Doctor Who 50th Anniversary: Did It Deliver?

Welcome Doctor Who fans to the final article of my 50th Anniversary year retrospective! As I write this, Matt Smith has departed, regenerating into Capaldi's 12th Doctor and 2013 is finally closing the door on the first five decades of the show. As to what's next...well there's always that uncertainty over what a new Doctor will bring...but with the revelations of 'The Name Of The Doctor-Day Of The Doctor-Time Of The Doctor trilogy, those changes look set to accelerate the show in a whole new direction. Before I conclude my retrospective, giving my thoughts on the Christmas Special and where Doctor Who might go next in 2014, here's a recap of everything I have covered so far: Doctor Who 50th Retrospective Part 1: New writers / producers, series 7b, Classic Doctor rumours, Matt Smith's departure announced and his replacement in Peter Capaldi, the many, many rumours as to who might join the Tardis as the 12th Doctor, the recovery of missing episodes, the resurgence of Patrick Troughton's 2nd Doctor and all the celebrations across the globe... Doctor Who 50th Retrospective Part 2: The long-awaited return of Paul McGann in Night Of The Doctor, the 50th anniversary trailers, more missing episode rumours and the first BBC special; Science Of The Doctor. Doctor Who 50th Retrospective Part 3: My review of all the anniversary specials; Big Finish's The Light At The End, Mark Gatiss's beautiful dramatisation of the creation of Doctor Who in An Adventure In Space And Time, and of course The Day Of The Doctor itself, complete with my thoughts on seeing it at the cinema in 3D. So with that vast wealth of information, speculation and review covered, let's conclude my look at the 50th anniversary year of Doctor Who!

Time Of The Doctor: My Review

Dr Who Totd I have to admit, the thought of a regeneration episode at Christmas wasn't something I immediately looked forward to. David Tennant's The End Of Time had left a bit of a bad taste in my mouth. As brilliant as the Tenth Doctor was, I didn't particularly enjoy his swan song; the main reason was that it just wasn't any fun at all. Had it been on at any other time of the year, I might have enjoyed it more...but what I've come to love from Christmas specials is the fun of it all; the ingenious festive themes, from a Dickensian planet (complete with flying sharks) to killer Christmas trees and snowmen. So, having enjoyed the many dark themes introduced through Matt Smith's era (the Silence, the cracks in space), I was apprehensive about these plot liens coming to a head at Christmas. And while I loved many, many things about The Time Of The Doctor, if there was one fault I could find, it was that it wasn't the kind of festive episode for casual viewers. Christmas episodes always get higher viewing figures and I'm sure there were many people asking Silence Will fall? The Kovarian sect? What on Earth is that? But for me, a fan that has followed every episode since the show came back in 2005 (and then watched masses of Classic Who over the last 3-4 years), The Time Of The Doctor was a fantastic episode that nicely rounded up the epic Name / Day / Time Of The Doctor Trilogy. And it was epic, as the 50th anniversary was deserving of. It tied up all the main story strands that had followed the show since The Eleventh Hour, making for a satisfying four years of television. I'll focus more on those threads on the next page, but here I wanted to capture some of the other moments that made this episode so good. Jenna Coleman and Matt Smith were never better than they were here (and they were bloody good in The Day Of The Doctor!!!). The scene as they watch the sunrise over Christmas (a rather saccharine place...but hey it was a Christmas special) is beautifully moving, particularly Clara's desperate plea to convince the Doctor to change his fate. While I would have liked more of a build up to the Doctor's death (knowing that he had no more regenerations), this scene certainly shone despite a lack of build-up. If anything, I would rather have Moffat had not announced that The Eleventh was in fact the last Doctor in the build up to the Christmas special. It would have a lovely revelation here...something my wife, who was unspoiled by that nugget of 'news', appreciated. I mean...its bad enough when the tabloids leak spoilers, but the man in charge? That being said, I'll still forgive Moffat because he delivered on all angles. A very personal journey for the Doctor here. Another great female character in Tasha Lem. The brilliant culmination of the 'Silence Will Fall' story line and a great throw back to the Doctor's worst fear in series six's 'The God Complex'. (The cracks). The brilliant Angels in the snow sequence that was better than anything they did in The Angels Take Manhattan. Silence versus Daleks; they're good now???!!!!! The wooden cyberman. Handles; how can you make a Cyberman's head dying sad? Because it was! Very much the Wilson of Doctor Who! Credit too for introducing the potential return of Gallifrey last month and linking it right back to the origins of the Eleventh Doctor's story. Whether it was all planned in advance or not (I think the final Doctor story line wasn't as he was clearly trying to regenerate at Lake Silenco in The Impossible Astronaut) Moffat brought every full circle and closed off all those plot points he has teased. And some of the very best music Murray Gold has ever produced for the show. The reprise of the theme from the Rings Of Akhaten as the Eleventh Doctor regenerated was truly emotive; topped only by the cameo of Amy Pond to say goodbye to her 'raggedy man'. Matt Smith's stunning final speech and the blink and you'll miss it regeneration into Peter Capaldi's Doctor. An amazing final five minutes. I would discuss it more, but fellow Whatculture writer Mark White has already summed up the 10 most beautiful things about he Time Of The Doctor. Instead, I'll finish of my review by saying that with the best performances yet from Smith and Jenna, the best music from the show, plenty of festive cheer in the town of Christmas and a strong resolution of the Silence story line, Moffat has closed off the Eleventh Doctor's tenure with one hell of a bang! And talking of a bang...wasn't the poem from Clara's cracker just priceless?

The End Of An Era: Were Those Unanswered Questions Resolved?

Whether a Christmas special was the right place to tie up the Eleventh Doctor's story threads or not, we did get the main answers we need. I'm sure audiences will continue to question little things here or there but personally I felt satisfied, knowing that all the big plot points had reached a resolution. In true Doctor Who timey wimey fashion, the story threads jump back all over the place between The Eleventh Hour and The Time Of The Doctor, so I'm boldly attempting to put in in some form of chronological order... The Doctors saved Gallifrey in the final moments of the Time War, locking it in another alternate universe. The cracks in time and space allow Gallifrey to send a message to the Doctor, only it attracts all the worst elements of the universe. Fortunately the Papal Mainframe gets there first, blocks the planet Trenzalore and thus stops the Doc tor from answering the oldest question - Doctor Who? The revelation of his name will allow the Timelords to return to the Galaxy and start Time War II. The siege of Trenzalore begins. The Doctor is forced to defend Trenzalore from his enemies, knowing this is the only chance to bring Gallifrey back, but knowing it will start the war again. The Papal Mainframe changes the nature of its religion to 'Silence Will Fall'; their mission to stop the Doctor saying his name. The Kovarian sect. unhappy with how things are progressing, travel back through the Doctor's timeline, intended to stop the Doctor ever getting to Trenzalore. They create the Pandorica, only it goes a little wrong and the galaxy is destroyed as the Tardis explodes, creating cracks in space and time. Ironically it is the creation of these cracks that allow Gallifrey to send their message in the first place. The Kovarian sect step up their game plan. Aided by rogue Silence, they infiltrate Earth and kidnap Amy and Rory's baby River, turning her into an assassin that will kill the Doctor. The Doctor is apparently killed by River Song at lake Silenco. The Kovarian Sect, along with the rest of the universe, believe the Doctor dead. Instead the Doctor outwits them, marries his assassin and sort of goes into hiding. The Doctor eventually reaches Trenzalore in the future when fighting the Great Intelligence. (Then we head back to point 1: I told you it was timey wimey!) As to the Eleventh actually being the last of the Doctors...well that is bigger than one Doctor's story. Which takes us onto the next page...

50 Years Of Doctor Who: How Was The Show Defined In 2o13?

Even more so than three series and one special, the 50th anniversary year impacted the course of the entire show. Some might argue that Moffat went beyond his tenure as show runner, playing with events that came before and after his 'reign'. But then I would argue that he had the vision to consider the scope of the 50th anniversary and make something suitably epic. It is only now, with the viewing of The Time Of The Doctor, that we can see just how epic it truly was. As before, let me pick out some of the big events that changed the course of the show forever. The Time War: If there was ever a moment when this mythical conflict deserved some focus, it was the 50th anniversary. From the birth of the War Doctor in Night Of The Doctor to the final battle of Gallifrey. The line of Doctors. Meta Crisis 10th Doctor counted. Furthermore, we had John Hurt's 'Doctor', a pivotal figure not just in the Doctor's timeline, but in the history of Gallifrey and the universe itself. Matt Smith's Doctor was the last Doctor...and what a life he had, outliving all his previous incarnations. Clara, the impossible girl, was pivotal to every Doctor, not just the final incarnation. She helped the First Doctor and Susan pick the infamous Tardis. She helped every version fight the influence of the Great Intelligence. She stopped the War, Tenth and Eleventh Doctor from committing the genocide of Gallifrey and she was the one who convinced the Timelords to give her Doctor a whole new set of regenerations. Possibly the most important companion in the history of Doctor Who. What's more, these events have had long lasting consequences for the show. The mission to find Gallifrey will be an important theme in the show as it moves into its 51st year and beyond. And with a whole new set of regenerations, the actors who will eventually take on the mantle of the Doctor past Peter Capaldi is endless...

Where Might The Show Go Next?

Series 8 is as much the next chapter for the entire show as it is the Twelfth Doctor. The aforementioned hunt for Gallifrey will certainly form an ongoing arc, I imagine much like the Silence / Trenzalore in Matt Smith's tenure. But what else? For a start, we are going to be faced with a very different Doctor. Possibly one with the gruffness of Hartnell and the superiority of Pertwee. As interesting a choice as Peter Capaldi is, we don't know exactly what traits he will bring the titular role. Okay, so he can't remember how to fly the Tardis but how else might he react? Particularly that unlike the Eleventh Doctor, he has a whole new lease of life. Furthermore, how will he react to Clara? She is no longer his impossible girl. Instead she has proven time and time again that she has been a valuable ally both at Trenzalore and the Time War itself. Not forgetting the whole saving every version of the Doctor from the machinations of the Great Intelligence. More so, they had a best mate relationship with a touch of flirty; I think that dynamic may change with a new older, possibly angrier Doctor. The great thing is that Clara has proven to be an excellent companion over the last few adventures (pretty much every time Moffat wrote for her).A few months back I wrote about all the new possibilities for Clara. Now that her mystery is solved, there are plenty of opportunities for her to continue on as a great companion. As to what else we might expect? Well it has been confirmed that we're getting a 12-episode series 8 without breaks (hooray!) and the usual Christmas special in 2014. As to the direction it might take, well M0ffat has announced "So now we've got to actually get a bit raw at it and do it in a different direction. It happens on every show €“ you get good at it and 'good at it' is the enemy in the end." Two / multi-parters perhaps? (Possibilities of an opening two-parter seem likely and I certainly miss cliffhangers) More zygons? (Moffat also teased that he would like to pick up where they left off in The Day Of The Doctor). The cybermen seem to be building up to becoming an unstoppable force - I'd certainly be interested to see if they get back to the menace they were back in Troughton's era. The Master perhaps? I suspect given that the events of The End Of Time seemed to immediately precede the 50th special and he might be the enemy to return alongside the Timelords. We're getting the Paternoster gang back. Yay! And I'd be really interested to see how Alex Kingston's River Song interacts with Peter Capaldi's Doctor. The truth is, the possibilities for Doctor Who post-50th are boundless. And I don't know about you, but I'm excited to see where the show goes next. Click on the next page for the conclusion of my four-part retrospective...

The 50th Anniversary Year: Looking Back, Did It Deliver?

Dr Who All Doctors Right back in my retrospective part 1 I mused that fans were never going to be totally satisfied. Expectations were impossibly high; maybe if there had been a new episode on EVERY SINGLE day in 2013, EVERY CLASSIC DOCTOR had returned (including those beyond the grave!!!), and ALL the lost black and white episodes were found, then perhaps we might have been happy! In truth, it wasn't the year-long celebration we were promised. So much of 2013 was a waiting game. Series 7b seemed to be done before it had even started and left us with a cliffhanger (introducing John Hurt as The Doctor) that was agonising. There was so much speculation and rumour. The biggest of course, was the tantilising tid bits of news that was the discovery of missing episodes. Over a hundred we were promised. We didn't really believe that. But almost two complete Patrick Troughton serials That was something I think no one quite believed would ever happen. The cynic in me might ask - isn't it a massive coincidence that they returned in the anniversary year? Still, fan manipulation or not, it was an awfully good 50th birthday present! And then in November, we finally got to see some of that magic we were promised. Classic Doctors in the hilarious 5ish Doctors and of course Big Finish's wonderful The Light At The End. The magical An Adventure In Space And Time, exploring the show's origins and the explosive special The Day Of The Doctor, which was a great cinema experience. Though for me, possibly the biggest surprise was the return of Paul McGann's Eighth Doctor in The Night Of The Doctor. It might have only been seven minutes long, but it was glorious. And like any good Doctor Who article writer as Whatculture, I was immediately on hand to speculate 5 Ways To Bring Back Paul McGann For More On Screen Adventures. And then we had a glorious end to Matt Smith's tenure at Christmas, just to round everything off nicely. Did the 50th anniversary year deliver? The epic-ness of the 'Name / Day / Time Of the Doctor' trilogy, An Adventure In Space And Time, Paul McGann, new Patrick Troughton stories and the global cinema experience that was Day Of The Doctor. All worthy of the 50th celebrations...but in truth it was less a year and more a few weeks. I find myself reaching the end of 2013 satisfied that Doctor Who has delivered. Would I have preferred more episodes? Certainly. I think there were too many gaps in 2013 where nothing was happening. Still, where was the budget ever going to come for a year's worth of celebration? At the end of the day I am going to remember watching Day Of The Doctor in 3D at the cinema, with my son wielding his sonic screwdriver and fans dressed up in costume, for a long time. And if nothing else, that was worth celebrating alone!

Contributor
Contributor

A writer for Whatculture since May 2013, I also write for TheRichest.com and am the TV editor and writer for Thedigitalfix.com . I wrote two plays for the Greater Manchester Horror Fringe in 2013, the first an adaption of Simon Clark's 'Swallowing A Dirty Seed' and my own original sci-fi horror play 'Centurion', which had an 8/10* review from Starburst magazine! (http://www.starburstmagazine.com/reviews/eventsupcoming-genre-events/6960-event-review-centurion) I also wrote an episode for online comedy series Supermarket Matters in 2012. I aim to achieve my goal for writing for television (and get my novels published) but in the meantime I'll continue to write about those TV shows I love! Follow me on Twitter @BazGreenland and like my Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/BazGreenlandWriter