Doctor Who: Ranking Debut Doctor Stories From Worst To Best

1. Spearhead From Space - The Third Doctor

How could it not be? From the outset it€™s absolutely game-changing stuff. The new Doctor, is exiled on earth by the Timelords after being on trial (see The War Games), he€™s managed to get himself roped into U.N.I.T (United Nations Intelligence Taskforce) his companion is (almost) his intellectual equal, he€™s got a tattoo and he€™s driving a car!? That€™s just onscreen. Offscreen, there€™s a new production team, new lead actor, new €œcompanions€ and the return of several actors from previous stories. Oh and it€™s also the first Doctor Who of the 1970€™s. Oh and it€™s the first Doctor Who that€™s broadcasted in colour. Oh and it€™s shot entirely on film (as opposed to film and video€ it€™s technical stuff) thanks to a BBC production screw up. Of course those aren€™t the only reasons why it€™s at number one. It€™s at number one because it€™s stone cold brilliant. Jon Pertwee€™s Doctor is absolutely mesmerizing, Caroline John€™s performance as scientist Liz Shaw€™s equally brilliant, and Nicholas Courtney€™s Brigadier is as sharp and dashing as he always is. U.N.I.T is very homespun and quaint by todays standards, and it hasn€™t quite reach it€™s potential yet.The concept of the Nestene Intelligence as devised by Doctor Who genius Robert Holmes is so dark and fascinating, despite being so basic. An alien life form that can manipulate plastic to give it life in order to carry out it€™s needs is so firmly based in science fiction, but is also so close to home that it feels genuinely scary. The only slight down point is the confrontation with the Nestene, which features The Doctor doing some incredible facial expressions whilst being strangled by unexplained tentacles, being watched by a perplexed Liz Shaw. On the whole it€™s an absolutely wonderful story, and it€™s a wonderful introduction to a wonderful Doctor. Most fans of the classic era will say that Season 7 (1970) is the best in the show€™s history (see also The Silurians, The Ambassadors of Death and Inferno), and they€™re probably right.
Contributor
Contributor

Massive Doctor Who fan, guitarist, chubby fella with a passion for long coats and heavy metal. Journalism graduate, and comedy fascist. Occasionally spotted in dark alleys dressed as The Undertaker. Tweet me.