Doctor Who: All 17 Series 7 Episodes & Special Ranked

The highs and lows of Matt Smith's finale series in the Tardis.

With the 50th anniversary year now at a close and Series 8 not arriving on our screens until later on this year, it's a good time to look back and reflect on Matt Smith's last series as the Doctor. To say it was a polarizing series is a bit of an understatement: some loved it, and others quite openly hated it. We saw the loss of two partners, a new companion and an underlying mystery of "The Impossible Girl," and there were some stunningly memorable moments along the way. Overall, most complaints arose from the disconnected feel of the episodes, because more than anything, it was very much a "monster of the week" series. Personally, I liked that approach - not all episodes were fantastic but there were some very good ones, and in the interest of celebrating both the highs and lows of the series, we're ranking every episode in Series 7, as well as the 50th and Christmas specials separately. Of course, a spoiler warning is in place. So, here goes...

13. The Rings Of Akhaten - Neil Cross

It's with slight trepidation that I put this episode at the bottom of my list: it was an episode loved my many and hated by the rest and it certainly sparked some controversy within the fandom. For me, the only redeeming feature of this episode was the final act, with the remainder of the episode being populated by underused villains and a fairly uninteresting plot, which is a fairly catastrophic short-coming. I still wish to this day that The Vigil were the main villains of this episode, their whispered voices of "where are you?" being fairly creepy, and definitely raising more than a few goosebumps. Although the market place and monster designs were amazing and the speech at the end is truly one of Matt's best moments, the rest of the episode just doesn't really hold up, which is truly a shame.

12. The Power Of Three - Chris Chibnall

The Power Of Three was an incredibly exciting prospect, and thankfully the first two thirds of this episode were brilliant, an enticing mystery, the return of U.N.I.T and the Doctor staying at home with the Ponds.

But then, the reveal of what the cubes were was, on the whole, pretty disappointing. Chibnall could have done literally anything with these cubes and he chose to have them deliver electrical pulses. Surely there could have been a greater revelation with more impact?

The Shakri were an interesting reveal but that came far too late into the episode. And on their subject, whatever happened to the other humans on board the ship? Who were the strange doctors with box mouths and what were they doing?

This episode also suffers from the sonic screwdriver resolution, as all the Doctor does to stop this big threat is to scan a screen. If there was ever an example of Doctor Who needing hour long episodes it was The Power Of Three.


11. Journey To The Centre Of The TARDIS - Stephen Thompson

What a premise for an episode: finally we thought we would get to see the inner workings of the TARDIS, and did we? Well... kind of: we did get a brief glimpse into the swimming pool, an Avatar style tree, a gorgeous library and eye of harmony and my favourite of all, the engine room in suspended explosion. It gets harder to place episodes when they are all of about the same quality, but the one thing that really brings down this episode though is the supporting cast. The Van Baalen brothers were bland to say the least. Quite how the three actors were cast is baffling; the awkwardness with which they deliver the lines is just astounding. It does have some good monsters, with the reveal that they are future versions of everyone on board a good payoff. The deus ex machina resolution does leave a lot to be desired, but doesn't feel like too much of a cheat.

10. Nightmare In Silver - Neil Gaiman

Oh how I wish I could place this episode near the top; part of me is trying to hold back from putting it this low down but I have to. Don't get me wrong, I like the episode but this has the same case of poor actors as Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS did. Those darn kids... Warwick Davis is brilliant, Matt Smith is at the top of his game as usual but it really says something when two characters have been cyberized they are more tolerant than when normal. Having said that, the central theme of the chess game between the Doctor and Mr Clever is brilliant, with Smith really selling the performance. Perhaps if this hadn't been marketed as purely a Cyberman episode people would have been less disappointed, but then Neil Gaiman was bound to do something different. The new Cybermen are actually a threat, they blow up a planet just to get rid of them, but there's something about that resolution that was a bit too easy. Perhaps if the episode had more time to explore the Emperors inner conflict it might have been more satisfying.

9. The Bells Of St. John - Steven Moffat

This episode had a hard job, it had to introduce Clara for the third time, provide a good story for her to be involved in, and convince audiences that Clara is a worthy companion. For what it sets out to do, it does it well, with the plot falling a bit flat at times. The big bad of the "spoonheads" and the sentient WiFi perhaps isn't as scary as it's meant to be, and doesn't provide much of a threat. Saying that, the scene in which the Doctor and Clara stop the plane from crashing into the street is excellent. Clara is fine too, but all the way through the episode I had a nagging feeling that I would be preferring this a whole lot more if it was Victorian Clara. It could have been so interesting and unique to have a historical companion in new who but once again we have a modern day girl from London. She also doesn't do much besides hacking the computer and drinking tea but Coleman and Smith do have excellent chemistry. It's not bad by far, but could have had a bit more oomph.

8. A Town Called Mercy - Toby Whithouse

One thing about this episode that must be said about this episode is that the music was absolutely fantastic. Now I've got that mild love affair off my chest, onto the episode itself. To be honest, there's not much to say other than it was a solid if not exactly spectacular episode. The morals surrounding the Gunslinger and why he can't enter the town were a bit sketchy at times but other than that A Town Called Mercy was a good and engaging experience. The darker themes surrounding it show off more of the Eleventh Doctor's darker side, and how he doesn't mind using a gun or being more violent than his predecessor. The Gunslinger and Kahler Jex are also good as villains, with some heavy hitting themes running throughout. But it's just missing a little spark to really push it up the ranks.

7. Dinosaurs On A Spaceship - Chris Chibnall

I do have a soft spot for this one - it's a fun romp with dinosaurs that also involves the Doctor's darker side, and what more could you want? Mark Williams is exceptional as Brian, his character providing most of the laughs but also most of the heart. The shot of him eating sandwiches and drinking tea while looking over the Earth is really quite beautiful, and having him traveling the world was a nice touch as well. The gang that the Doctor assembles is also fun, letting Amy lead a team and show off her companion skills. The dinosaurs looked great too, with the showdown between Amy, Riddell and the raptors being a highlight of the episode. Some plot points were a bit to convenient, such as the teleporters burning out and the fact that only Rory and his Dad could pilot the ship but overall great, fun.

6. The Angels Take Manhattan - Steven Moffat

The final episode with the Ponds was most certainly going to have to live up to a lot of hype. Did it deliver? To some people yes, and to others not at all. The use of the Weeping Angels was heavily criticized, saying they had become tired and boring.The cherubs did shake them up a bit and provide some creepy moments but they didn't really do anything. River Song is back for no apparent reason also, even if she is vital to the plot and fairly interesting. Some plot points on the other hand make no sense such as the Statue of Liberty, which was really just done to be iconic. Despite its flaws, I've put it in this position because of the Ponds. Their goodbye is so heartbreaking and so well done that it's all but impossible not to praise it. Amy chooses Rory over the Doctor and they're gone, just like that. Everyone's performance is amazing, and I am not ashamed to say that this episode still brings a tear to my eye whenever I watch it. The film noir style of the episode provided a brilliant atmosphere, and that one smiling angel offered an enduringly creepy image...

5. Hide - Neil Cross

Having watched The Rings Of Akhaten, to say I didn't really have high hopes for Hide was a bit of an understatement, but boy was I wrong. The episode was excellent, and it gave a really chilling atmosphere, perfectly blending a ghost story with sci fi with seamless execution. The sections inside the house were suitably creepy and tense, with great atmosphere and the supporting cast were also interesting, providing a nice comparison to the Doctor/Companion dynamic. Hide was also a well-paced episode (until the end), and the use of time travel to see the whole life cycle of the Earth was a nice touch, and allowed Clara to get some nice dialogue when telling the Doctor that "we're all ghosts to you". In all honestly, the ending with the monsters in love was largely unnecessary, feeling tacked on and provided a rushed feeling to the end of what was otherwise, a really good episode of Who.

4. Cold War - Mark Gatiss

Cold War, is in my opinion, an underrated episode: it kicks off with action right from the start and never lets go, and the Ice Warrior is brilliant. The menace that it brings actually feels like a real threat, as it picks off crew members in a way very reminiscent of Alien. Both Professor Grisenko and Captain Zhukov are enjoyable as well, and the scene between Clara and Grisenko as he asks about Ultravox a nice change of pace from the frantic nature of the episode. It sets out to do what Dalek did in 2005, and although it's not as good as Dalek it does do it well. The setting is gorgeous too, the sinking submarine providing a claustrophobic atmosphere in which this tank of a martian is running riot. The decision to show what the Ice Warriors truly look like was a big risk and it mostly payed off, even if the CGI looking a little bit dodgy. On a side note, if you own the Series 7 DVD or Blu Ray the commentary to this episode is brilliant.

3. The Crimson Horror - Mark Gatiss

With The Crimson Horror, the revived series of Doctor Who reached 100 episodes, and it was a great way to spend it. With the interesting decision to have Vastra, Jenny and Strax as the main focus of the episode, Mark Gatiss does what he does best and gives us a hammer horror-esque tale of purity and small red leeches. You have to suspend your disbelief a bit to believe that the rocket could have been built in those times but other than that it's another solid script from Gatiss. Dame Diana Rigg and Rachel Stirling are excellent as Mrs. Gillyflower and Ada, Gillyflower being a classic mad villain with an interesting motive. Jenny gets more time to show off in this episode, as she goes off investigating inside the "factory", and I for one hope to see more of her and Vastra develop over the coming years. Strax again is used mainly for comic relief but it still isn't old, him simply behaving like a typical Sontaran is still brilliant, and all three bouncing off each other really works. Just one gripe: the sat-nav joke... really?!

2. Asylum Of The Daleks - Steven Moffat

What a way to start a series: in an attempt to make the Daleks scary again we got Asylum of the Daleks, a wonderful Dalek story, and an episode that set up themes that would continue through the series. The Asylum itself was an eery enough setting, throwing in damaged and insane Daleks really did the trick though. Sure there weren't as many classic Daleks as one would have hoped but at least we saw a brief glimpse of the Special Weapons Dalek. The main point of this episode was to introduce us to Oswin/Clara, and truly shocked us all when the new companion appeared in the 1st episode. Then it turned out she was a Dalek, and then she got blown up - it certainly got us all talking that's for sure. My major gripe about this episode is the divorce subplot that appeared out of nowhere: the only background we got to this was the final episode of Pond Life, and even then it wasn't that fleshed out and kind of an unnecessary addition to the episode. The Dalek servants were also chilling, the eye stalk cracking out of the skull is really a terrifying sight.

1. The Name Of The Doctor - Steven Moffat

I feel like this is somewhat of a controversial decision, but I'm keeping it at the top. No other episode of Doctor Who has ever made me shout at the television, but at the end of this dark and somber finale the reveal of John Hurt made me jump up and shout "WHAT?!" in both excitement and glee, my heart was racing. The Name Of The Doctor isn't a particularly action packed episode, but the threat is very real here. Moffat could have easily given us the Doctor's name, and I think there was a bit in all of us that was waiting for it to come for the entire duration. The Whispermen are fantastic also, the rhyming couplets that they speak in really adding to the atmosphere of the situation. River Song returns yet again, and her presence is very welcome; the final conversation between her and the Doctor being very emotional, and giving us a further look into the Doctor's character. The resolution to the "Impossible Girl" story arc was also well handled, and enabled us to get some lovely montages using past footage of all the Doctors. I don't believe that any other episode has cause more internet speculation, or ever will. With Series 7 done, now it's time for the specials...

The Specials

4. The Doctor, The Widow And The Wardrobe - Steven Moffat

Yes this counts as Series 7, if it's in the box-set then it counts. This somewhat enchanting tale that is very reminiscent of Narnia was let down slightly by lack of any real villain and a bit of a weak plot. It was fun to watch and had a nice ending but other than that, it was fairly forgettable. The scene in which the Doctor is showing off his adjustments to the house is probably the best part of it, the lemonade taps and the hammocks really showing of the Doctor's personality. Another highlight comes when the Doctor returns to Amy and Rory, and we get a heartfelt reunion between the old friends. And who could forget the happy crying? It was a truly touching, human moment.

3. The Snowmen - Steven Moffat

The 2nd Christmas Special on this list, the Snowmen was the first episode to fully feature Clara as a companion, and as stated before I still wish it was this Clara who was in Series 7. We also saw a different side to the Doctor, after having lost his beloved Ponds he retreats to the clouds with his new-look TARDIS. The stairs leading up to the clouds is definitely an iconic image, and brings back the more fairytale element of the Eleventh Doctor's tenure. The Great Intelligence is a good villain, and Sir Ian McKellen as the voice is inspired. Vastra, Jenny and Strax are again a welcome addition to the team and provide some good laughs as always. The mystery of the Impossible Girl is put on the back burner here, so we get to see Clara as more of a person in this episode. Clara's inquisitive nature and ability to rival the Doctor was most welcome, and it's a shame some of the better character traits didn't rub off on modern day Clara.

2. The Time Of The Doctor - Steven Moffat

Let me get this out of the way: I loved it, but boy, were the fan-base up in arms. Well, half of them were at least, while the other half were praising it and crying. Or was everybody crying? The Time of the Doctor is a fitting end for Matt Smith: even if it is perhaps a little too rushed, it offered a story that wrapped everything up in a neat bow. Themes that had been present for the last four years ran through this episode, with the Eleventh Doctor ultimately meeting his end by his body becoming too weak, and receiving a brand new cycle of regenerations. And really, how else were they going to do it? His final monologue was touching, as he looked back on the past but also looked to the future, and Capaldi's first moments were frantic and fun. I'm not going to change anyone's minds about this episode by writing this but for me, Smith went out in style.

1. The Day Of The Doctor - Steven Moffat

Was it going to be anything else? The Day of the Doctor was spell-bounding, and gave us a great twist that changes up the show from the more guilty Doctor to one of hope. The decision to bring back Gallifrey was a good one, and even if it doesn't sit well in your stomach there's no denying how awesome the scene with all 13 Doctors in was. Smith and Tennant had fantastic chemistry, and John Hurt completely sold me on being the Doctor. The Zygon subplot that mirrors the time war is also interesting, even if it doesn't have a proper resolution. A big risk was taken with this and it really did pay off. If you saw it in cinemas in 3D then there were no compromises there either, everything looked glorious. It didn't spend any time brooding on foreshadowing Smith's exit either, which I feel is a wise choice. A worthy episode of the 50th anniversary, here's hoping that the task of finding Gallifrey is one that isn't brushed over in one season with Capaldi. Think an episode should be higher or lower? Feel free to share your thoughts in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Jake lives in a small town in England with nothing much to do besides watch far too much television, play games and occasionally have a cup of tea. His favourite things to do are play the guitar and eat scones. Follow him at @_jakelennon if you wish.