10 Insane Doctor Who Episodes That Went Unmade

Doctor Who vs the Nazis, arcade games and... Derek Acorah?

The BBC's premiere sci-fi kids show (which neither kids nor adults can understand) has featured some kooky premises during its time. Like tiny monsters made of excess fat, Bertie Bassett as a supposedly terrifying villain, and the end of that Peter Kay episode where that woman got turned into a paving slab but still had a sex life. Shudder. It seems like nothing's off limits to Doctor Who, a series which has often swung violently between huge, sweeping epics that take in lofty concepts like war, life, death, and the place of humanity in the galaxy...and stories about farting aliens. Which makes you wonder: if those are the scripts that make it to screen, what do they reject? Considering sentient evil mannequins and monosyllabic tin-foil robots have found themselves amongst the most iconic and hiding-behind-the-sofa terrifying villains in Doctor Who, what kind of out-there ideas never made it into the show? There's a surprisingly long laundry list of unmade Who scripts, some of which lived on regardless. Some were worked into other, produced episodes. Some were adapted into novels of Big Finish audio dramas. Others still were so weird, so beyond the pale, so bonkers that even those weren't viable options. From teleporting Nazis to a guest appearance on Most Haunted, here are ten insane Doctor Who episodes that went unmade.

10. The First Doctor Vs Teleporting Nazis

Even before Matt Smith's €œLet's Kill Hitler€ jaunt (which sadly didn't live up to the early promise of its title), Doctor Who attracted a surprising amount of Nazi-themed scripts. In 1966 Brian Hayles literally wrote one just called €œThe Nazis€, which ended up being rejected for the prosaic but understandable reason of hitting too close to home. Far more thrilling was the proposed Patrick Troughton serial €œOperation Werewolf€, where the Second Doctor arrived at D-Day just in time to stop the Nazis from using teleporation technology to interrupt the Normandy landings. As if the real-life story wasn't weird enough, right? Only one script was written, with other episode titles including €œChateau Of Death€ and €œLair Of The Werewolf€, suggesting The Doctor would come up against some Grindhouse-type villains along the way. Who wouldn't want to see The Doctor, Jamie and Victoria trying to shut down a Third Reich fourth-dimensional transportation machine, eh?

9. The One With Samurai Insect Aliens

Nowadays Ben Aaronovitch is best known as the author of the Rivers Of London novels, following a secret division of the London Met police force who deal with supernatural and otherworldly threats. Before all that, though, the author cut his teeth as a scriptwriter on Doctor Who €“ mostly during the dark, later years prior to its cancellation. Sylvester McCoy's Seventh Doctor heralded a final strike for Doctor Who, with the series finally having the long-threatened axe brought down upon its head. The shift to a comical, pantomime approach didn't help. Neither did ignoring legitimately awesome-sounding ideas like Aaronovitch's €œEarth Aid€, about a race of samurai insectoid aliens. The serial would have seen The Doctor meeting the Metatraxi, an extraterrestrial race who live by a strict code of honour and find themselves in a bit of a pickle when they meet the Time Lord €“ they don't believe in fighting unarmed enemies, after all. Reportedly, the story would also have concerned the politics of humanitarian aid. But of course.

8. Infertile Aliens Kidnap Greek Women

Doctor Who has always leaned heavily on the €œTime€ rather than €œSpace€ parts of the TARDIS's capabilities, mainly because it meant they could reuse old sets from costume dramas of the sort the BBC adores so. Often the fun comes from putting an alternate history twist on a familiar time period or event €“ as was so with €œUnderworld€. Written by Barbara Clegg for Peter Davison's third year on the show, the episode involved the Fifth Doctor in Ancient Greece. Investigating reports of young women being abducted by black tentacles sprouting from the ground, The Doctor takes a trip down the mythical River Styx and discovers a hidden alien race called the Hadeans. Like Hades, get it? It transpires that the reason these aliens have been kidnapping all of the women of a certain age in Greece is because the female Hadeans are infertile. So, um, they need them to carry on their species. Thankfully, The Doctor offers advice on genetics. Can't think what didn't make for suitable tea-time telly there...

7. The One Where The Doctor Appears On Most Haunted

Besides frequently boring sets and costumes from other shows, Doctor Who has often crossed over with its fellow TV programmes. There was the Children In Need special where Five Doctors wound up in Albert Square from EastEnders, the Tom Baker-era episode with John Cleese as a gallery owner, and there's been parodies everywhere. Things nearly went full meta during the Tenth Doctor's reign, with David Tennant's Time Lord appearing on an episode of Most Haunted. Yes, the reality show dedicated to people screaming at creaky doors in night vision, and medium Derek Acorah coincidentally only ever managing to channel Scouse ghosts. €œCentury House€ by Tom MacRae would have had Martha Jones watching the show at home as a framing device, whilst The Doctor dragged the ghost hunting show off track to a house haunted by the €œRed Widow€. A light, comedic episode, they never found room for it (even adapting it to include Catherine Tate's Donna), and so it went unmade.

6. A Blackpool Arcade Comes To Life

Whilst it was the Sylvester McCoy era that put the final nail in the coffin, Colin Baker's spell as the Sixth Doctor didn't exactly help matters. The ornery actor made for a grumpy, arch Time Lord that suffered no fools (or anybody else for that matter). Still, he might've found time for a bit of fun if the season 23 episode €œThe Nightmare Fair.€ If it had actually been made, anyway. Graham Williams's two-part script was later adapted to both a novelisation in 1989 and a couple of audio plays as well. All versions involve The Doctor's old immortal adversary the Celestial Toymaker bringing the TARDIS to...Blackpool Pleasure Beach, not exactly one of the show's most glamorous locations. As if that wasn't kitschy enough, the Toymaker's ploy involved trapping The Doctor and companion Peri in a video game arcade. Their major obstacle? The characters from those arcade games coming to life and attacking them, like a reverse-TRON situation. It might have worked, but probably not with the sort of special effects budget old Who had.

5. The Doctor's Assistant Inspires A Sexual Revolution

€œThe Prison In Space€ by Dick Sharples, otherwise known as €œThe Amazons€, is one of the few unmade Doctor Who scripts that would actually still work today. And it was written in 1968, for Patrick Troughton's third season as the Second Doctor. The episode started off on a planet ruled by women, instead of men. Sadly not called Planet Misandry. The concept was previously floated with the First Doctor's €œThe Hidden Planet€, but Sharples actually went all-in with the concept. During their time on the €œfemale-dominated planet€ companion Zoe inspired a sexual revolution before being brainwashed, whilst fellow partner Jamie experimented with dressing in women's clothing. Sadly, the climax of the episode was planned to be far less radical €“ namely, with The Doctor deprogramming Zoe's mind control by spanking her. Ew. Changes in the cast kept pushing production of the script back, and Sharples refused to rewrite it, so eventually a disgruntled crew opted to drop it completely.

4. The Home Counties In Space

For most hardcore, old school Whovians, the show never got better than Tom Baker's run as the Fourth Doctor. That's not to suggest it wasn't without its qualitative valleys as well as peaks, with the actor's singularly eccentric, Jelly Baby-scoffing Time Lord being as good a fit for serious moments of acting as he was for utterly ridiculous serials of whimsy. Case in point: John Lucarotti's €œThe Ark In Space€, with the former Moonbase 3 writer drafted in to replace another rejected script called €œSpace Station€. The four-part storyline for Doctor Who's twelfth season would have been a cheap-o one that reused sets from €œRevenge Of The Cyberman€, which Lucarotti perhaps didn't take into account. Because, in that writer's mind, the most intriguing idea for a space station episode was for the station in question to be a huge plot of countryside the size of Kent, a €œHome Counties beyond the stars€. His six-part serial was deemed to ambitious, with the main enemy being some sentient fungus taking over the idyllic pastures. Properly bizarre.

3. The First Time The Doctor And Tom Baker Teamed Up

It's a well-known fact that Douglas Adams, creator of Hitchiker's Guide To The Galaxy, got his sci-fi start as a script editor for Doctor Who. It's also reasonably well-known that ideas and plots for books in that series and Dirk Gently came from rejected scripts by Adams himself, who pushed for the show to get even weirder, funnier and post-modern. In that vein, the writer searched far and wide for potential screenplays that were totally different to their usual sort, even going so far as to €“ gasp €“ attend a sci-fi convention! It's there that he met Starbust movie critic John Bronsan, who pitched an idea that would have thoroughly demolished what was left of Doctor Who's fourth wall. The Fourth Doctor story would have involved the Time Lord finding himself at modern-day BBC Television Centre, where he met none other than Tom Baker, playing himself. So, he would've played two roles? Just imagine the bad special effects they would've used for that, as the pair battle against an unknown alien threat. Could it get any more meta?

2. The One With The Gladiator Cats

Believe it or not, it took until the fourteenth series of Doctor Who for the Time Lord's home planet of Gallifery to make an on-screen appearance. Almost every iteration of The Doctor had talked about the place, but after the success of the serial €œThe Deadly Assassin€, producer Graham Williams was eager to return to the setting once more. Which is how he commissioned David Weir's six-part serial €œKillers Of Dark€, sometimes called €œKillers In The Dark€, or the far more literal €œThe Killer Cats Of Geng Singh€. Whatever it was to be called, the story was planned as the grand finale of season fifteen. Except it soon became clear the show's meagre budget couldn't manage it. That's because Weir's script drew on Asian history whilst crafting a story about Gallifrey's forgotten race of cat people. Yes, cat people. Including a major action sequence where the cat people fought in a gladiatorial arena, presumably with a ball of yarn as the prize. The script called for €œcrowd scenes in Wembley Stadium, 96,000 human shaped cat-people.€

1. The Christmas Special With JK Rowling

Oh yes, Doctor Who managed to get plenty more meta than that rejected John Bronsan story. The Christmas specials have become a major part of the revived series, racking up some of the most-viewed episodes in the history of the show and enticing in celebrity guests stars from David Morrisey to Kylie Minogue. And JK Rowling. At least, that was the hope. An untitled script penned for the 2008 Christmas special was set to star the Harry Potter author. The story involved an alien being attaching itself to Rowling's brain and making anything she dreamt up reality, meaning The Doctor had to fight through a world full of witches, wizards, and other non-copyrighted characters. Showrunner Russel T Davies planned the episode as a gift to young fans of the show, but it was eventually scuppered by David Tennant thinking was too silly (Davies had worried that it was €œeither brilliant or more like a Blue Peter crossover€). Rowling had previously been invited to write an episode, and declined, so who knows if she'd even agreed to star?

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/