10 Most Controversial American Dad Episodes (So Far)

Given that the cartoon manages to be very entertaining most of the time without offending anyone, it feels unnecessary that they even have to go to these lengths to make people laugh.

Seth MacFarlane has come to be known for pushing the boundaries of what is and isn't ok to say. Whether that's his opinion-dividing stint as host of the Oscars, on his original show Family Guy or on his most underrated show American Dad!, the point is still the same. Yes, some people might find it funny and sometimes clever, but making a joke about domestic violence by calling Django a date movie for Rihanna and Chris Brown is highly inappropriate. It needs to be said before this article that in no way is the point being missed. It is part of American Dad's premise that Stan Smith is the caricature of a very close-minded Republican and is a vehicle for writers to satirise the kind of extremist opinions that exist in politics. Most of the time, this works and to hilarious ends as Stan is shown to be a bigoted fool. But are there ever episodes where, like Seth's domestic violence joke, it just shouldn't be said, no matter what your point is? And doesn't it only take one person who doesn't get the show's premise to either get offended or think it is endorsing their prejudicial opinion? Given that the cartoon manages to be very entertaining most of the time without offending anyone, it feels unnecessary that they even have to go to these lengths to make people laugh. Let's take a look at some of the more controversial episodes American Dad has made so far over the last 8 seasons.

10. Pulling Double Booty - S4E06

Imagine your parent works at the CIA. Now imagine they have a body double for life-threatening missions etc. Now imagine being sexually attracted to them. Sick right? Well that didn't stop American Dad writers from basing a whole episode around it. The way the moment pictured above is set up, the viewers are made to think it is Stan and Hayley as we have not yet been introduced to Bill, Stan's double. Francine approaches Hayley's bedroom and accidentally eavesdrops on the incestuous couple making out on her bed. She soon passes out from shock before we're relieved to learn that it is Bill after Hayley objects to him talking like her dad. The next scene we see is her downstairs scolding the real Stan (how she got there and ignored what was going on in the bedroom is a bit confusing). The writers walk a really fine line with their wordplay as Stan defends himself (thinking Francine is talking about cookie dough) saying he couldn't help himself because 'it's so sweet and tempting' and Roger admits that he has 'stuck his fingers in there too'. Francine ends up throwing up in the popcorn before it's revealed that Hayley is with Bill and not Stan, although this is not much relief. Only Francine thinks of it as disgusting, while Stan thinks it's the perfect arrangement. But as if this wasn't quite creepy enough, they take it that bit further. When Bill makes a move on Francine and Stan bans him from their lives, Stan has to pretend to be Bill in order to get Hayley to dump him. He ends up taking her on a weekend away where Hayley intends to have sex with him. What follows is some rather disturbing exchanges between them given that they are father and daughter climaxing with Hayley's suggestion that she has sex with the waitress while Stan watches. Eventually Hayley finds out it is Stan, thank god, and nothing happens between them but that doesn't really save this episode from inducing shudders in viewers everywhere.

9. Don't Look A Smith Horse In The Mouth €“ S5E10

Ok, this episode isn't actually overly controversial yet somehow is the only episode on this list to have cost American Dad $25k due to a fine from the FCC. This is because of one particular scene that allegedly received over 100,000 complaints from viewers when it aired. The episode involves Roger and Stan buying a race horse in order to try and make some quick cash. After Stan punches Roger in the arm (for basically just being Roger), Roger decides to exact revenge on Stan by instructing him to 'do the horse chores' because his arm is too sore. The chores include giving the horse a 'full release' which Roger spells out with some colourful metaphors before Stan understands that Roger means he will have to induce an ejaculation from the horse. We don't actually see any sexual images. There is a cut as Stan bends down and the next thing we see is Stan hosing himself in the face and Roger gloating that he actually got Stan to do it. But that was clearly enough to offend some people. The rest of the episode is one of the strongest across the whole series. It's incredibly funny, very quotable and manages to avoid some of the 'so bad it's cringey' writing that sporadically emerges at odd points in episodes. But seen as how this caused the most controversy in the public eye, it's only fair that it makes an appearance on this list.

8. Love, AD Style €“ S8E01

This episode is just...disgusting. And no I'm not talking about the shameless self-promotion from the voice of Hayley (and Seth's sister, Rachel) who released a jazz album around the time this episode aired. But there are way too many stomach-wrenching images in this episode that are completely unnecessary. The episode is funny enough without them and so these moments of rank and graphic violence feels excessive. There's the moment Roger graphically squashes two waltzing rats on his bar or the moment a lion mauls a woman in the street. Or even when Stan shows his SUV's brakes off to potential buyers only to see them go smashing into the windscreen. But grosser than all this is the final scene of the episode which requires explaining. Roger opens a lounge bar and hires Hayley to sing for him. He ends up falling in love with her and after she rejects him, he can't handle it so decides to shoot her. In hospital, he brings her a gift to make it up to her and reveals Christina Aguilera's larynx which he goes on to sing through (what happened to Christina Aguilera for him to cut out her larynx is left up to our imagination). He decides this isn't enough and so kidnaps Hayley and ties her up. Unhappy that they can't get close enough, he ultimately plans to cut off her skin and wear it so they can be united. Just in time, Jeff bursts in to save Hayley and she manages to explain that no matter what Roger does, she only wants Jeff. Cut to...Roger wearing Jeff's skin, with 'everything held together with a clip' under his hat. In seconds he decides that he's over Hayley and yells to a skinless Jeff (who has been left in a bathtub) that he can have his skin back. Just gross.

7. Shallow Vows - S5E06

Stan really is the worst husband in the world. Firstly, he forgets their twentieth anniversary and then thinks renewing their vows is a rubbish idea. But the main problem with this episode is that Stan reveals he only married Francine for her looks, he hasn't listened to her in thirty years and he really knows nothing about her. Francine sets out to make a point by letting herself go. She puts weight on, stops waxing her eyebrows and gets messy hair, all of which disgust Stan and cause him to run out on their wedding. Even though he commits to getting to know her, he only takes her to activities where he doesn't have to look at her. He says he loves her (this doesn't really make sense given that he's admitted to not knowing her) so in order to continue their marriage he blinds himself. Yep. He has the CIA take out his retinas just so he can stand being around his wife. Francine is appalled at first but then seems to prefer it. Stan listens to her and really wants to get to know her for the first time in their marriage. Really? She is fine that her husband would rather be blind than look at her? Hmmm. What's worse is that the writers don't really reconcile this issue. Instead, Stan tells Francine that if this is going to be the permanent arrangement, Francine will have to be his carer and work to support the family. Francine doesn't like this and so they both decide that they are shallow and accept that. There's just something about this that doesn't sit right. It's a cartoon and we're not meant to take it seriously but even still, Stan's openly shallow and uncaring attitude to his wife just makes us feel uncomfortable and the fact that it isn't corrected like Stan's usual idiotic ramblings just makes you wonder what the point of it really is? Unnecessarily awkward viewing.

6. Oediple Panties €“ S3E11

Whilst the title of this episode may be a clever play on words, it is also a disturbing hint at Stan's own relationship with his mother. We're all familiar with the mommy's boy type who is a little too close to their mother, but Stan Smith characteristically takes it too far. Voiced by Swoosie Kurtz, Stan's mother makes a visit to the Smith home after being heartbroken. We gather from Francine's reaction that this is a regular occurrence and that Stan's mother is a little manipulative to make sure Stan is always there for her. Yeah, cliché stuff that we've all heard before, which is exactly what Roger says to Francine when she starts shooting whiskey in the attic. Francine sets him straight by sending him on a trip to the bathroom. Roger opens the door to Stan and his mother sharing a bath together. Stan is singing a rather distasteful shanty that is too explicit to repeat here but let's just say involves Stan sponging down his mother very, very thoroughly. Roger's reaction mimics ours as he sits speechless on the sofa, shaken and sipping a stiff drink. He corrects Francine when she said it was complicated. 'Changing planes at O'hare is complicated. This is...what is this?' he says and we're all thinking the same thing. It turns out Stan has been kidnapping his mother's boyfriends to make sure she stays alone and therefore always needs him. As well as this, he is also far too keen to label Francine, the love of his life and mother of this two kids, as woman B in his life, not being able to possibly rank her above his own mother. For a character that is usually the pinnacle of misogyny and inappropriateness, even this feels a little too much.

5. Surro-Gate €“ S3E07

Surro Gate This episode wastes no time before homophobic nonsense starts spewing out of the usual culprit, Stan Smith of course. And yes, we're all aware that it is the usual satirical tactic of the show. They make Stan spout illogical, unreasonable and politically incorrect stuff so the rest of the characters can point out how stupid and bigoted he is. But this episode goes way too overboard and the resolution is far too shallow for it to be classed as one of their better attempts at political satire. Greg and Terry decide they are ready to have a baby which they share with Stan and Francine and Francine ends up being their surrogate. Stan gets genuinely outraged because after he 'let' them be gay, they have the cheek to try and procreate. Stan condemns IVF as sci-fi nonsense, describes Terry and Greg's relationship as an abomination and diminishes their natural paternal instincts as just wanting to dress something up and suggests they dress their dog up instead. Eventually he pretends he's on board with the surrogacy but only so he can kidnap the baby and take it to Nebraska where gay parents have no legal rights. Suddenly a point to all this bigotry starts to take shape. As Stan nears Nebraska, he accidentally totals the car trying to escape the rainbow trucker brigade but is offered help from a woman on a quad bike. The woman turns out to have some great kids which Stan admires, that is until he learns that both the parents are women. So of course, he must kidnap these kids as well. The only thing that changes his mind is that the kids argue just like his kids. So they must be normal and therefore their parents must be ok. After all the hate and his firm position that gay parents are against nature, his mind changes in a flash and it feels a little too easy for the writers. So rather than trying make a point, it feels more like they were just poking fun at some pretty serious issues in America (and globally) and skirts the edges of recklessness. Funny? At times. Irresponsible? Yes.

4. Homeland Insecurity - S1E06

Another example of Stan's bigoted behaviour being relied upon for laughs is the early episode Homeland Insecurity, in which Stan takes a paranoid disliking to his neighbours because of the colour of their skin and their surname. Bob and Linda Mamari are both American. Yet Stan assumes they are Islamic terrorists purely because of the colour of their skin. The writers' get-out clause is there in full of course. It's a stab at the US Patriot Act and its encouragement of racial profiling. That's ok then. Let Stan be as racist as he likes. Stan sets out on a mission to harass his neighbours in order to provide Hayley, always the voice of reason, with proof to justify his prejudiced opinion. He goes on to stalk and spy on them culminating in him ultimately detaining them in his back yard, citing the patriot act as all the permission he needs. Hayley points out that this 'violates every tenant of a rational and just society' to which Stan replies 'High five!'. Ok American Dad, we get it. Rather than being laugh-out-loud funny, the relentless close-mindedness makes for some pretty uncomfortable viewing as Stan attempts to do cavity searches and interrogations. In the end, it's justified because the Mamaris prefer Stan's bigotry to their old neighbours who were black. So they're racist too and we're meant to feel better about how Stan treated them. That's ok then!

3. Camp Refoogee €“ S2E01

In this episode, Stan mistakes a refugee camp for a summer camp and instinctively packs Steve off to have the summer of a lifetime. When Francine and Hayley tell him it's not Camp Refoogee, it's a refugee camp, Stan sets off to Africa to fetch Steve back to the US; meanwhile Hayley takes the opportunity to do some charity work. But when Stan arrives at the refugee camp, he doesn't think it's as bad as everyone always makes out and sets out to make it a summer camp of his very own. Is it really OK to make light of such desperate situations? This episode might make audiences laugh but it's the kind of laughter where you're not really sure whether it's OK. He diminishes their suffering because they have sun and sand, and gives all the refugees nicknames because he can't be bothered to learn their real names. When he's decided to convert it in to a summer camp, he demands cheques from all the refugees' parents and gets them E! t-shirts and tether balls rather than malaria pills or water. When one of the refugees informs him about the militant rebels that forced them out of their homes and into the camp in the first place, Stan dismisses it as the rich kids' camp which is made even more awkward when they invade the camp, killing people and burning down tents and Stan laughs it off as a 'panty raid', making light of the violence and death. Not even Haley escapes this one, as she turns hypocrite as soon as she learns they're staying there longer than she thought and dives in to the buffet and hotel. The writers try and make out like they're making a statement about how Stan (AND the rest of the world) likes to act oblivious to third world plights but, fearing it was going to be too obvious, they make a joke out of this too as someone fetches Stan a soapbox to stand on during his realisation. Some funny moments but this episode is mostly too close to the truth.

2. 42 Year Old Virgin €“ S3E06

In this episode, it is revealed that Stan has never actually killed anyone in his entire CIA career. In a spoof of The 40 Year Old Virgin, Stan cracks under repeated questioning from friends at a poker game and admits his lies, to the horror of all his friends and family. So in an effort to help him out, his friends parade people who they deem 'killable' in front of him at a bar, because they believe they have nothing left to live for. Hmmm. But the really controversial aspect of this episode comes later when a convicted paedophile is doing his civic duty and informing all his neighbours that he has moved into their vicinity. The audience are expected to laugh at the way the sex-offender metaphorically salivates over glimpses of Steve in his underwear in the Smith's living room while Stan remains completely oblivious to the potential threat. The episode takes a slightly too sinister turn when the paedophile kidnaps Steve and all his friends and takes them to his private lair at a water park, where there is just a dirty mattress on the floor and they are all in their bathing suits. Stan races to the rescue but refuses to pay the admission until he gets discount, at which point he actually says the words 'I hope my son is still about to be molested'. He manages to arrive just in time and holds Randy the paedophile at gunpoint, ready to make him his first kill. Randy's unapologetic attitude towards his 'offensive sex' tendencies is used as the cornerstone of the episode's morality. Stan looks at Randy's attitude and sees a positive acceptance of a controversial lifestyle and so uses it as a life lesson of how he should accept that he is a killing virgin. This all makes for some pretty uncomfortable viewing. Are we meant to admire Randy and the way he is at peace with the fact that he's a paedophile? It feels like we're directed that way. Oh! Now the episode's point is made clear. It's a jab at the US legal system's leniency on sex offenders. Randy brags that he'll be out of prison sooner than we might think because his mom's rich and he has a good lawyer. Well it feels a little too late and doesn't erase the fact that Stan learned this episode's lesson (he'll learn many on this list) from a paedophile. A little too close to the bone American Dad writers. Should we really be directed to laugh at one of the most serious offences a person can commit? I think not.

1. Stan of Arabia - S1E12 & 13

In a way, this episode enforces a lot of what is wrong with the episode 'Shallow Vows' but the thing that sets this episode apart is that instead of mocking specific attitudes and opinions, American Dad writers really go for the jugular and instead satirise an entire culture, making fun of the language, names and beliefs. After Stan insults his boss, Avery Bullock, whilst attempting to roast him at his birthday, he and his family are shipped out to Saudi Arabia as a punishment. Whilst Francine and Haley are initially excited about absorbing a brand new culture, Stan is predictably apprehensive, assuming that he has moved to a land of terrorists. When natives pass him and the family, he instructs them to shut their mouths as that is how they invade bodies and lay their eggs. Just usual Stan nonsense. But, unlike in other episodes when Stan is corrected or comes to some epiphany, in this episode Francine and Hayley are manhandled, chased and called whores so they end up hating Saudi culture as much as Stan, because in the world of American Dad, it is portrayed in a completely negative light. Of course, Stan ends up loving it because their beliefs about men and women suit him to a tee. He's fed up of Francine disagreeing with him and doing what she wants so gets a second wife to suit his needs for a more submissive partner. Without going too much into whether we agree or disagree with this depiction of Islamic countries and Sharia Law, it is completely politically incorrect and goes unchecked throughout. And the fact that this was in the first season of the show and the writers have never really gone this far since suggests that perhaps they agree it was not necessary to make the show great. What episodes do you find stomach-churning? Are people who think it's a controversial show just being too sensitive? Let us know and leave a comment!

In this post: 
American Dad
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Born in Yorkshire, Katie is a freelance journalist currently based in Essex. As a keen sports writer, Katie has a diploma in Multimedia Journalism from the Press Association and has worked on the busy Newcastle Chronicle sports desk. She has also written for Gateshead FC and contributed to various websites including Give Me Sport. When she's not watching sports, films or playing music, she's gaming. 8 hours and eventually reaching wave 80 on Modern Warfare 3′s Resistance is a productive day!