10 Times Star Trek Didn't Think It Through
Some of these Star Trek moments were awesome on first glance, but when you stop to think about it...
Occasionally Star Trek will introduce an idea so profound it will ripple through the rest of the franchise. Other times, Star Trek will introduce a profound idea immediately forgotten by all concerned.
Listen, opening up the writers' room to submissions has its ups and downs, ok?
In saying that, these ideas can sometimes be enormous in their implications but too enormous to give the requisite time to. Does the franchise want to spend years discussing something that happened in one episode, once?
*cough Tuvix cough*
There are times that something makes it into the script that really did deserve further exploration, only to be dropped from any future mention. Now, there are also other examples - ideas that are inserted into canon that truly strain what has already been established.
Something inserted to one era can have a major impact on another. So, why isn't it mentioned?
Tough luck, huh?
10. Achieving Warp 10
Beginning with The Next Generation, Warp 10 was established as the unachievable limit. We see the Enterprise reach speeds of 9 and above but for short periods. Transwarp was introduced in Star Trek III: The Search For Spock (in Starfleet ships, namely the Excelsior).
Descent introduced transwarp corridors. These would return in Star Trek: Voyager as the primary mode of travel for the Borg. Transwarp still far slower than Warp 10.
In Threshold, the Shuttle Cochrane achieves Warp 10 twice. The episode claims that it inhabits every point in the universe at once. If we allow for a literal dramatic liberty, it's still very fast. Within the episode itself, there are plot shortcuts - if the evolved Paris could take Janeway anywhere, why did he just stop a couple of days away from home?
Having managed to cure Paris and Janeway of their mutations, why were there no efforts to adapt Voyager with this new technology? Or when they reached home, why was their research not immediately spread through Starfleet?
While they may have struggled to master the technology in the 24th Century, might not they have achieved this by the 32nd? This was a case of - fun episode, but never intended to play a larger role in Star Trek's history. Therefore, just like those salamander babies, it was brushed under the carpet and never spoken of again.
9. The Mycelial Network
By the time Star Trek: Discovery was on the air, the audience was well aware of the Beta, Gamma, and Delta quadrants, so restricting this new show to the Alpha quadrant ran the risk of making this new series smaller in scope. The mycelial network became a chance to get the Discovery to places the audience was aware of, but that contemporary starships couldn't hope to reach.
Sending the ship to the future to avoid Control was a handy dramatic plot, but it left some big questions. Classifying Discovery's very existence wasn't possible - too many people knew about it. So, the story that Discovery had been destroyed worked - sort of.
The mycelial network had already been experimented on aboard the USS Glenn. While it went badly there, that was no reason to shutter the project. Discovery proved it was a success. Once the genie is out of the bottle, one cannot put it back in.
Not informing Captain Janeway about said network seems a large oversight. One hundred years later, was it possible that no one had been working on adapting the jump drive for the rest of Starfleet? Is there no Mycelial Directive in place?
With all respect intended - this felt like Star Trek: Discovery wanted a new toy, and that was that.
8. Those New Phaser Rifles
The USS Voyager left Deep Space Nine in 2371, equipped with the new compression phaser rifles that were only seen in Star Trek: Voyager. Equinox revealed that at least two classes of ship - the Nova, along with the Intrepid, had been stocked with them.
In 2373, newer rifles were in circulation, first appearing in Star Trek: First Contact, aboard the Enterprise-E. They quickly made an appearance in Deep Space Nine as well, then also...Voyager.
Macrocosm shows Janeway in her now iconic, Ripley/Sarah Connor-inspired, tank-top and pants, armed with one of the newer phaser rifles. Production staffers joked that Voyager must have had these in storage all along, but this seems unlikely.
In 2371, the Next Generation phaser rifle was standard issue, with Voyager's new compression rifle as the updated tech. Did they leave DS9 with additional updated technology, years before the rest of Starfleet gained access?
Perhaps Star Trek: Prodigy can help explain this one - after all, Ouroboros shows Starfleet struggling with resource sharing. Maybe Voyager really was that lucky ship?
Bit frustrating to immediately lose it in the Badlands then.
7. Curing Death
In Star Trek Into Darkness, Dr McCoy cures death.
When Kirk is killed toward the film's climax, all seems lost. McCoy, spent and upset, collapses into his chair only to then be distracted by Tribble Jesus beginning to move. This divine creature had been the recipient of Khan's blood, which revived it. Inspired, McCoy then calls for Spock to bring Khan in alive.
A few fisticuffs later, Kirk opens his eyes, having been resurrected by McCoy. The doctor jokes that Kirk had only been 'barely' dead, and not another word is said about it.
So, in the Kelvin universe, now that Khan is on ice, is death merely a state like sleep? Can people who are killed in the field get access to a synthetic version of Khan's blood? Does this mean that genetic engineering is completely fine with Starfleet there?
Did anyone care? The entire sequence makes for a nice save in this quasi-remake of The Wrath Of Khan, but one has to wonder how much thought went into the ramifications of McCoy's realisation.
6. Just How Far Away Is Qo'noS Anyway?
This may best be described as an inconsistency in Star Trek, one that applies to Enterprise in particular. The location of the planet Qo'noS, or even the system it's been located in, seems to change depending on the situation.
Broken Bow sees Enterprise arrive in orbit of the planet, dropping off their quarry, the Klingon Klaang. According to Star Trek Into Darkness, Qo'noS is located in the Omega Leonis sector, roughly 112 light-years from Earth. The episode sees Enterprise make that journey in roughly four days.
Zefram Cochrane, in his recorded speech, speaks about how Warp Five engines will revolutionise Starfleet - which is a bold claim, as in his time, Warp Two was the maximum speed. Later, in the episode Two Days And Two Nights, Enterprise visiting Risa was the first time a starship had travelled roughly 90 light years from Earth, despite having been to Qo'noS in the pilot.
This may best be attributed to an inconsistent distance tracker - or a galaxy that's far less constant as the northern star.
5. Kronos One At The Fleet Museum
The official explanation for Kronos One's presence at Starfleet's Fleet Museum is that it was 'on loan' from the Klingon Empire. This feels a bit tongue-in-cheek, and we're on board with that. But that's really think about this.
Kronos One played a pivotal role in the Federation-Klingon peace talks, so its presence for posterity makes sense. It is also not the only foreign vessel on display - the HMS Bounty and a Romulan-Bird-Of-Prey also adorn these space halls. The Bounty was stolen by Admiral Kirk, whereas there is no Romulan Empire left to demand the return of the Bird-Of-Prey - those we can more-or-less understand.
Kronos One was the Klingon flagship. Allowing for Klingons not being particularly sentimental, it was also the site of the assassination of their Chancellor. Putting it on display feels a bit morbid. Retiring it from service makes more sense but loaning it out to Starfleet - for what purpose?
It was wonderful to see the ship on display, but it doesn't make a lot of sense for it to be there. Still, it was great to see the refit NX-01 in the same shot!
4. Brainless
Spock's Brain is an honest, fun hour. Sure, it's been derided in almost every discussion about it since its airing, but was it ever trying to be anything truly great?
The episode was the big premiere after The Original Series had been saved from cancellation and it wasn't exactly the celebration of all things logical. Having Spock's name in the title does not a Search For Spock make.
There's no need to get too deep into it here - Vulcans can live, for a time, without their brains. Alright then. Is it any wonder why this particular medical marvel has never been revisited in Star Trek since then?
Brain? Brain! What is brain?
Certainly nothing on show here.
3. Scotty Hates Women
Wolf In The Fold was written by Robert Bloch, of Psycho fame. It is an atmospheric, scary Original Series outing, one that captures the paranoia and fear of an unknown serial killer. Bloch was no stranger to creating these dark settings but he included a theme that sticks out.
Scotty had been injured in an accident caused by a woman, which causes McCoy to fear he will end up resenting all women.
In the mid-'60s, while psychological understanding of the complexities of our psyche wasn't as developed as they are now, this still feels like a reductive take. If Scotty had cause (which he didn't) to hate all women, wouldn't this immediately end his career on a starship? At least one populated by men and women?
If medical knowledge equated to - 'woman hurt you, so you think woman bad' - then what had humanity been doing in the medical field for two hundred years?
The script is scary, intense, and is still a great episode years later - but this element of the plot simply doesn't hold up to scrutiny. It felt like Bloch simply needed something to put Scotty in the crosshairs.
2. Transwarp Beaming
If perhaps you were wondering why we had mentioned Star Trek Into Darkness specifically when discussing the distance from Earth to Qo'noS, then wonder no more!
Khan beams from Earth to Qo'noS thanks to a transwarp beaming device. How impressive, ok that's fine, we'll just -
Excuse me, what? Khan beamed 112 LIGHT YEARS from Earth? This is, at the very least, one of the greatest scientific advancements in Star Trek's history. At worst, it could make all forms of planetary security obsolete - why send a fleet, when one can simply beam an invasion force onto another world?
Planetary shields for everyone! Welcome to the new age of paranoia and fear - Khan just rendered all fleets useless. With the invention of the transwarp beaming device, there was no longer any need for Warp capable ships - why commit resources to a starship when you can simply step onto a transporter pad on Earth and step off on Vulcan?
As fun as Star Trek Into Darkness is, there are some fairly major questions raised by its inventions. This is a shame - we don't hate this technology at all, we're just bummed it was never developed!
1. The Big Goodbye's Long Goodbye
The Next Generation's first season re-introduced a version of the holodeck after its debut in The Animated Series (as the Rec Room). Captain Picard hit play on his Dixon Hill program, Dr Crusher and Data joined him, as did Mr Whalen - the ship's 20th century historian.
The implications behind The Big Goodbye are far more disturbing than presumably intended. For example, once Wesley and Geordi can open the doors to the holodeck, Redblock and Leech step outside. Despite being holodeck characters, they take a few moments to dematerialize - during which they remain fully aware of what's happening to them.
Inside the holodeck, Officer McNary asks Picard if he, along with his wife and kids, will cease to exist once Picard leaves. This, at the very least, suggests a form of sentience on his part.
Though the episode was crafted as a bit of fish-out-of-water fun, it depicts a horrific half-life for these holograms. Fun?