Broadchurch Finale: 12 Questions That Still Need Answering

Think it's all wrapped up in a nice little package? Think again.

So that's it. Not guilty, and the Sandbrook lot ALL did it. After a slow-burn second season, Broadchurch is done and dusted for another year, and justice has taken a severe kicking in the process. But at least there was some resolution thanks to the mob justice moment that saw Joe run out of town: that at least closed up his case nice and tightly. Or did it? For a show that thrived on complex story-telling, not everything was tied up nicely into the finale. Perhaps some of it will feed into the next - now confirmed - season, but you have to think that someone just dropped the ball a bit. Some things appear to have been used as conscious misdirection: the postman's argument with Danny was a red herring that was cleared up in a deleted scene (though you'd have thought that someone as thorough as Sharon the angry QC might have picked up on the information and tried to cast more doubt on Joe's case with it, since it wasn't actually in the final show). Then there's the fact that Will Mellor's psychic wasn't explained away - was he a magician or a con-man? And why did the Latimers' clocks all stop? Presumably that's a symbolic thing, but the magic realism of the symbolism somewhat derails the ethos that everything had an explanation in the real world. And those are far from the most pressing questions...


12. Did Joe Even Do It?

It might seem a redundant question, since Mr Miller admitted his guilt in the finale of season one, but there is still scope to believe that he was protecting someone else, or that something else happened. The judicial system seems to believe he's not guilty, at the very least, even if mob justice prevailed by the end. And if not him, then who? Tom seems the most likely candidate, since everyone else pretty much has an alibi or has been explained away: there's every possibility that the lad's conviction that his Dad was innocent came from his own guilt? Maybe there is more to this tale than has so far been revealed.

11. Why Did Claire Turn On Lee?

Perhaps it just wasn't explained openly enough - or lost in the slow drip, but it was never sufficiently shown why Claire turned informer on her husband. If she withdrew her false alibi in order to get him locked up, she was playing pretty fast and loose with her own freedom, considering she'd definitely end up in prison herself. And if she was doing it as some sort of ridiculous convoluted gambit to direct Hardy's attention elsewhere, then she clearly didn't think it through, or failed to tell her husband to play along properly. Plus, Hardy pretty much thought it was her from day one, so she brought it on herself. Admittedly, it made sense for Claire to turn on her husband if she was threatened by him, but the finale seemed to suggest that she was the more evil (and his villainy was a necessity, which he was far more sorry for)

10. Why On Earth Did Lee Even Come Back?

So, if Claire was playing the grand manipulator and keeping close to Hardy in the hope that he wouldn't notice that she was guilty, she should probably have passed this key information on, rather than inciting him to come to Broadchurch to draw more attention to them. Hardy was struggling to come up with anything in the case until Lee re-appeared, and the philandering killer seems to have come from the same brainless school of thought as his wife in basically drawing attention to himself. If he hadn't implicated Ricky with his own "evidence", Ellie might never have got the pieces together. He'd have been better staying in France. Did Claire just want her husband to come back for a bit of angry sex? If she was so resolute in getting him convicted, why not just confess from the start: she can't have reasonably thought his prosecution wouldn't have seen her wind up locked up as well.

9. Who Else Was In France?

Red herrings are the natural enemy of the crime thriller viewer, particularly when the show is supposedly encouraging you to guess the killer yourself (something the show-makers admitted in the first season), and when they don't have an explanation, it's frustrating. When Lee and Claire faced off for some sex/a fight in the sea, the femme fatale made a seemingly throw-away comment about there being someone in France who knew Lee. It was clearly supposed to be a misdirected clue that Lisa was still alive, but then there was absolutely no explanation of what she meant, so the red herring feels like an unresolved point.

8. Why Was Alec So Adamant Lee Was The Killer?

Broadchurch Lee Alec Gif Aside from the fact that Claire flipped on her husband - presumably because he was unhinged by the murder (because the way the finale showed the crime suggested he wasn't really as sinister as everyone had been lead to believe) and she was scared - there wasn't much evidence available to Alec that Lee genuinely did it. Hardy actually did very little to solve the case, relying on Ellie's superior detective work to put the final pieces together, and he seems to have based his entire case on the fact that Lee was "a bit creepy". That in itself proved also to be misdirection, as the suggestion that Lee might be a paedophile turned out to be a nasty little lie (his attraction to Lisa might have been silly, but it was entirely legal), so what the hell was Hardy seeing in him to make him believe he was the killer? Was he supposed to be some sort of extra-sentient super-policeman?

7. What About The Text Messages Tom Deleted?

Though it wasn't explicitly investigated, it was fairly simple to join the dots together and assume that Tom was abused by Joe (if he was indeed the killer and a sex offender). That might explain why the boy seemed so haunted. But if that was the case, why not say it? The show didn't shy away from anything else as harsh, and it could have at least explained why Tom was seen to be deleting text messages and getting rid of his laptop. Now, without that spelled out, it looks like Tom has something to hide. Which again feeds in to the pertinent theory that Joe was covering for him.

6. What Did Paul The Priest Do?

Though he was always presented as a man of the cloth, Paul was one of the favourites to be unveiled as the killer in the first season (even at considerably shorter odds than Mark Latimer, in fact) and there's always been a suggestion that he has demons. By his own admission, Paul had a dark past, but he "turned away from it" towards the light, which helped him see the benefit in offering counsel to Joe. So what did he do? There was briefly a suggestion in the finale that he might be the one to deal with Joe after his release, but that turned out to mean considerably less than it could have, but that served only to highlight the fact that the question remains hanging open.

5. What Were The Secrets Joe Miller Threatened To Expose?

When the show was setting up Joe's claim for freedom, his assumed innocence - or at least his reluctance to go to prison - seemed to stem from his knowledge of everyone else's dirty secrets. He clearly believed they would be sufficient currency if push came to shove to get him cleared. Ok, so maybe he was simply being desperate and scrabbling for freedom, but Paul didn't seem to react like someone in the face of empty bluster, and then very little ended up being revealed about this apparent ball of secrets. In the end, it seems Mark's brief affair (which nobody knew about, unless Joe looked out of the window of the shack, while murdering Danny - which seems a bit rich) was the only real secret. Unless they just conveniently forgot it was in the script.

4. Will Joe Come Back?

While he was packed off in his taxi to Bournemouth by Paul, and spirited away to Sheffield by the Church (on some sort of priest social network), Joe has every reason not to believe that his exile from Broadchurch will be permanent. He shouldn't care what the residents will do to him, because as far as he's concerned, the law is on his side, and though his wife threatened him with death, he could quite easily report as much. And then there's the question of him being a genuine danger to children (something probably not lost in critics of the church's backing of shady figures in the past). If he was indeed the killer, then he's probably a paedophile (or at least that's how it should be viewed for the safety of others. Isn't just sending him away a little short-sighted of the Broadchurch mob?

3. Won't The Court Case Just Happen Again?

So, the "happy ending" for the Sandbrook case had the three murderous accomplices packed off to jail to face the consequences of having killed Lisa and Pippa. Surely nothing could go wrong, and they'll be imprisoned for a very long time. Except, they were brought to justice by pretty much the exact same methods that saw Joe Miller's case capitulate enough to turn his confession into a not guilty verdict. Has nobody learned anything? Won't the defence simply point out that Hardy had kept Claire in his own witness protection? That he'd entrapped Lee? That personal relationships definitely got in the way of the case? Expect all three to walk away if they enter Not Guilty pleas (and surely Claire will?) The long and short of it is that justice doesn't even matter in Broadchurch - which is sort of the point - it only matters that the Latimers felt peace (and "knew" the killer had been dealt with), and that Hardy didn't have to live with his guilt. As far as actual criminal justice is concerned, it's a secondary issue at most.

2. What Happens To Nige And Mark Now?

Surely someone is going to have to look at Mark Latimer a little more closely now that Joe has been cleared of the murder, and there's some compelling evidence to suggest he might have been involved (at least in the eyes of the jury)? And then there's Nige: accused of moving Danny's body by his own - admittedly unhinged - mother. If the court has "proved" that it wasn't Joe who moved the body, surely the police have a duty to look at all the other bald men in Broadchurch, even if his mother's testimony is under any doubt. So no matter how "happy" the ending looked, Mark's probably going to be at least questioned further by the police who fundamentally don't have a solution to the murder.

1. Where To Next?

Obviously the news that Broadchurch would be returning wasn't that much of a shock to anyone who had seen the rumours of a third season, but to see it confirmed was still a good thing for fans. Now, admittedly a lot of fans were put off by the dramatic shift in tone and pace from the first season, but the finale still pulled in good numbers and a generally positive critical response, so there's enough goodwill to keep the hype machine turning for the third season. The question now - which was deliciously posed at the end of the finale - is where next? Will Hardy take up a new job elsewhere? Will Ellie (the other confirmed returning character) go with him? Or is it all back to Broadchurch to investigate a new case (possibly Joe's return and a Who Shot Mr Burns-style scenario where everyone's implicated in his death)? Either way, it's going to be intriguing. Were you satisfied with the end of Broadchurch season two? Did you spot any other issues that weren't addressed? Share your thoughts in the comments thread below.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.