10 Most Underrated Buffy The Vampier Slayer Episodes

Gems lost amongst the classics...

Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Buffy the Vampire Slayer is a cultural phenomenon and a widely beloved TV show. It's a series full of some truly breathtaking and in some cases revolutionary episodes of television. Sure, there have been some duds, but for every "Doublemeat Palace", "First Date" and "Go Fish" there's a "Passion", a "Hush" and a "Fool for Love." The duds are often fun, that can't be denied, but they're not Buffy at its best.

But what about the episodes that rarely enter the conversation of Buffy greats? This list will focus on those lost gems, from the far too hated to the tragically overlooked. Be them episodes which added much needed layers to some of our favourite characters and the overarching story, or episodes overshadowed by the events and arcs that surrounded it, every season will have a chance (or two) to shine.

Because after 144 episodes, and being off air for sixteen years, means rather inevitably that some episodes have been forgotten or dismissed to fast. And once you've read the list, why not re-visit the episodes featured? Major spoiler ahead, but enjoy.

10. Nightmares

buffy the vampire slayer
Warner Bros.

At its surface, Season One's “Nightmares” is a typical monster-of-the-week episode: a boy in a coma who makes people’s nightmares come true, and a demon trying to stop Buffy from uncovering a morbid truth. But each character gets a chance to shine. More than that, they get the chance to go face-to-face with what they fear most.

In many ways, this episode is an early example of what was to come, and how good the show and the characters were going to be. It also showed that the gang were the core of the show, and it wasn’t all doom and monsters and vampires.

Key moments such as Xander taking on a killer clown, Willow getting stage fright, Giles imagining Buffy is dead and Buffy herself imagining she's a vampire and also responsible for her parents’ divorce. All these great dives into the characters makes this an episode well worth re-visiting.

It also gets bonus points for Xander confronting his old birthday clown: “Your balloon animals were pathetic. Everyone can make a giraffe.”


9. Lie To Me

Buffy the vampire slayer
Warner Bros.

This Season Two vehicle gives fans the chance to see just how complicated and dark Buffy's life has become. Her old school friend Ford has come to town and the pair reconnect. Unknown to Buffy, Ford is dying and wants to become a vampire to save himself.

Angel is suspicious of Ford, however, at first appearing like a jealous boyfriend until it becomes clear to audiences that Ford is hiding something pretty major. Whilst this should be the crowning moment of the episode, "Lie to Me" allows audiences to have a deeper look at the world Buffy inhabits, as Angel, Xander and Willow come face to face with a vampire-worshipping cult in the city's underground.

This sub-plot introduces fans to Chantarelle/Lily/Anne, whose arc extends into Angel and is one of the best, most subtle parts of both shows.

When Ford finally reveals himself to Buffy, it's a genuinely affecting moment and forces Buffy to make a devastating decision. The acting and the writing is great, considering it begins with a classic high school vibe and ends as a look at the true extent of human evil. It also gives Giles the chance to give a bleak speech about the ways of the world and that the good guys don't always win. It's riveting if heavy stuff that's well worth checking out.


8. I Only Have Eyes For You

Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Warner Bros.

Another Season Two addition, this is one of Buffy's most emotional outings, as it gives fans a chance to see Angel and Buffy together again. You know, only possessed.

This episode is excellent. For the last few episodes Angel has been Angelus – soulless, evil and calculating. But after the ghosts of a tragic murder begin possessing people and forcing them to recreate the heart-wrenching lead up and the murder itself, Buffy and Angel have a chance to talk to one another like lovers.

It’s brutal and moving. The acting is exquisite and watching Buffy and Angel pour their hearts out, saying all the things they want to say but can’t, is brilliant. The actual death being recreated is in itself very shocking and heart-breaking, and adds to the gravitas of Buffy and Angel’s brief reunion, which you can’t help but notice on re-watches is a foreshadowing of the inevitable end to the Angelus storyline.

Also, future Oscar nominee John Hawkes turns up, which is cool.


7. Earshot

“Earshot” is an emotional rollercoaster and a clear example of the power of television. It’s an almost revolutionary piece of TV, funny and bleak.

Buffy gets infected with the blood of a demon after a skirmish and develops the ability to read minds. At first, this is brilliantly funny, exactly what you would expect from the show. Buffy starts doing well in class; learns of Xander’s frequent thoughts on sex; and tries to get inside Angel’s head (but can’t, because he’s a vampire). Oz and Cordelia also shine, as philosophical and typically forward, respectively.

But things get out of hand fast and the stakes go from funny to bleak in only a couple of scenes. The voices become too much for Buffy and someone threatens to kill the students at school. Comedy is replaced with a thriller, which in turn becomes an assessment of teenage depression when Buffy saves Jonathan from killing people, only to find he was going to kill himself.

The themes at the time were controversial and the episode was postponed following the Columbine Massacre, but at its core this episode is so much more than a school shooting situation with a sprinkle of telepathy.

This is powerful and harsh, but even today speaks volumes about growing up.


6. A New Man

Buffy the vampire slayer
Warner Bros.

Often criminally dismissed by fans, "A New Man" is Buffy at its most fun, comical, affecting and light. Giles finds himself out of the loop with the gang; he doesn't know about Riley and the Initiative, and he is generally a bit down about his role in the group now that high school is over and he's no longer an official Watcher.

After getting drunk with old friend turned mortal enemy Ethan Rayne, Giles wakes with a bad hangover and a bad case of having turned into a demon. Seeking Spike's help to find answers as Buffy and the gang hunt him - unaware of who he really is - Giles races against time to fix his problem and not get in anyone's way.

Yes, it's silly in most parts, and Giles and Spike make for a brilliant odd couple, but the ending, where Buffy can tell the demon is Giles by looking into his eyes, is quite sweet. It's an episode designed to remind the audience of just how important Giles is to Buffy and the gang, and he will always in someway be needed.


5. Intervention

Spike buffy
Warner Bros

This might be a controversial pick, one of those episodes anti-Spike supporters cite as proof he was no good for Buffy. But in a lot of ways that’s the point of the episode. Spike is still evil; he may have a chip, and a major crush on the Slayer, but he is still soulless. In “Intervention”, he has Warren Mears (evil but with a soul, we think) to create the hilarious if sick Buffybot for his own…gratification.

This creates a lot of laughs, some of them uncomfortable, and gives fans a chance to see Spike fight with his feelings. But the entire episode is flipped upside down when Glory’s minions kidnap him believing him to the Key, an artefact of power that Glory needs to fulfil her evil plans. Spike is tortured and beaten, but never lets slip who the true Key is.

The ending, as with many Buffy episodes, is affecting, and shows just how much Spike is able to care for Buffy and her sister despite the missing soul. It’s one of many Spike-centric episodes where it is almost impossible not to feel for the bloodsucker.

And outside of the Spike escapades, audiences are also treated to the First Slayer's prophetic (and now crushing) line: "Death is your gift." It's an emotional rollercoaster of an episode, but well worth the time and the pay off.


4. Tabula Rasa

Buffy the vampire slayer
Warner Bros.

Following Buffy’s revelation that she was in heaven and Willow, Xander, Anya and Tara pulled her away from her newfound peace, Willow and Tara find their relationship on the rocks. This is Season Six at its most menacing.

Simply put, Willow is using too much magic and has even resorted to using it on her loved ones to make her own life better. The final nail in the coffin is when she uses a memory spell on Tara so she’ll forget a recent spat. Willow promises to stop using magic but succumbs to her addiction quickly, and her latest spell sees Willow and all her friends forget who they are.

There’s a lot to unpick from such a vast and sweeping episode. It’s funny watching everyone interact without knowing each other; Spike thinks he’s Giles’ son; Willow and Xander think they’re together; Buffy calls herself Joan and Spike takes on the name Randy Giles. But despite this level of classic comedy, the end of the episode is the saddest the series has ever been. Giles and Tara leave; Willow is left alone, addicted to magic and increasingly friendless; Spike and Buffy get together, and though this should lead to rejoice from many fans, it is a sombre revelation.

All of this, played in a montage over Michelle Branch’s song “Goodbye to You”, make this episode an emotionally devastating tour-de-force. Funny, sure, but dark and moving, and it gets bonus points for having a loan shark which is actually a shark.


3. Dead Things

Buffy the vampire slayer
Warner Bros.

This is about as dark and twisted as Buffy ever gets over its seven seasons. The reason for its inclusion in this is simple: Warren Mears. Whilst Season Six’s the Trio are often seen as the weakest Buffyverse villains, save perhaps Season Four’s Adam, there can be no doubt that the ringleader, Warren, is fantastic.

Adam Busch is great in this episode and once more shows that not all evil in the world is supernatural and steeped in mystery. Man is the true villain, and Warren is that evil personified.

Outside of Warren’s descent into rape, murder and insanity, you also have Buffy, believing she’s killed someone and wanting to turn herself in. Enter Spike, who lets himself get pummelled by the Slayer to let out her hate and anger. This episode not only shows how evil people can be, but also how truly broken and warped Buffy herself has become.

The acting is fantastic and the editing of Katrina's "death" is nothing short of genius.


2. Help

Buffy the vampire slayer
Warner Bros.

This Season Seven entry is everything you want from Buffy and more. Buffy has just began a job as the counsellor at the new Sunnydale High School, and one of her first visitors, Cassie, lets slip that she’s going to die soon but she doesn’t know how.

That’s it, in a nutshell. Buffy and her friends are forced to race against the clock and stop Cassie’s death. Although this could have been a classic Buffy monster-of-the-week escapade, writer Rebecca Rand Kirshner and director Rick Rosenthal manage to keep things very straight and simple. Yes, there is a monster, and a group of demon worshipping students, but they are by no means the focus.

The focus, you notice, is actually Cassie herself, one of the show’s most tragic figures. Played beautifully by Azura Skye, Cassie is melancholic, sweet and oddly optimistic in the face of her coming demise. The shock twist at the end of the episode solidifies this as a not-so-typical entry in the Buffy canon, showing viewers how good does not always triumph and showing Buffy and her friends that not everyone can be saved.


1. Lies My Parents Told Me

Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

A late Season Seven episode, this entry is somewhat overshadowed by the episodes surrounding it and the threat of The First Evil. It’s all about conflict - physical, emotional and otherwise. Spike is conflicted by the sinister First Evil, and Buffy, Giles and the gang are desperate to bring him back. But there’s a catch: Principal Robin Wood, a freelance demon hunter, reveals to Giles he is the son of Nikki Wood, a Slayer whom Spike murdered in the 70s.

Wanting revenge, Wood lures Spike into a trap and attempts to kill him whilst Giles, who believes the vampire to be a threat to their success, tries to stall Buffy.

Within this episode the writers manage to open the door to even more of Spike’s backstory, helping fans understand what happened after he was sired by Drusilla and how his relationship with his ailing mother was changed after he returned to her. It’s always sad to see Spike’s past; he was once so innocent. But watching him kill his own mother is the hardest thing to watch in his journey.

Of course, Wood's plan fails and he inadvertently saves Spike from The First. It's peak Buffy, but an episode nonetheless lost in a show full of peaks.


Watch Next


Buffy The Vampire Slayer Quiz: Who Killed Who?

Luke Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

1. Luke

Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/