Arrow Season 7: 4 Ups & 2 Downs From ‘Star City 2040’

Arrow's long-term trip back to the future yields some shocking results.

Arrow S7 Ups Downs 16
The CW

Contains spoilers from Arrow Season 7, Episode 16.

Arrow has spent the better part of its seventh season reviving its flashback days by utilising a series of flash-forwards instead. Set 20 years in the future, these flash-forwards have been attempting to set up an arc involving Oliver Queen's children, William Clayton and Mia Smoak, as they navigate their way around the once-great Star City where vigilantes are outlawed in a desperate bid to locate Felicity. In doing so, they have run into their father's old allies Roy Harper, Dinah Drake and the new mayor of The Glades, Rene Ramirez.

In many ways, this week's episode, 'Star City 2040', was the moment that it was all building towards as it was solely set in the future. After discovering Felicity's message last week, William and Mia made their way over the wall and into the esteemed Glades to figure out what Felicity was really up to. Of course, that was a lot easier said than done.

'Star City 2040' was the payoff that we had been waiting for, finally giving us some answers while neatly tying the events to the present-day narrative, making our new characters all the more relatable in the process.

First, the positives.


Ups...

4. Something A Little Different

Arrow Star City 2040 Roy Felicity William Zoe Dinah
The CW

Let's start with one of the most enjoyable things about this entire adventure.

When a TV show runs all year-round and produces 22-23 episodes on demand, things can get a little repetitive. Throw in the fact that the Arrowverse shows love maintaining the status quo and we're lucky if we see much change at all from episode to episode. With that in mind, you can see why it was somewhat revitalizing to see an episode focused solely on something else entirely.

Being a flash-forward-centric installment, 'Star City 2040' was rooted firmly in the dystopian future that we had seen all too little of over the course of the season and, as a result, gave center stage to William, Mia and Connor Hawke, while also making time for Arrow mainstays Dinah, Roy and Rene. Save for the final few seconds, none of the episode was set in the present, giving it more of a special, standalone feel. But the beauty of it was that it wasn't actually a standalone episode.

It managed to give us a little breather from the season's main narrative while also remaining highly integral to the plot. Now that is a feat worth celebrating.


3. Adding Some Context

Arrow Mia Smoak Blackstar Nyssa Al Ghul
The CW

While we already knew quite a lot about Mia Smoak, there were still some gaps that needed filled in. We knew the "whos" and the "whats" of her outlook on life without every really knowing the "whys". This week, however, we finally got to see the answers to all of those questions.

The episode opened with a rather touching scene between Oliver and Felicity as the would-be vigilante parents prepared for the arrival of Mia into their lives. From there, we discovered that the archer-soon-to-be-known-as-Blackstar ended up living with her mother out in a quiet house in the woods and actually received extensive training from Nyssa Al Ghul. Her discovery of Felicity's secret Arrow-cave within her own house kick-started her hatred towards vigilantism and sent her to Star City.

You could argue that hearing about this information would have sufficed, but it wouldn't have had nearly as much effect. Opening with the flashback (can we call it a flashback if it's ahead of the present-day narrative?) added some context to the episode's story and set the stage nicely for the eventual family reunion that followed.


2. Tying It All Together

Arrow Felicity Smoak Laptop
The CW

When the flash-forward arc first began in the Season 7 premiere, it was so out of left field that it left us a little puzzled as to whether or not it directly related to the current timeline, or if it was just one of many potential futures. However, in recent weeks, things began to seem a little clearer.

From Felicity's confirmed pregnancy to William's departure, the writers have been planting some breadcrumbs - all of which seemed to suggest that this grim future for Star City was indeed set in stone. However, 'Star City 2040' finally confirmed the inevitable with its closing moment.

Following a 40-minute adventure set in the future, the episode's final scene took us back to the present where we saw Felicity in her apartment testing a trial version of the Archer programme. If you've been keeping tabs on the flash-forwards, you'll know that the Archer Programme is the most advanced technology of its time and allows its owner to see everything and anything that is going on across the whole of Star City.

When Laurel Lance first questioned Felicity's bizarre new, over-the-top, home-security system, none of us could have guessed that it would go on to become the revered Archer Programme, but that's exactly what appears to have happened. The writers deserve some major credit for their long-term planning here, as well as their subtle method of introducing the future's most powerful weapon.

Yet another amazing asset created by Team Arrow's resident genius, it would undoubtedly be dangerous if it fell into the wrong hands, especially if those hands belong to the villainous Kevin Dale.


1. The Next Generation

Arrow Mia Smoak Connor Hawke William Clayton Harris
The CW

'Star City 2040' may have added some context and progressed the plot, but its greatest strength didn't lie in its storytelling or in its twists, it lay in the cast's strong performances. The younger actors weren't just supporting the main narrative through a series of recurring flash-forwards anymore, they were leading the whole episode - something they all did incredibly effectively, especially Ben Lewis and Katherine McNamara.

Teaming up in an attempt to rescue Felicity, William and Mia spent a lot of time together as they made their way over the wall that separated The Glades from the rest of Star City. Not only did it allow them to grow that little bit closer, it highlighted the chemistry between Lewis and McNamara. The pair thrived on-screen together as the Queen siblings threw jibes at each other one moment and shared a heart-to-heart in the next.

From Lewis' emotional turn (when William was reunited with Felicity) to McNamara's feisty offering (when Mia clashed with her mother over their respective outlooks), their powerhouse performances showcased their true potential, highlighting just how strong they were in the lead roles.

Joseph David Jones and Andrea Sixtos also delivered as Connor Hawke and Zoe Ramirez, proving that they too were capable of the heavier load that this week's episode offered as they worked incredibly well with Arrow vets Juliana Harkavy, Colton Haynes, Emily Bett Rickards and Rick Gonzalez.

With Arrow ready to head off into that emerald sunset within the next year, and rumours circulating about a potential spin-off, the young cast of the flash-forwards have proven that they would be more than capable of leading their own show.

Now, for the negatives...


Downs...

2. Rene's Character Journey

Arrow Rene Dinah Future
The CW

It goes without saying that the most shocking character development in all of the flash-forwards belonged Rene Ramirez. By 2040, the former Wild Dog had ascended through the ranks of Star City to become Mayor of The Glades.

While his sudden change of heart was problematic at best (given that he was the one who always championed the vigilante life), you could at least attempt to see where he was coming from, due to the fact that his new position allowed him to finally rebuild the one place he always held close to his heart: The Glades. The same, however, could not be said for his arc this week.

Begging his daughter to stop fighting crime and let the agenda against Galaxy go, he refused to believe that the company he was working with had faked Felicity's death and was secretly planning to level the city and pin it on her (sure Rene, your hero friends are wrong). In the end, he discovered that they were right and even teamed up with his former allies to stop the destruction.

It makes sense that the showrunners wanted one of the characters to be drastically different following the time-jump, but this ended up coming off as contrived. The endgame was predictable from the start but, it would have been worth it if it was actually believable. Being a former superhero, Rene would have sensed that something was off about Galaxy (especially after his recent meeting with Kevin Dale), so his whole stance on the matter was off from the get-go and portrayed him as a lot more naive than he should have been.


1. All About Felicity

Arrow Felicity Smoak Star City 2040
The CW

While 'Star City 2040' was undoubtedly one of the better offerings of the season, it merely highlighted the biggest issue with the flash-forward narrative: it was literally all about Felicity.

The reunion of William and Mia? All about Felicity. The returns of Dinah and Roy? Also about Felicity. The mission to stop the destruction of The Glades? All orchestrated by Felicity, who had yet to even make an appearance before this week.

Now, Felicity Smoak is definitely one of Arrow's most memorable characters. With her quirky one-liners and endearing personality, she has proven herself over the years and, without a doubt, deserves her place on the show. Unfortunately, she is also somewhat responsible for the show's now-infamous decline in standard between Seasons 3 and 4 when she literally became the center of everything that it tackled.

While the current creative team seems to have a much better grasp of what the show is about under the tutelage of Beth Schwartz, it still doesn't change the fact that Felicity functions much better as a supporting character. If she is given too much involvement in the plot, she risks enveloping the show altogether, and we all know how that turned out the last time.

With Arrow's end in sight, the writers should be focusing on other more important characters or, at the very least, sharing the screen-time out evenly. Making Felicity dominate both the present and future is not the way to go out on a high.

-

Did you enjoy this week's episode of Arrow? Tell us in the comment section below.


Arrow Quiz: How Well Do You Really Know Oliver Queen?

Arrow oliver queen barry allen flarrow
The CW

1. When Is Oliver Queen's Birthday?

In this post: 
Arrow
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.