10 Worst Doctor Who Episodes According To YOU

We’ve covered your Doctor Who favourites, now it’s time to look at your not-so favourites…

Doctor Who Kill the Moon Peter Capaldi Twelfth Doctor
BBC Studios

A few months ago, we put together a list of the top Doctor Who episodes according to fans. So now, let's flip that on its head and examine the bottom of the barrel in the modern era of the show.

The fine folks at Doctor Who Magazine released a poll last year to coincide with the 60th anniversary, where every single episode was ranked from best to worst by readers, one Doctor at a time.

We’ll be using those results for this list, which means, for once, we can rank bad episodes guilt free! We are but the messengers today.

Here’s how it’s going to work. We’ll take the bottom two episodes from each modern Doctor (minus Fourteen and Fifteen, who were not included in the poll), and talk about their second-worst episode in the first half of the list, and their worst episode in the second half of the list.

We’ve ranked these in Doctor order too, so that means a Thirteenth Doctor episode will be number one by default. However, we doubt many will disagree with its placement (spoilers!).

10. Aliens Of London/World War Three

Doctor Who Aliens Of London Slitheen
BBC Studios

The first two-parter of the revived series could easily have dodged the bullet, and of all the episodes in this list, it probably has the most merit conceptually.

Intended as a commentary on the Iraq war, this story has a bit of bite to it, in a good way, even if it is a little on the nose with its political allegories at times.

But for every scathing criticism of false-flag operations, there’s a fart joke, and all notion of taking the message seriously wafts away into the wind like… well. Y'know.

The Slitheen Family is a really interesting villain in theory – intergalactic mobsters trying to commit insurance fraud at a planetary level. Great idea! But they're let down by some wonky effects, which leads to a huge discrepancy in their mobility, dependent on whether CGI or practical effects are being used from scene-to-scene. They also suffer from some baffling and childish writing which genuinely devotes half their screen time to fat jokes and flatulence.

Doctor Who Slitheen laughing
BBC Studios

It’s a shame, because with some minor tweaks, the Slitheen could've been the classic foes RTD clearly wanted them to be.

It's still a decent story overall, but with the Ninth Doctor having such a short run, it's easy to see why this would be regarded as one of his bottom two stories.


9. The Lazarus Experiment

Doctor Who The Lazarus Experiment
BBC Studios

Onto the Tenth Doctor now, and you were probably expecting Love & Monsters and Fear Her to be his entries on this list. So were we! Readers of DWM weren't on the same page however, meaning that at least one of those infamous duds will not feature here.

The Lazarus Experiment isn’t often mentioned as being irredeemably bad, so we're chalking its low ranking down to it being so forgettable that people don’t actually remember it.

In this episode, Mark Gatiss Benjamin Buttons himself into an iffy wig, before transforming into The Mummy’s Scorpion King (with CGI effects of around the same quality). He then chases the Doctor and Martha for half an hour before getting spooked by a pipe organ, and falling to his undignified, naked death.

It's okay though – it's Mark Gatiss, he'll be sure to cameo again soon enough!

Doctor Who The Lazarus Experiment Mark Gatiss Lazarus death
BBC Studios

There are a couple of interesting conversations about immortality sprinkled in throughout The Lazarus Experiment, but it’s not enough to save what is essentially 45 minutes of corridor chases. It might've worked if the episode leaned more into its horror setup, but it doesn’t, and having Gatiss’ face photoshopped onto a mess of limbs doesn't really sell the monster.

The supporting cast doesn't do much to elevate the episode either, and the Jones' remain the weakest family dynamic of the RTD1 era. The series never really knows what to do with them – they don’t have a patch on the Tylers or the Nobles, despite them having future superstars in their midst with Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Adjoa Andoh.


8. Nightmare In Silver

Doctor Who Nightmare In Silver Cybermen
BBC Studios

It’s rumoured that the original Nightmare in Silver script handed in by Neil Gaiman was heavily doctored by The Moff’s grubby mitts. And when we say ‘grubby’, we mean it quite literally, given the notoriously creepy "skirt just a little too tight" line that always brings the cringe on a rewatch.

On the plus side, there are some strong character moments, a really unique (if underutilised) theme park setting, and the ever-lovable Warwick Davis. Still, Nightmare in Silver is fairly criticised for a number of reasons, and it's not surprising to see it rated as Eleven's second-worst outing.

There's the inclusion of Doctor Who’s most annoying children to date (which, after 50 years, was quite an achievement), and a fundamental misunderstanding of the Cybermen's M.O., and what makes them scary.

Their redesign here makes them feel more like robots than cyborgs, with the human component barely mentioned at all, and a design that’s more reminiscent of a chromed-up Iron Man.

The attempt to make the Cybermen scarier by giving them super speed and the ability to software-patch out a weakness to bullets does the opposite, and we’re glad this rather lame ‘upgrade’ was dropped, even though we were stuck with the Tony Stark Cybermen in Series 8 too.


7. Kill The Moon

Doctor Who Kill The Moon Twelfth Doctor Clara Oswald
BBC

Kill the Moon gets more flak than it deserves. Having said that, the episode’s critics do have something of a point.

Let’s deal with the glaring, spherical elephant in the room first. Doctor Who has been known to go way past suspension of disbelief on many occasions, but Kill the Moon takes a running leap and plants its feet firmly in a sandpit of absolute nonsense.

The Moon is an egg, which hatches a mega-dragon and doesn’t immediately cause some pretty serious gravitational issues, only for that newborn dragon to lay a new moon instantly, with that new moon being four times the size of the creature that laid it? And the writers room just expected us to sit back and say ‘Yeah, that tracks’? Get out of town!

You’ve also got the teensy issue of the first half being an utter snooze-fest, with a supporting cast that we assume might've done some stuff, but honestly have little memory of.

Those last ten minutes though? Fantastic, cathartic, and a real sobering moment for a character that needed some serious humbling – Series 8’s arc is so, so underrated. Regardless, readers of DWM still rated Kill the Moon as Capaldi's second-weakest story.


6. The Battle Of Ranskoor Av Kolos

Doctor Who The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos
BBC Studios

A large portion of fans questioned how The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos could've possibly been the best script available for Jodie Whittaker's first finale. It therefore made a lot of sense when Chris Chibnall revealed that, due to time constraints, the version put to screen was in fact the first draft.

It's not unknown for a series finale to be polarising (hello Hell Bent and The Timeless Children), but the Battle of Roastbeef Av Kofte is guilty of far worse. Aside from having the worst title in the show’s history, it also feels like a filler episode – somehow moreso than any other episode in Series 11, a series that has no shortage of them.

This was what we were building up to for ten weeks?! It's like counting down to a holiday and realising it's actually a dentist appointment.

The episode tries to have stakes by teasing the origins of Evil Graham, but rather than seek revenge, he dooms his nemesis to an eternity paralysed in a single spot, completely conscious the entire time, just like all the good guys do. Also, planet Earth is apparently in grave danger, but it never feels like it, as we never see anything from Earth's perspective. We're instead meant to feel the peril while an Earth-coloured bowling ball gets thrown about a bit.

No arguments with this one – a deserved low ranking.


5. The Long Game

Doctor Who The Long Game
BBC Studios

Onto every Doctor's lowest-ranked episode now, starting with Nine.

Having just one series to pull from, Eccleston is at a disadvantage. Aliens of London/World War Three probably wouldn’t be here if he had another year. On the other hand, The Long Game thoroughly deserves its position, on account of it being one of the most dull portions of Who ever put to telly.

It's the single outing for failed companion Adam Mitchell, who continues his attempts to woo Rose, which are surprisingly successful given he’s basically a plank of wood with a smug face drawn on. Adam soon gets distracted however, and decides to get a data-storing orifice drilled into his forehead (which is click-activated – problematic if you’re moonlighting as a jazz musician).

Meanwhile, the Doctor and Rose head upstairs and find Simon Pegg, along with another much bigger orifice – this one screams a lot and is ceiling mounted. But the Mighty Jagrafess is no Nick Frost, and Pegg has very little chemistry with this angry CGI roof blob. He gives it a good shot, but you can’t help but wonder why The Editor wasn’t the solo big bad here – could've saved many viewers’ eardrums, and all £5 of the monster budget.

Doctor Who Jagrafess The Long Game
BBC Studios

All in all, there are no standout moments, no memorable dialogue, and it all feels a bit too pedestrian. Ironically, The Long Game doesn’t seem to know where it’s going half the time, and tries to spin multiple plots that are all as soulless as each other.

It's the only true poor story for the Ninth Doctor. 12 out of 13 ain't bad!


4. Fear Her

Doctor Who Fear Her
BBC Studios

Fear Her seems to have dethroned Love & Monsters as Tennant's least-popular episode as time has gone by. Is that deserved? Well, it's certainly a contender.

The 2012 Olympics setting means that the episode is a little dated now, but that’s far from its biggest failing. No, that’d be the plot, the antagonist, the effects, and the supporting cast. So pretty much everything.

Ten and Rose find themselves pitted against Chloe Webber, a child possessed by a lonely jellyfish, whose superpowers include turning people into drawings and speaking only in whispers at all times. The plot trundles along at a snail’s pace, and has one of the highest cringe-per-minute ratios in modern Doctor Who.

Meanwhile, Rose befriends certified legend and walking meme, Kel the Council Worker, who is a shining light in the dark. Rose also fights an angry scribble, but the less said about that, the better.

Doctor Who Fear Her Scribble monster
BBC Studios

In the end, the Doctor takes it upon himself to steal the Olympic Torch and light the Olympic Flame, but what’s more impressive is that he isn’t tackled to the ground and arrested.

Despite a few funny moments – like the TARDIS materialising facing a shipping container, or the Doctor nonchalantly helping himself to some marmalade in the middle of a serious conversation – it's not enough to save an episode whose script we can only assume resembles that scribble monster quite closely.


3. The Doctor, The Widow And The Wardrobe

Doctor Who The Doctor, The Widow and the Wardrobe
BBC Studios

It's not Victory of the Daleks or The Curse of the Black Spot that DWM readers think is the worst Eleventh Doctor episode – it's The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe, which is easily the weakest Christmas special of them all, and might be the weakest script Moffat ever wrote.

This story sees the Doctor hired as a nanny for two children with a father who is MIA. He does this as a favour to Madge, who once helped him out of a bind involving a wardrobe malfunction in a spacesuit. He returns this favour by putting her children in serious danger of being melted to death. Repeat, the only danger in this episode is created by the Doctor himself, and gift-wrapped for two young kids.

He tries to give them the Narnia treatment, but instead of friendly Fauns and Liam Neeson Lions, the Doctor’s Narnia has acid rain, giant mechs, and Bill Bailey. At no point is he appropriately chastised for this rather major faux pas.

Elsewhere, the trio of harvest rangers are painfully unfunny, the plot meanders along, and to add insult to injury, the Doctor mutters the phrase "humany-wumany", a line that viewers across the country simultaneously rolled their eyes at.


2. In The Forest Of The Night

Doctor Who In The Forest Of The Night
BBC

Even unpopular stories from Series 8 (like Robot of Sherwood), have had a bit of a renaissance in recent years, but one thing's for sure: In the Forest of the Night is still terrible, and no amount of Capaldi withdrawal will fix that.

The Doctor intrudes on a school trip after the kids come under threat from a load of trees. Not sentient warrior trees, or poison trees, or anything of the like – just bog-standard, run of the mill trees. Careful though: there’s a lot of them, and they’re making public transport an absolute nightmare.

This episode attempts to focus on the character drama, with minimal action throughout. This is no issue whatsoever if the drama is meaty, but here the emotional beats are basically retreading the plot of The Caretaker a few weeks prior, except this time, there’s a bunch of precocious children and a lame monster of the week sprinkled on top.

The Doctor also endorses a child rejecting their mental health medication and encourages her to tap into the voices in her head. Regardless of whether this actually saved the day, it's a terrible message for a family show.

It's just a bit bland overall isn't it, and you can see why fans would consider this the bottom of the barrel of Twelfth Doctor stories.


1. Orphan 55

Doctor Who Orphan 55 The Dregs
BBC Studios

Unsurprisingly, DWM readers voted Orphan 55 as the worst Thirteenth Doctor story of them all. What is there to say about this one that hasn’t already been said?

Most episodes on this list are let down by one major element, or are generally weak but with one or two positives that make them worth rewatching. But not this time. Orphan 55 is the sole episode, in the entire 19-year run of NuWho, that we wholeheartedly recommend you never watch again.

It is, of course, commonly remembered for the infamously bad ‘Benni’ subplot, which comprised almost entirely of his wife shouting his name over... and over... and over again.

Doctor Who Orphan 55 Vilma
BBC Studios

Focusing on this gives the rest of the supporting cast more credit than they deserve though. Seriously, there isn’t a single likeable character among them, from Hyph3n, who looks like she’s wearing ears and paws from a cheap fancy-dress shop, to Jay from The Inbetweeners, who is seemingly more irresponsible here than his schoolboy counterpart. There's also Ryan’s ‘love interest’ for the episode. They don’t have much in common, but they do this thing where they suck their thumbs at each other. It’s… deeply uncomfortable. Every single time.

This group of losers is then dropped into a plot that spends about 20 minutes driving them out into the middle of monster-infested nowhere, only to turn around and come back again. The rest of the runtime is spent heavily telegraphing the most obvious plot twist of all time, before taking an important message and delivering it in the most patronising way possible.

We’re not sure what the opposite of firing on all cylinders is, but Orphan 55 most certainly fits the bill. The Razzies are in the post.


Watch Next


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Alex is a sci-fi and fantasy swot, and is a writer for WhoCulture. He is incapable of watching TV without reciting trivia, and sometimes, when his heart is in the right place, and the stars are too, he’s worth listening to.