10 Times Star Trek Hit The Reset Button

Star Trek has never been afraid to shake things up.

Star Trek Nemesis
Paramount

In over fifty years of history, Star Trek has had to rely on re-invention from time to time, much like any long-running story. New series and new casts have helped to keep the ideas that the franchise espouses alive, yet these are not the only changes that have occured within the show.

There are obvious hard reset buttons that involve time travel or paradoxes. Year of Hell, All Good Things and Endgame are all examples of this - stories that are almost self-contained, yet with enough residuals to either be alluded back to later, or have enough groundwork laid to be payoffs in their own right.

But this list is not simply a list of time travel changes that pop up within the show. What are the big changes that the franchise made along the way? Which are the behind the scenes decisions that either benefit Star Trek the most, or detract from the overall quality of the franchise for the sake of doing something flashy?

While this list is not entirely centered on the newer shows that have released in the last few years, there certainly will be a discussion on them as, arguably, Star Trek is currently enjoying its biggest shake-up since the days of James T. Kirk.

But before any of that, wind the clock back.

10. A New Pilot, A New Crew

Star Trek The Original Series Where No Man Has Gone Before
NBC

Star Trek famously stumbled out of the starting gate before it was wrangled back in again for a spot of maintenance. By which we mean a complete overhaul and tone shift, lest the idea die before it had any chance to breathe.

The Cage had all the hallmarks of what Star Trek would become later in the franchise, with its cerebral plot proving too much for an introductory episode. To be fair, there is a lot of sense in this argument. There are many franchises that have lasted for years with pilot episodes that have very little to do with what the show became. The Cage was a mirror of this - but it was a hard sell to the networks.

Where No Man Has Gone Before is much closer to the tone of early Star Trek, with Kirk in his shirt-tearing best in his brawl against the superhuman Gary Mitchell. Spock, the only holdover (bar the ship itself) from The Cage was still present, though was now a cold, unfeeling officer, rather than the more overtly emotional one displayed before.

While Jeffery Hunter's Christopher Pike shares many traits with Kirk, including their love of horseriding and affinity for scantily clad women, Pike was a slower-to-act person, haunted by recent tragedies, whereas Kirk was more of an action hero ready to go. He would later evolve into a character more closely resembling Pike, but this was after the show had been sold.


9. Star Trek Goes To The Movies

Star Trek Motion Picture
Paramount Pictures

With the show cancelled and the animated series failing to continue past a single separated season, Star Trek was dead by the mid-'70s. The convention circuit certainly kept fan interest alive and this in no small way contributed to the return of the franchise. However, much more directly, Trekkies everywhere have George Lucas to thank for the first Star Trek film.

The enormous success of Star Wars earned 20th Century Fox a small continent-sized swimming pool full of money, which left all competitors scrambling to join the space race. Thankfully Paramount had Star Trek in its back pocket.

The success of Star Wars also showed what could be done when properties were given a decent budget and so when Star Trek: The Motion Picture was greenlit, it finally had a production budget that at least partially matched the imaginations of those involved.

The ship was redesigned, the Klingons were redesigned, huge sets were built and expansive special effects scenes were crafted for the movie. Even now, more than forty years later, whether or not Star Trek: The Motion Picture is a fun movie is up for debate (check out the stellar documentary about it on our YouTube channel), but there is no denying that it looked fabulous.

This was both the Original Series as it was meant to be seen, along with an additional decade of experience in how to realize the final frontier.


8. Star Trek: The Spin-Off Series

Star Trek 11
Paramount

This entry encompasses all of the spin-off series up to Enterprise, as it was the very notion of creating spin-off series that again saved Star Trek and spurred it on. The movie franchise had been enjoying several highs along the way, most notably with Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, but by the release of Star Trek V, the series was again in danger of getting stale.

Star Trek: The Next Generation arrived in 1987, drawing both excitement and ire (much like every succeeding show) from the fans and, in fact, from members of the Original Crew. Both George Takei and James Doohan were outspoken in their criticisms of the show, though they eventually softened.

The Next Generation took the cerebral style of the Original Series and ran with it, with Captain Picard vying for the position of greatest Captain in Star Trek. Deep Space Nine would take a different path almost from the beginning, centering the action in one location rather than in the Alpha Quadrant as a whole. Voyager saw Star Trek banished to a distant corner of the galaxy so that it could explore strange new worlds in peace.

Enterprise fell victim to franchise fatigue, even as it attempted to reinvigorate the show. The idea of making a prequel to the Original Series had been bandied about for years, though the audience of the day was not quite as receptive as the showrunners and studio had hoped. When Enterprise was cancelled after the fourth season, Star Trek was, in a word, dead.


7. Star Trek Shakes Off The Ghost Of Roddenberry

Star Trek Deep Space Nine In The Pale Moonlight
CBS Media Ventures

Gene Roddenberry is the creator of Star Trek and one of the key figures for ensuring it ever reached the air waves at all. He, along with a dedicated team of writers and producers, crafted the Star Trek that is so often referred to when people say that the franchise has veered sharply away from it. Star Trek: Deep Space Nine was something that he was aware of, but his ill-health prevented him from seeking any active participation.

One of Roddenberry's golden rules for Star Trek was that the main characters were not to face conflict with each other, as his utopian future would not allow for any such strife. With his influence removed, Michael Pillar and Rick Berman crafted Deep Space Nine to be a show featuring many different viewpoints and beliefs, which only became stronger in their differences when Ira Stephen Behr took over as showrunner.

The first couple of seasons stuck a bit closer to The Next Generation and the Original Series, while from season three onward, Deep Space Nine was the darkest iteration of the franchise. Officers fought with each other, humans betrayed Starfleet, terrorist cells were given legitimacy and many other examples of the cracks in Roddenberry's utopia began to appear.

The Dominion War is possibly the biggest 'upset' in the Star Trek universe, insofar as the impact it had on both storytelling and consequences was nothing that had been seen before. While Majel Barrett held the opinion that Gene would have hated the arc, others claimed that the only thing that prevented a war in the Original Series was the lack of budget.

The war arc defined the latter half of Deep Space Nine, pushing Star Trek into murkier territories than it had before and opening up a Pandora's Box that, for better or worse, has never truly been shut.


6. Star Trek Does 9/11

Star Trek Enterprise Xindi Weapon
CBS Media Ventures

While Star Trek: Voyager is a fantastic show in its own right, introducing some of the most influential characters in the franchise (Captain Janeway, Seven of Nine and The Doctor among them), it didn't do an awful lot to reset the franchise. The aforementioned examples of Year of Hell and Endgame serve to reset their own stories, but not the franchise as a whole.

The same cannot be said of Enterprise. This was the first series to air after the September 11th attacks and the first season was poorly received by audiences. This was a combination of occasionally shoddy and clunky writing, mixed with a wide-eyed wonder that simply wasn't in the air at the time.

It was renewed for a second season and the writers decided to shake things up in a way that had rarely been attempted before. In the closing episode of the second season, an alien weapon arrives from nowhere and cuts a devastating swathe across Earth, killing seven million people.

It was a direct parallel to the 9/11 attacks that equally left people stunned and afraid, completely changing the tone of the show for the third season. It also led to Star Trek's longest experiment with serialised storytelling up to that point, with the third season of Enterprise effectively becoming one long film.

The quality of the show drastically improved but unfortunately the audience numbers didn't. Though it was renewed for a fourth season, it was to be its last.


5. Hot Rod Star Trek

Star Trek 2009 Ship
Spyglass Entertainment

Without a doubt, Star Trek needed something new to save it from fading away into memory as the early '00s went on. While the hardcore fans (myself included) would continue to watch all previous series on repeat for all time, the franchise was less attractive for newcomers, as there was no promise of new material to digest.

Along came J.J. Abrams, fresh from his massive success that was Lost. He was hired to make the next Star Trek film, which audiences quickly discovered was going to be a prequel.

Star Trek did for the franchise what The Motion Picture had done back in 1979. It both breathed a new life into what had, objectively, become a stale franchise, while also honouring everything that had come before. Characters returned, either as major stars or in smaller cameos, and the Kelvin Universe films would become box office smashes in their own right, even if each successive film was a little less successful than its predecessor.

Chris Pine and Zachary Quinto, along with Zoe Saldana, became an instantly likeable trio of heroes to root for. They were younger than their television counterparts and therefore a little easier for new audiences to relate to. The technology on board the Enterprise was updated to reflect more modern innovations, drawing ire from some long-term fans while undoubtedly serving to create a new ship for the times.

Star Trek 2009 was an enormous success, rejuvinating the franchise and winning an entirely new generation of fans, thus ensuring a continued Trek presence for several years to come.


4. Star Trek Goes Back To The Small Screen

Star Trek Discovery
CBS

Venture near the internet and one is sure to find many passionate opinions on Star Trek: Discovery. Since the initial announcement of the new prequel show, there has been a lot of intense debate as to whether or not its good, great or absolutely terrible. That is a question best left to the gods. What it is, however, is a hard left turn in the direction of the franchise.

Much like Star Trek 2009 before it, Discovery served to reinvigorate the franchise, while bringing it back to the location it had always enjoyed the most success: television. While the Star Trek films were certainly popular, it was and remains the television shows that invite the greatest discussion and following.

In a similar way that The Motion Picture did in 1979, Star Trek: Discovery enjoyed a far higher production budget than much of what had come before. Computer technology had also advanced significantly since the days of Matt Jefferies' Enterprise, meaning more could be done with the ships and universe it attempts to depict.

The designs on the show are deliberately different from what came before, making it a new era of Star Trek in an old era of history. This is really a question of personal taste. Gone are the days of the old Constitution class ship, here to stay are the more angular, sharper designs by John Eaves and the rest of the crew behind the camera.

Each season is serialised, character decisions have consequences (most of the time) and the galaxy certainly feels like a more dangerous place (although that may just be the Twitter comments).


3. Star Trek: Nemesis? Thank You, Next

Data Star Trek Picard
CBS Media Ventures

Star Trek: Picard divided fans when it aired in early 2020. Here was a version of Captain Jean-Luc Picard who was jaded with Starfleet, bitter at their failure to step in a save the Romulan people in advance of the Supernova, the one introduced in Star Trek 2009. One thing that the show did very well, as agreed by much of the audience who followed the show, was addressing the anti-climactic ending that Data received in Star Trek: Nemesis.

Data went out in a sudden blaze of glory in Nemesis, though the shock was not matched with an earned feeling of pathos. Added to this, the fact that it was the last cinematic outing of The Next Generation left a sour taste in the mouths of much of the audience.

Star Trek: Picard opens with a dream sequence, in which Picard and Data (featuring a returning, de-aged Brent Spiner) play poker. There is another dream sequence later in the episode, though it is the final scene between the two in the series' ending that sets the story to rights.

In a quiet, emotional scene between the two, Picard and Data manage to muse on the existentialism of death, along with the fact that to appreciate life, one must accept that it ends.

It effectively retcons the death of Data, giving him a beautiful send-off that truly feels earned, rather than a twist ending to shock the audience.


2. Star Trek Succeeds At Animation

Star Trek Lower Decks
CBS

Star Trek: The Animated Series was the franchise's first attempt at bringing the show to a younger audience, targeting the Saturday morning cartoon crowds. While the episodes were still very much in the same vein as the Original Series, the style was not fully embraced by fans at large. While it has aged a little better than one who viewed it in 1973 might believe, it still rarely ranks highly on most countdowns of Star Trek.

Mike McMahon saw this and said no more!

It is hard to quantify just how good Star Trek: Lower Decks is. While it undoubtedly benefited from the low expectations that were a hangover from Trek's earlier animated effort, there was still a lot riding on it as 2020's second new Star Trek series. Frankly, the world needed a laugh. And Lower Decks delivered.

It is a very tongue in cheek veer away from the ultra-serious tones of Star Trek: Picard and Star Trek: Discovery, recapturing some of the episodic magic of The Next Generation, while still cramming enough jokes into every episode to get a belly laugh out of young and older audiences. There are enough references for long-time fans to keep screen-pausers busy for days, as this is a lovingly crafted tribute to Trek.

In a year when positive feeling was sorely needed, Star Trek: Lower Decks took the franchise back to that optimistic tone of earlier years.


1. Star Trek Goes Back To The Beginning (Again)

Star Trek Strange New Worlds
CBS

Star Trek: Discovery's second season was a sharp step up from the dour tone of the first season. While it had been a well-designed show from the beginning, it was sorely lacking in the heart that was a staple part of most of the crews that had come before. Thankfully, the first episode of the second season, Brother, changed all of that with the arrival of Anson Mount and Captain Pike.

Mount is the fourth actor to portray Pike, after Jeffery Hunter, Sean Kenney and Bruce Greenwood, although he already has put his flag firmly in place as, arguably, the best. He brought an adult, caring nature with him (something that had been lacking thanks to the evil Captain Lorca), while experienced enough to keep things light on Starfleet's most downbeat vessel.

The announcement of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds followed a message from Alex Kurtzman, saying that 'the fans have been heard'. This is an extremely important development in the Star Trek franchise. Not only is this a new show, but it is a show born from the wishes of the fan-base. More than that even, it has already been ear-marked as a more optimistic and episodic approach to Star Trek again.

There are those who love Discovery. There are those who love Voyager. There are those who have taken the long road from there to here. Strange New Worlds seems to be a return to the Star Trek of old, offering those who don't love the direction the franchise has taken another outlet. While we are massively optimistic about this - let's hope this entire entry doesn't age badly!


Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"