Doctor Who: 10 Huge Moffat Plot Twists That Pose Bigger Questions

Damn you Steven Moffat, you're such a tease...

'The Time of the Doctor' is nearly upon us, as his fobwatch approaches Twelve. Matt Smith's tenure in the TARDIS is all but complete, and as we look to the future with Peter Capaldi, it's also a time to look back at the Eleventh Doctor. But if you're looking for sugary nostalgia here, I'll direct you now to the "X Reasons to Miss Matt Smith" articles. What about all the questions we still want answers to? Moffat loves a plot twist. He's known for them: he's brought the lead characters from both his big dramas back from what was almost certainly their death scene, and that's just the tip of the iceberg, twist-wise. Every twist creates a fissure in story-telling and we're hoping that Moffat will paper over the cracks in 'The Time of the Doctor'. Here are ten twists that left gaping questions; some of them will be resolved at Christmas, some of them we'll never know.

10. It's River That Kills The Doctor

We'd always guessed that it was River killed the Doctor; back in 'Flesh and Stone', Father Octavian practically confirmed it. I mean, who else was going to be the best man that she ever knew? But River's murder sentence did pose a big question: why didn't the Doctor break her out of prison permanently? Why would he ask someone he loved to rot in jail for something she didn't do? The Doctor's not perfect, and the guilt of his mistreatment to River is clear in 'The Name of the Doctor'. He clearly did love her, but he's never been that great in relationships, or with women in general to be honest; I mean, did he honestly not see how he was treating Martha? It would be nice though if Eleven could undo all those days that River waited for him. River seemed fiercely strong and independent, so it would be a shame if she never had a life outside her marriage.

9. The War Doctor

It's possibly the biggest twist since William Hartnell fell to the floor, only to wake up as Patrick Troughton. No one had dared insert another Doctor into the mythology of the show, and John Hurt was fantastic in the role. Why did no one ever hint at him before though? Yes, he was a secret, but his acts in the Time War weren't. Did no-one ever see this Doctor? He said he'd keep a low profile at the end of Series 6, but by Christmas, he was running from explosions; surely a Doctor who committed double genocide couldn't be that secret? Regardless of that though, it feels like we've missed out somewhat on some of the characterisation involved with this war-weathered incarnation. An audio drama starring Hurt is crying out, really; it would've been impossible to tie up so many threads in 'The Day of the Doctor' whilst keeping the story moving, but it would be nice to know a little more about him.

8. The Impossible Girl

Clara Oswald was born to save the Doctor, we know that much. But when she jumped into the Doctor's timeline, what actually happened? Why did we only meet her twice, if she was supposed to be saving him at every corner? How did she actually kill the Great Intelligence? How did she survive? A simple explanation might be that the Doctor only started hearing her when he needed her most, and he needed her as a friend most during the Ponds' departure. Maybe she survived thanks to River's connection with her, and maybe she never actually killed the Great Intelligence, she just created a paradox/resolved a paradox/timey-wimey thing that we don't understand. 'The Time of the Doctor' might not explain that, but maybe an episode next series might. More than likely though, Steven Moffat is leaving it to our imaginations. Which is a shame; there could be a whole story in there. It stretches over the course of the Doctor's timeline, after all...

7. The Doctor And Clara Escape The Timestream

...Which leads me onto another question posed in 'The Name of the Doctor': how did the Doctor and Clara go from the darkened valleys of his timestream, populated with his former selves, to a few months later? Surely Clara couldn't have studied for a PGCE teaching qualification in such a short period of time. The teaching aside, there's another story in there somewhere, surely €“ what about a minisode where we see how they escaped? It's a question that led a lot of us scratching our heads at the start of 'The Day of the Doctor' and it's, again, something that could really develop the relationship between Clara and the Doctor. So much of what they talk about €“ the Doctor always talks about "the day he did it" €“ Clara sometimes asks him what he dreams about - is offscreen. Why doesn't Moffat change that? It would've given us a chance to know that much more about the character, but it's been sadly missed out.

6. Gallifrey Stands

And to follow a complaint of 'The Day of the Doctor', let's have another one: what are the implications of Gallifrey standing? Moffat seemed to focus heavily on the children. If you ask me, the Doctor made the right decision to save his planet, and thinking of the children is an incredibly Doctor-like thing to do; but what about the High Council? What about the planet being in a state of warfare? And if the Doctor can still hop from one pocket universe to the next ('The Doctor's Wife', 'Hide'), can't the Time Lords? They were supposedly capable of parallel universe-hopping back in the day. A couple of lines of dialogue would've been enough to explain all of that, and maybe we'll still hear it. Perhaps Gallifrey is still time-locked. Perhaps the planet will sort itself out now there's not a war going on. Perhaps closing them in a smaller universe and reducing their power will be enough to change their ways. Or perhaps it doesn't matter, and it's giving them the chance that's important. Any way up, it still needs explaining.

5. Amy And Rory's Divorce

Okay, this is one that we'll never get an answer to. But just why did Amy and Rory get so close to divorce? It took them three to five minutes locked in an alien asylum to sort their differences, on their own; did they never talk about their problems before that? What gives Rory the right to throw his two thousand-year wait in Amy's face as proof that he loves her more? Can Amy not have kids because it's too mentally traumatic after last time? Or is there a medical reason? Again, for the sake of character development, it would've been nicer if 'Pond Life' had dedicated more time to these questions, and less time to the Ponds walking in on an Ood in their bathroom. Or, Moffat could've done away with breaking up the companions altogether, if it was only going to exist as a storyline for that one episode before never being mentioned again.

4. The "Woman In The Shop"

It's a question that everyone asked after 'The Bells of Saint John', along with the conundrums of the leaf, the mystery of Clara and the mention of Oswin. And whilst most of the mysteries have been solved, we still don't know who the woman in the shop was. I mean, I've listed it as a twist because it still could be a twist. Or could've been a twist, if people had correctly theorised that Rose - a known shop girl - gave Clara the number in 'The Day of the Doctor'. But could it be River? A version of Clara? Tasha Lem, the Doctor's "old friend" who appears in 'The Time of the Doctor'? Or maybe that's the Doctor's next mystery: searching for a new companion who hired the last one.

3. Amy Loses Her Baby

In an episode of twists, 'A Good Man Goes to War' threw up the same one twice,when it was revealed that Amy's baby was a ganger. The real Melody was far away by now, and Amy had lost her only child. So why wasn't more made of that? We never really saw the effect of that on Amy, which relates back to the point about the Ponds' divorce. Did she really sufficiently recover from losing her daughter to a space religion in time for 'Let's Kill Hitler'? Does this not alter the relationship she has with River? Does "bringing up" Mels make up for the horror of her baby melting in her arms? You could argue that none of that stuff is appropriate for a family show, but it's an important subject that shouldn't have been shied away from in the same way that Richard Curtis tackled Vincent van Gogh's demons head on. Even the new Hunger Games film makes reference to post-traumatic stress: a little detail on how Amy coped could've been a fascinating exploration into when the Doctor lets down his companions, and how he deals with the guilt of that.

2. The Doctor Deletes Himself From The History Books

"Oh, that is cool," Oswin boasted. "The Daleks, they have a hive mind. Well, they don't, they have a sort of telepathic web. I hacked into it. Did a mass delete." And since then, we've seen the Doctor show a blank on Solomon's system and River mention her pardon from Stormcage on the basis that the man she murdered never existed. Mr Clever teased the Doctor over the gaping holes in this plan, and a minisode has seen the Doctor go a step further, going to the Inforarium to completely erase all knowledge of himself. But where's this going? How do the Daleks catch up with him for 'The Time of the Doctor'? And most importantly, why did the Great Intelligence of all villains despise him so much as to corrupt his entire life? This is a creature made of information, is it not a paradox that they even know about him, let alone hate him? What exactly is going on here? Please Steven, explain...

1. The TARDIS Explodes

And finally, the big one: the unanswered mystery that has fuelled Doctor Who fans since Series 5. But Steven Moffat claims that he'll answer this one at Christmas, even though he's already said that it was the Silence. Assuming that their main goal was to ensure that "Silence will fall when the question is answered", and assuming that means "We don't want the Doctor to answer the question "Doctor who?" when the Great Intelligence try breaking into his tomb", that suggests that the Silence were trying to blow up the universe to save it from the Great Intelligence turning every one of the Doctor's victories to defeats. Basically, they wanted to prevent a universe without the Doctor. But that was before we knew they were returning; if the question was "Doctor who?" then why are they back? It's more complex than we originally thought, or more simple, giving the convoluted way with which the last paragraph unravelled. Do you have any answers to any of these though? Do you have any questions I haven't touched upon? Do you know where the Stetson went? Comments below are always welcome.

Contributor
Contributor

Mark White hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.