Doctor Who: 10 Great Writers For Future Series

New Doctor, new writers?

Cover Let's be honest- Doctor Who is in a rut. I cannot believe that Steven Moffat, as recently commented, planned everything from the beginning - that he intended everything that happened in Series 5 and 6 to be a direct consequence of what happened in Time of The Doctor. The show is convoluted, and though even more popular than ever before, it's nowhere near as engaging as it used to be. As wonderful as Matt Smith's performance was- truly one of the great Doctors- the writing has under-performed him from the start. Steven Moffat is one of modern television's great writers, the man behind such classics as Jekyll, Sherlock, Blink and The Empty Child. The man is a genius- have you seen His Last Vow yet? Simply incredible! So what's happened to the show he adores under his reign as showrunner? There's been many an argument asking this exact question- so rather than praise or criticise, all that will be said on the matter is that the show needs a major overhaul, especially now that one of Britain's greatest actors is in control of the TARDIS. Television is still considered to be the writer's domain. Yet the last few years of Doctor Who have been the same predictable boys' club- and Series 8 doesn't seem set to change. Yes, newcomer Jack Lothian is doing a script; Frank Cottrell Boyce is rumoured; and Phil Ford is finally being given his own episode after serving his time on The Waters of Mars, Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures. But once again we're getting scripts from Mark Gatiss, Chris Chibnall, Neil Gaiman, Neil Cross... whilst the aforementioned writers have produced perfectly fine scripts, even if some have been flawed, it's the same old writers- and all men. Whilst the show has been in a state of decline for the last 3 years, there's still every chance that Moffat will hit his stride now- but he needs to move away from his same old trusted writers and branch out into ventures new. After all, by casting Capaldi and hiring Ben Wheatley to direct the first 2 episodes of the next series, he's definitely heading in the right direction. Not every episode for Series 8 has yet had a confirmed writer, so it doesn't hurt to speculate who might have been offered the chance to come out with a script. Read on for 10 writers who have either never written for the show or haven't done so for quite a while. Everyone in the list would bring a breath of fresh air to a show that's become dangerously stale, despite the pedigree of the recurring writers.

10. Charlie Brooker

Charlie BrookerNotable Work: Dead Set, Black Mirror A self-professed fan of Doctor Who, Brooker is the lovechild of Chris Morris and Dennis Potter, and has previously said he'd be up for writing an episode of the show if approached. He is best known for his quick-witted, barbed-tongued criticisms of culture and current affairs on his variety of 'Wipe' programmes. However, the guy's matured leaps and bounds as both a writer and a showrunner in recent years- Black Mirror, and to an extent Dead Set, are two of the best dramas produced on British television for decades. They perfectly balance emotion, twisted humour and chillingly realistic social commentary. This is exactly the kind of thing that Doctor Who- a blockbuster family show all about big ideas- should be encouraging. Though Brooker's piercing scripts may need a little bit of censoring, but certainly not dumbing-down, there's no doubt that whatever he produces if hired for the show would be phenomenal. Even if it's flawed, it would be a damn sight more thought-provoking and exciting than what we've seen in the last couple of years of Doctor Who. It's hard to imagine what he'd come up with, but there's a good chance it'd be an emotional satire feeding on Capaldi's Malcolm Tucker persona without resorting to swearing. Getting Charlie Brooker to script even one episode of Doctor Who would be a massive coup and exactly the kind of refresher that Neil Gaiman provided with his first script, and Moffat provided when he was simply writing for the show and not running it.

9. Jane Goldman

Notable Work: Kick-Ass, The Woman in Black, X-Men: First Class Arguably the coolest writer in Britain working today. Goldman's scripts spark off the page, crackling with ingenuity, wit and heart. Plus, she's a massive nerd which is a great bonus. Goldman is the perfect blend of edgy and populist that the show needs. Her work on Stardust is a good indicator of the kind of tone she might strike if hired to write for Doctor Who. Goldman has stated before that she's a massive fan and would be worried of writing for something she adores. But as her star power increases and she produces classic after classic, it seems more likely she'd be willing to challenge herself and give the audience a unique episode or two. Her Stardust pal Neil Gaiman has already given it a shot, and at least with The Doctor's Wife proved to be a very safe bet. Whilst it's pointless comparing the two, perhaps Goldman might give us more of a horror-orientated episode closer in tone to The Woman in Black than her comic book movie fare. Then again, we may just get a far more comedic episode from Goldman- since its revival, the Doctor Who episodes that have been totally light-hearted and knockabout in tone have more often than not been awful. But with Goldman at the helm, it seems likely Moffat & co would have a winner on their hands.

8. Paul Cornell

Cornell WhoNotable Work: 'Father's Day', 'Human Nature/ The Family of Blood' This might seem like cheating, as Cornell has already written for the show. But it's been so long that he might as well be considered a new writer if offered the chance again. The scripts Cornell has written have been two of the best stories in the show's 50-year history, so bringing him back on board for another go seems like a no-brainer. Like Russell T Davies, Moffat, Mark Gatiss and other Doctor Who fans now working on the show he helped to keep it alive during the wilderness years of the 1990's with novels, comics and audio plays. He is as integral to its survival and resurrection as any of the other writers who have been writing scripts since 2005. By the time Series 8 hits our screens, it will have been 7 years since we've had a Paul Cornell script, and that's far too long. Now, Cornell is busier than ever. As well as writing his own drama pilot Pulse for BBC Three, he has been working on the new Wolverine comic series and wrote the hit novel London Falling, so it might be hard to fit into an episode into his schedule. Then again, Neil Gaiman's managed to knock out a script for the last two series, so it's not impossible...

7. Dan Harmon

Notable Work: Community, Rick and Morty, Monster House Dan Harmon is a god of Cult TV, and behind one of the best sitcoms to come out of America in ages. His love of Doctor Who is apparent in the spoof show Inspector Spacetime he created in Community- so why not give him a crack at the genuine article? Harmon can write, that much is obvious. Like, really write. His scripts are full of humour and heart, and some of his arcs and complex ideas ape even Moffat's. He's the perfect choice for a one-off episode, and one of television's more unique voices. He could certainly stand toe-to-toe with Moffat and challenge whatever the showrunner's overall vision is if it clashes with ideas Harmon might have. And that's not necessarily a bad thing for either man. One could even argue Harmon would be great as a showrunner (or at least a co-showrunner) in future years, despite being American. But that's another argument for another time. If he has his way, he'll be offering the show something surreal, heartfelt and oh-so witty. Out of everyone on this list, Harmon seems the most natural choice- and if Community isn't renewed for a Sixth Season (and a Movie), then there may just be enough time for him to squeeze it in.

6. Paul Abbott

Notable Work: State of Play, Shameless, Hit & Miss Paul Abbott is a writer whose work you definitely would have seen in the last decade- you simply couldn't avoid it! Be it the cracking miniseries State Of Play; cult pre-op-transsexual-assassin series Hit & Miss; or long-running dramedy Shameless, Abbott is perhaps more influential than even Russell T Davies and Steven Moffat. Like him or loathe him, Abbott's creations strike a balance between being controversial, relevant and relatable. And that is something the show needs- a bit of grounded relatability, regardless of whether or not you're a fan of the dark fairytale Doctor Who has become. The reason the show became such a huge hit upon it's return is that people could relate to Rose Tyler, what she was going through, and saw the incredible Universe of Doctor Who through her eyes. Even if it's just for one episode, Abbott would bring something intriguing to proceedings, placing Capaldi in a modern-day setting and having him tackle contemporary issues (not to pigeonhole a guy known for gritty drama, but...) Even if Abbott were to instead write a far-out adventure in deep space and chock full of aliens, you can guarantee that the dialogue would be marvellous and make us invest in whatever peril the characters might be going through. No, scratch that, definitely would be going through.

5. Abi Morgan

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WCt060Gh_dg Notable Work: The Hour, Shame, The Iron Lady, Birdsong, Brick Lane, Sex Traffic There's been a lot of hyperbole thus far in this list of talented writers, but Abi Morgan is included because she is one of Britain's most important writers. The Hour was one of the best dramas the BBC has aired in years. She's adapted one of the most beloved novels of all time. She wrote the devastating character study Shame, which contained Michael Fassbender's finest performance. She's courted controversy and opened dialogues on difficult issues. But her writing never feels message-driven or artificial. So it would be fascinating to plant a talent like Morgan in the domain of a 1000 year-old, time-travelling alien. What tone would be struck? Would it be even sweeter for Capaldi to utter her words a second time around (after previously appearing in The Hour)? Could we expect a horror, a romp or even a romantic drama? The show has managed to recruit some of the best writers working today- James Moran, Richard Curtis, Toby Whithouse, Robert Shearman... so it's high time that the production team made the effort to hire Morgan as soon as possible! It may be hard to do- even though The Hour was ruthlessly cancelled, Morgan has a variety of feature projects already on her slate- but it would be worth it.

4. Helen Blakeman

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cVmxjC-jfIA Notable Work: Pleasureland, Dustbin Baby Every name thus far on the list has probably been recognisable. So the next choice is no less prolific, but certainly not as well-known. Helen Blakeman is far more active as a Playwright, but her television work is worth serious merit. Pleasureland tackled taboos as it depicted a 14 year-old girl determined to lose her virginity in order to escape social pressure. Blakeman's last major work, an adaptation of Jacqueline Wilson's novel Dustbin Baby, is a seriously good children's drama. Up next for Blakeman is an adaptation of Jacqueline Wilson's novel Hetty Feather on CBBC. She's certainly shown herself to be the ideal person to do justice to Wilson's text... Blakeman's career draws some parallels with that of previous showrunner Russell T Davies- she's balanced controversial drama with soaps and high-quality work for Children's television. It would be silly to suggest her writing would be similar to Davies, but since both come from a similar sort of background in terms of TV writing. BAFTA-nominated, International Emmy Award-winner... Blakeman has some real pedigree as a writer for both children and adults. And whilst some of the choices on the list are a little unrealistic due to their fame or previous work, Blakeman is the most realistic choice suggested so far, and has the best chance of ending up as a writer for Doctor Who.

3. Graham Linehan

Notable Work: Father Ted, Black Books, The IT Crowd, Count Arthur Strong Many people have suggested Armando Iannucci write for the show, now that Peter Capaldi is The Doctor. And whilst that's a great idea, at the moment it seems both too obvious- he's a great writer and a fan of the show- and highly unlikely- he's extremely busy as the showrunner of HBO's Veep. So another choice of renowned comedy writer and über-nerd is Graham Linehan. Hiring a writer well-versed in comedy can go one of two ways- beautiful (Richard Curtis) or uneven (Simon Nye). But as well as being a seasoned veteran, Linehan also directs most of his own work, so has an advantage over a lot of writers. His comedy is always a treat, mixing subtle pathos with trouser-wettingly funny absurdity. Most of the time when you watch a Graham Linehan script, it feels like a live-action cartoon. Having someone as sophisticated, silly and passionate as Linehan write for Doctor Who is a very good move. He's well-known in a lot of circles, but nowhere near as internationally famous a writer as Abi Morgan or Jane Goldman, so he's a sensible choice. You just know that if he wrote for Capaldi, it would go down as one of the funniest episodes in the show's history. And for all we know, Linehan hides a darker side that he's been waiting to unleash on an opportunity like Doctor Who- that's something definitely worth pushing for.

2. Lucy Prebble

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1pP90sy574 Notable Work: Secret Diary of A Call Girl, Enron Lucy Prebble has been a showrunner herself, and a frequent collaborator with Billie Piper on both the critically-acclaimed play The Effect and Secret Diary Of A Call Girl- a seriously good drama worth checking out if you haven't already. In short, she is more qualified than most to write for the show. But Prebble is even more well-known for her play Enron, one of the most entertaining and sharp pieces of British theatre in a long while and is currently being developed for the big screen by George Clooney. This is a writer who looks set to explode into the stratosphere at any moment, so before she does it'd be a good idea to get her to write an episode. Like Helen Blakeman, Prebble is more prolific as a playwright, but this is a distinct advantage and a quality it'd be nice to see in more of Doctor Who now. It's hard to say what a Lucy Prebble-scripted episode would be like, but perhaps it might be some kind of satire- a funny and sexy affair (but not the kind of "sexy" that is forced, and has been embarrassingly present in Doctor Who for a while now). Prebble is also a journalist, and may bring the same bite to be expected from a Charlie Brooker script. As covered in Newsnight, towards the end of the classic run Doctor Who was distinctly political and anti-thatcherite. But at the same time, in terms of quality it was the strongest it had been in a while. Maybe writers like Prebble are exactly what the show needs to push it in a new direction with an older Doctor and a change of tone. With writing like that, it might even bring about a golden age of script for the show that we haven't seen since the early Tom Baker years.

1. Katie Baxendale

Katie Baxendale Notable Work: Sugar Rush Unfortunately, Katie Baxendale is perhaps the least well-known writer on the list. She has written for Eastenders, Fat Friends and The Paradise and is adapting Nick Hornby's terrific novel Slam for Channel 4. But Baxendale's best-know work as a writer is Sugar Rush, of which she is the creator. Adapted from the novel by Julie Burchill, Sugar Rush tells the story of a young lesbian living in Brighton who obsesses over a straight girl- it bagged Baxendale an international emmy and a BAFTA nomination. With a career trajectory very similar to Helen Blakeman, she seems a natural fit for Doctor Who. With Sugar Rush behind her, she stands out as a fantastic writer of Drama that can appeal to all ages. It's been far too long since she's been in the public eye for her work, and now is the time to bring her back into the spotlight. Any show that can get Katie Baxendale to write for it is a luck show indeed, and Doctor Who should be the next. In conclusion, Moffat-bashing is getting boring. He's a great writer, but to be perfectly honest the show has gotten stale. Let's hope he keeps to his promise and strips back Doctor Who for Capaldi's first series. No drawn-out arcs and less timey-wimey complex concepts crammed into 45 minutes. Series 8 and 9 will not be split, and there's every chance that this will be a golden era for Moffat as a writer- but he would help himself and the show by getting in a ton of new writers, and some of them women. Because it's the endless cycle of getting in the same old writers that have made the show predictable. The show's future is safe as the ratings have been increasing and the show is more popular than ever across the globe. Moffat is a smart guy and it seems he's ready to shake things up with Capaldi. But let's get some new writers in amongst the old, please!

Contributor
Contributor

Aspiring Director, Screenwriter and Actor. Film is my passion, but I indulge in TV, Theatre and Literature as well! Any comments or suggestions, please tweet me @IAmOscarHarding