10 TV Shows That Ruined Other TV Shows
When shows make it tough to watch other shows.
It's often said that comparison is the thief of joy, and believe it or not, that's also true where TV shows are concerned.
It simply isn't enough for some TV shows to just exist and be really bloody great - their mere presence in the pop-culture sphere then has an unavoidable knock-on effect on how similar series are regarded, typically for the worse.
Sometimes a TV show is just so brilliant, so iconic, or so genre-defining, that it makes it tough for those that follow to meet the same standard or avoid being compared to it until the heat death of the universe.
And so, inspired by this recent Reddit thread on the very subject, we come to 10 TV shows that just so happened to wreck and ruin other series beyond any and all credibility.
Even years from now, new entries into these genres will still find themselves being compared to these seminal TV shows, which remain high watermarks for the type of storytelling they were trying to achieve.
It may not always be this way, but these hit TV shows left some mighty corpses in their shadows...
10. Lost RUINED Most Mystery Shows
No matter your own feelings on Lost, it's tough to deny the influence it had on small-screen mystery dramas.
One of the quintessential "water cooler" TV shows of the last 20 years, Lost was on everybody's lips during its first few seasons, and though its ending remains hugely polarising to this day, it captured the public's imagination in ways that few shows ever have.
It also threw the gauntlet down and challenged every network to try and make "the new Lost," ensuring that just about every promising mystery show with a large ensemble cast from the last 15 years has had that crushing pressure placed upon it.
Lost also confirmed how difficult it is to conclude mystery shows in a manner that satisfies most, and so, with Lost's divisive ending being so firmly rooted in the public consciousness, any time a new mystery series shows potential, it's tough not to pessimistically consider how clunky its ending will be.
As such, there's an honest argument to be made that you just shouldn't ever watch Lost because it'll forever taint your perception of serialised mystery TV.
Even with shows like Severance and From ranking among the most tantalising mystery series of recent years, it's hard to take them entirely on their own terms and not within the shadow of J. J. Abrams and Damon Lindelof's iconic sci-fi drama show.
9. Game Of Thrones RUINED The Wheel Of Time & Rings Of Power
Lost isn't the only show to basically usher in a glorified subgenre of pretenders. Game of Thrones is unquestionably one of the most popular TV shows of the last decade-plus, delivering mega-budget fantasy thrills like audiences had never seen before on the small screen.
Just like Lost, its enormous success compelled everyone in Hollywood to start looking for The New Game of Thrones, with the more persuasive recent possibilities being Amazon's high-fantasy literary adaptations The Wheel of Time and The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power.
Long before either premiered, they were already being stood next to Thrones, as is basically a ritual for any large-scale fantasy series at this point.
Game of Thrones produced such a deep footprint in the genre that, at least so far, it's been near-impossible for anything since to just... exist without being tirelessly compared to it.
8. The Expanse RUINED All New Star Trek Shows
The Expanse is one of those rare, once-in-a-generation sci-fi TV shows that thoroughly humbles, even shames, just about everything else in the genre.
So richly crafted is its world and characters that basically every other recent show featuring spacecrafts and outer space looks positively "mid."
There are a few exceptions, for sure - Star Wars' Andor, for one - but The Expanse has especially made mincemeat out of Paramount's newer Star Trek projects.
Impossible though it is to deny Trek's statuesque, decades-long presence in the genre, the newer, glossier era of Trek TV - that is, Discovery, Picard, and Strange New Worlds - feels like shiny junk food compared to the meticulous technical craft and deep-dish storytelling of The Expanse.
If newer Trek feels like a mere time-passer - "something to watch" while scrolling on your phone, you might say - The Expanse both demands and rewards your absolute attention, as all great sci-fi does.
7. The Haunting Of Hill House RUINED American Horror Story
Not dissimilar to the Expanse-Trek comparison, Mike Flanagan's debut Netflix horror series The Haunting of Hill House proved that small-screen horror didn't need to be appointment trash TV propelled forward by shock value - it could be as emotionally involving as any "prestige" drama series.
Almost immediately after The Haunting of Hill House premiered, it received favourable comparisons to FX's horror series American Horror Story, especially its first season, Murder House, to which it bares a number of not-superficial similarities.
And while American Horror Story's debut season absolutely ranks among its best, it's basically left dead in a ditch in light of Flanagan's more nuanced, artful riff on similar material - that is, exploring familial discord and trauma amid a haunted house scenario.
Stood next to The Haunting of Hill House, American Horror Story, even in its best moments, is basically a fun rollercoaster ride.
It's high-calorie, dumb fun, but once Flanagan showed us all what televisual horror could be, that just didn't seem good enough anymore.
6. Succession RUINED Billions
Showtime's Billions recently wrapped up with its seventh season, though if you ask many fans, the ferociously addictive drama series began to noticeably decline around the start of its fourth season.
Not so coincidentally, this was also the same year that HBO's similarly-themed finance drama Succession made its debut and basically showed Billions a thing or two (or twenty) about crafting captivating, unforgettable TV.
The strength of Succession's stingingly satirical storytelling and characterisation, not to mention the note-perfect quality of its central performances, categorically blew Billions out of the water and near-instantly made it less fun to watch.
Hell, even Succession star Brian Cox himself intimated as much, insisting that his show wouldn't go "past its sell-by date" like Billions so undeniably did.
If Billions treats its premise and characters in relatively superficial, surface-level fashion not unlike a well-made soap opera, Succession is basically the inverse of this.
Given their thematic similarities, Succession makes it tough to go back to Billions now, especially in its wonkier later seasons.
5. Andor RUINED Every Other Star Wars Show
The Expanse wasn't the only sci-fi show to wreak havoc on its like-minded genre brethren. Though it wasn't the most-watched or vocally celebrated Star Wars show on social media, Andor was by far the most critically acclaimed, and with damn good reason.
From Tony Gilroy's nimble depiction of fascism to the show's use of actual sets - as opposed to restrictive "StageCraft" popularised by Disney in recent years - and the outstanding performances of the cast, Andor was a much-needed reminder that there's still room for storytelling in Star Wars that isn't breathlessly reliant on nostalgia.
I's not merely a "pretty good" TV show - it's easily one of the dramatically strongest narratives in the entirety of Star Wars, standing tall with the first two films.
And so, sandwiched between mediocre shows like The Book of Boba Fett, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Ahsoka, and the latter seasons of The Mandalorian, how couldn't Andor seem leagues ahead?
Even The Mandalorian, which certainly ranks among the better of the Disney+ Star Wars shows, feels shallow and safe compared to Andor, which takes dramatic risks and doesn't merely lean back on the franchise's inestimable legacy.
There's absolutely room for silliness in Star Wars, but Andor proved just how seriously the series can take itself and in turn heighten viewer investment.
And above all else, it was made with real care, which has felt so lacking in so much Star Wars media over the last five or so years.
4. The Wire RUINED Most Cop Shows
There's a strong argument to be made that The Wire is the most underappreciated TV show of all time, for though it was a major critical darling during its five years on the air, it didn't win a single Primetime Emmy Award throughout its run.
David Simon's almost impossibly detailed and unexpectedly Shakespearean police drama is the cop show to own all cop shows, even if that label seems a tad reductive as a way of summing up everything that The Wire is.
All the same, it's a stone-cold all-timer masterwork elevated by both Simon and co-writer Ed Burns' journalistic account of crime in Baltimore, and the phenomenal work of a gigantic ensemble cast.
Bar a few other standout contenders like The Shield, True Detective, and Simon's own Homicide: Life on the Street, The Wire makes the majority of contemporary cop dramas seem like flippant, trashy slop.
That's not to say there isn't a place for mostly mindless entertainment like NCIS - after all, nobody wants to watch The Wire after a long day at the office - but The Wire's rigorous attention to detail makes most other police dramas look like they're written in crayon.
3. Daredevil RUINED The Arrowverse
Small-screen superhero shows are at an all-time peak in output right now, but years before the Marvel Cinematic Universe planted its flag in a major way, there was the Arrowverse.
The CW's laudably ambitious interconnected world - comprising Arrow, The Flash, Supergirl, Legends of Tomorrow, Black Lightning, and Batwoman - was nevertheless a wildly mixed bag both creatively and in terms of production values.
All the same, the early seasons of Arrow and The Flash in particular were warmly received, but the entire enterprise took a nasty hit once Netflix's Daredevil arrived on the scene.
Even if it wasn't enticingly set in the MCU - though, strategically, only ever hung out on the fringes of it - Daredevil was a huge breath of fresh air for superhero TV.
From its more sturdy, source-faithful storytelling to its mightier performances, bone-crunching action, and generally more mature tone, Daredevil made the Arrowverse look like kids playing dress-up.
As the Arrowverse's narrative became increasingly unwieldy and soap opera-reliant, Daredevil soared on the strength of its grittier plot and technically sublime style.
We can only hope that the upcoming Disney+ Daredevil show, Daredevil: Born Again, can get anywhere close to the Netflix series' intensity and kineticism.
2. The Last Of Us RUINED The Walking Dead
The Last of Us isn't just a brilliant adaptation of Naughty Dog's legendary video game - it's a genuinely great slice of post-apocalyptic drama in its own right and, more to the point, arguably the best zombie-adjacent TV series ever produced.
In fact, it's so well-made, impeccably acted, and dramatically potent that it basically leaves the previous top dog, The Walking Dead, necrotising in the dust.
Now in fairness, there's a strong argument to be made that The Walking Dead lost much of its lustre after its first few seasons, and the seemingly never-ending fleet of spin-offs have caused the franchise to basically become a shambling, soulless zombie in of itself.
But The Last of Us is nevertheless everything that The Walking Dead isn't - a technically stunning, character-driven masterpiece that also dares to respect the audience's time.
When you compare the canvas which HBO gave Neil Druckman and Craig Mazin to the more sanitised, slapdash one The Walking Dead had on AMC, there's just no comparison.
To go back and watch the latter now, it just seems quaint and even a bit corny - a grotty relic from an era where pulpy source material couldn't be translated into prestige drama.
Perhaps had AMC let Frank Darabont deliver his more character-focused iteration of The Walking Dead instead of canning him during production of the second season, things could've been different.
1. South Park RUINED Family Guy
While all other shows on this list ruined other series simply by being a much better iteration of their central concept, that strategy proved a little too classy for Matt Stone and Trey Parker, who gave Family Guy both barrels in South Park's tenth season episode "Cartoon Wars Part II."
The episode centers around Cartman's attempts to get Family Guy cancelled, and by far its most memorable scene reveals that the show is in fact written by a tank full of manatees, who pick an "idea ball" containing a verb, noun, or pop-culture reference, which is then delivered to a joke-generating machine to create one of Family Guy's famed cutaway gags.
Even accepting that enjoying Family Guy and finding South Park's joke funny aren't mutually exclusive, this relentlessly memed scene did nevertheless draw real attention to Family Guy's flimsy, Mad Libs-inspired style of writing, while comparing it less favourably to South Park's smarter brand of satire.
Though Family Guy certainly remained popular in the years that followed, it's tellingly also around the time that Cartoon Wars Part II aired that the show's best, most golden years came to an end.
Whether you're a die-hard South Park fan or have only seen the offending scene in isolation on social media, it's tough to watch even a single Family Guy cutaway now without thinking of those damn manatees.