Doctor Who: 10 Best NuWho Recurring Characters
The ones who just can't stay away.
When someone mentions the TARDIS team, most fans' first thought is likely to be of a Doctor and his companion or companions. For example, the team of Eleven, Amy and Rory, or Five, Nyssa, Tegan and Adric. However, there have been a number of characters who pop up every now and again as enemies or allies who augment this team. One of the most famous examples of this during the Classic Series was the Brigadier, who first appeared alongside the Second Doctor and then had adventures with Four, Five and Seven as well as being a series regular during the Third Doctor's reign.
However, having lots of returning characters has been especially true of the new series. This is thanks to a number of reasons, most notably the companions' families getting a stronger focus in the Russell T Davies years, the groups of the Doctor's allies cropping up during Steven Moffat's time in charge and the recurring allies from both eras of the show.
Each recurring character has added something extra to the show that has helped it to rise to its current popularity. As such, many have become firm fan favourites and here's our defintive countdown of 10 of the very best so far, analysing just what makes them so appealing.
10. Osgood (Ingrid Oliver)
Episodes: The Day of the Doctor, Death in Heaven
She's only had two episodes so far but, despite being killed in the most recent one by Missy, she's confirmed to return for Series 9. It looks like the numerous fan theories suggesting that her Zygon duplicate from Day of the Doctor was either the version that got killed - or a version of the character that could come back - are about to be paid off.
However, it only took those two appearances for Osgood to become a fan favourite,. Seen by many as an in-show embodiment of the fanbase, Osgood is just as much a fan of the Time Lord as many of the viewers, dressing up in his old costumes. It's a quirk that endeared her to many Whovians who were delighted to see themselves represented on screen.
On top of that, Osgood was portrayed as a resourceful and clever scientist, becoming a key part of UNIT as they dealt with Zygons and Missy. Her ability to deduce the Queen of Evil's identity - a female regeneration of the Master - even impressed Capaldi's Doctor, who offered her a place on the TARDIS. Which severed to make her death even sadder. And her return even more awesome.
9. Jenny Flint (Catrin Stewart)
The first member of the Paternoster Gang to make it on to this list, Jenny is the only one native to the Victorian era the group inhabit. This doesn't stop her from being as capable a fighter as the other two, however, and she can easily hold her own against the threats the gang come up against. She is courageous and resourceful, as shown by her investigations into Sweetville in Series 7 episode The Crimson Horror, which adds to how interesting she can be.
On top of that, she's the heart of the team. She is extremely caring towards her wife and even if she gets exasperated by Strax there's a clear warmth to that relationship. Additionally, she's the only member of the gang that sympathises with Clara in Deep Breath when Clara is struggling with the Doctor's regeneration, which in turn makes Jenny more likable as she's willing to try to understand other points of view and be kind towards those who hold them.
Furthermore, Catrin Stewart is a brilliant actress and her delivery often works to make the stories she's in even better. Who can forget the effectiveness of "I think I've been murdered" in the Series 7 finale? Just chilling.
8. Strax (Dan Starkey)
Episodes: A Good Man Goes to War, The Snowmen, The Crimson Horror, The Name of the Doctor, Deep Breath
The Paternoster Gang's butler, Strax, is generally a source of humour. His lust for battle, warfare and bloodshed and lack of understanding of humanity often failing to fit in the Victorian era he lives in. For some, he's hilarious, generating laughs with every one liner. For others, the jokes grate and Strax becomes tiresome. Some fans even go so far as to suggest that he's made the Sontarans a permanent joke. That hit and miss nature is why he's so far down this list.
However, that comic relief is often a much needed aspect of the show and the episodes featuring the popular Paternoster Gang just wouldn't be the same without Strax. His heart is in the right place (even when he''s becoming too obsessed with his grenades!) and his battle expertise makes him one of the Doctor's most useful allies.
Furthermore, far from ruining the Sontarans, he's actually helped to provide an insight into their culture. His struggles to understand gender suggest Sontarans don't have such a concept and his role as a nurse after being disgraced shows the Sontarans' concept of honour, being forced to heal is a disgrace for the warlike race. These insights make Strax a highly interesting character.
7. Mickey Smith (Noel Clarke)
Episodes: Rose, Aliens of London, World War Three, Boom Town, The Parting of the Ways, The Christmas Invasion, School Reunion, The Girl in the Fireplace, Rise of the Cybermen, The Age of Steel, Army of Ghosts, Doomsday, Journey's End, The End of Time Part 2
Mickey the Idiot. The tin dog. Mickey didn't have the easiest of starts in the Whoniverse, often being looked down on by the Ninth Doctor and, to an extent, the Tenth, too. He's more of a comic relief figure throughout his first series, struggling with fears over the aliens attacking often in a comical manner. In fact, he even turned down a place on the TARDIS to begin with because he was scared of the worlds he might see.
However, Mickey really came into his own in the second series. He kept his charm and, while he couldn't compete with some of the other characters on an intellectual level, he finds the courage to help against the Krillitanes and decides to stay in an alternate dimension to join the fight against the Cybermen. He becomes a true badass alien fighter and, having been obsessed with Rose for so long, finally becomes his own person, warranting a deserved place on this list.
6. Madame Vastra (Neve McIntosh)
381258Episodes: A Good Man Goes to War, The Snowmen, The Crimson Horror, The Name of the Doctor, Deep Breath
The leader of the Paternoster Gang and wife to Jenny Flint (also of the Paternoster Gang), Vastra is an incredibly smart detective, supposedly the inspiration for Sherlock Holmes within the Whoniverse. A Silurian friend of the Doctor's woken up by some human construction workers, she has gone on to help Scotland Yard with many cases, both in dealing with terrestrial criminals and extraterrestrial menaces they don't understand.
She provides an interesting dynamic with both the Eleventh and Twelfth Doctors, able to match them in understanding alien cultures and worlds, even having an insight into the Doctor that other characters don't have. Just see where she delicately asks about the baby in A Good Man Goes to War or helps him through the regeneration crisis in Deep Breath.
But it's not just the dynamic with the Time Lord that sets her apart. She's an accomplished fighter like her wife, so she's a good character to work with the TARDIS team given the trouble that they tend to get themselves into. Furthermore, she manages to combine a sense of leadership (of the Paternoster Gang) with surprising levels of compassion for all living things. All of this makes Vastra really interesting, and it's always great to discover more about her.
5. River Song (Alex Kingston)
Episodes: Silence in the Library, Forest of the Dead, Time of Angels, Flesh and Stone, The Pandorica Opens, The Big Bang, The Impossible Astronaut, Day of the Moon, A Good Man Goes to War, Let's Kill Hitler, Closing Time, The Wedding of River Song, The Angels Take Manhattan, The Name of the Doctor
Intially mysterious, a few fans were disappointed with how River Song developed, feeling she went from a secretive and interesting character to being immature and lovestruck. However, given that her appearances are out of sync, her character development is all over the place and so there's still a lot to love about the Doctor's wife.
She's a great fighter, for starters, protecting her parents from the likes of the Silents and she's resourceful and adventurous to boot, adding an extra level to a number of her stories. She shows a lot of inner strength when it comes to dealing with her emotional pain, such as refusing to cry like the Doctor, and even encouraging Amy to join Rory in the past, in The Angels Take Manhattan.
Even if you don't like the character's more recent episodes, the episodes in which she was mysterious and awesome are still there to enjoy. Furthermore, River was an interesting experiment in telling a character arc in a non-chronological manner. This is something to be celebrated as if Doctor Who doesn't experiment, it'll never advance and will just turn stale. And who would want that?
4. Wilfred Mott (Bernard Cribbins)
Episodes: Voyage of the Damned, Partners in Crime, The Sontaran Stratagem, The Poison Sky, Turn Left, The Stolen Earth, Journey's End, The End of Time parts 1&2
First appearing in Voyage of the Damned as a newspaper salesman stubbornly staying in London despite multiple alien invasions, Wilfred Mott was revealed to be the grandfather of companion Donna Noble in the Series 4 opener, Partners in Crime. Kind, caring and an all round loveable chap, Wilfred Mott was always supportive of his granddaughter which bought him a lot of fans among those who felt Donna was one of the best companions of all time.
He also really respected who the Doctor was and what he was doing. A lot of the time, viewers could get the sense that Wilfred sympathised with the ancient Time Lord and his loneliness. Even if he couldn't understand all the decisions the Gallifreyan made, there was an inkling that he understood that they had to be made.
This made him an excellent foil for the Tenth Doctor when the two were paired together to take on the Master in The End of Time. Their central relationship was the emotional core of the story and easily one of it's strongest and most relateable aspects. And even when the odds were against him, Wilfred didn't give up saving lives, a heroic quality which merits him a place here.
3. The Master/Missy (Derek Jacobi/John Simm/Michelle Gomez)
Episodes: Utopia, The Sound of Drums, The Last of the Time Lords, The End of Time Parts 1&2, Deep Breath, Into the Dalek, The Caretaker, In the Forest of the Night, Dark Water, Death in Heaven
Is there a Doctor Who villain better than the Master? Probably not. So far the new series has seen three different incarnations of the manic Time Lord/Lady. Viewers got a mere glimpse of Derek Jacobi's incarnation, but it was still enough to get across the character's gravitas and fear of the Time War, which deepened him.
Then came along John Simm's cackling mad man. This portrayal has been divisive. While some found him threatening, others found him to be overly silly. However, he was a brilliant antagonistic foil to David Tennant's Tenth Doctor and his insane edge made him more unpredicatable and threatening. Furthermore, he was a tragic figure having been manipulated by the Time Lords since his youth, which made him more sympathetic and his redemption at the end of The End of Time particularly poignant.
Most recently came Michelle Gomez' Missy, who took the character's villainy to whole other level. Just as threatening and unpredicatable as Simm, Missy is a highly destructive figure, tearing through UNIT and killing fan favourite ally Osgood. It showed another aspect of a multi-faceted character.
And she's back for Series 9, which is something to look forward to.
2. Captain Jack Harkness (John Barrowman)
Episodes: The Empty Child, The Doctor Dances, Boom Town, Bad Wolf, The Parting of the Ways, Utopia, The Sound of Drums, The Last of the Time Lords, The Stolen Earth, Journey's End, The End of TIme Part 2
The Torchwood boss and former Time Agent is arguably the character that Whovians, at least those that grew up with the Russell T Davies era, want to see back the most. There's a lot of room to explore with him. The two year gap in his memory mentioned in his first episode has yet to be explained, making him mysterious, and it's a real shame that Barrowman didn't get the chance to reprise his role when it was mooted for A Good Man Goes to War because he was filming other things.
It's really the sheer force of John Barrowman's charm that makes the character so compelling. He can light up the screen with a smile and an introduction, often accompanied by a stern look or comment from the Doctor. He has a great dynamic with the other characters whenever he is on the show, bouncing well off both the Ninth and Tenth Doctors.
He has a great arc too, moving from a conman willing to run from trouble to a brave hero willing to stand up against evil. The viewers journey with the character, which makes him more sympathetic.
1. Sarah Jane Smith (Elisabeth Sladen)
Episodes: School Reunion, The Stolen Earth, Journey's End, The End of Time Part 2
One of the most iconic companions of the Classic Series, the late, great Elisabeth Sladen returned as Sarah Jane Smith in School Reunion. Combining as well with David Tennant's Tenth Doctor as she did with the Third and Fourth incarnations of the Time Lord, Sladen reminded classic fans what they loved about the character and introduced her to new viewers. Her courage and investigative nous helped endear the character to that new generation so that everyone got something from the cathartic goodbye between Sarah Jane and the Time Lord at the end of the episode.
She later returned again in The Stolen Earth and Journey's End, having spent some time leading her own spin off series in the aptly titled Sarah Jane Adventures. Again the character's courage, and Sladen's Whoniverse experience, helped her to stand out against all the other returning characters in a massive battle against the Daleks. Viewers also got to see another aspect of Sarah Jane, her motherly side as she worried about what would happen to adopted son Luke.
Given how well the iconic Sarah Jane was transcribed over to the new series, linking the two eras of Who, she deserves top spot.