This is a wonderful time to be a Doctor Who fan. The show is popular, the stories are mostly good, the production values are usually high and change is in the wind. As hard as it to let go of the past there is a glorious sense of heightened anticipation when a new Doctor is about to be introduced. Its like your first taste of sushi if youre someone who wasnt exposed early to that flavor its either intoxicating or repulsive but either way its strong, almost overpowering and incredibly interesting. Here is what I would love to see happen in series 8. I have high hopes for the future of the show but I also have some quibbles about series 7 that Id like to see addressed. I also have a few far-flung dreams and outright fantasies but well, its Doctor Who so they fit right in.
7. A Matt Smith Directed Episode
While Matt Smith the actor may be leaving the role of the Doctor, there are other ways he could continue to contribute to the show. His directing debut in Cargese was beautifully shot the stark, bleak framing and muted color choices creating a highly unsettling atmosphere. How fascinating would it be to watch the unique take on another Doctor by a director who had actually lived and breathed the same role? Smith has certainly proven his ability to surprise us with his creative choices as an actor and his debut in Cargese suggests his direction would be just as thoughtful and provocative. Series 7 was missing something for me and until recently I havent quite been able to put my finger on it. The quality was good overall but something wasnt quite right and I think Ive finally figured it out. We needed more depth of character. There were some standouts in the series Professor Palmer in Hide, Ada in Crimson Horror but for the most part guest stars felt under-utilized. I think that as an actor himself, and judging by his work on Cargese, Matt Smith would be a good directing choice to bring back the profound character moments that make Doctor Who so special.
6. A Well-Defined Clara
Claras character is basically a mess at this point. Shes been all over the place, literally and figuratively. At first I thought this might be a deliberate choice on Steven Moffats part but it now appears to be more likely that writers werent given clear guidance as to what this character was really all about. To her credit, Jenna Louise Coleman has done everything asked of her convincingly portraying Clara in about fifty different ways but unfortunately the indecisiveness is making it very hard to connect with and care about the character. Clara feels under-developed; as if she hasnt quite stepped out of the clay from which she was molded. She does things but we dont understand why shes doing them. Thats a shame because Coleman is brilliant and deserves the opportunity to shine. Right now shes the most important piece of cardboard in the Doctors life. I hope series 8 turns her into a person.
5. The Time War
The effects of aggression and war on the psyche have been touched upon throughout the Steven Moffat era. In series 6 we learn that the doctors legend is morphing from healer to warrior and we examine what steps the Doctor takes to change that. In series 7 we learn that hiding from the responsibility of power brings about its own set of consequences. Will series 8 dig deeper into the Doctors more personal experience with the horrors of war? The appearance of the John Hurt Doctor would suggest so. We know very little about the Time War at this point. Its been established that it was a horrific conflict which threatened to destroy the universe until the Doctor found a way to end it. Apparently that depended upon him committing genocide against his own people. It would be fascinating to explore some of the actual events of the Time War though I personally dont believe it would be a good idea to reveal too much about it. The Doctors power as a character is centered in his mystery. He is essentially unknowable. A glimpse into his life as a soldier however would certainly be illuminating.
4. Two-Parters
Heres my theory on the lack of two-parters in series 7. I think it has way more to do with catering to American commercial interests than with the requirements of a story. I say this as an American and it makes me sad. So many of the episodes of series 7 have felt rushed and incomplete. A couple of them (looking at you The Rings of Akhaten) felt badly in need of editing. American hour-long drama shows include around 22 minutes or so for commercials. To sell to the American market you are forced into this format. Two-parters are discouraged and while there is nothing wrong with standalone episodes, it would be nice to occasionally take the time to explore a story a little further. I think a lot of writers have struggled with the time constraints of modern Who and consequently characters are undeveloped and endings have felt tacked on. Some stories take a little longer to be told and that should be OK.
3. River Song
Let us take a moment for the River Song haters to curse me up and down and get it out of their systems. Feel better? Well probably not but heres my reasoning. Whether you relate to River Song the character or not, Alex Kingston the actress is superb at playing her. The chance to see Miss Kingston create a new dynamic with a different Doctor is just too delicious to pass up. River Song has become a kind of guiding force at this point the outsider who comments on the action and occasionally interacts with the main characters. Its interesting because as River has developed she has become more like the Doctor the driving force behind the action; the manipulator who uses others to do their will. The Doctor may think River is tucked away neatly on a shelf but I have a feeling she and Steven Moffat have other plans. I look forward to finding out.
2. Female Writers and Directors
Seriously its time. Women have always been fans of Doctor Who despite the propaganda to the contrary. There are many strong female voices in science fiction and fantasy today Jane Espenson immediately comes to mind - and it would be thrilling to experience a fresh perspective on the Doctors life. One of the best things about Doctor Who is that the story is open to so many different interpretations. Theres room for many points of view and becoming more inclusive will only make the program stronger and more likely to continue into the future. Adaptation and change is the key to survival both for the Doctor and the show itself.
1. A New Doctor
When it comes to the portrayal of the Doctor I dont care about reproductive systems or how much pigment is present in skin. I want the actor to inhabit the role in a way that is entirely their own while still respecting the essence of the character. That takes creativity, brains and heart the rest is superfluous. Arguing about the sex and/or ethnicity of the character misses the point. Its the energy that matters an intellectual curiosity, an individual flair. All thats required of the audience is an open mind. Doctor Who is a show that forces you to re-examine your perceptions because the character and his companions are constantly changing. That is a very good thing.
Mary Ogle is the author and illustrator of “Orangeroof Zoo” a whimsical tale of magical realism told through the pages of a coloring book for adults. Working as a professional artist in the digital medium, Mary’s commissions have included everything from fine art to fan art, book cover design, illustration and book layout. Find more of Mary’s work at www.maryogle.com. Mary currently finds inspiration in the Ojai Valley, residing in a snug little cottage with a recalcitrant cat.