange New Worlds)
Rhys Darby's unnamed wedding planner in Wedding Bell Blues brought an upbeat, mischievous joy to Strange New Worlds. Though the clues were present throughout, the confirmation that he was playing Trelane, the bold child originated by William Campbell in The Squire Of Gothos, brought smiles to many faces.
This return is an outlier on this list because, technically, no one is returning. This was Rhys Darby's debut in Star Trek, while William Campbell passed away in 2011. Wedding Bell Blues then sets about making some changes to the lore, while also honouring the earlier episode.
In The Squire Of Gothos, Trelane is shown to be a powerful being, albeit one who focuses his power through, effectively, a magic mirror. At the episode's conclusion, he is whisked away by his parents, both of whom are represented as glowing green mist. John De Lancie makes a vocal cameo in this episode, effectively confirming a theory that had long been out there: Trelane was a member of the Q Continuum.
It's all handled in suggestion rather than outright confirmation, while at the same time, it's fairly concrete. Trelane can now be assumed to be Q Junior, originally played by Keegan De Lancie in Q2. In that episode, this younger Q vanishes for some years, followed by his father. This episode, and the wedding therein, is inferred to take place during that sojourn.
It is a fun addition to the lore, while never outright contradicting anything else that's been established. Rhys Darby is wonderfully manic in the part, so one very much hopes for a return from this well-dressed trickster.
7. Jake Sisko (Star Trek: Starfleet Academy)
Star Trek: Starfleet Academy may remain a painful title for some of us to hear in 2026. A show that debuted, aired one season, and was announced to be ending with its upcoming second season was more than disheartening; it was upsetting. Whether it was everyone's favourite iteration of the franchise or not, it was already making strides to bring all previous Star Treks into the same sphere.
We have discussed the now infamous Wall Of Heroes several times on TrekCulture, including breaking down every name. While these inclusions were a treat for long-term fans of Star Trek, actually seeing Cirroc Lofton standing in the same space as Kerrice Brooks took things to a new level.
Jake Sisko's last on-screen appearance was in 1999, closing out What You Leave Behind alongside Nana Visitor's Colonel Kira Nerys. Almost thirty years had passed before SAM calls up the holographic recording from the Sisko Museum in Series Acclimation Mil. Had there been only a single scene featuring Jake, we, the audience, would probably have been satisfied, yet the episode decided to take things one step further.
While the exact logic of the second scene is up for debate, watching Jake and SAM interact over the copy of Anslem was beautifully written, acted, and directed. They bond over the Prophets, over Jake losing his father at such a young age, and about the struggles of being an emissary alone.
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine has always been this writer's favourite version of Star Trek, even if the viewing figures had never quite reached The Next Generation's levels. Seeing it receive such a respectful honour, featuring the perfect character to do so, was an easy highlight of this sadly truncated show.
6. Spock/Odo/Uhura/Scotty/Crusher (Star Trek: Prodigy)
One day, we will finally run out of steam to complain about the treatment Star Trek: Prodigy received from the studios. It is not, however, today. Prodigy remains one of the best Star Trek shows that people never watched, with Season One's Kobayashi serving as a great example of what they're missing.
When Dal is struggling to command the Protostar, he activates the Kobayashi Maru exam on the holodeck. The computer adds additional characters to help him, leading to Spock, Odo, Dr Crusher, Uhura, and Scotty making extended cameo appearances.
Gates McFadden returned to record new dialogue for the episode, while the others had sadly passed away or were too ill to return. Aaron Waltke, friend of the channel and card-carrying Star Trek nerd, trawled through hundreds of hours of pre-recorded dialogue to build the conversations that Dal would have with these famous faces.
Some of it is clearly lifted from The Original Series, during which time recording equipment was far less sophisticated than today. This, however, adds to the utter charm of the episode. Dal is not simply interacting with avatars of these people. He is, in a way, becoming part of their overall narrative and joining them at different points along the way.
While the final scenes between Dal and Spock are particularly affecting, the entire episode is constructed with such care and reverence for Star Trek of old that, for half an hour at least, it truly felt like some of these icons returned to life again.
5. Daniels (Star Trek: Discovery)
Star Trek: Enterprise may have only run for four seasons, yet its impact is still being felt twenty years after it finished its run. The Temporal Cold War was a controversial inclusion in the show's first season, one that suggested a slight lack of confidence in the prequel setting. While there remains a question of just how well that overall arc was handled, we were gifted with Matt Winston's Daniels, the time-travelling hero.
He was both a part of the action and often a source for exposition in the show's first two seasons. His primary point of contact was Captain Archer, with both of them acting as a kind of secret ops team, battling the other factions in the War. Daniels died and returned to life (standard Tuesday in Star Trek), with that death signalling the end of the War.
Through the lens of Enterprise, we saw a young Daniels, working tirelessly to right the wrongs of these battles. Though the audience wouldn't discover it until Life, Itself, Daniels returned to Star Trek in Discovery's third season episode Die Trying, now sporting the name of Dr Kovich.
For Discovery's 32nd Century arc, Kovich acts as a serious, if sardonic, liaison between the ship and Starfleet, interviewing the crew and, in particular, paying close attention to Emperor Philipa Georgiou. His enigmatic depiction suggests something a little outside of the usual structure of Starfleet, so when he is revealed as an older Daniels in the finale, things finally make sense.
This was no mere inclusion for inclusion's sake. Enterprise had seen several nods and references through Discovery's run, with Daniels' return cementing that show's place in the franchise's history. Of course, it would be Daniels to guide (albeit with a lack of gentility) the 23rd Century crew into the future. With his wall of relics behind him, it was a real treat to see the man again, bouncing from time to time like a certain Doctor.
4. Sito Jaxa (Star Trek: Lower Decks)
Star Trek: Lower Decks was inspired in no small part by Lower Decks, the seventh season episode of The Next Generation. At the time of release, it was an unusual episode, in that it focused on a cast of characters who were not the bridge crew. While the conceit would prove to be a great success, it was a gamble at the time.
Shannon Fill had previously appeared as then-Cadet Sito Jaxa in The First Duty, the fifth season episode that focused on an accident at Starfleet Academy, one which she and several other cadets attempted to cover up. While that episode focused primarily on Wesley Crusher and Nick Locarno, Lower Decks saw Ensign Sito attempting to prove herself as an officer aboard the Enterprise.
The announcement of her death at the episode's close was a crushing blow, so it was quite the surprise when Fill reprised the role in a vocal cameo for the show that was inspired by her episode. Old Friends, New Planets features a flashback to Beckett Mariner's Academy days, during which time she was enamoured by Cadet Sito. Wil Wheaton and Robert Duncan McNeill also reprise their roles from The First Duty, but the greatest surprise came from Shannon Fill herself, as she had retired from acting by this point.
Returning to the franchise in an episode celebrating the story that spawned it, Shannon Fill as Cadet Sito Jaxa was a true sit up and point moment in recent Star Trek history.
3. The Guardian Of Forever (Star Trek: Discovery)
Few expected to see that glorious arch again in Star Trek, especially after nearly fifty years between appearances. However, the booming voice of Bartell La Rue was heard once more in Star Trek: Discovery's third season episode Terra Firma Part 2. The Guardian, or Carl as they now like to be known, had moved planets and timelines to find a nice quiet spot for themselves to get away from it all. That is, until Michael Burnham and Philipa Georgiou popped by for a visit.
With the third season onwards of Discovery set against the backdrop of Temporal Wars and interstellar Burns, the Guardian was the perfect foil to get around iron-clad laws. Georgiou was dying - horribly - while there was nothing Starfleet were legally able to do about it. Thankfully, the Discovery itself (with a little help from the Sphere Data) managed to identify a way forwards (or back.)
First appearing as Carl, a fairly enigmatic and relaxed man in a bowler hat, the Guardian didn't reveal their true appearance until the story was nearly at a close. Thankfully, this was no mere nod to the past. The Guardian's previous appearances were alluded to, including a quick sentence explaining that any past changes had been allowed as long as the travellers cleaned up after themselves. The temptation it offered to Temporal agents was too strong, so it went into hiding.
The music swells and the vocals boom and in that moment, it was like Kirk, Spock, and McCoy were facing one of their toughest missions once more.
2. Wesley Crusher (Star Trek: Prodigy Season 2)
When Wesley Crusher returned in Star Trek: Prodigy's second season episode The Devourer Of All Things Part 1, he revealed himself as a time traveller. When attempting to trace his lifeline, there is simply no better way to understand him than as a man out of time, wearing only the finest of jumpers.
Technically, Wesley returned first in Star Trek: Picard's second season finale Farewell, picking up Kore Soong (presumably before beginning her shift in The Pitt). Wil Wheaton also returned in Star Trek: Lower Decks, in the fourth season finale Old Friends, New Planets, though in that case he was reprising the role in a flashback.
Other Wesley Crusher's have appeared through the years (including an enigmatic 'Crusher' in OTOY's 765874: Unification short film), yet it was in Prodigy that he received the greatest chance to shine. He was described by that show's creators and writers as the original prodigy in Star Trek, so having him appear on the show was a must. Having him appear as this particular version of the character was simply the most logical move forward while time was circling them all.
It is also no mere cameo. Wesley is a supporting character in the show's second season, appearing right through the finale, wherein he even gets the chance to meet his mother (and brother) before disappearing off into the winds of time again.
This was fan service done correctly, logically, and with extremely entertaining payoffs. We're still waiting for that Wesley and Kore spin-off, mind.
1. Sulu (Star Trek: Lower Decks)
Star Trek: Lower Decks has been a true gift for long-term fans of the franchise. This list alone has offered some incredible surprise returns in that show alone, though it isn't a show that is entirely devoted to fan service. While some cameos are there to make us simply smile, there are others that are handled so deftly and beautifully that they rank among the most moving scenes in Star Trek.
Crisis Point II: Paradoxus sees Bradward Boimler attempt to write his own holodeck program, to the usual mixed levels of results. Mariner quickly shows him how easy it is to confuse the system, but neither of them were expecting a certain vision that Boimler has toward the end. He arrives on a farm, but not just any farm. The letterbox says 'Kirk' and Boimler sees the shadow of a figure brushing down a horse.
The voice that rises is not that of William Shatner, but George Takei, reprising the role of Captain Hikaru Sulu. He is there to offer the young officer sage wisdom and advice, speaking softly of his own personal journey and even tragedies. The scene, arriving largely out of the blue, was devastatingly moving, yet instantly uplifting as well.
While Takei has returned in both the Very Short Treks and Star Trek: Khan, it was this surprise, sweet cameo that truly melted our hearts.