10 Radical Ideas To Save Arrow
Can DC/The CW's flagship superhero show be rescued from the hole it's fallen into?
Arrow was a bit of an eye-opener when it debuted in October 2012. Darker and more dynamic than anyone expected a Green Arrow adaptation would be, season one of the show still had its ups and downs, but the quality was apparent even as the show found its feet.
Star Stephen Amell was formidably physical in the title role, giving billionaire playboy Oliver Queen a grim, relentless presence, while John Barrowman was wickedly sinister as Merlyn, the villain of the piece. There was a clear debt owed to the Dark Knight Trilogy in the show’s driven, brooding superheroics, the narrative just as grounded in reality.
Season two built on that rewarding early promise to deliver one of the best sophomore seasons ever delivered by a genre show. The storytelling was paced beautifully, the flashback scenes to Oliver’s dark past meshing seamlessly with the action going on in the present day, and Manu Bennett’s antagonist, Slade ‘Deathstroke’ Wilson, was pitch perfect: charismatic, dangerous and utterly terrifying.
So where did it all go wrong? Arrow's third and fourth seasons have seen a marked plunge in quality, with generic fight scenes taking the place of the usual breakneck action, plot sacrificed for melodrama, superfluous flashbacks, and childish, inconsistent characterisation.
And the fanbase has noticed: online engagement has taken on a bitter, angry slant in the last year. With the show’s renewal for a fifth season, can Arrow be dragged out of the doldrums? Naturally it can. Here’s how (and here also be spoilers).
10. Kill The Flashbacks
To begin with, the flashbacks in every episode were vital to the show’s narrative, but that hasn't been the case now for two years.
Interviews with the showrunners, Marc Guggenheim and Wendy Mericle, have revealed that they know that the flashbacks have gotten dull and pointless. They believe that season five will be different, because they’re headed towards an endgame: the flashbacks are getting closer to the point we started out at in the pilot, with a tattered, hobo-haired Oliver being rescued from Lian Yu.
The problem is that they said more or less the same thing last year, and nothing’s changed. Season three's flashbacks told a worthless story over an entire season: a story that could have been told in four episodes.
This year has repeated that mistake and worse (which I'll talk about in a moment). Now we’re told that season five will take us to Russia for the Bratva back story that people were curious about in season one.
And that's the point - we were curious. Back in season one. Four years later, we could care less how Oliver Queen became a captain in the Russian mafia, where he got the ink, how he learned to speak Russian. It’s been a fait accompli for too long now, and hasn’t been mentioned since. He just did; let’s leave it at that.
Enough’s enough. We don’t need the flashbacks anymore. Mericle says “it would be weird” to ditch them completely. Maybe for you, Wendy. The rest of us would be over the moon.
9. Get Rid Of All The Archers
A bow-wielding hooded vigilante materialising to save a crime-torn city and to wreak an unspecified vengeance: that’s how Arrow was introduced to us. When Malcolm Merlyn turned up as the dark archer, the antagonist of season one, it was like Ollie had an even darker mirror image of himself to fight. His defeat of Merlyn in hand to hand combat was a significant personal victory, even if he failed to prevent the evil scheme going ahead.
Fast forward three years to near the end of season four, and it's not special or important that Green Arrow be a bow-wielding vigilante ninja, because practically everyone else is too.
Malcolm’s still around; Nyssa Al-Ghul and the League cropped up again this season, and were the focal point of the whole of season three. Hooded, bow-wielding Arsenal left last season, but Thea took his place (and his costume), even though her dad taught her to fight with a sword, not a bow.
We’ve had Cupid, we’ve had Komodo... how is Green Arrow, the star of the show, supposed to stand out and be a unique little snowflake when there are a whole bunch of hooded archers constantly wandering around Star City flinging arrows at one another?
No more archers. If Nyssa or what’s left of the League crop up again, forget about the bows. If Arsenal returns to Star City, have him live up to his name and use a variety of weapons. Have Speedy be a swordmaster. Portraying Green Arrow as forever battling with or against people with archery gimmicks is just reductive and pointless.
8. Write The Plot For Every Season Before Shooting Begins
This really, really shouldn't be a radical idea. However, the showrunners' recent casual admission that they had no idea who was going to be ‘the body in the grave' when they set up the tease at the beginning of this season indicates a worrying lack of storytelling ability.
Guggenheim and Mericle have admitted that they wrote themselves into a corner, and picked Laurel because they couldn't afford to lose anyone else. You can guarantee that they have no idea what Laurel’s final whispered words to Oliver were either, and will put it off until sometime after next season kicks off. It’s how they ‘work’.
For another horrendous recent example, look at this season again. In the last few episodes, it’s been revealed that Ollie had actually encountered Damien Darhk’s mystical totem years before - yet he doesn't make the connection between the events of his past and the suspiciously similar events of his present. Surely that was the point of the flashback storyline this season: to show that Oliver encountered yesterday something that might help him out today?
Instead, three episodes after they find and filch the thing we get a throwaway line acknowledging that he's seen the idol before. He doesn’t elaborate further, and no one asks, because this line isn’t supposed to open up a new scene of dialogue between characters that fills them in on Oliver’s backstory. It’s a clumsy insert to hide painfully bad plotting errors.
Clearly the season hadn’t been properly sketched out in pre-production, or indeed as it began. They had no idea where the flashbacks were going, or where the main plot was going. This particular gaping hole in the narrative renders the flashback sequences in season four largely irrelevant to the contemporary plot.
These are problems that would be solved if the writing team carefully wrote out narrative beats and arcs for the A-plot and all of the main characters throughout every upcoming season. Novelists do it as a matter of course: why can't these supposedly seasoned writer/producers do likewise?
7. We Don't Need A Big Bad Every Season
There have been so many filler episodes in both season three and season four that Ra's Al Ghul and Damien Darhk’s stories could have been told over half that time, and probably much less, without losing anything. Twenty-three episodes is a long time for a season to meander this badly.
The fact is, filler episodes shouldn't be happening at all in an action-packed superhero show like this. Guggenheim and Mericle should be taking lessons from The Vampire Diaries on the same network. No matter what you might think of the cheesy Twilightesque set-up and the Abercrombie & Fitch cast, each twenty-two episode season of 'TVD' is like a stampeding herd of wild horses: there’s a genuine cliffhanger every single week, and enough non-stop action crammed in to fill two or three seasons in any other show. All killer, no filler.
Contrast that with Arrow’s third and fourth seasons, where the villains present themselves, the heroes front up to oppose them… and then there are long, listless stretches where the villain lies low for no real reason, while the heroes pace around like caged tigers getting melodramatic about it (and, inevitably, about each other).
Why not have the season broken up into arcs, with the main ‘big bad’ taking up the final six or so episodes, but foreshadowed throughout the previous seventeen? Other, lesser villains can be built up to take on double or triple episode arcs, rather than the single episodes they get as filler cannon fodder at the moment.
Anarky, for example, has appeared twice in the fourth season, and both outings have felt rushed. He’s one of Batman’s most interesting villains of the past twenty years, a genius-level terrorist and master criminal, and potentially a major antagonist in and of himself. The character deserves a lot more than he’s been given as a weird sociopathic stalker on Arrow.
6. Invest More In The Fight Scenes
In the first season, before the storytelling began to take on a life of its own, the action was the unique selling point of the show. Remember, this was pre-Daredevil: very rarely had anything like Arrow’s fight scenes been seen on US television before. Here, have a reminder:
Anyone who's watched through to the present day knows that these days those fight scenes are, if not quite a thing of the past, then a rare occurrence. Nowadays the fights are like something out of Buffy: all dodgy wirework, generic combinations and fast cuts to disguise slow, lazy form.
I’m no expert on the technical challenges of blocking, shooting and editing an on-screen scrap - everything I know, I learned from watching Jackie Chan films. But as far as basic storytelling goes, this is a standard that works across the board, from superheroes to pro wrestling to football to chess: no one looks good beating a schmuck.
Season four has cast Oliver Queen and Team Arrow as the schmucks, with bog-standard sociopaths going toe to toe with them: the Demolition Team, crooked cops, Anarky, Cupid, to name but a few. Worse, sometimes one of these third-rate losers has taken on two of Team Arrow at once and held his/her own, or even got the upper hand.
While it’s understandable to want the villain of the week to seem like a decent threat, these guys don’t look like badasses by landing a few on the heroes. Instead, the heroes just look like they've lost their mojo.
More creativity and effort urgently needs to be put back into the fight choreography. If the problem is money, then more needs to be allocated to the action. If your villain of the week is a putz, don't shore up their weaknesses by making the heroes look like schmucks.
5. Start Creating Their Own Rogue's Gallery
DC/Warner have made it very clear to Arrow's producers that the Suicide Squad are off the table from now on because of the upcoming big budget movie. That meant that two major players in Arrow's world needed to be permanently removed to avoid confusion with the (very, very different) big screen iterations of those characters: hence the sudden deaths of both Deadshot and Amanda Waller.
For the same reason, we’re not going to see anyone big from the Superman and Batman mythos in the Arrowverse version of DC continuity. In fact, as more and more movies get greenlit, less and less of the characters from the comics will be available for them to use.
This, of course, causes all kind of problems for DC’s flagship TV shows - but only if they let it. If Arrow isn’t going to get the support it needs from DC/Warner, then it needs to be be its own thing. They’ve already put four years into crafting a Green Arrow adaptation. Perhaps that’s enough.
There's no real reason to keep shoehorning second-string DC villains and supporting cast into every single episode or storyline. Look at John Diggle: the character was invented for the show, and he’s worked like gangbusters on a variety of levels.
No one was gagging to see the Demolition Team on the show, and who really cares about Lady Cop, or Double Down? You’d have to be a massive DC geek to know who these people are in the first place. Everyone else was on Wikipedia in the commercial break trying to figure out who the bloody Bug-Eyed Bandit was. They've adapted the lamest of the lame, and for no good reason.
Arrow needs to create a few of its own antagonists, ones that fit the show properly. As original creations, the CW would have the rights to them forever.
4. Completely Rebuild The Storytelling Machine
Oliver’s relationship with Felicity is the catalyst for the final steps in his three-year journey from murderous vigilante to hero. She’s lightened him up, and given him something else to live for and work towards. But this show’s not called Olicity And The Superfriends.
I understand the idea behind foregrounding their relationship. It’s the narrative principle that conflict creates drama. To begin with, the pairing was very popular: but the problem is that they've replaced the engine that drives Arrow with one from a melodrama, or a romantic comedy.
A romcom is structured in a specific way. You want person A and person B to get together, but you have X amount of time to fill: so obstacles are contrived to keep them separate and unhappy until the last ten minutes. This is a show about superheroes, not a Bridget Jones movie.
The engine that drives a show like this should be based on a far more traditional kind of conflict - the defeat of the bad guys by the good guys. Arrow's spin on that involves the protagonists trying not to become worse than the antagonists: it's a light versus dark thing.
For example, the story of season four’s 'Broken Hearts' wasn’t the return of heartbroken serial killer Cupid to exact vengeance for her lost ‘lovers’, and it should have been - yet the villain played second fiddle to Oliver and Felicity’s recent break-up, the resolution of her plotline based around two heartfelt speeches on the nature of love like the show was a bloody Shakespearean comedy.
Olicity’s issues were front and centre in 'Legends Of Today', too: Oliver was depicted as being so distracted by the problems in their relationship that he dropped the ball and allowed Vandal Savage to murder him and all of his team.
Keep the two of them apart, or get them back together, if you must, but don’t let the show’s driving force and primary narrative become subordinate to the mediocre conflict created by a bumpy relationship. Which brings me to...
3. Dial Felicity Back A Few Notches
Throughout season three and the latter part of season four, Felicity has been allowed to drive the car when it comes to propelling the narrative on Arrow. She's become the co-protagonist of the show with the Green Arrow himself, and the current backlash against her shows what a mistake this was.
If there’s an issue between two people on the show and a tough love speech needs to be made, in comes Smoak with her two cents. If it involves Oliver, she swaps out those two cents for a roll of quarters. Everyone raves about how awesome she is: and even when she's wrong, she's never, ever portrayed that way.
There are all kinds of logical fallacies involved in her insistence that Oliver has to be honest with her at all times. She lied to his face for months when she went behind his back to provide support to Team Arrow after the pair of them ‘retired’ - but she made a cute face, so that was forgiven in seconds.
More than that, though - this is Oliver Queen we’re talking about. She fell in love with an isolated and withdrawn screw-up with more baggage than an airline lost property office. Since the day she met him, all he’s had are secrets.
She knows full well that she still knows next to nothing about those five lost years of his - the places he went, the things he saw and the worse things he did. Breaking it off with Oliver Queen because he kept something from her is like throwing out stilton because it’s got mould on it: yes, of course it does, it always does... and be honest, that’s kind of why you bought it.
Of course, Felicity is not a real person. The fault lies in the writing - and in the performance. Emily Bett Rickards is not a convincing enough dramatic actress to carry all of that contrariness off and still allow her character to remain sympathetic, another reason for the recent backlash.
Felicity needs to transition back into a supporting role on Arrow. If she remains on the show, that is.
2. Stop F*cking With Black Canary!
If, as the showrunners insist on telling us, Laurel is genuinely dead, then can we have the other Canary back, please?
Arrow’s already done the Canary switcheroo before, when the show brought back Laurel’s supposedly dead sister to be the a*s-kicking Canary. As Sara Lance, Caity Lotz had all the chemistry with Stephen Amell that poor Katie Cassidy didn’t. Problem solved, right? No - because then they had Sara killed (temporarily) to make room for Laurel to take on the Canary mantle in tribute to her sister.
Unfortunately, Katie Cassidy never really worked as a superhero: she’s never stopped being endearingly gauche in the costume and clumsy-looking in fight scenes. But killing her? Another Canary bites the dust. And poor Quentin Lance - how many times has he mourned one of his daughters now?
It’s baffling to me that Arrow’s showrunners think that niche, geeky fan service for lesser baddies like the Clock King, the Calculator, Double Down, the Bug-Eyed Bandit or the Demolition Team is something to be pursued every season and at all costs, but that providing fandom with a properly realised version of the legendary Green Arrow/Black Canary team-up is somehow a step too far.
Time to stop messing with a DC comics mainstay, people. Either commit to a Canary-less Arrow completely, with all the fanboy grumbling that this decision entails, or have Sara return to help Team Arrow beat Dahrk in the finale and, guilt-ridden at abandoning the amateur version to be killed, become the proper Black Canary.
Caity Lotz is by far the better Canary, and Legends Of Tomorrow is a rolling ensemble: it doesn't need her. Moreover, it makes perfect storytelling sense: Thea's already proven that Darhk's vampiric powers don't work on things brought back by the Lazarus Pit. Speedy and Sara are the ones who need to kill Darhk, not Oliver.
But either way, we need Arrow to sh*t or get off the pot, and right now. Either bring back the Black Canary, or keep her off the show for good. No more of this halfway house nonsense.
1. Dance With The Girl That Brought You To The Party
Arrow became a success because, on the back of the Dark Knight movies, audiences wanted to see that shadowy ninja/broken protagonist thing happen on television. It’s how the show originally sold itself, and how the first season presented itself.
Today, we have far too much narrative emphasis on doomed romance and soap opera style ‘lessons being learned’. The casual approach to plotting, the foregrounding of the relationship most discussed on social media, the increasingly lazy action scenes, the worthless flashbacks, the inconsistent approach to satisfying comic geekdom… everything mentioned in this article really boils down to one thing. Arrow is no longer the same show that it was in the first and second seasons.
Add to that the unfortunate tendency for Arrow to borrow a goofy vibe from The Flash, and you’ve got a sugar-free, safe, frictionless version of Arrow: one with all the rough edges filed off, desperate to appeal to the largest possible demographic.
The frothy tone of The Flash just doesn’t fit here. A shared universe doesn't mean that the style and the villains need to cross over: there's a reason why different heroes have their own rogues gallery.
Most of the cast are bringing their A-game: frankly, it's embarrassing that such good performances are being lost within such pointless storytelling. Stephen Amell, in particular, has stepped up so far since the first season that he now absolutely nails everything required of him, even in thankless roles with cringeworthy dialogue in nothing episodes.
Arrow needs to return to the glory days of season two, when it was perhaps the best iteration of superhero tropes ever seen on television. It’s alarming how far it’s slipped since then… but there’s still time to dance with the girl that brought it to the party. Who'd let a date like that slip away anyway?
What do you think is needed to save Arrow? Do you think it's in need of saving at all? Let us know in the comments.