8 Great TV Shows That Would Have Had Incredible Prequels

We've seen Tony Soprano's fall, so why not his rise?

Some believe that prequels are rarely a good idea; just ask any disgruntled Star Wars fan who turned their nose up at Attack Of The Clones, and they'll probably have a list prepared as to why. Look out for the name "Jar Jar Binks" scribbled down three times. Prequels are rarer in television though; the last notable one on British TV was probably Rock And Chips, the story of a young Del Boy before Only Fools And Horses, which was met with an overwhelming "Meh," from fans and critics a-like, and Breaking Bad fans are currently holding their breath over the plans for Better Call Saul. The parent show ended so perfectly, after all: but what will the spin-off be like? It's a shame really that prequels tend to be so hit and miss because they offer fantastic opportunities and, at the very least, talking points for speculation. The very best shows build incredible backstories, and these backstories could be worth exploring; fans would love to see just an episode of the Doctor's life before he stole the TARDIS, or a glimpse into the childhood of Sherlock Holmes. Of course, they're never going to happen, but here are eight shows with backstories incredible enough that actually, a prequel sounds like a fascinating idea on paper.

8. The Doctor: Escape From Gallifrey - Doctor Who

The Premise: A young First Doctor feels like an alien on his home planet, as he plans to see the stars for himself. There are so many ideas of spin-off shows and prequel episodes that get the Doctor Who community excited. There have been whispers about getting Eighth Doctor Paul McGann his own series, the idea that maybe the Paternoster Gang should get a spin-off and then the match made in heaven that is River and Captain Jack fighting aliens in the days before she died in the Library. One that's never been talked about is perhaps the most obvious, actual "prequel" idea. The Doctor set off for the universe because he was disheartened with Gallifrey: why? Who were his family? How did he become so close with Susan and why did he take her with him instead of his wife or, presumably, his other grandchildren? It's an idea that could quite easily come to fruition with a younger actor, playing William Hartnell's Doctor in his earlier days. It would however cancel out so much of the mythology surrounded around the character. The Doctor's origins are fascinating, but perhaps we should let sleeping Time Lords lie, on this one.

7. Old Tricks - New Tricks

The Premise: Four cops, all with strikingly different talents, lead the Metropolitan Police in the 80's, unbeknownst that they all return to the force in their twilight years. New Tricks is still going, for those who didn't realise. What started off as quite a fun crime show clearly aimed at an older audience evolved into one of British TV's highest ratings winners. The BBC never had the guile to axe it; most of the original cast have been written out, and yet 2014 will bring the eleventh series of the show. It's a shame the show is so clearly holding on to being a "favourite with parents" because the original premise was alright: there's the strong woman, her mentor, the rough-and-ready geezer and the meticulous outsider. It's a decent set-up with established character traits; wouldn't it be a whole lot more exciting though if it was set during the prime of these cops' lives? The blatant BBC marketing towards an older audience is probably what stops a lot of younger viewers watching New Tricks, but it doesn't make it a bad idea as a show. If the same idea was reimagined with younger, brighter, more exciting faces imagine the possibilities that New Tricks would have...

6. The Holmes Brothers - Sherlock

The Premise: A highly intelligent young boy struggles to fit in with the rest of the world; only his patronising older sibling who understands him. Series 3 has delved deeper into the mind of Sherlock Holmes than ever before. The cases have taken a backseat in favour of developing the man solving them and it's become apparent that he's the real mystery. He's the reason we watch the show. Further to the point about New Tricks, a good detective show needs a good presence reading the case files. The idea of Sherlock's upbringing is one that perplexes modern fans as well as Conan Doyle nerds. The BBC series only adds to the mythos, giving a whole new audience clues and hints as to how Sherlock became the man he is today. Could you imagine a Smallville-esque coming-of-age drama, starring a young, Cumberbatchian actor with support coming from an icy, young Mycroft? It's a potentially dramatic, hilarious or poignant premise, whichever direction you take it. He doesn't even have to be solving crimes. Recent episodes have proved that Sherlock's brilliant no matter what he's doing. Maybe we could see his life of heroin?

5. Patrick Jane's Psychic Life - The Mentalist

The Premise: A cocky young trickster hustles his way to a fortune before coming face-to-face with a man who will change his life. The backstory behind The Mentalist is more fascinating than the actual show. A former psychic - he never had any particular gifts he was a con artist - never goes to school; he just joins a circus to show off his talents for cold reading. He marries another star of the show and together they have a daughter. In a tragic twist he teases a murderer on live television only for that very man to murder the two people he loves. The Mentalist Episode 1 begins at that point when Patrick Jane, living with the guilt of how his wife and child died, joins the California Bureau of Investigation to find this murderer, Red John, and kill him personally. There's so much potential for the story before the show starts, especially considering how brilliant lead actor Simon Baker is as an anti-hero; he was a con artist without any remorse for what he did, charismatic and using his "gifts" for personal gain. The Mentalist has arguably gone on too long and even Red John was brought to justice six seasons into the show: that's a story arc that's more than run its course. The truly fascinating stuff is totally unexplored within the show. It was hinted that Jane used to be a bit of an a-hole: don't we want to see more of that?

4. Schmidt At College - New Girl

The Premise: Schmidt has just found his confidence; with friends Winston and Nick by his side, he embarks on a new life of romance and excitement. Schmidt At College might come with a ridiculously bad title, but it's also a show that seems obvious. The true star of New Girl - flanked by the other two guys - gets his own shot in the limelight. Yes, it's pretty much New Girl in a new place and a few years before without Zooey Deschanel, but that's what makes a Schmidt prequel/spin-off so appealing; he's easily the most loved character of the bunch - at least he was at the start, before things started spiralling out of control - so it makes sense to not only make him the lead, but take him back to a more likeable phase of his life. It also makes sense to get rid of Zooey Deschanel given that she's, the most annoying of the bunch. Starting the show with Schmidt excited about life and centring on the popular dynamic between the guys just seems like the most obvious answer to such an opinion-dividing sitcom.

3. The Tony Soprano Origins - The Sopranos

The Premise: Tony Soprano grows up to learn his father is in organised crime. Among other things he has to choose between an honest education or following in his father's footsteps. The Sopranos started with Tony receiving treatment for his panic attacks and piece by piece we learned all about the early life and childhood of Tony Soprano. It was such a detailed and intriguing character backstory that formed one of television's all-time great lead characters and it's definitely a story big enough for its own show. The relationship that Tony had with his parents was particularly interesting; his father was a mafia man and his mother possibly had a personality disorder. He attended university, juggling half-hearted studies with a life of crime, before dropping out completely to pursue the latter. It was a unique formation of a criminal, and though much of it was seen or discussed in The Sopranos, it's a brilliant story that would make an excellent show in its own right. To actually make that show, some would call sacrilege. It's a fantastic tribute to The Sopranos, to the ingenious James Gandolfini and to the characterisation in the programme, that such an upbringing is so fascinating though.

2. Heroes: The First Generation - Heroes

The Premise: In the 1960's, a group of young friends discover that they have superpowers; together, they form an organisation to help others with the same abilities. Do you remember how much we loved Heroes back at the start, when this fresh crop of characters found out that they had magical abilities? No? Chances are then that you just remember most of them losing their powers. Oh, and then there was that huge, corrupt network, set up by their parents, who had already been there, done that, got the t-shirt and screwed their lives up. Taking Heroes back to the 1960's, to the point in the universe where superpowers were actually a big deal, would solve that problem. The previous generations' characters like Charles Deveaux, Kaito Nakamura, Arthur Petrelli, even Claude Rains, were on the whole, far more exciting as characters than their kids. If a show about superheroes isn't exciting, then what's the point? Isn't it a huge anti-climax to develop these characters' stories, only for us to discover that their mums and dads did all that stuff before them? It normalises the extraordinary. We wait with baited breath for Heroes: Reborn. Has Tim Kring developed the ability not to overcomplicate and sentimentalise absolutely everything, yet? Hopefully. And hopefully Zachary Quinto won't steal it from him.

1. David Brent's Life On The Road - The Office

The Premise: Awkward paper merchant and fame-obsessed David Brent strikes out in his band, Foregone Conclusion. David Brent never belonged in an office: he was a rock and roll superstar longing for a life of fame. Ricky Gervais has played gigs as Brent, given him a Comic Relief mini-episode, and even created guitar tutorials online in character, but still, all Office fans would love to see more of David's music career. A David Brent prequel series goes against everything that Gervais stands for; he drew a line under The Office, and doesn't want to cheapen his master character with yet another TV series milking his popularity. But just imagine it? David and Foregone Conclusion, embarking on a nationwide tour, performing hits such as Freelove Freeway, Spaceman Came Down, and of course, Equality Street ("mega-racial, anti-racist"). Another option entirely is to write a show about Brent's musical career to take off in 2014; he has some more dates lined up, and it would be great to hear tales of Wernham Hogg between tracks. He might not ever return to the small screen for a proper series again, but he's a character that we'll never have had enough of. Are there any fantasy TV prequels you would like to see? Share your thoughts in the comments thread below.

Contributor
Contributor

Mark White hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.