5 Darkest Black Mirror Moments (So Far)
The most disturbing moments in an already disturbing show.
It's safe to say that Black Mirror isn't the nicest of shows. Since it debuted in 2011, the show has been spitting out episodes that provoked reactions ranging from "wow, that's dark," to "I feel physically ill and I need to lie down."
But looking back on the show's nineteen episodes, it's hard to pinpoint which moments, exactly, are the hardest to watch. Which moments are the most likely to stick in your head for the rest of your life? Which moments will re-emerge into your thoughts one night years in the future, and keep you laying in bed for hours, parsing through all the little implications and horrifying details?
There's a lot to pick from, but these are the ones that surpassed all expectations and went horribly dark, even by Black Mirror's standards/
(Warning: Spoilers ahead.)
5. Cooper Loses His Memory
Playtest is best known for its twist ending, which is completely understandable, but the most unbearable moment in this episode is the scene where Cooper develops a sudden case of Alzheimer's.
He can't remember who he is, where he is, and he can't even recognize himself in the mirror. Before he wakes up, he's reduced to a tiny shell of his former self. It's a scene that would horrify anyone, but to people who've had friends or family members diagnosed with Alzheimer's in the past, it hits a little too close to home.
What makes it worse: unlike the majority of Black Mirror characters who get screwed over in the end, Cooper doesn't actually do anything wrong. Okay, so he probably should've called his mother, but he was still a genuinely good person who ended up dying in his worst nightmare.
4. Hundreds Of Thousands Of People Get Violently Murdered By Robot Bees
It's amazing how good Black Mirror is at messing with the audience's emotions. Throughout Hated in the Nation, the people using the #Deathto hashtag are portrayed as thoughtlessly cruel and sadistic, and the show makes you hate these people right until they get what's coming to them.
The show wisely decides not to show the mass murder itself, instead choosing to leave it all up to the imagination. The more you think about it, the worse it gets: you realize that those schoolchildren would not only witness their teacher die violently in front of them, but that a lot of them would come home that day to dead parents, to dead relatives. You realize that there were probably a lot of people who'd died from joke tweets, like "#Deathto [a fictional character]." You realize that a lot of the victims were probably children, with kids taking part in social media as young as ten years old.
The show hits you in the gut one last time, as Detective Kelly MacDonald leaves the Courthouse and is bombarded by screaming, angry protesters. Despite the horror this country's faced, the mob mentality is still just as present. People haven't learned a thing.
3. A Woman's Consciousness Gets Trapped Inside A Stuffed Animal
Black Museum was one hell of a rough episode. It was hard to pick the most tragic character within the three main stories, but in the end Carrie took the gold.
From the moment Rolo Haynes introduced the idea of inserting her consciousness into her husband's head, it was clear this could only end poorly. And sure enough: Carrie eventually wakes up inside a stuffed monkey, unable to communicate with anyone, except through two buttons by her side that can only say "monkey loves you!" and "monkey needs a hug."
Her husband moves on, her son forgets about her, and she ends up spending the rest of her time trapped inside a glass box by the man who put her in this predicament to begin with.
It's debatable as to whether Carrie's story is as bad as the other two tragic figures in her episode, but what stands out with her is her inability to communicate. At least the convict was able to express himself, as terrible as his situation might be. The idea of having all of your agency taken away from you, even something as basic as being able to speak, is the element that makes her story all the more devastating.
2. Kenny Gets A Call From His Mother
Shut Up and Dance is probably the bleakest episode of the entire show, bordering on nihilistic. From the moment Kenny realizes he'd been recorded masturbating, everyone in the audience knew, deep down, that the video was going to be released. It had to be, or it would've been anticlimactic. (And more importantly, it wouldn't have been Black Mirror.)
But it isn't until Kenny robs the bank that it becomes clear there's something more going on here. A video of you masturbating is embarrassing, sure, but it's not embarrassing enough to commit a felony over.
When the guy in the woods asked, "how young were they?" a lot of viewers chose to believe the guy was merely projecting. The idea that Kenny, the innocent-looking kid we've been rooting for this whole time, was a paedophile, was too hard to stomach.
And then Kenny gets that call from his heartbroken mother, and it's undeniable: Kenny was looking at child porn. Everything Kenny did and said throughout the episode -- the scene with the little girl, him looking at the child's drawings, his paranoia over his sister using his laptop -- takes on an entirely new meaning.
1. Joe Is Stuck Listening To The Same Song On A Loop For Millions Of Years
There's a recurring plot point in Black Mirror, one that revolves around a person who does something bad, but then gets punished so severely that you can't help but feel terrible for them. Be it Victoria the child-murderer, Kenny the paedophile, or Matt the charming psychopath, it's hard not to feel like they got the raw end of the deal, even if they aren't the greatest of people. But the final moments of White Christmas take this concept to a breathtaking, almost incomprehensible extreme.
After Joe confesses to the passion-induced murder of his ex-girlfriend's father, (which unwittingly leads to the death of a little girl), he is left stuck inside the same cabin, unable to leave, unable to sleep, unable to even kill himself to end his misery. He is trapped inside the worst moment of his life for millions and millions of years, and he has to listen to that godawful Christmas song the entire time. Most people would go insane after a couple days of this, let alone an eternity.
Of course, the viewer can take solace in knowing that this version of Joe is technically not real. But after future episodes like USS Callister and Black Museum, it's hard to think of Joe as anything but human.
Which Black Mirror moments do you think are the darkest? Let us know down in the comments.