10 Things You Learn Rewatching Gilmore Girls
A lot goes by unnoticed when the Gilmore Girls talk so fast.
Even if it's been over ten years since Gilmore Girls ended, the series is still very much treasured and discussed. And thanks to the revival, it has fueled the ambiguity and unanswered questions based around the lives of Lorelai and Rory, such as the mystery of who the father of Rory's unborn child is.
The mother-daughter series is thoroughly rewatchable for its comforting atmosphere, snappy dialogue and gripping drama.
And it's not just the Gilmore family, the show's run provided us with several different supporting characters who were so quirky and unusual. With a strong ensemble flowing throughout each season, it's no wonder we were so hooked on the fictional town of Stars Hollow.
But for such a quaint dramedy series, there are actually plenty of hidden details and moments which go right under your noses until you rewatch the episodes from start to finish. When revisiting Gilmore Girls, you think differently about the storyline, you have a better understanding of the setting and most of all, you see the characters in a completely new perspective.
10. Richard's Least Favourite Food
Emily and Richard clearly have a refined palette because during their Friday night dinners, they only have the most exquisite meals. But there is one food which Richard seems to detest and it isn't something like a pop tart or a takeaway burger - it's fish.
In the episode "Love and War and Snow", whilst Richard and Emily are unusually eating a frozen pizza, Richard remarks that it is actually quite good and better than the salmon that keeps showing up. Later on in season six when Rory takes over the DAR event, he thanks her for not serving the salmon puffs. And then in season seven, after Richard's heart attack, Emily seems to be develop an obsession with fish, to which he repeatedly tells her over and over that he hates it.
Yes, it is a frivolous trait about Richard Gilmore, but it is very cleverly written in as part of his character.
9. Caesar The Chilton Alumni?
This is one for the more eagled-eged fans.
We all know Caeser as the lovely, slightly overbearing chef at Luke's Diner. There isn't much he contributes to the overall storyline of Gilmore Girls, but he's always been a nice background character.
However, he takes 'background character' to another level because in the episode "Rory's Dance", he can be seen at one of the tables just as Tristan and Dean are about to fight. There was a debate over whether he was a student at Chilton or whether his actor, Aris Alvarado, was just playing an extra.
According to Alvarado, Caeser was at the Chilton dance and was not playing another character. Was he actually a student of the school or was he just going as someone's date? And if he did study at Chilton, it then leads to the question of why he attended such a prestigious school to then work a simple diner job in his local town.
It is yet another little mystery brought to you by the town of Stars Hollow.
8. Yale Foreshadowing
During the first three seasons of Gilmore Girls, sometimes referred to as the "Chilton" era, there is a huge build up to Rory working hard in her studies in order to secure a place at Harvard university, the school she's been dreaming of going to since she was four years old. Likewise, her then arch-nemesis Paris has only ever desired attending Harvard.
As we all know, both girls changes their plans to attend Yale instead. Although it was an unexpected twist in the show's storyline, there was a very subtle foreshawdowing in the season one episode "Rory's Birthday Parties".
When Rory attends a college fair, she and Paris happen to bump into each other when looking at the Harvard booth. In the scene, Rory is wearing an argyle sweater, comprised of the colours blue and white. This just so happens to be official colours of Yale university.
Whilst it could be just a sheer coincidence from the costume department, it is at least a nice way of presaging what Rory's future holds.
7. Rory The Anti-Heroine
Arguably, this is a subjective aspect of the series, but it can't be denied that several viewers, even the most die-hard fans, felt disappointed in Rory's characters development across the series when re-visiting the show.
On surface level, Rory is the person we all want to aspire to. She's hardworking, book smart, polite, with a drive to be the best in life. Her lofty goals of going to an elite college and becoming a journalist seems like she'll turn out to be really successful.
But when you re-watch her character, the cracks begin to show. Rory is actually incredibly spoilt, and socially awkward - whilst she is book smart, she lacks any common sense. Whether it was her constant cheating on Dean, not being able to take criticism for her writing, or recklessly stealing a boat, she simply wasn't a very good person.
The revival amplified her faults as she had an affair with an engaged man whilst stringing along her poor boyfriend Paul. Moreover, she struggled to get a journalist role with such little experience, whilst fulling expecting to have any job she could desire.
Creator Amy Sherman-Palladino should be commended for writing Rory's character realistically, and not as a perfect cardboard cut out.
6. Stars Hollow Is (Sadly) Fictional
It would be nice to believe that Stars Hollow is a real place that we could all go visit for coffee and folksy festivals. Sadly, it's all fictional (although it is based on Washington Depot, Conneticut) and the filming set isn't even unique to Gilmore Girls.
You'll notice a lot of the set pieces were used by the producers of Pretty Little Liars for the town of Rosewood. From the white chapel to the central gazebo, all of these well-known Stars Hollow landmarks were reprised for Pretty Little Liars.
Another example of a shared set piece is the exterior of the Dragonfly Inn - it looks familiar because it was also the home of The Waltons. In fact, you probably recognise the set on a lot of other television shows, including Hart of Dixie, Riverdale and The Dukes of Hazzard.
5. Jess Mariano's Spin Off
Towards the very end of season three, there is an episode called Here Comes The Son, which unusually has less focus on the titular characters, and instead looks into the backstory of Jess Mariano and where he originated from.
The reception to this episode was mostly negative because it felt like a big block in the build up to Rory's Chilton graduation. As well, Jess' character plainly wasn't engaging enough to carry the whole episode.
However, the odd shift away from Rory and Lorelai makes a little bit more sense when you realise it is actually an unspoken pilot episode for Jess' very own spin off show. The working title was Windward Circle and the WB had committed to six episodes of the series, but was dropped to due to problems with the filming location in California.
It's hard to say how popular an alternative series about everyone's favourite bad boy would have been, but suffice to say the pilot episode didn't leave a good impression.
4. Art Imitates Art
We've seen characters come and go throughout the Gilmore Girls series and often, the writers like to make references to what the actual actor who played them did next, amid their absence on the show.
For example, Adam Brody who played Lane's boyfriend Dave, left after his first season on the show in order to play Seth in The O.C., which takes place in California.
To explain his departure, Lane claims he went to university in California. Similarly, when Chad Michael Murray (Rory's Chilton classmate, Tristan Dugray) left the show, his exit was explained by the character being sent to military school in North Carolina. That same location is where Chad filmed for roles in Dawson's Creek and later One Tree Hill.
And once more, when the character Brad Langford, played by Adam Wylie, returns to Chilton Academy after several months away from the series, he explains that he was away playing Jack in the Broadway musical Into the Woods. The irony is Wylie quite literally was playing Jack in the revived musical of Into the Woods, during his absence from the show.
3. Where Was Lane's Dad?
A recurring joke throughout the series is how Lane Kim's father is never seen on screen. He has frequently been mentioned, with both Lane and Mrs Kim claiming he is at home or around town, yet no one encounters him.
Even with his contstant absense, it always felt like we'd seen Mr Kim present at least one, perhaps in a very brief blink-and-you'll-miss-it flash. But the truth is Lane's dad is not present ONCE throughout the original series, not even for a second. Even on her wedding day with Zach, he didn't attend.
It makes us wonder what lifestyle Mr Kim led for him to be so private. In an interview, Emily Kuroda (Mrs Kim) and Keiko Agena (Lane) believed he worked in Korea most of the time as a minister and travelled a lot.
The 2016 revival on the show did graze on the mysterious figure as Lane's father is seen for a casual moment, before never appearing again in A Year in the Life.
2. Two Characters, One Actor
Having a cast member play more than one character on Gilmore Girls became a recurring habit over the series.
Alex Borstein was cast as the rude harp player in season one, before later playing the odd stylist of Emily Gilmore. She also played unseen characters, such as the crazy woman on the answering machine.
She is not the only one. Seth McFarlane played Zach at Lorelai's graduation, as well one of Emily's lawyers and on another occasion, an uncredited folk singer. Meanwhile, Marion Ross played Richard's mother Trix and her niece Marilyn (this was probably intentional so that the two beared a resemblance). Additionally, there are other minor examples, such as Lance Barber as Hugo and an Inn guest, and Riki Lindhome as Juliet and a Stars Hollow High student.
Arguably the worst instance of using one actor for two roles was with Sherilyn Fenn, who portrayed both the girlfriend of Jess Mariano's biological father and April Nardini's mother. Whilst they're obviously meant to be two different characters, it was very hard to distinguish them because of the connections they had with the main characters.
Otherwise, the two characters for an one actor habit is mostly a quirkly little staple of the Stars Hollow universe.
1. The Storyline Isn't Really Feasible
As adorable as the Gilmore Girls and their delightful town are, it's all a bit muddled. The story is based around Lorelai getting pregnant at sixteen and fleeing from home to make a life of her own as a single mother.
In Emily in Wonderland, we find out that when Lorelai left her rich parents to raise a child alone, and that she and Rory lived in a small shed just on the back of the Independence Inn. It's a tragic backstory, but it's also hard to believe anyone would let a sixteen year old and their baby live in such poor living conditions.
When Lorelai finally gets a decent home for her and Rory, she is able to maintain a fairly expensive lifestyle of frequent take-outs, business school and frivolous shopping of unnecessary items, all on an innkeeper's salary. It is true that Lorelai has asked Emily for financial help a couple of times over the years, but not enough to cover the cost of her way of life.
And furthermore, Rory's journey through her education makes no sense. How did somewhere as elite as Chilton accept her when she was two months behind in the academic year? How did she achieve valedictorian when Paris got better grades than her? And how did she graduate Yale on time after doing all that community service? Something doesn't add up...
We still love the Gilmore Girls - and always will - but factually, they shouldn't be doing so well in life!
Watch Next
Gilmore Girls Quote Quiz: Which Character Said What?