8 Dream TV Castings That Came True

Somebody give Nick Offerman an award!

Bill The Last of Us
HBO

Every time a piece of media announces a live-action adaptation - be it a book, video game, or comic - the first thing we do is wonder who will play its most iconic characters.

But just think about what it takes for a dream casting to come true. It doesn't matter how unanimously agreed upon the idea is across the web - sometimes, it just doesn't work.

Schedules must line up - so if a star is already busy then they're already out. More than that, both the actor and the showrunners have to want to do it, and must be able to work together effectively.

But when it all comes together it's a beautiful thing, because more often than not, it pays off.

There are a few great examples of this in film (Samuel L Jackson as Nick Fury or Zachary Quinto as Spock, for example) but it's even tougher to find in television. However, this list highlights the most exciting and exhilarating fan-castings that eventually became a reality.

8. Peter Dinklage As Tyrion Lannister - Game Of Thrones

Game of Thrones Tyrion
HBO

For almost a decade, Game of Thrones was the biggest show on television. It was a spectacular dark fantasy with a host of interesting, duplicitous characters. Amongst these was the man who “drank and knew things”: Tyrion Lannister, an outsider from his family, in part due to being born a dwarf.

The books had been around for quite some time when the show was greenlit, and had amassed their own cult following. Most fans were in agreement that there was no better man for Tyrion than Peter Dinklage, an assessment that the showrunners also held. However, they were hesitant to approach him.

Dinklage had just finished work on the fantasy film Prince Caspian, and the actor had a distaste for the genre’s tropes. As he put it:

“In fantasy, everybody speaks in broad strokes. There's no intimacy. There's dragons and big speeches, and there's nothing to hold on to. And for somebody my size, it's f**king death, the opposite of [the activism] I was involved with.”

However, he was friends with the wife of co-writer David Benioff, and decided to read the script for the pilot despite his initial negative reaction. And the rest, as they say, is history.


7. Rosario Dawson As Ahsoka Tano - The Mandalorian

The Mandalorian Ahsoka Tano
Disney Platform Distribution

With a universe worth of lore, Star Wars has a long line of interesting characters outside of the main players in the live-action films. Ahsoka Tano is a Jedi warrior who first appeared in the animated Clone Wars movie, and immediately connected with fans due to her awesome design and general badassery.

This popularity was reflected in her repeat appearances. She was a major character in The Clone Wars TV show, and Ashley Eckstein (the character’s original voice actor), even got to cameo in The Rise of Skywalker.

When it came to live-action however, there was only one name that fans were interested in, and that was Rosario Dawson.

Adored by consumers of nerdy media, Dawson broke out in slacker comedy Clerks II, and has gone on to appear in Netflix’s Marvel shows and graphic novel adaptation Sin City, to name a few.

Responding to a fan casting on Twitter with the hashtag #AhsokaLives caught the attention of someone at Disney’s Star Wars division. Sure enough, in Chapter 13 of The Mandalorian, Dawson made her debut as the Togruta hero.

This would snowball into appearing in The Book of Boba Fett two years later, and, with the momentum totally behind her, she will soon be starring in her very own Ahsoka show.


6. Henry Cavill As Geralt - The Witcher

Witcher geralt netflix
Netflix

Both a book series and now a video game franchise, it was only a matter of time before The Witcher came to live-action. A medieval fantasy with a supernatural twist, the show’s world was ripe for exploring in a serialised television format. But of course, the big question was who would play the leading man, the monster-slaying Geralt of Rivia?

No one was a bigger supporter of Henry Cavill in the role than the man himself. In many ways, as a player of the Witcher games, this was his own fan casting.

Cavill has admitted that he would not relent when it came to securing the part. Not only did he constantly badger his agent about it, he would reach out to the studio repeatedly to put himself forward. Lauren Schmidt Hissrich, writer/producer on the show, recalled that:

“He was really annoying. I finally said, ‘I will meet with you. The show is not green-lit. There is nothing. Thank you. Now I have to go write the show.’”

Despite apparently seeing 206 other actors for the part, it became obvious that Cavill was the man for the job. This, however, makes his 2022 announcement that he is stepping away from the role all the more heart-breaking. Two new seasons of the show have been greenlit, with Liam Hemsworth taking up the sword in Cavill’s stead.


5. Idina Menzel As Shelby Corcoran - Glee

Glee Shelby
20th Television

From 2009 onwards, Glee took over television as one of the biggest shows around. Its school setting, bright musical numbers, and strong casting caught the eyes of many, especially around awards season.

Fans immediately agreed that Lea Michele, who played hopeful Broadway star Rachel Berry, had the air of Idina Menzel about her. Menzel is, appropriately, regarded as the Queen of Broadway. Viewers took to the internet to discuss, requesting that the showrunners take notice, and do what they could to bring Menzel in. As Rachel was the daughter of two gay men, there was a space for Menzel to enter the show as the character’s biological mother.

Glee then took a mid-season break, and during this time, the creators admitted they had met with the Queen of Broadway.

Appearing in episode 14 of the show as Shelby Corcoran, the vocal coach of the school’s rival group Adrenaline, fans were disappointed at first. However, a few weeks later, it’s revealed that Corcoran was indeed Rachel’s mother.

The character’s storylines throughout the show are often a point of contention with fans, but, for the most part, long-time Gleeks will remember the excitement of seeing their idea come to life onscreen.


4. Alexander Siddig As Ra’s Al Ghul - Gotham

Ras Al Ghul Gotham
Fox

Batman is, without a doubt, the comic-book character with the most recognisable villains. Joker, Penguin, Poison Ivy, Mr Freeze… this list goes on.

Ra’s Al Ghul, despite being a cornerstone of the Batman comics, has never had too many live-action appearances. Notably, Liam Neeson portrayed him in Christopher Nolan’s Batman Begins, which was fine, if a little odd. The name Ra’s Al Ghul is Arabic in origin, literally translating to the Head of the Ghoul, so fans began to consider actors more appropriate for the casting.

The most popular of these was Alexander Siddig, best known for his time portraying the softly spoken Dr Bashir in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. Just after fellow DC show Arrow introduced its own interpretation played by Matthew Nable, Siddig was announced to be coming to Fox’s Gotham, a show that takes a look into the younger years of Bruce Wayne.

In the show, Ra's Al Ghul is an ambiguous character who is instrumental in shaping the destiny of the future Batman. Siddig’s performance as the character was so good, that DC fans moved from fan casting his appearance to fan casting his return, hopeful that he may cross over into the Arrowverse, or even into the feature films somewhere down the line.


3. Nick Offerman As Bill - The Last Of Us

The Last of US
HBO

HBO’s belief in adapting video game mega-hit The Last of Us for TV speaks volumes in its monumental budget, spent on impressive sets and brilliant casting.

Nick Offerman wasn’t necessarily on everybody’s lists when the show was first confirmed, but as soon as the announcement came, there was a collective rumble of excitement. Offerman became a beloved figure working on Parks & Recreation as the very GIF-able Ron Swanson, a gruff man with deadpan delivery, suspicions of the government, and (secretly) a heart of gold. He was the perfect choice to play Bill: the sardonic, pessimist survivalist

What makes this such a remarkable case is that it almost didn’t happen. In July 2021, HBO announced some of the supporting roles for the show, including Chernobyl’s Con O’Neill as Bill. This was walked back before the end of the year due to scheduling conflicts, and Offerman stepped up.

And it’s fair to say he knocked it right out of the park.

While some fans saw the Bill-centric episode of the show as a sudden diversion, no one can truly deny Offerman’s dramatic chops. He demonstrated the character we knew from the game with way more depth, as he explored a beautiful and tragic love story in a post-apocalyptic world.

Offerman trended on Twitter for days after the episode aired, with many calling for him to get his flowers once awards season rolls around.


2. Hailee Steinfeld As Kate Bishop - Hawkeye

Hawkeye Kate Bishop
Disney Platform Distribution

The Marvel Cinematic Universe has been a game-changer in many ways, but related to this topic, it has changed and revitalised careers forever. Decoupling the men and women who have played the most prominent roles in the franchise from their characters is very hard. The best of them have left a huge mark on Marvel going forward.

In the comics, Kate Bishop is the apprentice of Clint Barton - aka Hawkeye. When it was announced that Barton was getting his own Disney+ spinoff, fans immediately began to talk about who could take on the mantle of Bishop, with Hailee Steinfeld being a prominent pick.

MCU fans get some interesting insights behind-the-scenes with the docu-series Assembled, and the Hawkeye episode highlighted Hailee’s ascension to the role.

Executive producer Trinh Tran mentioned that they chose to meet with her for a conversation, but that it was clear she was the perfect casting, and so they offered Steinfeld the part after just one meeting. She also admitted that she figured MCU godfather Kevin Feige had always wanted Steinfeld for the role.

And thankfully, it paid off, as Kate Bishop’s debut was a highlight of the show, which makes it not at all surprising that the star had signed for multiple upcoming MCU productions.


1. Ben Barnes As The Darkling - Shadow And Bone

Ben Barnes Shadow Bone
Netflix

Shadow and Bone is a dark fantasy series that its fans had a very specific dark fantasy about: the casting of Darkling. Focusing on a Russian orphan who discovers she has supernatural abilities, she finds herself up against the Shadow Summoner General Aleksander Kirigan.

Based on a novel of the same name and its ensuing sequels, Netflix picked up the property for streaming in 2019. When looking to cast the enigmatic Kirigan, Ben Barnes knew he was right for the role. At the end of his conversation with the casting director, he showed them a Tumblr post from literally years before the show had been picked up, that showed fan-edits of him as The Darkling.

Barnes had shown his range with appearances in Westworld and The Punisher, but his breakout performances were on the big screen, in Prince Caspian, and the 2009 adaptation of Dorian Gray. He certainly caught the eye of many, and Tumblr fans of Shadow and Bone were adamant about Barnes as The Darkling should it ever get picked up for television.

In fact, unknown to Barnes, the casting director had seen that same fan-edit previously. And, before long, everything came together in a way that caused a great many Tumblr users’ dreams to become a reality.


Watch Next


How Well Do You Know Netflix TV Shows?

Stranger Things Barb
Netflix

1. Name This TV Show

Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite