10 Most Inglorious TV Character Deaths (After The Actor Left The Show)
Starring in a TV show is a big deal a long term commitment to something that will dominate an actors career for what could be a number of years. None of us are going to feel sorry for someone in such a privileged position, but it must be daunting if an actor is unhappy in their job. Sometimes a situation comes to the point that it cannot be resolved, be it behind the scenes problems or simply the talent wanting to leave for pastures anew. As such the character must leave the series, in a way that wasn't the originally planned. These kinds of exits can often feel extremely rushed, completely out of place with what came before it and in some cases the writers take the opportunity to give the outgoing actor the finger. Depending on the situation the exit can take place off screen or the actors may stick around to show the death of their character, but either way it just doesn't feel right. The writers don't always have a choice, so they have to make the best of a bad situation. Yet almost always, when a character's death is unplanned it sucks. Be it the character, the story or the rest of the show's cast, there is always a casualty. A television series is meant to be a long-form story, something that takes a number of years to get through. Season after season the plot will develop and eventually a character may come to its natural conclusion, but if this conclusion is forced it can result in a notably poor departure. With that in mind, here are 10 inglorious character deaths.
10. Prue Halliwell Charmed
Shannen Doherty was one of the biggest TV stars of the 90s; she was also notorious for her involvement in various off-screen problems which led to the actresses early departure from both of her hit shows. She made her name in what many consider to be the prototypical teen drama (though Degrassi fans would argue differently) Beverly Hills 90210. She played Brenda Walsh who along with her twin Brandon, attempted to adjust to the glamorous lifestyle of Beverly Hills. The series was a hit but after four seasons Doherty and the character of Brenda were written out of the Aaron Spelling-produced series and she never returned to the original show which concluded its ten season run in 2000. The reason for her departure has been attributed to bad relations with several of her cast mates, but for whatever the reason Aaron Spelling was seemingly happy enough to leave them in the past when he later cast her as one of the three leads in another of his shows Charmed. Though not quite on the same level as 90210, Charmed was also successful especially for a show on the WB network but backstage tensions would again lead to an early exit for Shannen Doherty and her character. Reportedly due to tensions with co-star, Alyssa Milano, Doherty was again written out of a hit show early in its run. After first contemplating recasting the role of Prue even approaching Doherty's 90210 replacement Tiffani Thissen it was decided that the character would be killed off and a long-lost sister would take her place in the show. Prues death comes at the end of the third season when shes thrown through a wall by a rather a lame looking demon named Shax. The next season picks up with the confirmation of Prues passing and her sisters have to plan her funeral. The power of three is soon restored however, after the discovery of a fourth sister, and Dohertys replacement Paige Matthews. After three years of battling demonic villains, this was it? I get that she couldnt be shipped off to London like Brenda, but Prue being killed by a wall simply didnt cut it.
9. Chef - South Park
If ever there was a show that would give a character an inglorious death, it would be South Park. For the majority of the early years of the series, Stan, Kyle, Kenny and Cartman would go to Chef for advice, which they would likely receive in the form of song. Voiced by soul legend Isaac Hayes, the character served as a mentor of sorts to the kids, and considering the degenerate idiots he was dealing with it's fair to say he never really had a chance of making a difference. Aided by a short production time and a fast turnover of episodes, South Park is always able to keep the controversy meter topped up by commenting on hot-button topics in double-quick time. One of these hot topics was Scientology, a religion which Hayes followed. Lampooning anything religion included had long been a staple of the series, but the episode "Trapped In The Closet" proved to be a step too far for Isaac Hayes. It took aim at both the religion itself, as well a number of its most famous followers, including John Travolta and perhaps most notably Tom Cruise. Despite his involvement in other religion criticising episodes, this depiction of Scientology was apparently a deal breaker for Hayes, who decided to quit the show. The creators of the series, Trey Parker and Matt Stone were then faced with the task of creating an exit for the character of Chef, and if there's one thing that South Park doesn't do its dignity. Chef was leaving and it wasn't going to be pretty. The exit occurred in an episode named "Return of Chef", with Chef's lines provided by recordings of Hayes which were edited together to give the impression of a new recording something the show acknowledged within the episode itself. The story sees Chef brainwashed into being a child molester by a 'fruity little club' (read: Parker and Stone's opinions on Hayes and Scientology) before suffering a brutal death. Just to show you how brutal, he's struck by lightning, falls from a great height, and then ripped apart by a bear and a lion. He soon returns in the form of Darth Chef, complete with a new voice. The character hasn't appeared since and considering Isaac Hayes death in 2008, it's unlikely that he ever will.
8. Danny Sorenson - NYPD Blue
Poor old Andy Sipowicz didn't have the best of luck with partners did he? First there was John Kelly played by David Caruso essentially Horatio Kane without the sunglasses who was forced into retirement early in the second season. Then there was Bobby Simone, probably Andy's most notable partner the two of them went through a great deal together including marriages, births and deaths of children. One of the most heart-breaking episodes in the shows history saw Bobby suffer a tragic death due to complications related to surgery. Understandably Andy was devastated by the loss of his partner and best friend, but the show must go on and as such he required a new companion. Next up was Danny Sorenson, played by former child star Ricky Schroder. Danny was a different kind of partner for Sipowicz he was young and hot headed, whereas Kelly and Simone were usually the calmer member of the team. He had his issues but was good at his job, which is how he managed to win over a Sipowicz who was still struggling to get over the death of Bobby. In time the two came to form an understanding, Danny wasn't taking Bobby's place in Andy's life, but like him had Sipowiczs back, who returned the favour. Though I believe the majority of viewers still missed Jimmy Smits's character, it is impressive how well the writers incorporated Danny into the show. Soon enough however, Andy would once again require a new partner. After three seasons on the show Schroder's time as an enforcer of the law was coming to an end, so once again a story was required to facilitate an important characters exit. So would it be something in vain of the tragedy of Bobby or perhaps more in the line of the explosive mob related exit of John Kelly? Nope, not even close. The eighth season ends with Danny involved in some rather nasty business with a stripper, we never see Rick Schroder again. In season 9 Danny's dead body is discovered, rolled up in a carpet, having been killed during his off screen investigation. His murder is solved and Andy buries a second partner. Not to worry though because John Clark, Jr. or Zack from Saved by the Bell arrives to reset the status quo, and unlike his predecessors he managed to stick around until the show reached its conclusion.
7. Mr. Eko - Lost
This one still hurts a little bit. Introduced in the second season as one of the survivors from the tail section, Mr. Eko quickly became not only the most interesting character from that group, but one of the most interesting in the overall show. Bernard was a supporting character and it was nice to see him on occasion, but occasional appearances was all he was ever going to make and if you watched the show you are well aware of what happened to Anna Lucia and Libby. It was brutal; some say awful and other say awesome but no matter what camp you fall into you were probably happy that it wasn't Eko. Though he entered the series as a rather quiet man, we soon came to learn that the apparent priest was hiding a dark and violent past. It was hardly a surprise that there was more than meets the eye when it came to Mr. Eko, but personally I wasn't expecting him to have been such a bad person in his life before the crash. In order to spare his little brother, the young Eko killed a man as ordered by a group of guerrillas in his native Nigeria. Due to his recruitment into the group he grew up to be a vicious drug baron, whilst Yemi his young brother became a priest. His decision as a boy to sacrifice his innocence for his brothers is what eventually killed Yemi, as he was gunned down after Eko forced him into one of his criminal plots. He soon took Yemi's place as a priest, before taking a seat on Oceanic flight 815. Though most of us would probably jump at the chance to live in Hawii, seemingly it's not for everyone Eko's portrayer Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje asked to be written off the series. The actor's desire to leave the show led to an abrupt exit for his character. Mr. Eko met his maker in the form of the smoke monster, who brutally mauled the faux-priest. The most frustrating thing about this exit was the fact that there was clearly so much more story to tell, so many places for the character to go. Instead he was bashed against some trees and it was all over.
6. Jonny Keogh - Two Pints Of Lager And A Packet Of Crisps
Well this is clearly the most obscure entry on the list. Two Pints was a BBC sitcom that had a ludicrously long nine series run, by the end of which the majority of the main cast had left. To put it bluntly Two Pints was not high quality television, at least in my case it was one of those shows you watch as a teenager and years later wonder what in the hell you ever saw in it. Will Mellor had been a soap star prior to getting his role in the series, but the most recognisable face was probably that of Ralph Little, who had not long finished portraying Antony Royle in fellow BBC sitcom The Royle Family upon taking the role of Jonny Keogh. The show revolved around Jonny, his love interest Janet and their friends Louise, Donna and Mellor's character Gaz.It seemed to run out of steam after a few series but remarkably it continued for a number of years, but it would soon do so without Jonny. Ralph Little decided to leave the show after the sixth series and it was decided that his departure would mean the death of Jonny. Seemingly the writers were fans of Happy Days, because much in the way Fonzy literally jumped the shark, we hear that off screen Jonny had attempted to do the same, only to fail and be eaten by it. It was half-arsed, but then again, I guess that was probably the point.5. David Hale - Sons Of Anarchy
If anyone on this list deserved an inglorious death, it was Hale. As far as I'm concerned the guy quickly became one of the most pointless characters in Sons. The original concept made sense while Wayne Unser was under the thumb of SamCro, Hale was the straight cop determined to bring down the gang that dirtied the streets of Charming. Though Unser and some of his fellow officers at the Charming PD considered SamCro an unfortunate necessity, Hale thought of them as nothing more than a criminal nuisance and a stepping stone for his own career, a step which would see him take the job of the corrupt chief. Slowly however this integrity began to slip away, and we saw Hale begin to cut Jax and the rest of the sons more and more slack. This left me wondering something if he gave up on his most fundamental driving character point, just what in the hell he was in the show for anyway? I get the whole shades of grey characterisation and all that, but if we already have Unser in the Sons' pocket, it seemed utterly pointless that we have the second highest ranking member of the local police force in bed with them as well, especially as he was the only law-abiding member of the cast. This is why I wasn't particularly sad to see him go, but still I didnt see it coming when it actually did. The characters portrayer had decided that he wanted to move on to another project, so it was decided to kill him off. Despite the fact that David was the Deputy Chief of the Charming PD, when it came time for him to spring into action in the opening episode of season three, he seemed to forget the most basic of training. Whilst he and several cops are providing security at Half-Sack's funeral, it comes under attack from a group in a van. Rather than taking cover and directing his officers, Hale decided to stand right in the path of the oncoming vehicle and is mowed down. So I guess if you decide to leave Sons of Anarchy of you own volition, you certainly aren't going to be doing it in style.
4. Charlie Harper - Two And A Half Men
I'd be lying if I claimed to have ever been a fan of this show. From the episodes I have seen, I found it was neither the sin against comedy that some describe it as nor a standout series worthy of the ratings and longevity that it's received. Whatever your opinion there is no denying that the show was successful, probably down to the charisma that was demonstrated by Charlie Sheen. Its hard to deny that Charlie has that star quality that makes you want to watch him; he is an interesting guy, both on the screen and off it. When you're the lead of a sitcom that star quality is a great thing to have, but as Charlie soon discovered, when your real life begins to become more controversial than that of a fictional character it's perhaps time to stand back and revaluate some things. After nine seasons of being the star of what is undeniably one of the most successful shows on television, the lifestyle of Charlie Sheen began to cause serious problems for the CBS series. After entering rehab several times costing Sheen himself and the network a lot of money as a result Sheen's heavy criticism of both the network and creator Chuck Lorre was the straw that finally broke the camels back. Charlie Sheen was fired from Two and a Half Men and the producers made the decision to kill Charlie Harper off. As the Ashton Kutcher era began the audience learns that Charlie Harper had died, after being struck by a train in Paris. If this rather violent death wasn't punishment enough, it is also implied that Charlie's was actually murdered by his crazy ex-neighbour Rose, having proposed and then cheated on her. Life goes on for the real Charlie, who after getting through his "winning" and tiger blood phase landed a new show on FX. Two and a Half Men also continued despite the fact that the show's name now makes virtually no sense whatsoever.
3. Jason Teague - Smallville
Well heres one entry we should all be happy about. The fourth season of Smallville is probably the last the show had in its original concept. After this season the comic books began to have a greater influence on the show as it shifted to a full on superhero show rather than the teen drama of the first half of its run. Of course nothing says teen drama like a high school love triangle, and that's exactly what we got. With Clark and Lana in splitsville again, the girl next door needed a new love interest. Whitney- Lana's Flash Thompson-was long gone and it was too soon for Lex to be stabbing Clark in the back, so a new character was created and that was Jason Teague. Played by the now CW stalwart Jensen Ackles, Jason like Lex was slightly older than the teen leads and having met her in Paris, came to Smallville to embark on a relationship with Lana. Of course the union was rather creepy considering the fact that Jason took a job as a football coach at Lana's school, but hey, teen drama right? If this less-than-sound level of decision making wasn't enough to make the viewer question the man's credentials, we were soon given a better reason to, as we learnt that Jason had other even the less noble reasons for being in Smallville. He was under the thumb of his mother and to cut a long story short, he kills a woman, steals some stones and ends the season pointing a gun at the Kents as the farm is struck by a meteor. In the next season we learn that Jason was killed as a result of this act of god, and after a season of build-up, he is quickly forgotten. Lets face it though it was probably for the best. Smallville was going in another direction, more comic book villains were coming and Lex was beginning to resemble his comic incarnation. Plus Ackles left to star in Supernatural, so everyone's a winner.
2. Jadzia Dax - Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
DS9 was the different Star Trek. It was probably the most un-Rodenberry like series of them all, meaning that its tone and storylines strayed from the vision of the franchise's creator. Despite this the series holds a special place in the hearts of many, with some even considering it to be the best Star Trek show of all. Though I would reserve this honour for TNG, I too greatly enjoyed the series and was happy that it was different and stood out from the rest. A big reason for this was the cast, which itself was a departure from those under the charge of Captain's Kirk and Picard. We had Sisko, Odo and Quark among others, one of which was Jadzia Dax, the DS9 science officer. Jadzia was a Trill who shared her life with the symbiotic Dax, who had already lived several lives by the time of the joining with Jadzia. The Dax character was an interesting concept Jadzia shared the memories of Dax and as such was wise beyond her years. She also held a bond with several characters from its past, including Sisko who dubbed her old man, in reference to its former life as Curzon Dax. Terry Farrell decided to leave her role as Dax in favour of the then in development Becker, so Jadzia was to be killed off, bear in mind that its Jadzia that died and not Dax as the character was murdered by the series primary antagonist Gul Dukat in the finale of the sixth season. Once again one of Worf's relationships came to a sudden end and to add salt to the wounds, Jadzias place was soon taken by a lookalike. I understand that it's the nature of the Trill to move to another host, but could the producers not have found someone who was a more obvious departure? It seemed more like we had a fake Jadzia for the final season, rather than a new Dax.
1. The Sixth Doctor - Doctor Who
So here we are, bathing in the afterglow of the fiftieth anniversary of Doctor Who, the crown jewel of the BBC and one of the biggest shows on television. But sadly it wasn't always this way there are a number of reasons that people of my generation didn't grow up with the show and this is one of the biggest. By the time Colin Baker took over the role of the worlds favourite Time Lord, the show was beginning to grow stale creatively its height during the long tenure of Tom Baker was well and truly over, the audience was beginning to shrink and high-powered executives at the BBC saw the chance to rid themselves of a series that they weren't particularly fond of. That is probably a concept that those of us who started with the modern Who will probably struggle to grasp, because as of this moment the series is a phenomenal success which begs the question of why the BBC would allow it to swing in the wilderness for as long as it did. However, the eighties were a different time (obviously) and science fiction wasn't exactly a respected genre of television in Britain. Plus, with ratings dropping it was getting easier to justify the end of Doctor Who. Colin Baker had perhaps the slightly easier task of following the guy that followed the iconic fourth Doctor, but the behind-the-scenes turmoil coupled with the rather dodgy writing of his era effectively screwed the guy over. Colin Baker was essentially forced out of the role by Michael Grade the then-controller of BBC One who for some reason decided that he didn't want the actor in the role anymore. So a new Doctor was selected in Sylvester McCoy, and the show was left with the small matter of a regeneration scene. Unsurprisingly, Baker didn't want to return to film the scene, so it had to be done without him. In what may well be the lamest regeneration of all, we see the Sixth Doctor clearly played by McCoy in a bad wig on the ground after a typically dodgy 80s CGI sequence. Then we see the wigged McCoy fade away as reappears and becomes the seventh Doctor. I would love to go on more about the exit, but that really is it. I know a lot of fans are upset that Christopher Eccleston didn't come back to film the War Doctor regeneration, but surely it isn't as bad as Colin Bakers departure is it?