Doctor Who: Wish World Review - 4 Ups & 6 Downs

Doctor Who Season 2 starts to fall apart at the final hurdle.

Doctor Who Wish World
BBC Studios

When I was a kid, I’d watch a series of Doctor Who, and as the season went on, my excitement would grow. Those little teasers spread throughout, foreboding what was to come – I’d eat them up. A Doctor Who finale was event television, the point at which the hype train arrived at the station. They weren’t always the best stories of the season, in fact they rarely ever were, but they always felt like a big deal.

My relationship with the Doctor Who finale is rather different these days, and I don’t think I’m the only one. Finales are something I dread – the mystery boxes are a chore, the inevitable twists and reveals are just words at this point. A finale is what drags a strong season like we’ve had this year right back down to Earth, and Wish World is no exception. Worse than that, Wish World makes me appreciate finales like The Battle Of Ransoor Av Kolos, because, despite being utter trash, at least it didn’t hinge it’s entire plot on the showrunner’s Classic Who fanfiction.

Wish World was, ultimately, more of the same. More evidence that we really, really need some flesh blood behind the scenes of this show.

10. DOWN - A Lack of Context

Doctor Who Wish World
BBC Studios

At the end of the previous episode, we were given a typical finale-lead-in cliffhanger. Fifteen and Belinda attempt to return back to Earth, and, as they do, the TARDIS doors explode.

If you were hoping that one was explained, I’ve got bad news for you, because you won’t be getting context. In isolation, this isn’t a big issue, it’s a gap we can conceivably fill in our heads. The issue lies in the fact that there’s an awful lot more we see in Wish World that I think it’s unlikely we’ll get context for. What’s up with the giant bone palace and the dinosaurs? Why is Susan Twist here again? What’s the deal with Belinda’s family? WHY IS MRS FLOOD BREAKING THE FOURTH WALL?!

There are at least five mysteries by my count (Susan Foreman, Omega, Poppy, Rogue, Mrs Flood) that are all far more central to the plot than any of the above, and the finale is going to struggle as it is to balance them all, especially with the Rani, Conrad, Ruby and UNIT also in play. It feels unlikely that these smaller threads are also going to be explored.

Quite simply, they’re there because they are – half-baked ideas that we’re just meant to run with because there’s not enough time. If an episode leaves you with this many questions, that’s not good writing. Give me one good mystery, not ten mysteries I couldn’t care less about.


9. UP - An Intriguing Dystopia

Doctor Who Wish World
BBC Studios

This is my biggest up of the week. I’ll admit, I found the central setup of this episode quite fun. I’m partial to a dystopia, especially one that’s a little bit George Orwell, it’s ‘doubt police’ and one-man propaganda machine. Despite all the other fluff, I do think Wish World nails this aspect pretty well.

Are we aping Marvel once again? Yes. If last season’s episode seven was inspired by Infinity War, then this year we’re clearly doing WandaVision (with a dash of Loki with that gorgeous retro UNIT set). It’s derivative, but they’re both excellent shows, and Doccy Who, for the most part, does manage to capture their vibe.

I like how this episode utilises Conrad, and a world that’s essentially constructed from a grifter’s imagination is a terrifying concept. I reckon he’s being set up to side with Mrs Flood against the Rani, what with his mummy issues and all, and whilst I think that may be one plot arc too many, I’m not mad that he’s here. He’s an easy character to love to hate, and a strong inclusion.

Two small jabs I enjoyed this week: firstly, Conrad finding ‘thinking’ extremely hard, and the not so subtle J.K. Rowling dig with that book cover.


8. DOWN - You Get A God! And You Get A God!

Doctor Who Wish World
BBC Studios

Please, please, please leave The Pantheon alone.

This week, we added another god to the Pantheon of Discord – a magic giggling baby. A magic giggling baby which, as I’ll discuss more later, I would argue was not necessary for the narrative at all.

We’ve had around twenty stories in RTD2 so far, and already we’ve had five members of the Pantheon show up (Toymaker, Maestro, Sutekh, Lux and now Desidirium). That’s not even counting the Midnight Entity, who was vaguely alluded to being one, and the barber from The Story & the Engine, who had a strong connection to the gods – the way things are going, I also fully expect Omega to be the God of Time next week, too.

This is way, way too frequent. They’re treated as the ultimate power in the universe for this era, and yet the Doctor is bumping into them every other week, and each time this happens, their appearance becomes less and less notable.

The other big issue with this overuse of the Pantheon is how limiting it is from a narrative standpoint. Sure, you can change up the setting, but the bones of these stories and the beats they hit are ultimately very similar.

The Whoniverse is starting to feel like a very small place.


7. UP - The Rani (For Now)

Doctor Who Wish World the Rani
BBC Studios

I didn’t think I’d be doing this last week, but I’ll give a hesitant ‘up’ to the Rani, for now. 

Just so we’re abundantly clear here, I’m talking about Archie Panjabi’s Rani, not Anita Dobson’s, though I am preferring the latter now that she’s actually a real character and seems to have stopped looking into the camera.

The ‘main’ Rani is fun addition to the show, and she certainly has the presence required for a Time Lord character. I’m also pleased to see she acts a lot more like Kate O’Mara’s original Rani than whatever Anita Dobson has been doing for two series – I buy her authority, and she’s not cartoonishly evil for evil’s sake, because her predecessor never was either. the Rani has always been more of a neutral, evil scientist type villain, in contrast with the Master’s gleeful, emotionally driven chaos.

I like that they’re sticking with the roots of her being a scientist at heart, even if she’s immediately leaning on magic for the bones of her plan, and I’m rather hoping that her as-yet-unrevealed end goal is in the interest of science, or a warped sense of greater good, as that’s always been her shtick. Personally, I reckon she’s working on a way of repopulating Gallifrey – given her offhand mention of ‘bringing life’.

Final shout out to her costuming, and to the pull-to-activate Sonic Syringe. A strong modern restyle without abandoning her classic look. I like it.


6. DOWN - Belinda Gets Shafted… Again.

Doctor Who Wish World Varada Sethu Belinda Chandra
BBC Studios

I’m absolutely devastated that Belinda is shaping up to get about as much screen time and attention as Dan did in Thirteen’s era. There’s a running theory online that big chunks of this series were originally written with Ruby as the companion and have tweaked accordingly, and the longer this run goes on, the more I buy into it.

Varada Sethu is so much fun, and has the potential to be the best companion we’ve had since Bill Potts, but this series just doesn’t know what it wants to do with her. She’s not felt like a main character since her first story, and to be honest, every story since would have remained pretty unchanged by her absence. She’s not even been given the standard companion trope of being the one to save the day fifty percent of the time, and it’s really sad to see her being so underutilised and under-appreciated.

She spends half this episode playing a brainwashed nuclear housewife, before she is thoroughly relegated to the background in favour or Ruby (again), who is the one who has a personal connection to UNIT and Conrad.

In a move that sums up Belinda’s role in the story, in the closing moments of the story, she fades into literal nothingness and, I promise you, I genuinely didn’t catch it until I rewatched it.

Justice for my girl. She better save the universe next week.


5. UP - Ruby’s Plotline

Doctor Who Wish World
BBC Studios

I may have just spoken about Ruby stealing Belinda’s limelight, but, in fairness, I also found Ruby’s story to be a highlight of this episode.

First up, I like that Ruby is the first to break through Conrad’s brainwashing, being the instigator of the episode in a sense. She’s essentially on the run, having had her foster Mum, Carla, disown her yet again – unbelievably, this is now the third time that Carla, due to an outside influence, has turned on Ruby. RTD really has it in for mothers, doesn’t he?

I’m delighted that Shirley was the one who got to lead the UNIT plot this week, as she’s tons of fun and has felt a little under-utilised since The Star Beast, and I also like that Conrad’s whole mindset could be his undoing. He overlooks the disabled community so much that they don’t occur to him, and are able to slip through the net of control because he’s so distracted doing CBeebies bedtime stories and being a homophobe. There’s a real satisfying comeuppance on its way here, hopefully.

Also really like the fact that the episode took the time to reinforce the whole ‘disability isn’t a superpower’ message, just to make sure that’s not what viewers took away from this. A small but necessary detail.


4. DOWN - More Of The Same

Doctor Who Wish World Conrad Omega
BBC Studios

My biggest concern for this finale was that we’d get a repeat of last year – a nothingburger of a first episode that only served to hype up an underwhelming reveal, which in turn kneecapped the finale, forcing it to both establish and overcome a universal threat in forty minutes. This was a formula that categorically did not work, and as soon as RTD used the same tropes as last year when it came to teasing the finale, I had my suspicions.

So, here we are. An overwhelming number of threads to resolve in one episode, and in amongst all that, we have to reintroduce Omega, make him feel like a threat, and dethrone him five minutes later. I daresay we could be heading for one of the messiest finales we’ve ever had, which would be a gutting way to end the best series we’ve been given in a very long time.

It speaks to what I think is this era’s biggest failing – a fixation on chasing these marketable, viral moments at the expense of storytelling. It feels like an era that’s designed to be consumed through Instagram reels – it’s all spectacle. Artificial tension, shock, and a whole lot of style over substance.

Because that’s what this episode is. Everything you’ve just watched, even the fun dystopian stuff, is just fluff that will be relegated to the background come next week.


3. DOWN - A Convoluted Scheme

Doctor Who Wish World
BBC Studios

Let’s run through the Rani’s scheme, shall we.

Step 1: Block the Doctor from returning to Earth so that he can charge up the Vindicator.

Step 2: Acquire magic god baby who grants infinite wishes.

Step 3: Upon his return to Earth, ambush the Doctor and steal the Vindicator (conjecture due to the aforementioned absence of context).

Step 4: Use magic baby powered up by Vindicator, which now has the power of twenty supernovas, to create a new world wished up by an alt-right conspiracy podcaster.

Step 5: Push the Doctor into realising he’s in a wish world by relentlessly monologuing at him (but you made a quirky fourth wall reference to exposition which makes it okay).

Step 6: Utilise the power of a Time Lord’s doubt (which as we all know, is super powerful) to break open reality.

Step 7: Omega, for some reason?

In the history of convoluted plans in Doctor Who, this rivals even the Master’s insane Rasputin gambit from The Power of the Doctor.

Doctor Who Wish World the Rani
BBC Studios

If you have an infinite wish genie baby, supposedly the most powerful god in the Pantheon (again…), why not just wish for Omega? And why does the most powerful god in existence need a little bit of tech that’s done some planet hopping in order to amplify its powers? Even if it does, why can’t the Rani charge the Vindicator herself in the form of Mrs Flood – she’s been everywhere the Doctor has been all season, so presumably she’s got her own TARDIS?

Everything about this premise is convoluted nonsense that doesn’t hold up to a degree of scrutiny. There are so many ideas that don’t gel together and belong in entirely different stories, and the depressing thing is almost all of them are fixed by removing the unnecessary genie baby from the equation.

The Rani is a scientist – just let her do a science thing to bring Omega back, if she really insists upon it.


2. UP - A Cameo We Actually Wanted

Doctor Who Wish World Rogue
BBC Studios

RTD thinks I’m sitting here jumping up and down because the Rani is back, or Omega is on his way, or even Susan. I’m not. For me, the only twist that actually caught me off guard and genuinely excited me was seeing Rogue again. I’m absolutely delighted.

I think after last season, a lot of viewers were expecting another episode with Rogue this year, and it became very obvious very quickly that it wasn’t to be the case. I was, in all honesty, slightly worried that the entire arc was going to be abandoned, which would have been devastating as more of Rogue was just about the only hanging thread from Season 1 that left me excited.

Is it a little disappointing that he essentially popped by to drop exposition like Jack Harkness did with the Lone Cyberman? Yes. But I’ll settle for knowing he hasn’t been forgotten, and that maybe we’ll get a follow-up, if not next week, then in the Season 3 everyone is convinced isn’t happening. Full-time companion, maybe?


1. DOWN - The Twists That Broke The Camel’s Back

Doctor Who Wish World
BBC Studios

I’ve touched on it a few times already, but let’s talk about those last few minutes, and the reveals themselves.

Firstly, Omega. I am in a state of utter disbelief that we’re pulling in yet another classic villain for this finale – apparently, that’s all the show knows how to do anymore. We bought in the Rani, just so she could bring in Omega the following week and immediately play second fiddle. I can’t wait until Omega arrives and reveals his plan to resurrect the Abzorbaloff (who’s also a member of the Pantheon by the way).

Jokes aside, I feel like the show is really starting to reek of desperation now and it’s giving me some major second hand embarrassment. We are scraping the barrel of pop-culture here, watching Russell T Davies smash his action figures together. This trend needs to stop now – please give me something fresh, or failing that, give me the Daleks or the Cybermen so we can at least spend less time on the reveal and more time on the story.

And then there’s Poppy. The captain from Space Babies who has inexplicably returned in the role of the Doctor’s fake daughter. Except, as is revealed in the closing moments of the episode, she isn’t fake? What does this even mean? And how does Fifteen not recognising his daughter in Space Babies make sense for those five people who willingly choose to rewatch it one day?

RTD has already released an interview saying that the finale is going to give us some ‘major shake-ups’ to Gallifrey’s lore. Yippee… just what we wanted. Because that went down super well after The Timeless Children was released.

I think we need to brace for impact on this one, gang.


Contributor

Alex is a sci-fi and fantasy swot, and is a writer for WhoCulture. He is incapable of watching TV without reciting trivia, and sometimes, when his heart is in the right place, and the stars are too, he’s worth listening to.